Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., March 01, 2007 Adar 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:51 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Legitimization of land theft
By Haaretz Editorial

The theft of private land and lawless construction, with the authorities' collaboration, have long been routine in the land of the settlers. The scope of these deeds and their seriousness are described extensively in the report on illegal outposts compiled by Talia Sasson, formerly a senior state prosecution attorney. The report was buried almost two years ago.

However, the decision of the Supreme Planning Council (SPC) for Judea and Samaria, which was revealed in Haaretz on Sunday, to legitimize the plan to build the Matityahu East neighborhood in Modi'in Ilit, beyond the Green Line, marks a nadir.

The plan is to legitimize 42 high-rises, which are in various stages of construction, some of them on land allegedly stolen from the villagers of Bil'in. All of the high-rises being built contravene the planning and construction laws. Peace Now and Bil'in's residents petitioned the High Court of Justice two years ago to have construction stopped. The legal counsel of Modi'in Ilit warned in writing of "construction offenses of such colossal proportions, ignoring the law and planning regulations, that words cannot describe [them]."

Advertisement

Following the petition, with the support of the State Prosecution, the High Court ordered a halt to construction and to the neighborhood's occupancy more than a year ago. At that time the prosecution instructed the police to open an investigation into those involved in the affair.

The authorities responsible for enforcing the region's planning and building laws knew what was going on and turned a blind eye. Instead, they recently decided to legitimize it retroactively.

Matityahu East is the latest in a series of such affairs in which the separation barrier, supposedly serving Israel's security needs, is used to annex West Bank territory to expand the settlements. The defense minister is dragging his feet on everything concerning the evacuation of illegal outposts. At the same time, bodies he is responsible for - led by the civil administration - are colluding in land grabbing and legitimizing illegal construction throughout the West Bank.

Attorney General Menachem Mazuz is not fulfilling his duty by publicly denouncing the anarchy in the territories in everything concerning law enforcement. He must demand that the defense minister halt the implementation of the SPC's plan until the inquiry into suspicions of land theft is completed.

The scope of the offenses and the advanced stages of building and selling of apartments most not provide shelter for scofflaws. Peace Now is to be commended for its legal aid to Bil'in residents - as are the Israeli and international peace activists who come every week to demonstrate against the fence being built there.

