Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., March 14, 2007 Adar 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Islam of a different kind
By Michael Melchior

The trip from Jerusalem to the heart of Hebron, a neighborhood that is considered the stronghold of Palestinian opposition movements, takes only half an hour by car, but it is light years away in Middle Eastern terms. I went to Hebron to express condolences to the family of the Hebron sheik, Talal Sider, who in the past few years was a senior and full partner to the attempts to persuade the leaders of the three faiths to turn religion into a lever for peace, brotherhood and hope.

The tens of thousands of people who participated in the funeral bore witness to the fact that despite the change in direction that Sheik Talal, one of the founders of Hamas, underwent, he remained a venerated religious and spiritual leader. The courageous path he chose, until he served in the Palestinian Authority as a minister and participated in the interfaith meetings, teaches us that despite everything it is possible to change. His change was not a tactical political move but stemmed from a pure religious stance.

Despite a difference in political positions and cultural dissimilarities, it turns out that the common religious denominator has the strength to create a different language. Contrary to what some Israelis think, the Palestinians are also sick and tired of things. They also want their children to come home safely. They also want to live.

Advertisement

The tendency to see the half-empty glass sometimes makes us forget the other half, the full one. In the past three decades, ever since the messages sent by Anwar Sadat at the beginning of the 1970s and his historic visit to Jerusalem, there has been a slow but steady and constant process among the 22 Arab countries of coming to terms with, and reconciling to the idea of, the existence of the state of Israel.

This process has not yet seeped down completely to the Muslim religious leadership. The rise in strength of Islam as an extremely significant force in politics has created a certain differentiation between the positions of the Muslim states and their spiritual leaders. Alongside expressions of hatred, some of them purely anti-Semitic, the first seeds of acceptance of the existence of Israel and a wish to become reconciled with it are starting to blossom among the spiritual leaders.

This voice was heard loud and clear in the interfaith meetings with the spiritual and educational leaders, in courageous and intensive programs, and even in some religious rulings that emanated from the schools of learning of religious sages in Saudi Arabia, Egypt and the territories. Everything must be done so that this positive trend can create a positive response in our religious camp, so that the message can also seep down among us.

The half-full glass of the Mecca agreement could be the one to show the way. With the Hamas victory in the elections, that organization found itself in charge of an administration whose right to exist came from the Oslo agreements. When it looked out from the roof after the victory celebrations, Hamas discovered to its great anxiety that there was a ladder below it offering a way to climb down from the roof, from the utopian Muslim ideology to the ground of reality, a large part of which was the need to reconcile with the existence of the state of Israel.

The agreement is far from satisfying all the requirements laid down by the Quartet to the PA. But if the sides know how to use the ladder, they will be able, with its help and with the required caution, to reach another diplomatic horizon, one of hope and reconciliation. The group picture of the Palestinian leaders, dressed in white in Mecca, once again stresses the important place and the great power of the religious path on the way to solving the conflict. We, too, no less than the others, need to climb down the ladder.

It is not possible to make peace with only half of the Palestinians. Abu Mazen cannot supply all the goods himself. The authority he received from Hamas to hold negotiations and a referendum has both political and religious significance. Even the terrorist, Khaled Meshal, has unwittingly started to speak a different language. This cruel and hard-hearted man has not yet accepted the state of Israel as an accepted fact, but even his declarations that the PA is obliged to uphold the agreements with Israel is indeed "a new diplomatic language" that Hamas has adopted because of "national necessity."

Together with Israel's uncompromising demand for the eradication of terror and for maintaining security, we must also broaden the existing channels of dialogue. Those who do not want the current leadership will tomorrow get Islamic Jihad and al-Qaida instead. If we bury all hope about the current alternative, we will find ourselves facing an Arab world united behind the Iranian intentions to annihilate Israel.

The continuation of the present situation will bring upon us nothing but disaster. With the lack of a diplomatic alternative, it is merely a question of time until the Israel Defense Forces returns to Gaza. If we allow despair to overcome us, it will do so quickly and easily. Among us also there is a need to realize that without the peace we yearn for, it is not possible morally to continue ruling over the lives of 3.5 million Arabs who do not want us. This moral position must drive us also to make the effort to try to climb the ladder of opportunity that has been placed at our side.

