Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., March 09, 2007 Adar 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Portents of joy for the Palestinians
By Danny Rubinstein

The chances for setting up a Palestinian unity government are greater now than ever. Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) is scheduled to be in Gaza this weekend to finalize the details of government structure with Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh. The sides are formulating the documents, submitting lists of ministerial candidates and, if all goes well, within a short time a Palestinian unity government will be established with the participation of Hamas, Fatah, the Popular Front and the People's Party (the former Communists) and independents. Perhaps even within a week or two.

Although the Palestinian spokesmen aren't connecting the two issues, the presentation of the unity government is clearly supposed to be part of a more comprehensive move that will include a deal for the release of Gilad Shalit, parallel to the first stage of the release of hundreds of Palestinian security prisoners. Without Shalit's release in return for prisoners, the unity government will not be able to begin its work.

On the Palestinian side, it is possible to discern the first portents of the near completion of the prisoner release deal. Announcements and slogans in newspapers call for "Liberty for the Prisoners" (from their perspective, they are prisoners of war, and not criminals). Hamas politburo member Osama Mazzini, who at the end of last weekend announced a breakthrough in the negotiations concerning Shalit and the prisoners, explained: "It is possible that this time the occupation leaders are evincing seriousness about bringing to an end the dealing with a case that has brought them domestic and international embarrassment ... and in the coming days several reports will be made public that will bring joy to the Palestinians, especially to the families of the prisoners."

Advertisement

In this context, it is desirable for the government of Israel to decide to release the secretary general of Fatah in the West Bank, Marwan Barghouti. It's the right opportunity to do so, as opined by Environmental Protection Minister Gideon Ezra, whose remarks have been given prominent play in the Palestinian media: "I know Barghouti well, and I know that he has the ability to strengthen Fatah and Abu Mazen."

Publicity like this does not always help Abu Mazen or the Fatah movement. If we assume the Palestinian unity government will not last and will fall apart shortly (a common assumption), another election race in the PA will be unavoidable. Then, the demand for Barghouti's release will grow, because only Barghouti is capable of coping with Hamas, and Israel might as well release him.

But freeing him in such circumstances could backfire. The Palestinian street could see such a move as a crude intervention in their elections and an attempt to dictate their vote - and will do the opposite. That is, they will vote for Hamas and trip up Barghouti. There is much discussion of such a possibility among Barghouti and acquaintances who visit him frequently in prison. Barghouti has been telling them that if Israel frees him so he can run against Hamas, he will refuse to be released.

The deal for Shalit will also free Palestinian political activists, headed by cabinet members and Hamas MPs, who have been held in administrative detention to pressure for Shalit's release. Popular Front leaders Ahmad Saadat and Abed Rahim Maluah, as well as Hussam Khader of Nablus, who was a Fatah MP, are also in an Israeli prison. Without doubt, most of these activists, certainly the Hamas people but also others, will be released now. Veteran prisoners known as those "with blood on their hands" will also be released along with them. In such an extensive framework, it will look reasonable and even legitimate to release Barghouti, too.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Double or nothing
In the ongoing saga of unpaid local authority employees, the Histadrut is not helping.
Not-so-free range
The free-range egg market in Israel is thriving, but it is plagued by deceptive labels.
  1.   Deserves death 09:51  |  Josef Matamoros 06/03/07
  2.   THIS IS THE TIME TO EXECUTE MURDERER BARGHOUTI ?? 10:10  |  Bill. 06/03/07
  3.   This tells you everything about Gangster Israel 10:10  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  4.   "Divide and conquer" 10:14  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  5.   Free Barghouti 10:39  |  Big Al 06/03/07
  6.   Free Barghouti 10:42  |  Angelo Tito Anselmi 06/03/07
  7.   slikstul rotmouth 10:47  |  Akiva Patysh, Tzioni 06/03/07
  8.   Maybe it is better to keep Barghouti for another few months..... 11:02  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/03/07
  9.   Mr Rubinstein D 11:31  |  John Blogg 06/03/07
  10.   I do think it is time to begin to seriously re-examine the option 11:38  |  Nadav 06/03/07
  11.   What civilized nation would consider releasing serial killers? 11:48  |  Yacov 06/03/07
  12.   Hi Nadav 12:06  |  Big Al 06/03/07
  13.   Eo free Barghouti?-NO. To free Shalie?-YES. Unconditionally! 12:13  |  Vittorio 06/03/07
  14.   Hey Rubinstein-It is Time To Free Yigal Amir 12:13  |  Ben Israel 06/03/07
  15.   Hey Rubinstein-It is Time To Free Yigal Amir 12:14  |  Ben Israel 06/03/07
  16.   YOU SHALL MAKE NO COVENANT WITH THEM OR THEIR gods ?? 12:26  |  BILL 06/03/07
  17.   No, Big Al, Egypt and Jordan will not leap at the opportunity, as 12:29  |  Nadav 06/03/07
  18.   Ben Israel, you are talking out of your hat 12:34  |  Big Al 06/03/07
  19.   To Nadav 12:40  |  Big Al 06/03/07
  20.   Reply to Big Al (Post No. 5) 13:03  |  Johnny Weintraub 06/03/07
  21.   Big Al, I am neither an optimist nor a pesimist. I try to be a... 13:06  |  Nadav 06/03/07
  22.   Disgusting 13:22  |  Choni Davidowitz 06/03/07
  23.   SEND him home with the video of him eating while fellow Pal.- 13:46  |  PETER SM 06/03/07
  24.   CFOOL.Killing Israelis is no crime for you.What`s new? 13:56  |  PETER SM 06/03/07
  25.   Danny Rubinstein would have freed Eichmann 14:25  |  Ken Jurist 06/03/07
  26.   Danny Rubinstein is correct on one thing. 14:29  |  David Stoler 06/03/07
  27.   My Plan for peace for the Middle East 14:35  |  Clickfool`s son 06/03/07
  28.   Shalit should already be free - Israel should have not caved 14:39  |  Dr David I. Gross 06/03/07
  29.   CLICKFOOL 4 14:45  |  chasaboy 06/03/07
  30.   Prisoner release 14:57  |  Mitch Cohen 06/03/07
  31.   Freeing a mass-murderer is the moral choice? 15:03  |  Ilan 06/03/07
  32.   # 10 - Nadav`s proposal 15:19  |  Qasem 06/03/07
  33.   For Peter SM # 24 15:19  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  34.   RUBINSTEIN STICK TO PIANO PLAYING 15:22  |  paul harris 06/03/07
  35.   #11 UNFORTUNATELY YACOV A PRECEDENT HAS ALREADY BEEN SET 15:26  |  paul harris 06/03/07
  36.   Hello Qasem, Let me response to your points: 1) Technically, .... 15:41  |  Nadav 06/03/07
  37.   ClickFOOL and the UK gangster state #3 15:43  |  Jonathan S 06/03/07
  38.   Dumb Mitch 15:44  |  Ilan 06/03/07
  39.   For Chasaboy # 29 15:44  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  40.   CFOOL You have said nothing in your post#33 15:59  |  PETER SM 06/03/07
  41.   Jonathan S opens his mouth and lets his belly rumble # 37 16:02  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  42.   How can Israel possibly survive? 16:03  |  Jonathan S 06/03/07
  43.   Nadav #17- Hard Questions. 16:21  |  Gabe1 06/03/07
  44.   If Fuad Ben-Eleizer is still free, Barghouti should be also 16:26  |  Yossi Cronenberg 06/03/07
  45.   Barghouti would have been great... 16:41  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/03/07
  46.   ClickFOOL denying the undeniable 16:49  |  Jonathan S 06/03/07
  47.   Nixon in China 17:22  |  W 06/03/07
  48.   No. 38 17:34  |  Mitch Cohen 06/03/07
  49.   Yossi Cronenberg #44 17:51  |  Gee 06/03/07
  50.   For Jonathan S, who`s done it again # 46 18:17  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  51.   M.Bargouti is really a political prisoner, 18:31  |  Angelina 06/03/07
  52.   Release Barghouti NOW, before Shalit 18:33  |  Tosefta 06/03/07
  53.   Appeasement - A Sickness 19:29  |  Tod Zuckerman 06/03/07
  54.   re # 22 Disgusting 19:36  |  Moshe B 06/03/07
  55.   pipe dreams 20:00  |  Wade 06/03/07
  56.   Clickfool, are you Sunni or Shia fanatic? 20:25  |  Omar 06/03/07
  57.   ClickFOOL defending settlers and treating of Untermenschen 20:27  |  Jonathan S 06/03/07
  58.   # 9 Rubinstein 20:30  |  Kulukundiakis Andrea 06/03/07
  59.   # 51 Angelina 20:53  |  Claire G 06/03/07
  60.   Mitch Cohen # 30 20:57  |  Salem B 06/03/07
  61.   #34 Hey Paul, are you still looking???!!! 21:29  |  ballistic 06/03/07
  62.   Tosefta #52 21:34  |  Gee 06/03/07
  63.   In prison because he outsmarted you 21:35  |  Tim 06/03/07
  64.   #61 BALLISTIC THE SEER SAYS ABBAS AND HANI WILL AGREE 22:09  |  paul harris 06/03/07
  65.   For Omar in NY # 56 22:16  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  66.   #62 Gee; on Space Station 7 - Wow 22:20  |  Tosefta 06/03/07
  67.   For Jonathan S # 57 22:28  |  Clickfool 06/03/07
  68.   #64 Well, Paul, I know you and many others 22:37  |  ballistic 06/03/07
  69.   Free Marwan! 22:50  |  Yonatan Netser 06/03/07
  70.   Prisoner Release 22:57  |  P. J. Casey 06/03/07
  71.   For ClickFOOL about wicked Englishmen 00:10  |  Jonathan S 07/03/07
  72.   #14/15 Ben Israel 00:49  |  Ari ben Yisrael 07/03/07
  73.   for the FOOL #67 00:59  |  Ari ben Yisrael 07/03/07
  74.   Free Marwan! 01:19  |  Yonatan Netser 07/03/07
  75.   Rest assured whatever happens with Barghouti release or lack of 01:26  |  Joe 07/03/07
  76.   The Farce 01:37  |  The North Wind 07/03/07
  77.   Shades of Nelson Mandela. 02:00  |  Racon-tour 07/03/07
  78.   THIS IS THE TIME TO HANG HIM 02:39  |  Meir Weinstein 07/03/07
  79.   To Jonathan and Clickfool 02:58  |  Oetis 07/03/07
  80.   Israel`s aging ace in the hole 03:33  |  Mark Lincoln 07/03/07
  81.   To no. 77 03:34  |  Mitch Cohen 07/03/07
  82.   Now is the time to free Ron Arad 03:51  |  Herbert Kaine 07/03/07
  83.   Now is the time to free Ron Arad 03:51  |  Herbert Kaine 07/03/07
  84.   Now is the time to free Ron Arad 03:51  |  Herbert Kaine 07/03/07
  85.   Now is the time to free Ron Arad 03:51  |  Herbert Kaine 07/03/07
  86.   Josef #1, then what about Begin, Shamir, and Sharon? 04:04  |  Palestinian Prince