Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., June 14, 2007 Sivan 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Antiquities Authority staff working at the site of the Mugrabi ramp last week. (AP)
Last update - 13:20 18/02/2007
Archaeologist: Muslim prayer room may have been found at dig site
By The Associated Press

An Israeli archaeologist said Sunday that what could be a Islamic prayer room was found at the site of the Mugrabi ramp in the Old City of Jerusalem, where excavation work has sparked angry protests by Muslims who say that the work endangers the Al-Aqsa Mosque.

Muslim leaders and critics of the work said the announcement of the find, three years after it was discovered, confirmed their fears that the Antiquities Authority is intent on hiding Muslim attachment to the site.

Israel says the project is needed to repair damage to the ramp caused by a 2004 snowstorm, and the dig won't affect Muslim holy sites on the nearby Temple Mount. Muslim leaders accuse Israel of plotting to destroy Islamic holy places, a claim that Israel has sought to refute by installing a web cam to monitor the scene and by agreeing to Turkish supervision of the dig.

Advertisement

In an article published recently on the authority's Web site, Jerusalem district archaeologist Yuval Baruch described the ruins that were discovered after the snowstorm three years ago.

In 2004, when the Mughrabi ramp collapsed, a small room was discovered which contained an alcove covered with a dome, a kind of Muslim prayer niche, facing south, Baruch wrote. Some suggest that these are the remains of a prayer room that was part of a madrasa (a Muslim religious school) which operated near the Mughrabi Gate.

Authority officials said the article was published earlier this month, around the time the project began.

Adnan Husseini, Director of the Islamic Waqf, which oversees affairs at the Temple Mount, expressed anger that Israel withheld news of the discovery for three years. "We didn't hear anything about this," he said. "They are always hiding things."

Baruch said the authority decided not to reveal the existence of the room sooner since it still is not clear what it was. He said finds in and around the room need further research before authorities can say exactly what the room was used for.

The archaeological dig is taking place about 60 meters away from the Temple Mount, the third-holiest site in Islam and holiest site in Judaism.

Activists for Palestinian rights in Jerusalem said the delayed publication of the archaeological find proved the Antiquities Authority has not been truthful.

"This coincides with the way they act," said Amos Gil of Ir Amim, an Israeli group that promotes coexistence in Jerusalem. "They don't want to find all the ruins, just the Jewish ones."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Condi Doctrine
Rice is distancing herself from the 'Bush legacy' in an attempt to create a legacy of her own.
Suicidal whale
Israel is the only modern country that has a suicidal educational strategy.
  1.   Flawed logic 13:29  |  Physicist 18/02/07
  2.   There was never a temple on the site 13:51  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  3.   Lefties Abu Firas Al Qudsi peace is a pipe dream 14:12  |  Steven 18/02/07
  4.   Common, the vandals from Waqf should shut their mouths 14:17  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 18/02/07
  5.   Amos Gil 14:22  |  david jacoby 18/02/07
  6.   #2 Abu firas: There was never a buddah in Avganistan? 14:24  |  Arnaud 18/02/07
  7.   Abu FirasL you use illogical logic to unprove a point 14:28  |  Richard S 18/02/07
  8.   Al Qudsi: If there was no Temple, than there is no Al-Aqsa 14:29  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 18/02/07
  9.   AS IF TWO HOUNDS ARE FIGHTING OVER A PIECE OF MEAT 14:47  |  THE JACKAL 18/02/07
  10.   regarding JERUSALEM 14:51  |  DANNY. 18/02/07
  11.   A Room With A View 14:57  |  Kate 18/02/07
  12.   Richard S the crackpot 15:07  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  13.   Holy site on Sheinkin street 15:15  |  Herbert Kaine 18/02/07
  14.   Shlomo Islamic sources dont mention a temple 15:19  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  15.   Clearly not scientists 15:29  |  Mark Lincoln 18/02/07
  16.   12. Abu Firas AL Qudsi 15:30  |  blim 18/02/07
  17.   aRCHEOLOGIST: MUSLIM PRAYER ROOM may have been found a 15:52  |  nergal52 18/02/07
  18.   Response to #14 15:57  |  Ian 18/02/07
  19.   If there were no Temple in Yerushalaim ... 15:57  |  Boris 18/02/07
  20.   #2 Abu Firas - then why did Jerusalem Arabs 16:01  |  Yonatan 18/02/07
  21.   #14 Abu Firas Al Qudsi - Muhammad was never in Jerusalem 16:08  |  Yonatan 18/02/07
  22.   jews need to act more like arabs,,, 16:08  |  benny 18/02/07
  23.   #12 THE ROMANS WERE MISTAKEN THEN 16:09  |  paul harris 18/02/07
  24.   Muslim prayer room is in Mecca and Medina where it belonges 16:10  |  Just Pray NO? 18/02/07
  25.   Abu Firas Yesterday - Jews Null & Void 16:15  |  ChanahS 18/02/07
  26.   #15 - Clearly not a comprehending reader 16:17  |  JES 18/02/07
  27.   abu firas al qudsi 16:17  |  Gabriel 18/02/07
  28.   #18 Ian.. the geordie is no scholar 16:18  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  29.   the temple 16:20  |  al quds remenber 18/02/07
  30.   Yonatan the wise man of Kefar Sava 16:27  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  31.   # 2 Abu 16:31  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  32.   al bus firas , then Jesus never visited the temple either??? 16:34  |  gabriel 18/02/07
  33.   Al Qudsi: are the Islamic sources the only truthful sources? 16:35  |  Alicia 18/02/07
  34.   Yonatan ..You are a nice man 16:37  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  35.   # 14 Abu 16:38  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  36.   ABU FIRAS , no need to deny jewsih History in order toreaffirm,yo 16:40  |  Gabriel 18/02/07
  37.   Build the ramp 16:41  |  Ron 18/02/07
  38.   Abu Firas aL Qudsi in cuckooland 16:43  |  Physicist 18/02/07
  39.   Gabriel.You raised some itneresting points 16:48  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  40.   Al Qudsi: You are lieing again 16:51  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 18/02/07
  41.   # 15 Mark Lincoln 16:53  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  42.   al Qudsi the ignoramus - Part 2 16:57  |  Phsyicist 18/02/07
  43.   Gabriel..Please read what I said carefully 17:00  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  44.   39: Abu`s flawed rationlizations 17:03  |  David Teich 18/02/07
  45.   Lynn and the conquerors 17:06  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  46.   Abu Firas 17:10  |  neutral 18/02/07
  47.   More profit cartoons! 17:12  |  HonestAbe 18/02/07
  48.   Ok Gabriel my last post for now 17:14  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  49.   work together 17:21  |  Ethan 18/02/07
  50.   Abu Firas - I found an islamic source 17:28  |  Mark Stevens 18/02/07
  51.   Prayer niche accompanying a madrassa. 17:32  |  sandra chitayat 18/02/07
  52.   Abu Firas: the Quaran was written well after old and new testamen 17:49  |  Richard S 18/02/07
  53.   #30 Abu Firas - your consternation leads to yur ridicule 17:55  |  Yonatan 18/02/07
  54.   read this 18:01  |  Lucy 18/02/07
  55.   # 50 Mark Stevens..The pride of Canada 18:02  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  56.   Richard S..Another wise Canadian 18:09  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  57.   Archaeology is a major front in the struggle for land. Finds that 18:13  |  Apartheid 18/02/07
  58.   Abu Firas - I found an islamic source 18:15  |  Mark Stevens 18/02/07
  59.   TO ALL 18:16  |  Harry D 18/02/07
  60.   Easy means to determine precedence 18:18  |  * BEN JABO 18/02/07
  61.   #8 Shlomo, You are mixed up in your ideas and education 18:18  |  Abu Samra AlMaqdisy 18/02/07
  62.   Islam and the rest have different truths and both are right! 18:20  |  Alicia 18/02/07
  63.   # 8 Part 2 Shlome TA 18:21  |  Abu Samra AlMaqdisy 18/02/07
  64.   answer to #2 18:22  |  Beit David 18/02/07
  65.   #12 Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18:23  |  * BEN JABO 18/02/07
  66.   #53 Yonatan..I did not mean to hurt your feelings 18:23  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  67.   The real facts 18:23  |  Charles B. Hall 18/02/07
  68.   Abu Firas # 58 18:26  |  ChanahS 18/02/07
  69.   Abu FSamra # 61 18:29  |  ChanahS 18/02/07
  70.   #58 Mark Stevens..here is the answer to your Q 18:33  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  71.   Another smoke screen 18:34  |  KUTW 18/02/07
  72.   Muslims are angry 18:34  |  Twogunz 18/02/07
  73.   The prayer niche, facing south 18:36  |  KUTW 18/02/07
  74.   Regarding Historical Evidence 18:36  |  Harry D 18/02/07
  75.   #65 Ben Jabo and the photos 18:43  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  76.   #19 Boris, If you permit me I will correct your knowledge 18:46  |  Abu Samra AlMaqdisy 18/02/07
  77.   It stands to reason.. 18:47  |  Avi Yerushalmi 18/02/07
  78.   Eureka! I Have The Answer! 18:54  |  Harry D 18/02/07
  79.   What if they find something from the 2 temple? 19:03  |  Dale 18/02/07
  80.   Abu Firas # 66, Abu Samra # 63 19:08  |  Avi Yerushalmi 18/02/07
  81.   # 63 Abu Samra AlMagdisy 19:09  |  * BEN JABO 18/02/07
  82.   Of course they had prayer rooms off the mount 19:18  |  Efox 18/02/07
  83.   Moslems are Always Angry 19:23  |  Efox 18/02/07
  84.   What Islamic Sources Actually Say 19:27  |  Efox 18/02/07
  85.   Efox. You sound too angry to me 19:48  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  86.   Peolpe have the RIGHT to choose 19:51  |  Sam 18/02/07
  87.   I am serious here 19:57  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  88.   79. Dale: That is what they are afraid of 19:59  |  KUTW 18/02/07
  89.   Weird muslim revisionism 20:00  |  lola 18/02/07
  90.   #81 Ben Jabo, Clear well received message, wait the second round 20:05  |  Abu Samra 18/02/07
  91.   #2Abu Firas Al Qudsi 20:06  |  Jan Vlaming 18/02/07
  92.   #85 Sam in Boston ..We dont need to dig 20:06  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  93.   # 45 Abu 20:07  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  94.   Abu Firas - I found an islamic source 20:19  |  Mark Stevens 18/02/07
  95.   #35, 93 Lynn its here for you to see 20:24  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  96.   Lynn - too many conflicts 20:27  |  Mark Lincoln 18/02/07
  97.   to ABU 20:27  |  Dorothy 18/02/07
  98.   # 46 neutral 20:30  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  99.   Mark my friend in Canada 20:33  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  100.   #57 Apartheid 20:37  |  JES 18/02/07
  101.   #92 To Abu Firas Al Qudsi- Discover! 20:42  |  Sam 18/02/07
  102.   Dear Abu Firas - Just One Question 20:44  |  Ron 18/02/07
  103.   # 79 Dale 20:46  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  104.   The Jackalass- ill informed historian 20:48  |  The Cid 18/02/07
  105.   Abu Firas - I found an islamic source 20:49  |  Mark Stevens 18/02/07
  106.   # 95 Abu 20:50  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  107.   Dorothy in OZ 20:53  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  108.   ben jabo # 60 20:59  |  dubious 18/02/07
  109.   #78 - very wise! 21:01  |  Marion 18/02/07
  110.   Jes ...allow me 21:05  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  111.   Ron in New York..They came from Egypt 21:09  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  112.   Islamic Waqf- Hypocrites 21:09  |  The Cid 18/02/07
  113.   100 JES. Its curious how Israelis can recall the demolition of 21:10  |  Apartheid 18/02/07
  114.   # 96 Mark Lincoln 21:11  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  115.   Lynn..you are back tracking.. 21:12  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  116.   until muslims extend same respect to our sites they do not deserv 21:16  |  ralph 18/02/07
  117.   # 76 21:18  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  118.   # 66 Abu 21:26  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  119.   Al Qudsi and bonehead-infidels 21:29  |  Alicia 18/02/07
  120.   62. Alicia: The truth of Islam is only valid for Muslims 21:47  |  KUTW 18/02/07
  121.   I visited it in 1969 but found no temple RIGHT ??? 21:49  |  M. Segal 18/02/07
  122.   Jews are from Egypt? 21:51  |  Ron 18/02/07
  123.   TO Mark Stevens 21:54  |  Alicia 18/02/07
  124.   Simple Questions 21:58  |  bimmer 18/02/07
  125.   Abu Firas al Qudsi 22:07  |  Avi Yerushalmi 18/02/07
  126.   # 92 Abu 22:10  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  127.   # 114 Alicia 22:12  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  128.   Second Temple finds trump distorted Muslim rhetoric 22:27  |  Wendy 18/02/07
  129.   Alicia.. I have few corrections for you 22:40  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  130.   #122 Ron try Arabia 22:46  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 18/02/07
  131.   Bimmer..I like your questions 22:55  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 18/02/07
  132.   TO: KUTW 22:55  |  Alicia 18/02/07
  133.   #130 Abu Firas try Israel 23:01  |  Ron 18/02/07
  134.   #122 Ron 23:13  |  Jan Vlaming 18/02/07
  135.   Mugrabi 23:13  |  Hilda 18/02/07
  136.   TO Mark Stevens 23:30  |  Alicia 18/02/07
  137.   Palestinian Preservation of History 23:33  |  Sam 18/02/07
  138.   abu firas al qudsi 23:35  |  Gabriel 18/02/07
  139.   so! we`ll treat with respect and keep digging! unlike the arabs!! 23:44  |  ralph 18/02/07
  140.   #130 Abu Firas Al Qudsi - Temple Mount Photo 23:54  |  * BEN JABO 18/02/07
  141.   #2 Al Kudsi is right: let`s stick to the facts 23:55  |  Comforti 18/02/07
  142.   # 115 Abu 00:00  |  Lynn 19/02/07
  143.   132. Alicia 00:04  |  KUTW 19/02/07
  144.   Abu Firas @131 00:12  |  ChanahS 19/02/07
  145.   #1, Physicist--and not only that... 00:23  |  Blogowitz 19/02/07
  146.   #138 Gabriel 00:28  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 19/02/07
  147.   Was Herodotus Arab? 00:28  |  Riccardo Lancino 19/02/07
  148.   # 136 Alicia 00:28  |  Lynn 19/02/07
  149.   HOW many Jewish prayer rooms all over the Middle East?. 00:32  |  PETER SM 19/02/07
  150.   Cultural Genocide 00:37  |  Hal Spears 19/02/07
  151.   to racist ABU 107 re my questions of 97 00:42  |  dorothy 19/02/07
  152.   Alicia #136 00:49  |  Mike 19/02/07
  153.   caesar`s wife - mark lincoln # 96 01:20  |  cicero`s amenuensis 19/02/07
  154.   #133 There was no Israel before 1948? 01:21  |  Abu Firas AL qudsi 19/02/07
  155.   #60 Ben Jabo, that is nonsense, never work! 01:47  |  ballistic 19/02/07
  156.   A.FIRAS.Jews have had a continuous presence before Arab invaders 02:03  |  PETER SM 19/02/07
  157.   There was once a Jewish soul, where did it go? 02:40  |  Lubnani Yehudi 19/02/07
  158.   Re: There was never a temple on the site 03:28  |  Roy Galut 19/02/07
  159.   Al Qudsi; just a small question,please. 04:08  |  Alicia 19/02/07
  160.   Roman Historian Tacitus report on the jewish war 04:41  |  Roy Galut 19/02/07
  161.   #155 Ballistic - You FEAR CARBON DATING 06:50  |  * BEN JABO 19/02/07
  162.   #155-2 Ballistic - LEARN BEFORE YOU SPEAK 07:12  |  * BEN JABO 19/02/07
  163.   129: More corrections for Abu the liar 08:48  |  David Teich 19/02/07
  164.   al-aqsa existed in the time of Sulieman 06:47  |  ali ibn adaam 14/06/07
 Today Online
Danny Rubinstein: Re-occupation of Gaza - is it the only way out?
Responses: 204
Hamas takes fight to Gaza City; 24 killed in clashes
Responses: 357
Peres named president, says he'll work to unite Israeli society
Responses: 133
Tory leader calls himself 'Zionist'; U.K. Jews fight boycott
Responses: 143
Ex-UN Mideast envoy says UN subservient to U.S., Israel
Responses: 161
Rosner's Domain
* "American realism" in the alleys of the Gaza strip
* WTR: Alabama like Iran, Israel like Oregon
* Resist Judaism that makes us choose between religion and politics
* Poll: What to do about the so-called 'British boycott'


More Headlines
06:31 Abbas, Haniyeh agree on need to end Gaza bloodshed
02:52 ANALYSIS: Hamas victory in Gaza presents new reality for Israel
05:28 Barak recruiting Labor allies as he prepares for future PM race
20:54 President-elect Shimon Peres: My job is to unite Israeli society
02:02 Ex-diplomat: UN failed in Middle East, subservient to U.S., Israel
03:20 Ayalon not to dispute results of Labor primary but may call for probe
02:40 PM to appoint finance minister in upcoming cabinet reshuffle
02:12 U.S. blames Hamas for latest round of fighting in Gaza
00:25 Broad spectrum of U.S. Jews praise Peres presidency
00:17 Police approve Gay Pride march in Jerusalem set for next week
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved