Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 22, 2007 Adar 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:09 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Rice's road map is full of holes
By Zvi Bar'el

How easy it is for the United States to deal with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: It is both sticking to the road map and not committed to it; Washington seeks democracy but can also dismiss its results; it is opposed to settlements, not to speak of outposts, but has already accepted them as a fait accompli; it is in favor of a final accord, but before this is achieved, it has defined its prior conditions.

In short, solving this conflict is not essential, it's a luxury item - from Washington's point of view. The conflict that brings Condoleezza Rice to the region conforms to the "turkey principle," which stipulates that if you have wings, this does not mean you can fly, but you can feel free to make noise.

For example, that noise about the road map. There is no document that is more vague and more unfocused; it's almost impressionistic: Everyone can find what he wants in it. Resolutions 242 and 338, the Arab initiative, the Arab League decisions of 2002, an end to terror and a functioning democracy in the Palestinian Authority and even, believe it or not, an Israeli commitment to enable Palestinians to lead normal lives. This entire salad is spread over the map, which is like a lacy tablecloth and has the pretension of resembling a work document only because it includes stages and a timetable. A timetable, by the way, which already ended in 2005.

Advertisement

Even if Rice declares that she is committed to the road map, it would be good if someone asks her to which part of it she is committed? To the longed-for Palestinian democracy? The same democracy that brought Hamas to power? Or, perhaps, the section that requires Israel to enable the Palestinians to conduct normal lives? Or could it be the first section of the document, in which the Palestinian Authority commits to take effective steps to dismantle the infrastructure of terror? Ah, but the terror infrastructure of 2003 is the same Hamas that is now running the government after winning the democratic battle Washington so wished to see.

Many other sections in the initial stage of the road map need to be realized, the first of which is that the Palestinian Authority recognize Israel's right to exist in peace, while declaring a complete cease-fire. But a cease-fire already exists between the PA and Israel and, in the meantime, the Mecca agreement was also signed. But this, as we know, is an odious agreement, one designed to deceive the world, only to bring about a lifting of the embargo on the Palestinian Authority.

For a long time now, the road map has not been a suitable mold in which to pour the contents of a diplomatic process. It was written and approved on the basis that Arafat would live forever; that Hamas would not want or be capable of participating in political life in Palestine; and that Fatah would always be Israel's contrarian interlocutor and thus eliminate the need to make concessions. Despite these assurances, Israel took the trouble of submitting countless reservations about this map, as if it really were about to become a work plan.

We have said nothing yet about the section in the map that requires Israel to demolish illegal outposts built since March 2001 and to freeze all settlement activity. Rice can say what she wants about the road map, but besides words, Washington has really done nothing to demonstrate this commitment.

This conflict needs a new working paper, one the current administration in Washington is incapable of producing. Primarily this is so because it does not think a strategic threat is involved, because the administration knows how to deal with real strategic threats, rather than imagined ones: When necessary, it conducts practical negotiations with the head of the axis of evil, North Korea; it conducts effective talks with Libya; it is ready to talk with Iran about Iraq and to conduct a dialogue in Iraq with terror gangs that are accorded the title of "rebels" or "insurgents." Because when there is a real threat, one does not get bogged down in the fine points. Instead, one talks with everyone and pays in legal tender. In Palestine, from Washington's perspective, it is possible to continue to market values, to aspire for a utopian state with a utopian regime, and to compose documents in its honor, because there is no immediate danger if they are not implemented.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Google expansion
Google is launching an ad program for Hebrew Web content sites.
Ofer's big bid
Purchasing the Haifa-based Oil Refineries is the first step in one billionaire's strategy.
  1.   Road is BLOCKED by HAMAS. So, Road Map is DEAD! FORGET IT FOREVER 10:18  |  Vittorio 18/02/07
  2.   Rice is a woman of war not peace. 10:37  |  Deborah 18/02/07
  3.   sole alternative 11:46  |  arab 18/02/07
  4.   Deborah 11:58  |  Arnie 18/02/07
  5.   Pals Fail To Become Finns 12:36  |  Rowan Berkeley 18/02/07
  6.   pals insist on the right to kill 13:06  |  Jasmine Murphy 18/02/07
  7.   Zvi Bar`el is another radical Haaretz writer 13:21  |  David Stoler 18/02/07
  8.   Road Map 13:28  |  Martin 18/02/07
  9.   America`s Focus 14:27  |  Ronnie Wolman 18/02/07
  10.   Unlike Barel Mrs. Rice does not have an easy answer for everythin 14:30  |  Shalom Freedman 18/02/07
  11.   Rice follows the road the AIPAC ordered her to follow–To nowhere 15:05  |  Anti-Semite 18/02/07
  12.   Deborah 16:07  |  Michael 18/02/07
  13.   RIce is Aronious 16:15  |  Jeff 18/02/07
  14.   Solution 16:29  |  Abe 18/02/07
  15.   Some Integrity needed to sort out the past 16:48  |  Stu 18/02/07
  16.   Mdme "I will look the other way when it comes to Israel" is 17:02  |  Ingrid Svensson 18/02/07
  17.   #16 INGRID AND ATROCITIES SEES THEM ALL 17:32  |  paul harris 18/02/07
  18.   Road map to Nowhere. 17:42  |  Racon-tour 18/02/07
  19.   Ingrid Svensson #16 17:53  |  Gee 18/02/07
  20.   Hey, Lefties who support PALS. Why are you so one-sided? What is 18:18  |  Vittorio 18/02/07
  21.   # 9 Ronnie Wolman 18:32  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  22.   # 16 Ingrid 18:34  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  23.   # 18 UN Quartet 18:41  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  24.   Ship of fools 18:47  |  Petro 18/02/07
  25.   She be committed to serving 18:53  |  Mark Lincoln 18/02/07
  26.   Mark Lincoln is sadly correct-and Ronnie is confused. 19:36  |  Ibrahim 18/02/07
  27.   Is Zvi calling for an other pal revolt to be portrayed as danger 19:57  |  Joseph E . 18/02/07
  28.   This conflict does not need a new working paper 20:11  |  Fred 18/02/07
  29.   Ibrahim: You should be a Painter 20:36  |  Ronnie Wolman 18/02/07
  30.   The road map was just to get Arab support for the Iraq war 21:11  |  tuairimiocht 18/02/07
  31.   Ibrahim, it does no good to hide your head in the tulips 21:12  |  Voice of Reason 18/02/07
  32.   Is Anyone Surprised? A Foregone Conclusion 21:14  |  chet 18/02/07
  33.   Rice: Anti Diplomat 21:33  |  Fran 18/02/07
  34.   The Road Map Is A Worm On A Hook 21:54  |  Tony Anthony 18/02/07
  35.   Mecca Agreement 23:31  |  Nechama 18/02/07
  36.   Bar`el`s Head is Full of Holes 00:05  |  Tod Zuckerman 19/02/07
  37.   #30 00:45  |  Walla 19/02/07
  38.   #32 Chet asks... 00:55  |  Johnboy 19/02/07
  39.   #23 00:56  |  Racon-tour 19/02/07
  40.   Mark Lincoln drops mask 02:09  |  Tulip 19/02/07
  41.   Where can I buy Ibrahim´s painting, Ronnie? 02:10  |  Tulip 19/02/07
  42.   Arnie 03:00  |  Deborah 19/02/07
  43.   Kath: What the Butler Said 03:10  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/02/07
  44.   Conjob Rice and the Road map of illusion! 03:16  |  The Cid 19/02/07
  45.   For #38 Johnboy From Oz 03:17  |  chet 19/02/07
  46.   Tulip, #40, there was never doubt of Mark Lincoln being a racist 03:21  |  Voice of Reason 19/02/07
  47.   vittorio 04:13  |  sam 19/02/07
  48.   voice of reason 04:17  |  sam 19/02/07
  49.   Ronnie, give me a break... 04:33  |  Ibrahim 19/02/07
  50.   Condi go home 04:37  |  Bill b 19/02/07
  51.   Ibrahim: Its funny but I thought same about the arabs 05:05  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/02/07
  52.   Ronnie, you are as confused as ever... 07:10  |  Ibrahim 19/02/07
  53.   #5 Rowan " Pals Fail To Become Finns" 07:33  |  benji 19/02/07
  54.   Chet # 32 08:07  |  Reid 19/02/07
  55.   Ibrahim (Ronnie, give me a break) 08:20  |  Reid 19/02/07
  56.   GREAT ARTICLE ! 09:07  |  Tom Peters 19/02/07
  57.   Is it a one way street? 09:13  |  Juan Perez 19/02/07
  58.   Sam on Palestinians on 9/11 09:25  |  Tulip 19/02/07
  59.   Ibrahim and Arab war 09:27  |  Tulip 19/02/07
  60.   US signed "Human Rts."Not Road Map! 19:00  |  sam 22/02/07
 Today Online
Syria said denying army deployment nearer border
Responses: 252
Rice wants to use rest of tenure to promote two-state solution
Responses: 75
Gaza evacuee families to get NIS 1.5-2 million in compensation
Responses: 96
Temple Mount open to Jews for first time in over three weeks
Responses: 84


More Headlines
19:03 IAEA: Iran defied UN deadline to halt uranium enrichment
18:23 Hamas: U.S. blocking European efforts to end economic boycott
18:32 Peretz urges Israel to avoid verbal escalation with Syria
19:08 Police Commander Levy to sue probe chief Zeiler for slander
16:31 UN: Almost half of Palestinians in Gaza, W. Bank are food insecure
16:16 Herzog yields tourism portfolio in exchange for Welfare Ministry
16:38 Egypt pursues two Palestinian militants in northern Sinai
16:13 State Prosecutor orders police to investigate Salah for sedition
18:57 Harry Potter fans line up to meet Hebrew translator at Jerusalem book fair
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved