Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., October 13, 2008 Tishrei 14, 5769 | | Israel Time: 03:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Rosner's Blog
Shmuel Rosner Chief U.S. Correspondent www.haaretz.com/rosner Biography | Email me
Posted:

Obama supports Israel. Period.

Barack Obama's big speech on Israel is now over, and as expected, the candidate made no secret of his support and dedication to the special relationship between the U.S. and Israel. "My view is that the United States' special relationship with Israel obligates us to be helpful to them in the search for credible partners with whom they can make peace, while also supporting Israel in defending itself against enemies sworn to its destruction," were Obama's words to Haaretz last week. Today, he sounded as strong as Clinton, as supportive as Bush, as friendly as Giuliani. At least rhetorically, Obama passed any test anyone might have wanted him to pass. So, he is pro-Israel. Period.

Iran

"The kinds of communications that he would engage in and the pressure he envisions on Iran may differ in some respect from the other candidates," an adviser to Barack Obama told the NY Sun yesterday. And in the speech he made today, in Chicago, Obama showed his cards. He was clear, but not as tough as Edwards' "Let me be clear: Under no circumstances can Iran be allowed to have nuclear weapons" or Clinton's "we cannot, we should not, we must not permit Iran to build or acquire nuclear weapons."

Here's what Obama said: "The world must work to stop Iran's uranium enrichment program and prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. It is far too dangerous to have nuclear weapons in the hands of a radical theocracy. And while we should take no option, including military action, off the table, sustained and aggressive diplomacy combined with tough sanctions should be our primary means to prevent Iran from building nuclear weapons."

As I wrote for Slate last week, I don't believe there's a big difference between Democrats and Republicans in regards to Iran-policy. Nevertheless, Obama today sounded somewhat different, more cautious, than the 2004 Obama I quoted at the end of that Slate piece: "In light of the fact that we're now in Iraq, with all the problems in terms of perceptions about America that have been created, us launching some missile strikes into Iran is not the optimal position for us to be in ... On the other hand, having a radical Muslim theocracy in possession of nuclear weapons is worse. So I guess my instinct would be to err on not having those weapons in the possession of the ruling clerics of Iran."

Speech

On engaging Iran: "We need the United States to lead tough-minded diplomacy. This includes direct engagement with Iran similar to the meetings we conducted with the Soviets at the height of the Cold War."

On stopping Iran: "Tough-minded diplomacy would include real leverage through stronger sanctions. It would mean more determined U.S diplomacy at the United Nations. It would mean harnessing the collective power of our friends in Europe who are Iran's major trading partners. It would mean a cooperative strategy with Gulf States who supply Iran with much of the energy resources it needs. It would mean unifying those states to recognize the threat of Iran and increase pressure on Iran to suspend uranium enrichment. It would mean full implementation of U.S. sanctions laws. And over the long term, it would mean a focused approach from us to finally end the tyranny of oil, and developing our own alternative sources of energy to drive the price of oil down."

On Iraq and Israel: "A consequence of the Administration's failed strategy in Iraq has been to strengthen Iran's strategic position; reduce U.S. credibility and influence in the region; and place Israel and other nations friendly to the United States in greater peril."

On American aid to Israel: "We must preserve our total commitment to our unique defense relationship with Israel by fully funding military assistance and continuing work on the Arrow and related missile defense programs."

On diplomacy: "Our job is to do more than lay out another road map."

On Israel's security: "Our job is to rebuild the road to real peace and lasting security throughout the region. That effort begins with a clear and strong commitment to the security of Israel: Our strongest ally in the region and its only established democracy. That will always be my starting point."

On the Palestinian leadership: "We should all be concerned about the agreement negotiated among Palestinians in Mecca last month."

On U.S. mediation: "We should never seek to dictate what is best for the Israelis and their security interests. No Israeli prime minister should ever feel dragged to or blocked from the negotiating table by the United States" - or is that about Syria?

Rivals

Is he really as friendly to Israel as any other candidate? Yesterday, writing about Clinton and Edwards, I mentioned the fact that "the constant interest in, and the open sympathy for, Israeli affairs that is required of all important elected officials in the most Jewish of states in the U.S. has had its effect on" Clinton and Giuliani, The Israel Factor favorites. Obama doesn't have this advantage. He isn't from New York and, more importantly, is relatively new to the public sphere.

Money

It is no secret that Jewish money plays a big role in the Democratic Party. "They don't have the number [of voters], but have the means to get the voters," a prominent Democratic operative told me last week. That's why I told the told the NY Sun that "I don't think his real motive is to win votes. It's, of course, Jewish money." Will he get it? Here's one clue. Rep. Robert Wexler of Florida is going to co-chair Barack Obama's White House drive in the state. And why would Wexler do such thing? Because "I have spoken with Barack to discuss the dangers facing our ally Israel, and I am convinced there will be no stronger supporter of Israel than President Obama", his statement says. It "appears as Obama plans a big day on March 25 of fundraising in Florida, where he will be looking for help from the Jewish Democratic donor community", writes Lynn Sweet of the Chicago Sun Times today.

Conclusion

So, did Obama achieve his goal? Sorry, but I will have to repeat here what I wrote just a week ago. It is as true today as it was then: "After talking to people about him all week, I can tell you this: They very much want to be persuaded that Obama should win their backing, as they all understand the excitement and enthusiasm surrounding his candidacy and the importance of Obama adding his voice to the camp of Israel supporters. With such an attitude, it is relatively easy to be convinced."

  1.   I`ll donate money to his campaign 23:42  |  Gregory 02/03/07
  2.   all roads.... 23:42  |  ahad aham 02/03/07
  3.   Obama 23:54  |  Wesley D. Marshall 02/03/07
  4.   pop up ads 23:55  |  Tom Bottman 02/03/07
  5.   Obama 00:36  |  Lloyd 03/03/07
  6.   Obama 00:36  |  Lloyd 03/03/07
  7.   Ridiculous 00:47  |  Shmuel Lapwitz 03/03/07
  8.   Money people? 00:55  |  ljm 03/03/07
  9.   Hillary`s Man 01:19  |  ivan 03/03/07
  10.   Promises, Promises 01:28  |  Rachael 03/03/07
  11.   Barack Hussein doesn`t have a clue ... 01:29  |  Rapid Robert 03/03/07
  12.   Watch for... 01:39  |  An international 03/03/07
  13.   To Lloyd 02:27  |  Tali 03/03/07
  14.   Who is Barack Obama? 04:02  |  Izzy David 03/03/07
  15.   Don`t be fooled about B.Hussain Obama 04:41  |  nic 03/03/07
  16.   to Lloyd #13 I`m amased how naive you are 04:45  |  mike 03/03/07
  17.   Evangelical`s will never support Barack Hussain Obama 04:50  |  Evangelical 03/03/07
  18.   hussain obama 04:52  |  noah 03/03/07
  19.   this article made me sick to my stomach 04:54  |  Julia 03/03/07
  20.   USA Jews only support the democrats.... 05:00  |  Aaron 03/03/07
  21.   obama supports Israel as much as he supports the war on terror 05:05  |  Avram A 03/03/07
  22.   Rosner are you on drugs??? 05:13  |  Samy 03/03/07
  23.   obama fever 05:23  |  ann coulter 03/03/07
  24.   You do not understand US Jews 06:26  |  Josh Gold 03/03/07
  25.   And they accuse Muslims of double-loyality 07:05  |  Lebanese in Canada 03/03/07
  26.   #24 - did we read the same article 07:18  |  E.G. 03/03/07
  27.   to Josh Gold 07:59  |  American Citizen 03/03/07
  28.   #25 to Lebanese in Canada 08:08  |  William 03/03/07
  29.   Well It`s Going To Be A Tough Fight 08:14  |  Yosemite 03/03/07
  30.   to #25 - "hosting countries"??? 08:37  |  Full-fledgedAmerican 03/03/07
  31.   OBAMA 09:11  |  Bill Stern 03/03/07
  32.   #5 Lloyd 10:22  |  Juan Perez 03/03/07
  33.   #16 Mike you have...... 10:26  |  Juan 03/03/07
  34.   Bill Stern, silly man 10:47  |  bbl 03/03/07
  35.   Yosemite #29 -- Vote your conscience 10:51  |  bbl 03/03/07
  36.   BARACK HUSSEIN OBAMA WILL NEVER BE PRESIDENT 11:09  |  PhiloEvraios 03/03/07
  37.   Obama is Christian 14:40  |  JEE 03/03/07
  38.   Obama 15:47  |  Stew 03/03/07
  39.   To American Citizen: Who`s a Traitor? 16:36  |  Josh Gold 03/03/07
  40.   What is this Business of "Special Relationship"? 16:56  |  Steven Grumman 03/03/07
  41.   Senator Barack Obama 17:41  |  Steve 03/03/07
  42.   Darkness that Cannot be Overcome by the Light 18:11  |  Rachael 03/03/07
  43.   Like Named..Like Minded 18:16  |  Rachael 03/03/07
  44.   Obama supports Israel. Period. 20:43  |  Jakoba Rabin 03/03/07
  45.   Shmuel Lapwitz and others 21:46  |  Lowell 03/03/07
  46.   To Josh Gold #39 23:01  |  Lowell 03/03/07
  47.   Not in New York but... 00:00  |  Joshua 04/03/07
  48.   Obama like like most African Americans 00:44  |  John Isenhower 04/03/07
  49.   Obama is the times they are a changing 02:07  |  margaret 04/03/07
  50.   #17 Evangelical 02:11  |  margaret 04/03/07
  51.   #31 02:13  |  margaret 04/03/07
  52.   #5 Lloyd 02:20  |  margaret 04/03/07
  53.   2% Intelligent Thinkers Better Than Pie in the Sky 04:19  |  Rachael 04/03/07
  54.   "margaret" 07:28  |  Gary Rosen 04/03/07
  55.   Obama 07:29  |  P. J. Casey 04/03/07
  56.   TailGating 08:29  |  Canis Major 04/03/07
  57.   #56 Tail: A Weed by Any Other Name... 13:32  |  Rachael 04/03/07
  58.   BBL 16:25  |  Bill Stern 04/03/07
  59.   #57 16:57  |  Canis Major 04/03/07
  60.   More Smoking? 17:59  |  Rachael 04/03/07
  61.   Obama not a friend of Israel... 18:24  |  Thomas 04/03/07
  62.   Rachel #53 19:09  |  margaret 04/03/07
  63.   Rosen #54 19:13  |  margaret 04/03/07
  64.   Bill Stern #58 pork eating Obama 19:20  |  margaret 04/03/07
  65.   barbosity 19:47  |  barbosa 04/03/07
  66.   barbosity 19:55  |  barbosa 04/03/07
  67.   This is what is going to happen 20:07  |  Tulip 04/03/07
  68.   John Eisenhower, Obama´s father was muslim 20:08  |  Tulip 04/03/07
  69.   Margaret, think about your heart 20:11  |  Tulip 04/03/07
  70.   You So Misjudge Americans 20:31  |  Rachael 04/03/07
  71.   Experience is Hopefully Not Always the Best Teacher 22:47  |  Rachael 04/03/07
  72.   Obama in Selma 23:22  |  margaret 04/03/07
  73.   #30 fully fledged american 23:45  |  Racon-tour 04/03/07
  74.   Margaret, Obama is a muslim 23:47  |  Tulip 04/03/07
  75.   margaret 00:03  |  Al 05/03/07
  76.   Show Biz 00:14  |  Rachael 05/03/07
  77.   At least rhetorically.... 00:27  |  Blogowitz 05/03/07
  78.   #64 Margeret 01:07  |  Racon-tour 05/03/07
  79.   Giuliani or McCain? 01:30  |  Sleven 05/03/07
  80.   There goes my vote 02:17  |  leslie duffey 05/03/07
  81.   #60 02:47  |  Arthur 05/03/07
  82.   tulip #74 03:27  |  margaret 05/03/07
  83.   Al #75 03:28  |  margaret 05/03/07
  84.   Your New Homeland 04:36  |  Rachael 05/03/07
  85.   Rosner`s Analysis is Sorely Lacking 05:22  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/03/07
  86.   Obama Might Be Great! Know Why? 06:15  |  Yosemite 05/03/07
  87.   loves Israel Ha Ha HA 06:20  |  Brian 05/03/07
  88.   Here`s an idear dont vote 07:18  |  Jakoba Rabin 05/03/07
  89.   Israel is toxic to the US 07:20  |  No support 05/03/07
  90.   margaret from nyc re. #17 evangelical 07:56  |  maria 05/03/07
  91.   margaret.....obama`s mother isn`t a christian. 07:59  |  maria 05/03/07
  92.   what...you are a jew. 08:03  |  maria 05/03/07
  93.   margaret...you really turn against your country and people. 08:11  |  maria 05/03/07
  94.   margaret....about obama 08:30  |  maria 05/03/07
  95.   Margaret and lies 15:52  |  Tulip 05/03/07
  96.   maria & margaret 15:56  |  Tulip 05/03/07
  97.   #96 Tulip 19:41  |  margaret 05/03/07
  98.   Jews love Obama 00:28  |  Izzy David 06/03/07
  99.   Evangelicals do support Obama 02:51  |  Zeje 06/03/07
  100.   To Yosemite 02:56  |  Zeje 06/03/07
  101.   #99 & 100 Zeje 04:32  |  Rachael 06/03/07
  102.   Zeje 07:30  |  Yosemite 06/03/07
  103.   obama 08:29  |  brend 06/03/07