Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., March 01, 2007 Adar 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
MK Esterina Tartman at the press conference Wednesday. (Pierre Terdjman / BauBau)
Last update - 00:49 01/03/2007
Tartman withdraws candidacy for Tourism Ministry amid scandal
By Gideon Alon, Haaretz Correspondent

MK Esterina Tartman (Yisrael Beiteinu) on Wednesday withdrew her candidacy for the post of tourism minister, following recent revelations of her disabled status and false claims about degree qualifications.

MK Yitzhak Aharonovich, and not Esterina Tartman, would now be Yisrael Beiteinu's tourism minister-designate, party chairman Avigdor Lieberman said Wednesday.

"I tried pleading with Esterina, from my point of view she is a candidate," said Lieberman, after announcing Tartman's decision in a press conference. "She decided to take a break in order to calm her family, her home, and her children. We have respected her will. I see no fault or problem in her decision to continue in her position. We accepted Attorney Dudu Rotem's proposal to presentAharonovich's candidacy."

Advertisement

Tartman blamed the media for bringing her down and adding her to the growing list of Israeli politicians mired in scandal. Party leader Avigdor Lieberman said he stood by her but respected her decision to withdraw. "I will not be broken by the media," she told a news conference, with Lieberman at her side.

Tartman told a press conference Wednesday night, "In the past few days, I have found myself in the center of a journey of incitement, ugly slander, half-truths and distortion of facts, and all in order to harm me and my good name. However, I did not break, even though m yspirit was within touch of death."

"Not once and not twice was I there," she said, referring to the unraveling of allegations against her over the last few days.

Only hours earlier, Lieberman had said that Tartman was Yisrael Beiteinu's sole candidate for the post of tourism minister.

The Yisrael Beiteinu leader slammed the media for "inflating" the issue of Tartman's false claims, saying that the media has become a "dictatorship." As far as he is concerned, the minister and party chairman said, the matter is "behind us."

The comments come after revelations that Tartman, the Tourism-Minister designate, does not hold a bachelor's degree from Bar-Ilan University or a master's degree from a Jerusalem institute, despite claims on her curriculum vitae.

"Nobody can cast doubt on our credibility," Lieberman said. "Yisrael Beiteinu is not the Shin Bet or the Civil Service Commission. I don't subject candidates to polygraph or security test."

"Sometimes mistakes happen, [but] there is loss of proportion here and intoxication on the part of the media," he said.

Tartman told the News First Class website earlier Wednesday that she didnot intend to relinquish the position of tourism minister. She also said she holds a bachelor's degree from Touro College and that she is studying for a master's degree.

Tartman told the website that she can understand what led former minister Avraham Ofer to commit suicide in 1977 amid suspicions of corruption.

"A person says unnecessary things sometimes in the heat of things," Lieberman said. "We are not rushing her anywhere. I didn't hasten my return from Russia and we aren't hiding."

Meanwhile, Tartman made preparations Tuesday for assuming the position of tourism minister, meeting with outgoing Tourism Minister Isaac Herzog. An assistant was scheduled to meet with the deputy director general of the Tourism Ministry, but the meeting was canceled.

Lieberman said he spoke with Tartman on Tuesday and Wednesday, and that "I have seen things that are completely unreasonable from the journalists' side. Keep things in proportion, guys, the soldiers are still in the field, and the Iranian nuclear bomb is still our foremost problem."

Members of the Yisrael Beiteinu Knesset faction on Tuesday expressed their "surprise and concern" at the revelations, but have refrained from issuing an official statement.

Tartman did not appear in the Knesset on Wednesday, and she was unavailable for comment throughout most of the day.

The Prime Minister's Office called the appointment "problematic" but said it would not intervene in the faction's internal matters.

"There is no known precedent in which the prime minister told another party who will be its minister," a statement from the office said.

Nonetheless, officials close to Olmert say they expected Lieberman to forestall further embarrassment and to ask Tartman to pass on the position.

In response to a request for a comment from Haaretz, a spokeswoman for Tartman said that the MK has decided not to respond to any questions on the matter at this time.

A probe by Yedioth Aharonoth into university records dating back to 1977 showed that Tartman was never a registered student nor has she ever completed studies there that would have awarded her a B.A.

It appears that Tartman had taken courses at the Center for In-Service Training, a private firm specializing in such programs. The courses are not academic and are not part of a B.A. program.

Yisrael Beitenu's Web site stated that Tartman holds "a graduate degree in economics and marketing from Hebrew University."

The Knesset Web site stated that Tartman holds an MBA with a specialization in management and marketing from the university in Jerusalem. An inquiry at the university showed that Tartman has never studied at that institution.

Once Yedioth Aharonoth reporters began their probe, however, the statement on the party's Web site was altered to say that Tartman had undertaken "graduate studies in business administration in Jerusalem." By Tuesday night, the mention of "Jerusalem" had also been removed.

Party officials said that one of the activists had made an honest mistake and wrote that Tartman is a graduate of Hebrew University, even though she had never made such claims.

But it is not only the Yisrael Beitenu activists who erred about Tartman's academic credentials. In an interview on the Knesset channel, after she was designated tourism minister, Tartman explained the reasons for which she was qualified for the job.

"Every minister needs to be knowledgeable in budgetary issues. I come with a management background... and a clear background in economics: I have a B.A. in accounting and finance, and an MBA."

Her academic credentials were also mentioned in the trial in which she sued for compensation for damages she suffered during a traffic accident a decade ago. The ruling, which appears to be based on her deposition, states that Tartman studied at Touro College in Jerusalem and received an academic degree with distinction, but does not specify whether this was a bachelor's or graduate degree.

Until recently Touro College was an extension of the New York-based institution and trained students mostly in Judaic studies.

Now the institution is a registered college in Jerusalem under the name of Lander Institute. However it is not authorized to confer MBAs.

An inquiry with the Council for Higher Learning showed that even when it was operating as Touro College the institution did not offer graduate degrees in business administration.

The Lander Institute refused to respond to Haaretz inquiries into the matter.

In an interview with Haaretz journalist Ari Shavit, aired on the Knesset channel, Tartman claimed that her ability to concentrate and her memory were harmed by the injuries suffered in the accident.

On Tuesday, the Knesset Ethics Committee decided not to take any steps against Tartman, despite harsh statements she previously made against Israeli Arabs and the ministerial appointment of Ghaleb Majadele.

The committee decided that despite the severity of Tartman's statements, there was no room for dealing with the matter any further on grounds that what she said constituted a personal worldview and did not undermine the Knesset, or its members.

Related articles:

  • Deflated Tartarina
  • Esterina Tartman's suicide mission
  • The minister and the agenda / If only there were more like her

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Timing the strike
    If the Histadrut cannot fight for salary payments, it is doubtful it even has a right to exist.
    Hasidic wedding bells
    A Hasidic dynasty wedding is a chance to examine the ultra-Orthodox public at large.
      1.   Tartman is a liar 02:20  |  newshound 28/02/07
      2.   She`s right and "Haaretz" should write about gang rapes of Jewis 03:04  |  Absolute Sweden 28/02/07
      3.   Tartman needs to be tarred and feathered and run out of Israel 03:14  |  Yossi Cronenberg 28/02/07
      4.   Tartman 06:44  |  Dave 28/02/07
      5.   She also lied on her resume 06:49  |  SJ 28/02/07
      6.   Are the rest better than her 07:09  |  KA 28/02/07
      7.   The settler "absolute sweden" defender of liars 07:12  |  Absolute honesty 28/02/07
      8.   Tartman 09:01  |  RKR 28/02/07
      9.   Titles for sale 09:43  |  H R H Prince Joseph 28/02/07
      10.   Honesty in Names Committee 09:54  |  Motic 28/02/07
      11.   Tartman 10:19  |  ChanahS 28/02/07
      12.   #10 Honesty in names 10:34  |  JW 28/02/07
      13.   #7 `The settler "absolute sweden..." ` 10:48  |  Colin Wright 28/02/07
      14.   SO WHAT???? 11:37  |  Jay A Friedman 28/02/07
      15.   @Police & prosecutors: 11:41  |  Spoon 28/02/07
      16.   WHAT`S IN A NAME?? 11:47  |  Robert 28/02/07
      17.   What "Ethics" Committee? 12:11  |  Marlene 28/02/07
      18.   Tartman is a liar and a thief 12:29  |  Maerton 28/02/07
      19.   Absolute Sweden must be drunk 12:35  |  Sakhneen_arboush 28/02/07
      20.   The disgusting Ms. Tartman 12:39  |  Big Al 28/02/07
      21.   Tartman`s degrees 12:53  |  J. CHALEFF 28/02/07
      22.   Send Sakneen jerk packing,"rape is understandable" 12:53  |  Absolute Sweden 28/02/07
      23.   Let those without sin throw the first stone 13:00  |  Chrissy K 28/02/07
      24.   If a Common Israeli Worker Did This: Sacked and No Severance Pay 13:12  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 28/02/07
      25.   The Real World? 13:13  |  Niall 28/02/07
      26.   Wow...what a light unto nations..more like darkness! 13:14  |  Tim 28/02/07
      27.   Investigate if Fraud Insurance Claims Funded Campaigns 13:17  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 28/02/07
      28.   To J. Chaleff 13:33  |  Robert 28/02/07
      29.   Marlene # 17 Where is your integrity? 13:41  |  ChanahS 28/02/07
      30.   How about "Topless Tartman on Tel Aviv Beach"poster? 13:41  |  Yacov 28/02/07
      31.   Absolute sweden has lost the plot 13:48  |  Sakhneen_arboush 28/02/07
      32.   Russian Mafia Princess? If so, Israel doesn`t need her. 14:37  |  Yacov 28/02/07
      33.   Esterina Tartman: You are fake. 14:48  |  Nora 28/02/07
      34.   Tartman 15:00  |  nancy Tamir 28/02/07
      35.   Deserving 15:05  |  Nancy Tamir 28/02/07
      36.   Lieberman..." Sometimes mistakes happen". Mistakes ?? 15:11  |  Klaudia 28/02/07
      37.   If Tartman is the Tourism minister then Israel is admitting... 15:20  |  Stephen Murray 28/02/07
      38.   Tartman 15:20  |  Roxy 28/02/07
      39.   Liebermans reaction 15:22  |  Jack 28/02/07
      40.   She`s Lovely on the Outside.... But Ugly as Sin on the Inside 15:33  |  Klaudia 28/02/07
      41.   Come on - you`d have no government in Israel 15:42  |  Clickfool 28/02/07
      42.   Hey, you`ve got a rapist for President, so? 15:55  |  Yaakov Sullivan 28/02/07
      43.   Clickfool: We Are In Trouble, So Enjoy for Now 15:55  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 28/02/07
      44.   22# 15:56  |  From the Moon 28/02/07
      45.   She`s one of the pack 15:58  |  sh 28/02/07
      46.   The next election will center about MK honesty. 16:13  |  bat yam 28/02/07
      47.   Tartman is absolutely cut out for the job - Good Luck Esterina !! 16:18  |  David Kat 28/02/07
      48.   2absolute sweden. 16:19  |  fed up!!!! 28/02/07
      49.   George Orwell`s Dream Candidate 16:21  |  Klaudia 28/02/07
      50.   Amazing ! 16:27  |  Frederique 28/02/07
      51.   Liars, theives and crooks 16:30  |  Stuart Wilder 28/02/07
      52.   Quo Vadis 16:30  |  S 28/02/07
      53.   Only In Israel 16:53  |  Timothy 28/02/07
      54.   If she has any moral decency left, she will quit 16:54  |  Alicia 28/02/07
      55.   #51 Stuart Wilder 17:15  |  Frederique 28/02/07
      56.   To#54 - Looks like we`re stuck with her 17:47  |  Jay A Friedman 28/02/07
      57.   Lieberman`s reaction 18:25  |  Regev 28/02/07
      58.   This is what Pals live in refugee camps for? 18:29  |  Tim 28/02/07
      59.   I was really going to vote for Avigdor, but now... 18:36  |  Spoon 28/02/07
      60.   Tartman for tourism Ministry 18:59  |  emile Tubiana 28/02/07
      61.   I love it... 19:00  |  Blinky the Fish 28/02/07
      62.   Clean of Hand an Pure of Heart.... 19:05  |  Baruch Nili 28/02/07
      63.   Better yet 19:07  |  Blinky the Fish 28/02/07
      64.   Outrageous Tartman 19:28  |  Esther 28/02/07
      65.   Response for Emile Tubiana #59 19:37  |  Esther 28/02/07
      66.   Tartman 19:43  |  Hilda 28/02/07
      67.   she is perfect 19:46  |  michael 28/02/07
      68.   Addendum to reponse for Emile Tubiana#60 19:50  |  Esther 28/02/07
      69.   To Esther no 65 : Tartman only Yisrael Beiteinu 20:00  |  emile Tubiana 28/02/07
      70.   The trouble with being honest is.... 20:03  |  Tim 28/02/07
      71.   Lieberman: Tartman only Yisrael Beiteinu candidate for Tourism Mi 20:08  |  Anne 28/02/07
      72.   Lieberman: Tartman only Yisrael Beiteinu candidate for Tourism Mi 20:10  |  Anne 28/02/07
      73.   Absolute corruption from the bottom up 20:13  |  Pablo B 28/02/07
      74.   We are closing the cultural gap with our neighbours 20:26  |  Ronen 28/02/07
      75.   LIEBERMAN ALREADY CHANGED HIS MIND SHE IS OUT! 20:35  |  naro 28/02/07
      76.   As a racist she is acceptable 20:36  |  Tal 28/02/07
      77.   tartman 20:37  |  monty 28/02/07
      78.   draft politicians 20:40  |  bram 28/02/07
      79.   Ok, now she is history 20:43  |  Funie 28/02/07
      80.   Corruption again and again.... 20:52  |  Chaval 28/02/07
      81.