Michael Melchior is chairman of the Knesset's Education and Culture Committee.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Flower power
Environmentalists are putting on display the wild orchids of Hanita Forest.
Strike season
Brought about by the gov't's weakness, Israel is about to experience a wave of strikes.
  1.   Arab states, not Arab people 11:02  |  Sami 05/03/07
  2.   Israelis Too 11:06  |  Walid 05/03/07
  3.   how very true... 11:24  |  ravi 05/03/07
  4.   You Have Given A New Dimension To "Slowly" 11:28  |  Terry 05/03/07
  5.   Recognize Arab stayes 11:38  |  Big Al 05/03/07
  6.   1: Walid can`t stop lying 11:49  |  David Teich 05/03/07
  7.   World Need Peace Too 11:49  |  Andrew 05/03/07
  8.   Peace? 11:52  |  Joe 05/03/07
  9.   if not 11:53  |  ravi 05/03/07
  10.   Stop Arab hypocrisy #2 11:56  |  Jonathan S 05/03/07
  11.   Its Not Islam of a different kind 12:37  |  Joseph E . 05/03/07
  12.   Israeli Truths 12:38  |  Walid 05/03/07
  13.   Arabs states await Iran`s nuking of Israel 12:54  |  Steven 05/03/07
  14.   The US on the Canadian boarder has a patchwork 13:02  |  Steven 05/03/07
  15.   Israeli Untruths 13:18  |  Walid 05/03/07
  16.   PEACE MEANS MANY THINGS 13:21  |  indrajaya 05/03/07
  17.   Walid in Beirut 13:27  |  CHGODMK 05/03/07
  18.   Great!IOnce again only Israel is expected to make peace moves 13:30  |  Hastaroth 05/03/07
  19.   Walid: Want the Checkpoints Opened? 13:32  |  CHGODMK 05/03/07
  20.   Israeli Heroines 13:36  |  Walid 05/03/07
  21.   Sami 13:36  |  CHGODMK 05/03/07
  22.   WHATABOUT INDIAS GREED FOR LAND RAVI #8???? 13:48  |  alonitzafonie 05/03/07
  23.   WALID SUPPORTS THE BLOODY HEZBOLLAH!!!! 13:49  |  alonitzafoni 05/03/07
  24.   MICHAEL SINGS IN THE CHOIR - ASONG OF HOPE 13:57  |  paul harris 05/03/07
  25.   CHGODMK 13:59  |  Walid 05/03/07
  26.   HAARETZ WILL YOU GUYS STOP EDITING MY POSTS!!!!!! 14:00  |  alonitzafoni 05/03/07
  27.   Arab Muslims still call for Israel to commit suicide 14:06  |  Yacov 05/03/07
  28.   Joseph E. 14:07  |  Walid 05/03/07
  29.   Sami # 1 and who cares what the ignorant people think? 14:09  |  The Equalizer 05/03/07
  30.   #2 Walid: Tell truth. Lebanese Arabs keeps Pals in ghetto camps 14:09  |  Yacov 05/03/07
  31.   #21 CHGODMK on Sami 14:14  |  Hastaroth 05/03/07
  32.   lower caste 14:17  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/03/07
  33.   Steven 14:17  |  Walid 05/03/07
  34.   Walid in Beirut 14:17  |  CHGODMK 05/03/07
  35.   David Teich re Walid 14:18  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/03/07
  36.   Proof that the Arabs are accepting Israel 14:19  |  Jonathan S 05/03/07
  37.   Hastaroth (& Walid) 14:31  |  CHGODMK 05/03/07
  38.   # 28 Walid @ Beirut / Lebanon 14:34  |  Joseph E . 05/03/07
  39.   Walid what is the Pal machsom watch called? 14:56  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/03/07
  40.   Yacov 15:00  |  Walid 05/03/07
  41.   Jonathan S (Post No. 36) 15:11  |  Johnny Weintraub 05/03/07
  42.   Jasmine Murphy 15:12  |  Walid 05/03/07
  43.   #40 Walid: Stop lying. Tell Truth about Arab Muslim invaders 15:19  |  Yacov 05/03/07
  44.   Walid and `politeness` 15:28  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/03/07
  45.   Incorrect article - 85% of Arab world against Shiites 15:35  |  redmike 05/03/07
  46.   30#WALID IS INTELLECTUALLY IMPAIRED!!! 15:36  |  alonitzafoni 05/03/07
  47.   Jasmine Murphy 15:51  |  Walid 05/03/07
  48.   Jasmine Murphy 15:59  |  Walid 05/03/07
  49.   42: Walid and the new definition of "polite" 16:02  |  David Teich 05/03/07
  50.   Consequences of actions 16:05  |  North American 05/03/07
  51.   Sami - and Israel`s "racist" policies 16:06  |  Stephen Connor 05/03/07
  52.   Johnny Weintraub 16:12  |  Gabe1 05/03/07
  53.   "..broaden the existing channels of dialogue." 16:23  |  Simon 05/03/07
  54.   Melchior is saying to gradualy talk to Hamas 16:26  |  Joseph E . 05/03/07
  55.   Walid on checkpoints #12 16:33  |  William 05/03/07
  56.   Walid`s lack of perspective - Machsom Watch #20 16:38  |  William 05/03/07
  57.   Walid: "time has also come for Israelis to come to terms with and 17:00  |  Nadav 05/03/07
  58.   Sami #1 - You are very right 17:08  |  Moises 05/03/07
  59.   Walid How about Shaheed watch? 17:16  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/03/07
  60.   Thank you Rabbi Melchior! 17:22  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  61.   William 17:25  |  Walid 05/03/07
  62.   # 7 Andrew @ Kuala Lumpur / Malaysia 17:36  |  Joseph E . 05/03/07
  63.   Nice to know..... 17:56  |  Ahmad 05/03/07
  64.   #50 North American - From a Central American: what? 18:04  |  Moises 05/03/07
  65.   Rabbi Melchior I think it is your duty to clarify..... 18:06  |  Emess 05/03/07
  66.   Jasmine Murphy 18:13  |  Walid 05/03/07
  67.   #50, North American 18:14  |  JB 05/03/07
  68.   When you run for PM 18:16  |  Muriel 05/03/07
  69.   61: Walid still avoiding 18:44  |  David Teich 05/03/07
  70.   I noticed, Sullivan, that you have claimed that 19:07  |  Yael 05/03/07
  71.   67 Borders should be the basis for a just partition 19:22  |  Mike 05/03/07
  72.   # 16 indrajaya 19:22  |  Lynn 05/03/07
  73.   JB & North American 19:26  |  Walid 05/03/07
  74.   North american 19:26  |  Lynn 05/03/07
  75.   Walid 19:29  |  ODP 05/03/07
  76.   Arabs/moslems will never accept israel-stop dreaming 19:39  |  Voice of Reason 05/03/07
  77.   Walid 19:57  |  JB 05/03/07
  78.   #26 Hey Aloni; you are another poster 20:09  |  ballistic 05/03/07
  79.   #46 Oh my Aloni, here you go again. 20:13  |  ballistic 05/03/07
  80.   #70, Yael. I noticed, Yael, that you`re not sure if you noticed 20:17  |  zmogus 05/03/07
  81.   Peace Means More Belly Dancers 20:27  |  Yosemite 05/03/07
  82.   #76, Beg you pad`n, Voice of what? 20:42  |  zmogus 05/03/07
  83.   ODP 20:45  |  Walid 05/03/07
  84.   JB 20:54  |  Walid 05/03/07
  85.   73: Wow, Walid can`t see truth when it slaps him 20:56  |  David Teich 05/03/07
  86.   is this sheik related to the sheik who was party 20:57  |  Tal 05/03/07
  87.   Sullivan, me too, still waiting for your clear writing that 20:57  |  Yael 05/03/07
  88.   Dear Mr.M.Melchior........................... 21:04  |  Kath` 05/03/07
  89.   zmogus, far be from me to ignore differences in moslem attitudes 21:04  |  Voice of Reason 05/03/07
  90.   Emess and the Voice from Hebron #65 21:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  91.   David Teich 21:14  |  Walid 05/03/07
  92.   # 42 Walid 21:33  |  ChanahS 05/03/07
  93.   # 73 Not quite Walid 21:42  |  ChanahS 05/03/07
  94.   Walid # 83 21:47  |  ChanahS 05/03/07
  95.   Melchior`s black magic.... 21:55  |  Blogowitz 05/03/07
  96.   #2 WHAT PAL GOVERNMENT 22:03  |  TOBIA 05/03/07
  97.   #84, Walid 22:10  |  JB 05/03/07
  98.   I see, Sullivan, that you have finally admitted that 22:11  |  David 05/03/07
  99.   Walid 22:18  |  ODP 05/03/07
  100.   ChanahS 22:24  |  Walid 05/03/07
  101.   Tal 22:27  |  Walid 05/03/07
  102.   TO # 29,the equalizer,to defend Sami 22:32  |  Wise Syrian 05/03/07
  103.   Voice of Reason 22:32  |  Walid 05/03/07
  104.   One butterfly does not mean spring yet. 22:45  |  Fortuna 05/03/07
  105.   #27,Yakov the hero from Ashkelon 22:46  |  Wise Syrian 05/03/07
  106.   David, and your point is??.........#98 22:48  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/03/07
  107.   Melchior 23:00  |  tadchase 05/03/07
  108.   More Delusions - Is Everybody But Bibi Taking Idiot Pills ? 23:07  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/03/07
  109.   WALID, YOU NEVER ANSWERED MY QUESTION 23:11  |  CHGODMK 05/03/07
  110.   #78 ballistic when do i get my answers ?? TO REAL QUESTIONS 23:15  |  paul harris 05/03/07
  111.   Israel in an Arab world 23:16  |  Ed Andrews 05/03/07
  112.   Islam of a different kind 23:17  |  linda herzberg 05/03/07
  113.   #20 WALID IS TOTALLY IN VALID WHICH MUSLIM HEROINES ARE CHECKING 23:19  |  paul harris 05/03/07
  114.   I`m reminded of the Dry Bones Cartoon 23:21  |  Jacob Blues 05/03/07
  115.   # 2 Walid, my friend 23:40  |  Lynn 05/03/07
  116.   #110 Hey Paul; you always ask `questions` 23:54  |  ballistic 05/03/07
  117.   Outlandish dreams 23:58  |  Rajesh 05/03/07
  118.   # 107 Tadchase 00:25  |  ChanahS 06/03/07
  119.   #116 BALLISTIC AND MORE HORSE MANURE 00:27  |  paul harris 06/03/07
  120.   Walid: Where Are You? 00:33  |  CHGODMK 06/03/07
  121.   Walid # 100 00:35  |  ChanahS 06/03/07
  122.   #48 Walid 00:51  |  Alex 06/03/07
  123.   #66 Walid 00:56  |  Alex 06/03/07
  124.   "Radical Islam is the Problem Moderate Islam is the Solution" 01:47  |  Jane 06/03/07
  125.   #119 The international community is EVERYBODY 01:56  |  ballistic 06/03/07
  126.   Thank you Rabbi Melchior! 02:10  |  Yonatan Netser 06/03/07
  127.   Mr. Melchior a Voice of Reason 02:13  |  Brian Freund 06/03/07
  128.   the son as father, both enemies of the jews 02:20  |  vladimir 06/03/07
  129.   @9, thanks cretin ravi from punjab for your 02:26  |  victor 06/03/07
  130.   @12, walid, i agree , there is not enough checkpoints. 02:29  |  vladimir 06/03/07
  131.   Walid, #103, even if you`re 99% right, you`re still all wrong 02:31  |  Voice of Reason 06/03/07
  132.   118 ChanahS 02:32  |  tadchase 06/03/07
  133.   @13, steven, i believe you, it is typical for arabs 02:32  |  vladimir 06/03/07
  134.   @14, steven, thanks a lot, i did not know that. 02:34  |  vladimir 06/03/07
  135.   Walid: Where Are You? (Second Cry in the Wilderness) 03:32  |  CHGODMK 06/03/07
  136.   ballistic 03:45  |  Lynn 06/03/07
  137.   Wise Syrian 03:52  |  Lynn 06/03/07
  138.   #128 Lynn; I suspect they will have 04:28  |  ballistic 06/03/07
  139.   #133 the reason is... 05:04  |  Alex 06/03/07
  140.   Nothing new 05:44  |  Spider 06/03/07
  141.   Spider - There is a systemic and consistent attitute 06:34  |  Geulah 06/03/07
  142.   #138 Well, alrightee, another opinion 06:39  |  ballistic 06/03/07
  143.   Spider 06:41  |  CHGODMK 06/03/07
  144.   # 72, LYNN 06:49  |  indrajaya 06/03/07
  145.   The ladder to peace. 07:28  |  sandra chitayat 06/03/07
  146.   Let`s See What Saudi Arabia Can Do 07:48  |  Yosemite 06/03/07
  147.   # 9 ---Ravi 09:15  |  Raj 06/03/07
  148.   # 40--Walid 09:24  |  Raj 06/03/07
  149.   #111, Ed Andrews. So far your accusation turns against you 1. 13:41  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  150.   Hope for peace 13:59  |  Allan Goldstein 06/03/07
  151.   #147, Raj. Absurdity contest 14:16  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  152.   #111, Ed Andrews. So far your accusation turns against you 2. 14:32  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  153.   To Zmogus - Palestinians as refugees 14:56  |  Ed Andrews 06/03/07
  154.   one more to Zmogus 15:00  |  Ed Andrews 06/03/07
  155.   sorry one more zmogus 15:06  |  Ed Andrews 06/03/07
  156.   zmogus #2 15:32  |  Ed Andrews 06/03/07
  157.   #153, Ed Andrews. Don`t embarrass Israel with the sensitive point 16:07  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  158.   zmogus 157 16:26  |  Ed Andrews 06/03/07
  159.   #153, Ed Andrews. This question is briefly answered in ... 16:37  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  160.   #158, Ed Andrews. Taking credit and profit at the same time? 17:59  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  161.   zmogus #160 18:51  |  Ed 06/03/07
  162.   #161, Ed Andrews. I will surely answer concrete questions 19:26  |  zmogus 06/03/07
  163.   zmogus I am trying to be thoughtful 14:59  |  Ed Andrews 07/03/07
  164.   #163, Ed Andrews. Regarding question #111. (1) 12:21  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  165.   #163, Ed Andrews. Regarding question #111. (2) 12:50  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  166.   #163, Ed Andrews, regarding question #153 14:37  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  167.   #163, Ed Andrews. Regarding question #154 14:49  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  168.   #163, Ed Andrews, Regarding question #158 15:04  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  169.   #163, Ed Andrews. Regarding implied questions #155/156 15:17  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  170.   #163, Ed Andrews. Regarding the "Palestinians` fault" accusation 15:30  |  zmogus 08/03/07
  171.   #170 17:13  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  172.   #164 - to whom should Israel be compared? 17:16  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  173.   #163 17:18  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  174.   166 citizenship 17:20  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  175.   167 refugees 17:23  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  176.   168 17:26  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  177.   169 18:50  |  Ed Andrews 08/03/07
  178.   92: Poor Walid, he hates it that the truth`s like "fly-paper" 09:30  |  David Teich 11/03/07
  179.   Drink the glass half full, and more will be given! 17:19  |  Ivar 14/03/07
 Today Online
Danny Rubinstein: No Palestinian state without East J'lem
Responses: 123
Peace Now: 32% of settlement land is owned by Palestinians
Responses: 82
Egyptian FM demands Israel probe alleged 1967 POW killings
Responses: 62
Solana: EU backs Syrian aim to regain Golan Heights
Responses: 37
Controversial Israeli song allowed into Eurovision contest
Responses: 31
Israeli firm says seaweed could help solve energy crisis
Responses: 34


More Headlines
15:34 Solana: EU supports Syrian initiative to regain Golan Heights
16:30 Hamas: MPs to vote Saturday on Palestinian unity government
11:16 Peace Now: 32% of land held for settlements is private Palestinian property
17:02 Anti-Semitic incidents down in U.S. for second straight year
15:50 U.S. ambassador: We won't stop Israel from talking to Syria
16:44 Russia: Late payments may irreversibly harm Iran nuclear plant construction
16:26 Poland's Senate honors woman who saved 2,500 Jews from Holocaust
12:39 Controversial Israeli song allowed into Eurovision contest
12:51 Kadima Council to meet amid fears of early election, PM ouster
12:54 Hungarian prosecutors investigating man suspected of WWII crimes
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved