Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., March 03, 2007 Adar 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 01:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Six comments on the situation
By Yoel Marcus

1. Why waste our breath? That's been the Likud way, from Sharon to Olmert: Jobs for votes. We'll see what Winograd has to say, and get ready for early elections.

2. A commission of inquiry operates very much like the Supreme Court. It hears testimony, analyzes evidence and issues verdicts. Beyond what goes on during work sessions, it is not customary for retired judges to set themselves up as media commentators, or to add or detract from the judgments handed down by their colleagues or themselves. The Agranat Commission, the saddest and most well-known of all commissions of inquiry, said what it said, rocked the country and was disbanded. In all this time, Agranat has not commented in the media, let alone shared with us the apocalyptic thoughts that no doubt passed through his head during those days. Vardi Zeiler of the Zeiler Commission did a good job. But since then, he has become a media star, churning out apocalyptic predictions and dire warnings that the end is near. Let him leave something for Winograd, for God's sake.

3. The story that appeared in London's Sunday Telegraph, claiming that Israel is seeking for the United States to establish an "air corridor" in the event of an attack on Iran, calls for an explanation. Either it's a leak from an American source or a fabrication. The main thing is that Israel absolutely cannot get involved in any such attack - not in initiating it, not in pushing for it, and certainly not in hitching a ride on it, as Europe looks on and denounces us to the high heavens. With all due respect to Israeli airpower, Iran is better left to the big guys. And once we're talking about air corridors, better we should start with Ben-Gurion Airport, where two passenger planes just missed one another while landing the other day.

Advertisement

4. Olmert says he would love to explore the possibility of an accord with Syria, but his hands are tied because America is opposed to it. In practice, Bush is the ideal alibi for whatever Olmert doesn't want to do, or cannot do. But in the history of U.S.-Israeli relations, Israel has acted without American permission at least four times: the occupation of Sinai in the Sinai Campaign of 1956; the London accord between Hussein and Peres (sabotaged by then-prime minister Yitzhak Shamir); the secret talks between Moshe Dayan and Anwar Sadat's advisor, Hassan Tohami, in Morocco, in which Dayan promised to return all of Sinai in return for an agreement, prompting Sadat's trip to Jerusalem; and the Oslo talks with the Palestine Liberation Organization. What about the hundreds of settlements and outposts Israel built despite fierce American objections? Oh, and we never gave the Americans advance warning when we bombed the Iraqi nuclear reactor either. If God wants it, even a broom can shoot without America's okay.

5. Esterina Tartman is the female version of the Talmudic bull that gores three times. Maybe she doesn't carry a whip, like Orna Banai does when she impersonates her on television, but Esterina has done a better job of turning herself into a cartoon character than Banai ever did. With all her lies and half-truths, she lost the chance of being tourism minister. Actually, if she had talked less and bragged less, she might have made it. Because the truth is, she's got something. But the real star of this tragicomedy is not Esterina. It's Avigdor Lieberman, who couldn't resist doing what he always does, i.e., launch an attack on the dictatorship known as the media. When our soldiers are being held hostage, he said, when the Iranian nuclear program poses a threat to our survival, is this the time to go checking if she worked in a bank or a kiosk on Ben Yehuda Street? Is this the time to investigate whether she was born in Israel or Birobidzhan? Is the time to go snooping around to find out if she served in the Israel Defense Forces or the Polish army? Ah, demagoguery at its finest. But what should worry us most is not Lieberman's rhetoric or the fishy appointment itself. What we ought to be worried about is the judgment of Israel's minister for strategic threats. The prime minister needs to tell the public what Lieberman has been placed in charge of, as a senior cabinet minister. Because if the strategy he's responsible for looks anything like this, we're in trouble.