The High Court did not hesitate to halt the construction in Matityahu East until the planning procedures and inquiry into the ownership issue could be completed. If the government does not quash the planning council's decision to allow construction to continue, the High Court will have no choice but to respond to the recent petition. It will have to abrogate that decision, to protect both the rule of law and the rights of those victimized by its breach.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Timing the strike
If the Histadrut cannot fight for salary payments, it is doubtful it even has a right to exist.
Hasidic wedding bells
A Hasidic dynasty wedding is a chance to examine the ultra-Orthodox public at large.
<
  1.   ANTI-SEMITE GOT THE POINT 08:48  |  indrajaya 27/02/07
  2.   Well, Israel itself is a huge theft 08:55  |  KA 27/02/07
  3.   Steal the land while you can 08:57  |  spyguy 27/02/07
  4.   land theft 09:00  |  kevin 27/02/07
  5.   #3 spyguy 09:29  |  Racon-tour 27/02/07
  6.   Thank you Haaretz and it`s ABOUT TIME! 09:38  |  Joe 27/02/07
  7.   No one will live there soon. 09:43  |  Deborah 27/02/07
  8.   Israels society, or when the "hostage" seems to accept her fate 09:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  9.   Israelis should be glad that Joe from Ramallah is here..... 10:19  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  10.   Settler-terrorist land grab 10:28  |  Mitch Cohen 27/02/07
  11.   Religious Jews 10:42  |  Sam 27/02/07
  12.   Thieves 10:50  |  David 27/02/07
  13.   Israeli soil 10:50  |  Josef 27/02/07
  14.   Haaretz: Print the truth about massive Arab land theft 10:57  |  Yacov 27/02/07
  15.   #1 Indrajaya: So when are you Muslims giving back stolen land 11:00  |  Yacov 27/02/07
  16.   keep ignoring the real problem!!!! 11:08  |  dr eric 27/02/07
  17.   Retroactive legitimization 11:39  |  sh 27/02/07
  18.   To the editors. 11:45  |  M. Franks-Lhermann 27/02/07
  19.   # 17 sh 11:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  20.   Thanks Haaretz 12:01  |  Walid 27/02/07
  21.   # 16 dr eric 12:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  22.   "Haaretz" already knows what the High Court would say. 12:09  |  Absolute Sweden 27/02/07
  23.   Yacov 12:11  |  Walid 27/02/07
  24.   Dr. Eric 12:22  |  Walid 27/02/07
  25.   Haaretz is the mouthpiece of extremist leftwing P....-Now 12:27  |  Matthias Roth 27/02/07
  26.   TO KA 12:28  |  Nicole 27/02/07
  27.   Haaretz should watch their use of common English ---to be a thief 12:29  |  Sal 27/02/07
  28.   TO DR ERIC 12:30  |  Nicole 27/02/07
  29.   TO DAVID 12:40  |  Nicole 27/02/07
  30.   Dino - Israel did that already!!! 12:48  |  DR eric 27/02/07
  31.   no problem 13:00  |  hadrian 27/02/07
  32.   Israelis are writing themselves into history 13:04  |  Dutch 27/02/07
  33.   I agree with you number 7 13:16  |  Alissa 27/02/07
  34.   Re #13: Exactly right!! 13:19  |  Matthias Roth 27/02/07
  35.   Swiss Dino 13:21  |  sh 27/02/07
  36.   steal and be damned 13:21  |  ravi 27/02/07
  37.   Re #3: Study the Torah 13:25  |  Matthias Roth 27/02/07
  38.   M. Franks-Lhermann - kindly check your maps 13:37  |  Skandar 27/02/07
  39.   # 30 Dr eric 13:47  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  40.   Every brick is a nail in the coffin of the peace process 13:55  |  Tzfonit 27/02/07
  41.   # 35 sh 13:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  42.   Sal 13:59  |  Walid 27/02/07
  43.   A very fine editorial 14:00  |  Johnboy 27/02/07
  44.   # 25 Matthias Roth 14:15  |  Josef 27/02/07
  45.   Matthias Roth - what message did the king of the universe 14:17  |  Skandar 27/02/07
  46.   #7 14:17  |  alonitzafoni 27/02/07
  47.   # 36 ravi 14:21  |  Josef 27/02/07
  48.   Its time for the lawyers to step in... 14:22  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/02/07
  49.   1# indrijaya 14:22  |  alonitzafoni 27/02/07
  50.   Swiss (Dino) 14:40  |  Walid 27/02/07
  51.   swiss dino 14:43  |  alonitzafoni 27/02/07
  52.   Haaretz: Is OPPOSITE of fair & balanced!!!!!!!!!! 14:47  |  Yoni 27/02/07
  53.   Tzfonit 14:48  |  Walid 27/02/07
  54.   Instead of suicide bombers....... 14:54  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/02/07
  55.   Where is says "Do not steal" it also says "Do not lie" 15:01  |  Ilan 27/02/07
  56.   Peace Now is a Foreign Entity 15:03  |  Harry Levy 27/02/07
  57.   # 50 Walid 15:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  58.   I`m beginning to wonder about haaretz 15:10  |  Sam Weinstein 27/02/07
  59.   # 51 alonitzafoni 15:12  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/02/07
  60.   Has no one every played CHESS 15:15  |  albert amato 27/02/07
  61.   #2 and #3: Israel is one big stolen property 15:19  |  Amitai B. 27/02/07
  62.   LAND CANNOT BE STOLEN 15:38  |  B 27/02/07
  63.   Walid #42 15:39  |  Gabe1 27/02/07
  64.   100 billion DOLLAR PROPERTY THEFT IN 1948 15:50  |  B 27/02/07
  65.   Ronnie #46 15:50  |  Gabe1 27/02/07
  66.   Frankenstein 15:51  |  Danite 27/02/07
  67.   Now a conservative nation 15:59  |  Mark Lincoln 27/02/07
  68.   Yoni in Jeruselum 16:00  |  Marilyn 27/02/07
  69.   Yacov - Two Wrongs Don`t Make a Right 16:00  |  Jane 27/02/07
  70.   STUPID EDITOR LEARN YOUR HISTORY.... 16:02  |  Emess 27/02/07
  71.   16, and they took the land, that the lord had given to them, 16:19  |  Fritz 27/02/07
  72.   Swiss (Dino) on questions of taste 16:27  |  sh 27/02/07
  73.   # 47 Josef 16:29  |  SAM 27/02/07
  74.   What This Calls for Is.... 16:30  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/02/07
  75.   Dear Noble Haaretz, IT WOULD BE FAR WISER... 16:31  |  Dutch 27/02/07
  76.   Arafat`s printing presses, phony deeds and "Arab" land 16:39  |  Yacov 27/02/07
  77.   ravi talks nonsense. 16:41  |  dimple kapadia 27/02/07
  78.   Tzfonit 16:45  |  Walid 27/02/07
  79.   theft of land is criminal. 16:52  |  azagury 27/02/07
  80.   Yoni 16:52  |  Walid 27/02/07
  81.   Simple Solution... 16:59  |  Ibrahim 27/02/07
  82.   Tzfonit #40 17:04  |  Gabe1 27/02/07
  83.   B and inheritance 17:06  |  StephenConnor 27/02/07
  84.   Yacov`s phony deeds 17:09  |  StephenConnor 27/02/07
  85.   Walid #76 17:13  |  Gabe1 27/02/07
  86.   Emess, you are time travelling mate 17:15  |  Marilyn 27/02/07
  87.   Gabe1 and His Need for Annihilation #82 17:18  |  Yaakov Sullivan