Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 27, 2007 Adar 9, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:00 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
In the heart of Palestinian consensus
By Danny Rubinstein

Forty years after the Six-Day War, the Palestinian attitude that has become consolidated toward the State of Israel is quite clear: It is possible and necessary to achieve an agreement for coexistence with Israel on the basis of the 1967 borders. Israelis who think it is possible to reach an accord with the Palestinians that includes annexation of settlement blocs in the West Bank or leaves East Jerusalem under Israeli jurisdiction are deluding themselves. In all the decades that have passed since occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, not a single Palestinian voice has been heard that agrees to less than that. Of course, there have been those who demanded more, and even today some want to destroy Israel entirely, but no Palestinian will agree to allow Israel to annex even one meter beyond the boundaries of the Green Line.

If one can speak of any power to this Palestinian position, it stems from the fact that it enjoys total public consensus. Aside from a few isolated exceptions, all Palestinians adhere to one position that the Palestinian state will be established within the 1967 borders and that East Jerusalem will be its capital. Of course, it is possible to speak about differences between the political approaches of the Hamas and Fatah movements regarding profound ideological gaps: Hamas' leadership is, under no circumstances, willing to recognize Israel, while Fatah is. But this can be viewed as differences in principle that lack any practical significance.

Fatah is ready for a peace agreement, while Hamas is ready only for a long-term cease-fire. Should an issue be made of that? We have very successful peace agreements with Egypt and Jordan, although, practically speaking, they are not much more than cease-fire agreements. And in general, if there is absolute quiet within the borders of Israel and Palestine, and that is called a cease-fire rather than peace, not a single Israeli will complain.

Advertisement

We can ponder that in light of the major effort being made by Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, and even more by Hamas leader Khaled Meshal, to prove to the entire world that the Mecca agreement for establishing a Palestinian unity government is a historical turning point. Meshal, who is scheduled to arrive for a visit to Moscow today, declared in Cairo at the end of the week that the Mecca agreement is: "A message of peace to the entire region." He called on the United States and Europe to recognize the existence of the new Palestine that was born in Mecca, and spoke of a Palestinian state to be established within the 1967 borders. When asked if that means recognition of Israel, he was evasive. Although Meshal is about to visit Tehran this week as well, the Palestinian leadership is talking about Hamas coming closer to the Arab world, and about tensions and suspicions between Hamas and Iran - all as a result of the Mecca agreement.

The Palestinian consensus regarding an agreement within the 1967 borders is strongly reinforced by the Arab position in support of it. A Spanish-Arab summit in which representatives of 19 Arab countries participated took place in Madrid last weekend. The announcement that emerged from there confirmed the decision of the Arab summit regarding peace, normalization and the establishment of full relations between the Arabs and Israel after Israel's withdrawal to the 1967 borders. Apparently most of the Palestinian public believes this is possible. In light of the Madrid announcement, a journalist from East Jerusalem said that if there are 22 Arab embassies in West Jerusalem, he is certain that the peace agreement will be stable.

What spoils the optimistic picture is the refugee problem and the right of return. But this is a relatively minor problem relative to the Israeli situation that has been created since 1967, which prevents us from even thinking about a return to the Green Line in general, and to Jerusalem in particular.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Patent gender
Israeli women invent wonderful things, but because of patent laws, they don't profit.
New York style
Tzameret Park, a new luxury neighborhood, arises from a desolate hill in Tel Aviv.
  1.   Liar Rubinstein,pal "right of return" a "minor problem"?!!! 14:03  |  Absolute Sweden 26/02/07
  2.   Time to pack up 14:15  |  Naftush 26/02/07
  3.   Rubinstein believes in land for terror camps 14:17  |  Dan Patton 26/02/07
  4.   Asking for a Do-Over 14:39  |  George Kaplan 26/02/07
  5.   1967 cease fire lines 14:50  |  chaim grosz 26/02/07
  6.   Sorry Rubinstein,it was jerk Rabin & Co conning you and the rest 14:56  |  Absolute Sweden 26/02/07
  7.   to Kaplan, Absolute etc - it`s not returning to 1967 at all 14:57  |  SD 26/02/07
  8.   #1 you know you`re misrepresenting him. 15:39  |  Rebekah S 26/02/07
  9.   22 embassies 15:48  |  Ben Marx 26/02/07
  10.   PALs do not want no matter size- so answer is... 15:55  |  Rafi 26/02/07
  11.   Agreement for coexistence?? 16:06  |  Justin B 26/02/07
  12.   Poor Danny 16:13  |  Dr. Robert Frosch 26/02/07
  13.   Civil War 16:14  |  Yisrael 26/02/07
  14.   And no other honest person elsewhere 16:22  |  Fritz 26/02/07
  15.   Thank you insane Mr. Rubinstein. 16:24  |  Omar 26/02/07
  16.   Mr Danny Rubinstein.Very good assessment. 16:25  |  Bradley 26/02/07
  17.   1967 borders 16:28  |  dima 26/02/07
  18.   Pre-67 16:32  |  David 26/02/07
  19.   absoluteSWeden#1.Mr Rubinstein is correct. 16:42  |  Arik. 26/02/07
  20.   #2Naftush. Yes SIR, time to pack up.. 16:45  |  Becky 26/02/07
  21.   Dan#3. What Kahane & Hamas said. 17:00  |  Brad 26/02/07
  22.   #George 17:06  |  Fred 26/02/07
  23.   Palestinians open to the idea of land swaps? 17:08  |  newageblues 26/02/07
  24.   And the world agrees 17:14  |  Marilyn 26/02/07
  25.   The Ultimate Aim 17:16  |  Dr. Stan Seidner 26/02/07
  26.   So what if Danny is 70? 17:21  |  Marilyn 26/02/07
  27.   No Palestinian will accept 1948 lines either 17:25  |  Gili 26/02/07
  28.   67 armistice line are not peace lines, but racist lines 17:32  |  David 26/02/07
  29.   Rubinstein, Rubinstein, Rubinstein... 17:57  |  Mike 26/02/07
  30.   Rubinstein is using Amir Peretz`s binoculars! 18:01  |  Dr. L. Brnd 26/02/07
  31.   1967 18:07  |  Serge 26/02/07
  32.   Land swap 18:12  |  ariel 26/02/07
  33.   Denial 18:15  |  Amir 26/02/07
  34.   Refreshing 18:24  |  Matt 26/02/07
  35.   David in Boston 18:38  |  Marilyn 26/02/07
  36.   #8, good post 18:39  |  newageblues 26/02/07
  37.   Palestine and the partition 18:40  |  Marilyn 26/02/07
  38.   Israeli soil 18:51  |  Josef 26/02/07
  39.   #28, Jews can stay in the West Bank 18:55  |  newageblues 26/02/07
  40.   #18.David.This is going to be a painful issue. 18:59  |  Aaron 26/02/07
  41.   Yes Hamas MUSTrecognize Israel. 19:10  |  Fairman 26/02/07
  42.   #25.Dr SS. Please wake up 19:17  |  Mireille 26/02/07
  43.   Well said Marilyn 19:19  |  Matt 26/02/07
  44.   #26 Marilyn. Nice to read your statements. 19:22  |  Bessy 26/02/07
  45.   Gilli.27)) I agree with you 19:29  |  Chantal 26/02/07
  46.   Even 2 states! 19:36  |  Inyaki 26/02/07
  47.   #David 28.The UN should make J`LEM as 19:44  |  Angelina 26/02/07
  48.   what a joke article ! 20:04  |  David 26/02/07
  49.   only force? 20:06  |  arab 26/02/07
  50.   Kotel 20:09  |  Jeffrey Blustein 26/02/07
  51.   Between the lines 20:29  |  Andrew 26/02/07
  52.   To #49 "arab" 20:37  |  Reuven 26/02/07
  53.   Peace talks and bombs 20:37  |  shulamit 26/02/07
  54.   "right of return" a minor problem ??? 20:43  |  David G 26/02/07
  55.   #47, Angelina. Would you make London, DC, intl cities? 20:47  |  David 26/02/07
  56.   #35, Marilyn, 800,000 Arabs driven into the sea??? 20:48  |  newageblues 26/02/07
  57.   Not getting a state anytime soon, so who cares? 20:55  |  Observer 26/02/07
  58.   #48, David, I`ll tell you why Hamas won 21:05  |  newageblues 26/02/07
  59.   No reasons to panic 21:09  |  Simon the J 26/02/07
  60.   Marilyn #37, you just keep making up facts as you go 21:17  |  Dr. L. Brnd 26/02/07
  61.   A new portion of leftist delusional garbage courtesy of Haaretz 21:23  |  Roni 26/02/07
  62.   Palestine/Israel 21:36  |  Naim S. Mahlab 26/02/07
  63.   Palestinian consensus 22:02  |  Mike Brown 26/02/07
  64.   Danny Rubenstein 22:05  |  goldie klugman 26/02/07
  65.   to arab #49 22:12  |  Mike Brown 26/02/07
  66.   Mariyln#35 claim of "800,000 arabs driven into the sea"? 22:18  |  Dr. L. Brnd 26/02/07
  67.   Marilyn #24 22:33  |  Avi Yerushalmi 26/02/07
  68.   Israel doesn`t want peace unless it agrees to 67 borders. 22:43  |  Deborah 26/02/07
  69.   history 22:44  |  rico 26/02/07
  70.   David G`s solution 22:46  |  Bob 26/02/07
  71.   Geneva Accords - Pals agree to leave settlement blocs in place 23:05  |  David 26/02/07
  72.   israel 23:17  |  dan 26/02/07
  73.   Like Moscow-Berlin 1939 23:22  |  Lucho 26/02/07
  74.   A sober and realistic assessment 00:37  |  Ben Alofs 27/02/07
  75.   #26 00:43  |  Moshe 27/02/07
  76.   "Refugees" are not the minor problem 01:23  |  Jonathan 27/02/07
  77.   Danny Rubinstein 07:50  |  simon 27/02/07
  78.   Green Line?? 08:10  |  Matt 27/02/07
  79.   Fritz 09:28  |  sweis Melbourne 27/02/07
  80.   #78 Matt 14:53  |  Johnboy 27/02/07
 Today Online
Scholars, clergy in Jerusalem slam new Jesus documentary
Responses: 135
Shahar Ilan: Naming a street for Meir Kahane
Responses: 68
Shai Benyamini: Radical settlers and religious Zionists
Responses: 31
Editorial: Legitimizing settlers' theft of land
Responses: 80
MKs seek to indict Prof. Toaff over claims in blood libel book
Responses: 42


More Headlines
16:49 EU: No swift end to embargo on new PA gov't
16:36 Histadrut cancels strike after PM vows to discuss wage payments
15:57 MK Tartman: I still suffer from memory and attention deficits
14:49 Police question top J'lem rabbi over threats against Maj. Gen.
16:55 Green agencies oppose construction for Gaza evacuees
11:08 Iran says will never halt uranium enrichment but welcomes talks
11:50 Lawyers: State close to indicting Gaydamak for money laundering
11:06 Pilot killed as crop spraying airplane crashes in north
11:25 Treasury requests NIS 1.5m for driver, bodyguard for Ariel Sharon
11:47 ADL condemns Farrakhan for touting 'notoriously anti-Semitic' books
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved