Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., October 04, 2008 Tishrei 5, 5769 | | Israel Time: 21:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 23:14 05/03/2007
How Belgium sacrificed its Jews to the Nazis
By Adi Schwartz

The first question that must be asked is why this has taken so long. About three weeks ago, 62 years after the end of World War II, a committee of historians appointed by the Belgian government published a comprehensive report on the role of the Belgian authorities in the persecution and deportation of the Jews during the war. In other words, the committee was appointed to investigate the extent of the Belgian state's collaboration with Nazi Germany.

"Most Belgians are unaware of the gravity of the persecution experienced by the country's Jews," stated the Belgian Senate in its 2002 decision to establish the committee. "Why was it necessary for half a century to elapse in order for us to discuss this part of our past? It is the Senate's duty to preserve the memory of the genocide, relying on facts that cannot be questioned. This is our obligation to the coming generations."

What, in truth, can possibly explain this delay? Professor Dan Machman, chief historian of Yad Vashem (The Holocaust Martyrs' and Heroes' Remembrance Authority) and a specialist on the Holocaust in Belgium and Holland, says Belgium began dealing with the Holocaust later than other nations, but its state-commissioned report is an exception to the rule. He says that such reports have only been published in Romania, Switzerland and Lichtenstein thus far, and similar research is currently underway in the Baltic states. However, in France, for example, no such project has been launched.
Advertisement
Machman explains that one of the reasons the Belgians held off from dealing with the issue was the fact that King Leopold III remained in the country during the German occupation, unlike the Belgian government, which went into exile in London. This fact gave rise to questions about his collaboration with the Germans; he relinquished his crown after the war to his 20-year-old son, Baudouin.

"The king problem" remained a very sensitive issue in Belgium, and historians preferred, therefore, to concentrate on the German occupiers and not to deal with the Belgian collaborators. In the matter of the Jews, says Machman, the Belgians emphasized acts of saving the Jews and participation in the anti-Nazi underground.

King Leopold's mother, Queen Elizabeth of Bavaria, even received the title of Righteous Gentile from Yad Vashem in 1964 for her intervention on behalf of several hundred Belgian Jews with Belgian citizenship (a small minority in the Jewish population). Today, says Machman, it is not at all certain she would have received this honor, as her intervention on behalf of a small group of Jews with Belgian citizenship could have been seen as giving the Germans license to deport all the rest without citizenship.

In total, 25,000 Jews were killed, 44 percent of the total number of Jews living in Belgium on the eve of the German occupation.

The title given to the 1,100-page report is "La Belgique Docile" ("Obedient Belgium"), and its conclusions state explicitly that "the Belgian state adopted an obedient approach, and collaborated in a manner unbefitting a democratic country, in various but critical areas, in a devastating policy toward the Jewish population."

In the epilogue to the report, its authors wrote: "War exposes the soul of the nation. Most of the (Belgian) office-holders retained a certain amount of independence of action even under the occupation. The occupier's power was in hardly any case absolute power. The ability not to carry out certain tasks or not to put certain orders into effect remained in their hands. The significance of this latitude is that at several crucial moments (the Belgian authorities) were required to choose."

The editor of the report, historian Rudi Van Doorslaer, says that the German occupier required the local authorities' collaboration and therefore power remained in the hands of the Belgians. "Our role was to examine when the Belgians complied with the Nazis' instructions and when they did not," Van Doorslaer has told Haaretz. "In general, it can be said that the Belgians sacrificed the Jewish community to try to preserve 'normality' and the orderly functioning of the economy. The Belgians were very much influenced by the experience of World War I, but they did not take into account the fact that in the second war, the occupation was of a political nature. In World War II the German occupation of Belgium had Nazi and racist characteristics with regard to part of the population, which had not been the case in the First World War."

Van Doorslaer says he and his colleagues identified three crucial moments that marked the Belgian authorities' attitude toward the Jews. The first was in the autumn of 1940, about six months after Belgium surrendered. In November of that year, the occupation regime ordered Belgium to register all the Jews in the country. In terms of the Belgian Constitution, this order was illegal, as it discriminated against citizens according to their religion. In addition, explains Van Doorslaer, this was a violation of The Hague Convention, according to which "family honor and rights, the lives of persons, and private property, as well as religious convictions and practice, must be respected" by an occupier. Van Doorslaer relates that the authorities indeed did have a problem with this order. At this stage, only senior officials called secretaries general remained in Belgium, replacing the government that had gone into exile in London. However, after legal consultations, it was decided to allow the registration. The logical solution went like this: The order to carry out the registration was given by the Germans, so that if the Jews presented themselves at the registration office to follow the instruction, then the Belgians could not avoid it. In effect, the Belgians saw themselves as passive intermediaries in this matter.

According to Van Doorslaer, the Belgians saw the Jews as foreigners, as 95 percent of the community did not have Belgian citizenship. "This action has no explanation apart from that it was an intentional decision that derived from the fact that the Jews were considered foreigners," states the report. Van Doorslaer says much of the Belgian elite was tainted with xenophobia and anti-Semitism and the war led them to prefer "the Belgian interest," which ostensibly did not include the protection of Jews, by virtue of the fact that they were non-Belgians. Paradoxically, states the report, even though the Jews were the most obvious group harmed by the German enemy, the Belgian authorities related to the Jews as though they were themselves the enemies.

Pro-German Antwerp

In the wake of this registration came a long series of instructions and orders, the aim of which was to separate the Jewish population from the rest of society. In December 1940, all of the Jews who held official positions were fired from their jobs. In July 1941, the Belgian internal affairs secretary-general ordered the word "Jew" added to identifying documents. From that moment on, states the report, "the transition from passive collaboration to active collaboration was accomplished with great rapidity." In October 1941, the authorities declared illegal those textbooks that were edited by Jews and in December 1941, Jewish children were expelled from the schools. In June 1942, Jews were prohibited from working as doctors.

The second crucial moment featured in the report took place in the summer of 1942 when the Jews were deported to the East - to Auschwitz. Since 1940, Van Doorslaer says, there had been administrative collaboration with the Nazis; the Belgians carried out the Germans' instructions. In the instance of the deportations, however, there was a clear difference between Brussels and Antwerp, the two largest cities in Belgium where most of the Jewish population was concentrated. The report states that the Brussels police did not take part in rounding up and deporting the Jews, whereas in Antwerp the police helped the German forces close off streets to carry out the deportations. One out of a total of three deportations, on the 28th and 29th of August 1942, was even carried out in its entirety by the Antwerp police. In this deportation, 1,243 Jews were caught and sent to the death camps.

The explanation for this difference between Brussels and Antwerp derives, according to Van Doorslaer, from the long-standing division of Belgium between the Flemish north and the Francophone south. On the Flemish side, he says, there was more collaboration, both passive and impassive. This difference did not derive from any love of Jews, he explained, but rather from patriotic and nationalist sentiments.

In Brussels, the sense of Belgian patriotism was greater and anti-German sentiment stronger. In Antwerp, however, there was a fierce sense of Flemish patriotism, which connoted pro-German sentiment. The Flemish feelings of inferiority, which date back to the 19th century and are still felt to this day, could explain their German leanings: They thought the Germans would rectify their "inferior status" within the Belgian state.

The third crucial moment described in the report occurred at the end of the war. At that stage, the Belgian legal system was weighing whether to try German collaborators. It was decided, for example, that the Antwerp police who participated in the deportation of the Jews would not be tried. Van Doorslaer says the issue was too sensitive, because if the police officers bore responsibility then so did their commanders - and if the latter had superiors, then the entire system was responsible.

This possibility meant opening a Pandora's box at a very delicate moment in Belgian history. "The Belgian state decided at the end of 1945," states the report, "that the Belgian authorities bore no legal or other responsibility for the persecution of the Jews."
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Out in the open
Security officials fear U.S. radar system will expose IDF secrets.
Israel on their minds
Biden: Bush Mideast policy a failure; Palin: Mideast will top our agenda.
  1.   To Addi Schwartz: Your facts are inaccurate 02:21  |  Francoise Bouvy 06/03/07
  2.   How can it be? 03:28  |  Harry 06/03/07
  3.   Francoise Bouvy 04:06  |  chelemer 06/03/07
  4.   Belgium 05:36  |  Ron Green 06/03/07
  5.   #2 Harry 09:18  |  Marco 06/03/07
  6.   @4, ron green 09:30  |  vladimir 06/03/07
  7.   all european governments were complicit 09:30  |  flashman 06/03/07
  8.   The Jews also collaborated with our enemies 09:52  |  Belgian 06/03/07
  9.   #8 Belgian 10:13  |  Marco 06/03/07
  10.   That`s why Belgians are so eager to try Israeli officers at Hague 10:38  |  Absolute Sweden 06/03/07
  11.   The past is not dead 10:58  |  Albert Edelson 06/03/07
  12.   Schwartz is missing background 11:45  |  sh 06/03/07
  13.   DOESN`T COME AS A SURPRISE, ABOUT THE BELGIANS 11:56  |  Inyaki 06/03/07
  14.   Universal collaboration by Xtians in the war against the Jews 11:58  |  Yacov 06/03/07
  15.   Belgian 12:06  |  Anyuci 06/03/07
  16.   Belgium 12:11  |  Naim S. Mahlab 06/03/07
  17.   How Belgium sacriced its Jews .... 12:13  |  Klaus Döbereiner 06/03/07
  18.   Our Jews are our people! 12:17  |  Edith 06/03/07
  19.   European Graveyard 12:32  |  ATLAS 06/03/07
  20.   Tens of millions of christians died to rightly save the jews 12:34  |  European 06/03/07
  21.   We managed to save half of our Jews 12:47  |  Edith 06/03/07
  22.   # 20 European 12:56  |  Ivor 06/03/07
  23.   re: European 13:06  |  Efox 06/03/07
  24.   what I do not understand... 13:40  |  Edith 06/03/07
  25.   Belgian complicity throughout 14:50  |  eddie haley 06/03/07
  26.   And what about today? 15:05  |  david 06/03/07
  27.   to european - tens of millions of christians? 15:07  |  jews were europeans 06/03/07
  28.   Saving Jewish children 15:17  |  david 06/03/07
  29.   # 28 David 16:05  |  Edith 06/03/07
  30.   "Nazis pendant les guerres, et Catholiques entre elles." 18:28  |  Jake 06/03/07
  31.   Yacov, what about Serbia, Russia, Italy, and Denmark? 18:48  |  Jake 06/03/07
  32.   Collaboration?? Belgian 19:07  |  Jo Moor 06/03/07
  33.   Yacov: Yad Vashem on rescue of Jews in Italy 19:07  |  Jake 06/03/07
  34.   Thats why Belgians..... #10 19:10  |  Jo Moor 06/03/07
  35.   #4 Ron Green 19:12  |  J. B. 06/03/07
  36.   Not to be a wet blanket but... 20:06  |  Colin Wright 06/03/07
  37.   Diamonds are a Belgian Jew`s best friend 21:00  |  Norman Stein 06/03/07
  38.   If it happened again 21:26  |  Maria Weimar 06/03/07
  39.   colin wright - condolence condolence condolence. 21:45  |  mb 06/03/07
  40.   # Re to David. 22:23  |  Sylvain Brachfeld 06/03/07
  41.   Colin Wright, 95% of the Belgian Jews WERE `foreign` Jews 22:44  |  Jake 06/03/07
  42.   Maria Weimar, if it happened again? 22:55  |  Jake 06/03/07
  43.   Sylvain Brachfield 23:03  |  Jake 06/03/07
  44.   # 30 Jake 23:09  |  Edith 06/03/07
  45.   # 40 Brachfeld 23:18  |  Edith 06/03/07
  46.   Edith, I speak about `Flamingants`, not Flemish 23:59  |  Jake 06/03/07
  47.   #38 00:08  |  van mear 07/03/07
  48.   Let`s stress the positive facts 00:23  |  Valery Novoselsky 07/03/07
  49.   #38 Maria 02:45  |  Ron Green 07/03/07
  50.   To Yacov 06:35  |  Jerry 07/03/07
  51.   To Jake #33 06:47  |  jerry 07/03/07
  52.   ... and Roma were victims too! 12:23  |  Valery Novoselsky 07/03/07
  53.   To 8, 17:15  |  Jozef 09/03/07
  54.   Obedient Belgium before the war, and today (1) 18:44  |  Rene Pailloucq 09/03/07
  55.   Obedient Belgium before the war, and today (2) 19:25  |  Rene Pailloucq 09/03/07
  56.   Edith 05:03  |  Solomon 10/03/07
  57.   THE ABSOLUTE SUFFERING 08:47  |  Basheer Abueid 10/03/07
  58.   #57, European Jews did suffer the most in WW II 05:42  |  newageblues 11/03/07
  59.   Germans killed 6 million Jews? 07:36  |  Hans 11/03/07
  60.   Adi Schwartz 10:26  |  Joji Cherian 11/03/07
  61.   re: Hans 00:35  |  Efox 12/03/07
  62.   #8, How Belgium Sacrificed its Jews to the Nazis 03:21  |  Steve 12/03/07
  63.   How Belgium sacrificed its Jews to the Nazis 03:36  |  Evelyne 12/03/07
  64.   Belgium during WW2 10:12  |  Daniel 12/03/07
  65.   To No. 58: Roma suffered not less then the Jews 20:57  |  Valery Novoselsky 22/07/07
 Read & React
ADL: Financial crisis sparking anti-Semitic upsurge on Internet
Responses: 334
UN General Assembly Chief: Some Security Council members are worse than Iran
Responses: 83
Yoel Marcus: Israel won't top agenda for either McCain or Obama
Responses: 67
Claude Kandiyoti: A red line is needed between Jews, Israel
Responses: 88
Hezbollah: Ghajar, Shaba Farms will soon be liberated
Responses: 97
Saudi cleric urges Muslim women to cover up all but one eye
Responses: 50


More Headlines
15:08 Israel: North Korea supplying weapons to six Mideast states
21:04 Iran: Natural gas conference in Tehran proof U.S., Israel pressure ineffective
20:07 Palestinian Authority on alert for Hamas takeover of West Bank
19:16 Israeli Arabs mark anniversary of October 2000 riots
19:41 VP debate / Palin beats the odds, fails to be field dressed by Biden
02:14 Fugee Friday Post III / From war-torn Sudan to a tiny classroom in south Tel Aviv
13:30 NEW ON HAARETZ.COM / Play the news: Build your own Israeli government
16:57 Bush: Our economy continues to face serious challenges
14:05 French FM says considering proposal to deploy int'l monitors in Palestinian territories
09:21 U.S. drops plan to set up diplomatic outpost in Iran
08:53 UN General Assembly chief: Some Security Council members worse than Iran
22:37 Comedian Jackie Mason hits back at Sarah Silverman's pro-Obama video
12:07 Saudi cleric urges Muslim women to cover up all but one eye
21:46 Time Magazine: Israel fears U.S. radar will leave it 'naked in front of America'
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
Dial 013 for your long-distance calls
and get all your money back
US CITIZENS
Vote for real change. Request your ballot today!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Jewish Singles Personal Ads
Find the love of your life on JDate.com
Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
www. israel-property.com
Hebrew Summer courses
From $39.95
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved