Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., March 17, 2007 Adar 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:06 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 09:51 09/03/2007
Far-right and wrong, or how to ruin Judaism
By Bradley Burston

This is the third in a series of exercises in over-generalization.

Apologies are tendered in advance to the rational right, the members of whom often hate the following as much as anyone.

________________


Advertisement

For years, the members of the radical right have done their best to help ruin any chance for peace. They've done quite a job.

Given free rein, in the end they'd ruin Judaism as well, replacing it with their own belief system. If the rest of us would only let them.

How would it look? Something like this perhaps:

THE NEW 13 ARTICLES OF FAITH

1. Jews have the full right, and the duty, to settle anywhere they choose in the biblically defined Land of Israel.

Author's note: No one in this world has the right to settle wherever they choose.

2. Settling the Land is a commandment of the highest order in Judaism.

Corollary:

3. Ceding land to Arabs under so-called peace deals is a sin. Judaism must revive the medieval concept of the moser, under which Jews who hand over Jewish land to gentiles, inform against fellow Jews or hand over fellow Jews to gentiles are guilty of capital crimes.

Author's note: The distortion of contemporary Judaism to a perverse extreme is especially evident in the works of the self-appointed "Sanhedrin" of leading far-right rabbis, whose rabbinical court recently pronounced overall IDF West Bank commander Yair Naveh, himself Orthodox, a moser for approving the eviction of 20 occupants of an illegal outpost.

Leaving aside the problematic issue of a Great Sanhedrin arbitrarily constituting itself after 1,650 years of inactivity, the ancient Sanhedrin was historically renowned, if for nothing else, for its marked reluctance to impose the death penalty.

4. Refusal of orders by leftist soldiers serving in the territories is an act of cowardice, self-hatred, treachery, defeatism.

5. Refusal of orders by rightist soldiers serving in the territories is an act of conscience, of uncommon valor, a defense of Jewish values, a historical necessity.

6. Meir Kahane was a saint and a prophet.

Author's note: Corollary - Racism against Arabs is thus not bigotry, but realism.

7. Baruch Goldstein was a saint and a savior.

Author's note: In Hebron, the second most holy city to Jews and the contemporary headquarters of twisting authentic Judaism into obscenity, Goldstein's grave has become a pilgrimage magnate for the Voodoo Jews who revere his massacre of 29 Muslims at prayer. Going obscenity one better, Goldstein chose for his terror attack the holiday of Purim, arguably the most joyous occasion on the Jewish calendar.

To hear the radical right tell it, Goldstein's action prevented an unimaginable terrorist plot from unfolding and murdering large numbers of Jews.

It was a fiction that has become an article of faith. Thus it is that radical rightist Jews have come to revere Goldstein not because of the lives - Arab and Jewish - that he saved as a physician, but because of those - exclusively Muslim - that he took as a gunman.

8. Leftist Jews are systematically destroying Israel. The leftist-dominated media foments and directs that process of destruction, through its treasonous criticism of right-wing governments.

9. Criticism by Jews of left-wing Israeli governments is a patriotic duty.

10. There is no difference between the Arabs of today and the Nazis of World War II. There is no such thing as a Palestinian people. The Arabs of the Land of Israel should be transferred to Muslim nations.

11. The Israel Defense Forces, the Border Police, and the Shin Bet, acting under the orders of left-leaning government officials, coddle the Palestinians and refrain from carrying out the kinds of operations that would put an end to terror once and for all.

12.Jews are no longer bound by the rabbinic prohibition against setting foot on the Temple Mount.

Author's note: No less an authority than Rabbi Abraham Isaac Hacohen Kook, first chief rabbi of British Mandatory Palestine, ruled that "it is a Torah commandment that until the day of the resurrection, we are not permitted to even enter the courtyard of the Temple."

The fact that Jewish law can be summarily ignored or rescinded for reasons of politics and ideology does not bode well. Neither does the possibility that it can only be revamped for reasons of right-wing politics or ideology.

13. The Muslim occupation of the Temple Mount should be ended at the first opportunity, and the construction of the new Temple to begin. Jews, who everywhere in the world pray facing the direction of the Temple Mount, have a clear right to the site, in contrast to Muslims, who pray facing Mecca.

Author's note: For Jews to decide how much Muslims care about their holy sites is fully as wrong as Muslims deciding how much Jews care about theirs.

Among many of us, there is a tendency to discount the potency and the danger of the far right. Perhaps this is because of the funhouse mirror carnival aspect of the ragtag righteous: the End of Days addicts, the Temple Mount groupies, the hilltop hormone punks, the Kahane-rama tubby hippies, the curiously mousy men of the Women in Green, the fanatical would-be settler, the gun nut, the Messiah crank, the Earthmother curser of Arab mothers, the thick of payes and the thin of patience, the wide of scullcap and the wild of eye, the would-have-been ghetto fighter and the might-have-been Maccabee.

What unites them? What do they know that we don't know? The destructive potential of the lunatic notion, the obscene plan, the crackpot mantra.

They know that this is no joke. This is a struggle for the soul of Judaism. Ultimately, however, the result will not be up to them. It will be up to the rest of us.

___________________


Recent blogs:

The BBC poll - Israel as Satan's bastard child
Why Israelis hate the left, or, How to Speak Leftist
Ten reasons the left hates Israel - five good, five bad
In what state should Bibi run for the U.S. Senate?

___________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Eating Well
The first association a person has when thinking about eating healthy is practical.
Cosi fan tutti
There isn't a corresponding phrase in Hebrew for the saying 'it's not done.'
  1.   Wonderful, wonderful stuff from Bradley 10:25  |  Clickfool 09/03/07
  2.   MOSHIACH:RESETTLE JEWS IN HEBRON,BETHLEHEM,GAZA,ELIMINATE TERROR! 10:33  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 09/03/07
  3.   Secular Left Has Abandoned the Field 10:36  |  Eli 09/03/07
  4.   This analysis has the unmistakable ring of truth and relevance 10:37  |  English Resident 09/03/07
  5.   What I always wanted to know about Israel......... 10:45  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/03/07
  6.   Brilliant 10:48  |  Marilyn 09/03/07
  7.   clickFOOL Strikes Again 10:50  |  El 09/03/07
  8.   Swiss (Dino) I`ll try to respond 10:59  |  Eli 09/03/07
  9.   Israel looking like a future religious train wreck 11:01  |  Michael 09/03/07
  10.   Dino 11:16  |  S 09/03/07
  11.   Bradley Burston is right on. 11:17  |  M. Franks-Lhermann 09/03/07
  12.   Right wing versus Right wing 11:19  |  Joe 09/03/07
  13.   Answer to Swiss (Dino) 11:23  |  Peter 09/03/07
  14.   Primitive values 11:27  |  Ben Azai 09/03/07
  15.   WELL DONE BRADLEY 11:27  |  indrajaya 09/03/07
  16.   # 8 Eli 11:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/03/07
  17.   Nemesis? 11:32  |  Sherlock Holmes 09/03/07
  18.   Nothing over-generalized here 11:37  |  John 09/03/07
  19.   Which rabbis support these alien values? 11:37  |  Joseph 09/03/07
  20.   # 11 S 11:47  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/03/07
  21.   Sure Blame The Proud Jews 11:49  |  Johnny 09/03/07
  22.   A parody and not an analysis 11:55  |  Ilan 09/03/07
  23.   Moshiach 11:55  |  Motic 09/03/07
  24.   # 14 Peter 11:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/03/07
  25.   For Bradley about a well-known hate poster 12:04  |  Jonathan S 09/03/07
  26.   More on the rules of adding to bradley`s list 12:04  |  dana 09/03/07
  27.   Dino #21 12:04  |  S 09/03/07
  28.   Swiss (Dino) 12:06  |  Eli 09/03/07
  29.   Ironically 12:06  |  Stephen Connor 09/03/07
  30.   This time I agree with Mr. Brad 12:09  |  juan 09/03/07
  31.   A SAINT AND A PROPHET 12:19  |  indrajaya 09/03/07
  32.   Johnny, how`s the latte in Miami. 12:26  |  Eli 09/03/07
  33.   Arabs and Nazism 12:26  |  Jonathan S 09/03/07
  34.   # 26 S 12:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/03/07
  35.   Swiss(Dino) 12:38  |  Stephen Connor 09/03/07
  36.   Two more items to add to bradley`s list - 2nd try 12:38  |  dana 09/03/07
  37.   clickfool the evidence against you is this 12:43  |  david hamoui 09/03/07
  38.   The Left is ruining Judaism 12:44  |  Elizabeth 09/03/07
  39.   The KKK in a Jewish incarnation 12:47  |  D Hirod 09/03/07
  40.   dana new shades of rage 12:47  |  rrw 09/03/07
  41.   CLICKFOOL is a charming fellow 12:49  |  juan 09/03/07
  42.   Wow Bradley, sounds like the Religious Left 12:53  |  FOX 09/03/07
  43.   # 36 Stephen Connor 12:54  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/03/07
  44.   #22 Johnny in Miami 12:56  |  Boycott 09/03/07
  45.   How Nazi ideology came to the ME 13:03  |  Jonathan S 09/03/07
  46.   rrw #41 - has issues with "pretend" western "lingo" 13:18  |  dana 09/03/07
  47.   REMEMBER: The First Commandment! 13:28  |  Alicia 09/03/07
  48.   Right Wing mild compared to Islamic views! 13:35  |  Psalm 09/03/07
  49.   Oh Bradley, what a mess you`ve got us into 13:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 09/03/07
  50.   Radical right 14:08  |  Mitch Cohen 09/03/07
  51.   The title is wrong on two points 14:10  |  Jonathan S 09/03/07
  52.   One article of faith trumps these...Infidels, Jews and Christians 14:19  |  The Equalizer 09/03/07
  53.   Theocracy or sanity 14:27  |  Yaakov 09/03/07
  54.   god of THE LEFT and ISLAM 14:34  |  Gabe1 09/03/07
  55.   Alicia - REMEMBER: The First Commandment! 14:35  |  Stephen E.Connor 09/03/07
  56.   Gross, Misleading Over-Generalizations 14:39  |  Ben Israel 09/03/07
  57.   Psalm - The essence of fanaticism 14:43  |  Stephen Connor 09/03/07
  58.   Articles of faith 14:49  |  Choni Davidowitz 09/03/07
  59.   Reply to #46 Nazis in the Middle East 14:51  |  Johns Hopkins 09/03/07
  60.   A Better Synopsis Could Not Be Written 14:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/03/07
  61.   Mr Bradley Burston 14:57  |  Shlomo M 09/03/07
  62.   Well said Bradley 14:59  |  Chris Linthwaite 09/03/07
  63.   Witness Many of Those Posting Here Part I 15:02  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/03/07
  64.   Choni Davidowitz 15:03  |  Stephen Connor 09/03/07
  65.   Bradley 15:05  |  Gabe1 09/03/07
  66.   Winess Many of the Posters Here, Part II 15:10  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/03/07
  67.   Choni Davidovitz: Making and idol Out of Kahane 15:13  |  Ronnie Wolman 09/03/07
  68.   Choni and quite frankly I prefer Jerry Seinfeld 15:15  |  Ronnie Wolman 09/03/07
  69.   #36 dana AND THE MAGIC EVIL FAIRY THAT CURSED THE ARABS 15:18  |  paul harris 09/03/07
  70.   Witness Many of the Posters Here, Part III 15:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/03/07
  71.   Ceding land is just stupid. 15:20  |  George 09/03/07
  72.   CUDGELING JEWISH CONNECTION WITH `PROMISED LAND` 15:21  |  B 09/03/07
  73.   354 AND OF COURSE YAAKOV THE MULIM WORLD IS FULLY INTEGRATED INTO 15:22  |  paul harris 09/03/07
  74.   You forgot the Messiah, Bradley 15:27  |  Tosefta 09/03/07
  75.   Yaakov but is he a doctor?????? 15:34  |  Ronnie Wolman 09/03/07
  76.   michael # 9 IS TALKING A LOAD OF HOGWASH!!! 15:40  |  alonitzafoni 09/03/07
  77.   Again, we see an example of what I mentioned above #73 15:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/03/07
  78.   right wing 15:45  |  j10 09/03/07
  79.   Yaakov #52: Theocracy 15:49  |  Psalm 09/03/07
  80.   The real danger is not to Judaism 15:52  |  Tzfonit 09/03/07
  81.   a bb with a good brain 15:55  |  nehemia dB 09/03/07