Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., March 07, 2007 Adar 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Following the path of Sharon's sins
By Akiva Eldar

When Attorney General Menachem Mazuz's drawers are bursting with files investigating the prime minister, and a state comptroller report follows a committee of inquiry report, Ehud Olmert's pledge to "continue Sharon's path" becomes somewhat ironic. The most obvious similarity to Sharon lies in the Greek island affair, which was closed in a dubious manner, the campaign finance affair, which resulted in the conviction of Sharon's son, and the culture of political appointments.

The policy of unilateral disengagement from Palestinian territory, a policy that shielded Sharon from the skeletons in his closet and became Kadima's diplomatic platform, has faded into oblivion. Olmert long ago shelved the unilateral convergence plan for the West Bank. Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni has even expressed public regret for what she called "the throwing of Gaza's keys into the street." Along the same one-way street, which has been revealed at best to lead nowhere, they have offered a "diplomatic horizon." That is to say, a dead end. For it is well-known that a horizon has a way of moving further away as you get closer. The government is fighting the Mecca agreement, which was designed to allow the Palestinian Authority unity government to authorize PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas to conduct negotiations on a final-status accord. Instead of talking to Syria and Lebanon on a peace agreement, the government is preparing the public for another war in the North. Essentially, the Olmert-Peretz government isn't offering anything but more blood, sweat and tears.

Many Israelis assumed the uprooting of the Gush Katif settlements would serve as a precedent for the removal of settlements in the West Bank. Good people hoped that the withdrawal from the Gaza Strip was a down payment on a withdrawal from the West Bank. They argued that there is no crime greater than the crimes of the occupation, and that in exchange for the "historical step," the attorney general and the media must "protect Sharon like a citron: including with a sealed box, a sponge, and cotton balls," as Amnon Abramovich put it during a conference at the Van Leer Jerusalem Institute in February 2006.

Advertisement

In hindsight, given the chaos in the territories following the disengagement from Gaza, and the frozen diplomatic process, it is doubtful if the followers of citronism (handling politicians with kid gloves) would be more forgiving toward Sharon than toward Esterina Tartman, whose iniquities are white as snow compared to the suspicions that surrounded the previous prime minister. However, it is precisely the dangers lying in wait at Israel's gates, and threatening the pragmatic Sunni regimes, that have provided the Olmert government with a rare opportunity to end the conflict with all Arab states, once and for all. Five years after the missed opportunity of the Arab peace initiative approved in Beirut, the Arab League is offering Israel a second chance. In a Riyadh summit at the end of the month, the Arab League intends to pave the way for accelerated negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians and lay the groundwork for an end to the conflict along the northern border as well. Israeli acceptance of the initiative would be rewarded by "normal relations" with all its neighbors. Even the Bush administration has discovered that anger is not a policy and decided to to talk with the Iranians and Syrians on ways to leave Iraq. The United States would no doubt be grateful to Israel for any contribution to the fight against the global jihad that is shedding its soldiers' blood.

An Arab diplomat told me several days ago that it would be best if I lowered expectations of the Riyadh summit. Not that he doubts the sincerity of the Arab League's intentions. "Our pessimism is derived from the condition of your leadership," he said. "What value would the summit decision have, if what concerns the prime minister is who will get to him first - Winograd, the state comptroller's report, or the attorney general?"

I was reminded that in honor of the military victory in the Six-Day War, the Knesset adopted the general pardon law, which led to the closure of 15,000 open case files and ongoing trials, excluding for serious crimes such as murder and rape. A partial and problematic step like the unilateral disengagement rescued Sharon from trouble and granted him the status of a national hero. Given the citron experience, a diplomatic agreement that would bring an end to the occupation will pardon Olmert. Only an end to the state of war with the Arab states will turn Olmert from a dismal, marginal footnote in the state's history into a great leader.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The cost of inspiration
Even if you're not part of the elite of Israel's artists, here is a space for you to exhibit.
Happy Women's Day
Men's salaries are still 58 percent higher than women's, a new report finds.
  1.   The author and peace 11:01  |  Sam 05/03/07
  2.   TRY ANOTHER CONFLICT 11:09  |  indrajaya 05/03/07
  3.   When Did Haaretz Become A Sci-Fi Journal? 11:11  |  Terry 05/03/07
  4.   Applies across the board 11:17  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/03/07
  5.   Akiva Eldar same old surrender type article 11:33  |  Ken Jurist 05/03/07
  6.   Akiva Eldar same old surrender type article 11:33  |  Ken Jurist 05/03/07
  7.   A gnome cannot become a giant 11:40  |  Jonathan S 05/03/07
  8.   DESTROYING IRANS NUCLEAR CAPABILITY MIGHT BE A GOOD START ?? 12:02  |  Bill. 05/03/07
  9.   What is a "good person" 12:08  |  Ilan 05/03/07
  10.   Are settlers today`s ostenjuden for today`s "good people"? 12:28  |  Ilan 05/03/07
  11.   Akiva Eldar wants the Messiah as Prime Minister 12:46  |  Steven 05/03/07
  12.   no, The United Terrorist Forces are planning to attack Israel, so 13:09  |  Pavel 05/03/07
  13.   Hello Akiva, I wish you were the Prime Minister 13:23  |  Dutch 05/03/07
  14.   This is ridiculous. No, we don`t need great leaders. 13:38  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 05/03/07
  15.   YES YES MAKE PEACE WITH SYRIA!!!!! SEE THIS REPORT. 13:45  |  Bongo 2 05/03/07
  16.   Olmert 13:47  |  Niall 05/03/07
  17.   Ilan 13:58  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/03/07
  18.   HAARETZ CLICKFOOLS MOUTHPIECE 14:06  |  alonitzafoni 05/03/07
  19.   The opposite is true 14:40  |  Tzfonit 05/03/07
  20.   Who will be able to detach the barrier in Olmerts brain....?? 14:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/03/07
  21.   Margie in Tel Aviv 14:44  |  Gabe1 05/03/07
  22.   # 17 Margie in Tel Aviv 14:45  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/03/07
  23.   Margie in Tel Aviv #17 14:50  |  Gabe1 05/03/07
  24.   That dog won`t hunt. Eldar has it exactly backwards. 15:26  |  Dr. L. Brnd 05/03/07
  25.   Bracha #19 15:58  |  Gabe1 05/03/07
  26.   But by their fruits you will know them, Mr. Eldar 16:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  27.   Come on, be realistic 16:14  |  Clickfool 05/03/07
  28.   Why not have polls on Israelis` peace desire? 16:24  |  J.M.Jordan 05/03/07
  29.   poor mayor ; worse Prime Minister 16:26  |  moshe shen 05/03/07
  30.   silk purses and sows` ears 16:31  |  jiminy cricket 05/03/07
  31.   For Alonitzafoni # 18 16:45  |  Clickfool 05/03/07
  32.   By Their Fruits You Will Know Them, Mr. Eldar 17:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  33.   Shlomo , It `s most definitely the PM`s task 17:31  |  Dutch 05/03/07
  34.   Isn`t that a confession? 17:32  |  Xaxam 05/03/07
  35.   shalom lecha Yaakov Sullivan. ani mevin sheatah dover 17:37  |  Yehudah 05/03/07
  36.   Yehuda, achshav b`ivrit gam ken? #35 17:48  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  37.   Sullivan #32, to the losers do not go the spoils 17:53  |  Dr. L. Brnd 05/03/07
  38.   For Jiminy Cricket # 30 18:52  |  Clickfool 05/03/07
  39.   Yaakov Sullivan who refuses to share his 19:04  |  Yehudah 05/03/07
  40.   worse than nonsense 19:05  |  Bob 05/03/07
  41.   Eldar the nutcase... 19:09  |  Blogowitz 05/03/07
  42.   Dr. L Brnd on losers and the lose of spoils #37 19:14  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  43.   Question for Yehudah # 35 19:25  |  Clickfool 05/03/07
  44.   Memo to naive fools: no peace in our time. 19:29  |  Voice of Reason 05/03/07
  45.   Entire Arab-Israel conflict explained in less than 20 lines 19:37  |  MG 05/03/07
  46.   Margie in Tel Avib 19:37  |  GS1 05/03/07
  47.   Dr Bmd, Your commentary, LOL 19:38  |  Dutch 05/03/07
  48.   #24 Dr. Bmd, Your commentary, LOL 19:42  |  Dutch 05/03/07
  49.   Voice of Reason 20:09  |  Sharonelle 05/03/07
  50.   Sullivan, you fantasize its only a land and property dispute 20:16  |  Dr. L. Brnd 05/03/07
  51.   #18 Aloni; golly day, mate, here you go again 20:21  |  ballistic 05/03/07
  52.   #22 swiss 20:42  |  duncan 05/03/07
  53.   # 43 Clickfool.re:Question for Yehudah. VERY IMRESSED,BUT! 20:44  |  Kath` 05/03/07
  54.   Dr. L. Brndt on Palestine as property dispute #50 20:50  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  55.   Sullivan - ani adayin mekaveh likro et t`shuvat`kha! 20:55  |  Yehudah 05/03/07
  56.   Kath`, wasnt that a wonderful translation! #53 20:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  57.   It has come to my attention, Y.Sullivan, that you 21:05  |  Rina Rabinowitz 05/03/07
  58.   Negotiate Negotiate Negotiate Negotiate 21:08  |  Mozie 05/03/07
  59.   I am writing from Lithuania, trying to ask Yaakov Sullivan 21:18  |  Rita 05/03/07
  60.   Kath 21:22  |  Gabe1 05/03/07
  61.   yehuah, ani kfar aniti lecha#55 21:30  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  62.   rina on the right . And where do you live, rinicka? #57 21:34  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  63.   Rita over to Rina, rita over and out#59 21:39  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  64.   # 56 Yaakov Sullivan. SORRY YAK` I WAS ADDRESING IT... 21:56  |  Kath` 05/03/07
  65.   For Kath # 53 22:08  |  Clickfool 05/03/07
  66.   Nu be`emet (for heaven`s sake) 22:17  |  Bemused 05/03/07
  67.   I insist that you, Sullivan, address me with 22:18  |  Rina Rabinowitz 05/03/07
  68.   Yaakov Sullivan, thank you for your poetic answer, 22:27  |  Rita 05/03/07
  69.   Question for Kath # 64 22:29  |  Clickfool 05/03/07
  70.   Tzfonit 22:35  |  Gabe1 05/03/07
  71.   rina rabidowitz, you forgot to change the text #67 22:43  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  72.   So, Rita, I assume you worked for the KGB? #68 22:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  73.   The differnce between smart and stupid 22:56  |  Gene 05/03/07
  74.   # 52 duncan 22:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/03/07
  75.   #5 Ken Jurist,wake up boy 22:57  |  Wise Syrian 05/03/07
  76.   #67 Boy oh boy Yaakov 23:06  |  ballistic 05/03/07
  77.   Give peace a chance. 23:07  |  Ben Azai 05/03/07
  78.   Liberalism is a mental disorder and Akiva Eldar is an idiot 23:17  |  Larry 05/03/07
  79.   #76 DONT KID YOUR SELF BALLISTIC YAAKOV HAS BEEN WRITNG THIS RUB 23:45  |  paul harris 05/03/07
  80.   #43 Clickfool 23:49  |  Racon-tour 05/03/07
  81.   fanatics Don`t blow this opportunity out. 00:53  |  Salman 06/03/07
  82.   #81 Hi Salman; well, you said a mouthful there 01:27  |  ballistic 06/03/07
  83.   Mr Akiva .I do agree with that thoughtful assessment 01:29  |  Arik 06/03/07
  84.   SALMAN=todays SOLOMON 01:38  |  Fairman 06/03/07
  85.   #79 Hey Paul; I thought you folks said you were 01:39  |  ballistic