6. The government convened a special meeting recently, and our ministers spent six hours listening to intelligence predictions for 2007. The reports were impressive, said Minister Eitan Cabel, but I didn't come out of there any smarter. But that's the whole trick, Minister Cabel. Since the infamous prediction on the eve of the Yom Kippur War that the war was highly unlikely, the intelligence agencies have been reporting in such a way that we don't have a clue of what we're in for.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Living with her
Ronit Yanitski, a painter, and Osnat Raziel, a surgeon, live in a rented Givatayim apartment.
The minimalist
Nahum Tevet's sculptures all begin with hundreds of hours of carpentry and painting.
  1.   Not bad, Yoel 12:46  |  S 02/03/07
  2.   Yes... 13:08  |  Somebody from Europe 02/03/07
  3.   six meaningful comments - my compliments 13:36  |  saul a. readner 02/03/07
  4.   re: iran 13:42  |  mark 02/03/07
  5.   Right now its all talk 14:50  |  Bruriah Sarah 02/03/07
  6.   #3 Mark of Toronto. 15:24  |  S 02/03/07
  7.   Marcus was proOslo, proItnatkut: So who is he to give "Aitzes"? 15:29  |  Rina 02/03/07
  8.   Yes... 15:57  |  Somebody from Europe 02/03/07
  9.   to mark 16:04  |  saul a. readner 02/03/07
  10.   to rina 16:06  |  saul a. readner 02/03/07
  11.   Just a reminder 16:14  |  Gene 02/03/07
  12.   If you dont accept Esterina Tartman as tourism minister 16:52  |  Herbert Kaine 02/03/07
  13.   Herbert Kaine 17:06  |  Somebody from Europe 02/03/07
  14.   Why? 17:08  |  Walter 02/03/07
  15.   Concerning point 1 17:12  |  Somebody from Europe 02/03/07
  16.   Mr Marcus Y 18:15  |  Simon Arzt 02/03/07
  17.   Marcus - Predictably Wrong 18:57  |  Tod Zuckerman 02/03/07
  18.   Tod Zuckerman 19:33  |  Somebody from Europe 02/03/07
  19.   WHAT BIG BOYS? 20:45  |  B 02/03/07
  20.   Why so sexist? Leave Iran to the "girls" 20:54  |  Voice of Reason 02/03/07
  21.   Esterina HAS a Degree 22:12  |  Efox 02/03/07
  22.   # 4 Mark from Toronto 22:41  |  Joe 02/03/07
  23.   GUESSING IS NOW CALLED INTELLIGENCE ?? 00:21  |  paul harris 03/03/07
  24.   Ask Libermann 02:04  |  Federico Glez 03/03/07
  25.   "Voice of reason"?? 03:34  |  Daniel 03/03/07
  26.   LEAVING THE JOB TO THE BIG BOYS.. 05:28  |  Willy 03/03/07
  27.   Is Iran a super power? 07:24  |  Guss 03/03/07
  28.   Iran left Israel for Hizbullah! 07:26  |  Universal Truth 03/03/07
  29.   Iran is better left to big guys?-HITLER was left to BIG guys.... 08:39  |  Vittorio 03/03/07
  30.   Europe fears Iran already so much... 11:45  |  Somebody from Europe 03/03/07
  31.   Remember Suez 1956? 12:03  |  Ari ben Yisrael 03/03/07
 Today Online
Israel pushes for changes to Saudi peace initiative
Responses: 499
Peres: Internal PA splits thwarting U.S. mediation
Responses: 185
Eurovision may ban Israeli song due to lyrics on nuclear war
Responses: 328
Schiff: Better to have Assad in power than Muslim Brotherhood
Responses: 101
Western intelligence worried by jihadist upsurge in Lebanon
Responses: 177
Yoav Sivan: Leftists must urge integration of non-Jews
Responses: 101


More Headlines
22:48 Salah urges Muslim states to take steps to halt 'Judaization' of Jerusalem
22:35 Peres says U.S. mediation bid stymied by internal PA divisions
20:06 Hamas presents Haniyeh with list of ministerial nominees
00:15 Ahmadinejad arrives in Saudi Arabia on first official visit
21:33 Vandals desecrate Jewish cemetery in southern Germany
15:11 In AIPAC speech, Obama repeats support for Israel, peace talks
18:00 UN sources: Security Council likely to impose harsher sanctions on Iran
21:25 Teen killed in tractor accident, 4 killed in car accidents over weekend
19:39 Petah Tikva woman, 20, in serious condition after rape attempt
23:52 Ban, Itzik meet in New York, discuss kidnapped soldiers, PA government
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved