Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., February 19, 2007 Adar 1, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:02 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Temple Mount dig / Ankara to the rescue
By Nadav Shragai

Since the Six-Day War, Israel has waged a religious-political dispute with Islam about the Temple Mount against two "local" players: Jordan and the Palestinians. The entry of an allegedly radical Islamic entity like Turkey into the Mugrabi ascent question signals to those two entities, who have not contributed to calming the crisis, that Israel has options.

Turkey, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Egypt and essentially the entire Muslim world protested when Israel, at different times, gave the Jordanians or the Palestinians status on the mount, arguing that the Temple Mount is a pan-Islamic issue.

When Israel negotiated about the Temple Mount with Yasser Arafat at Camp David, the Muslim world attacked him with unprecedented vehemence and asked him, "Who gave you the right?" When the Israel-Jordan peace treaty determined that Israel "grant high priority to the historic Jordanian role in the Islamic holy sites in Jerusalem," many Muslim countries protested.

Advertisement

In both those instances, the Muslim world sought to make Israel realize that the Temple Mount was not a private matter. Until now, Israel has ignored that: A Libyan delegation did visit the Al-Aqsa Mosque several years ago, Egyptian president Anwar Sadat visited the Temple Mount and carpets donated by the King of Morocco serve as prayer mats in the mosque. But the major "treats" were given to Jordan and the Palestinians according to Israeli interests.

Allowing the Turks a kind of "supervision" over the construction at the Mugrabi ascent, in order to ensure that they do not undermine the foundations of al Aqsa, is not really anything new. Anyone who installs Webcams, as Israel has done, has nothing to conceal.

Nonetheless, this opens the door to involvement on the part of additional Islamic countries in the permanent solution for the mount. In his days in the Foreign Ministry, Shimon Peres suggested a multi-national religious administration that would include representatives of Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, the Palestinian Authority, Israel and the Vatican to manage the Old City's holy sites. Turkey was not in the picture then but now Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is waving Ankara at the Palestinians and the Jordanians in an effort to calm the eruption.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Alter ego
The door opens and a young guy with a flabby paunch stands there in his underwear.
A 'unity of opposites'
The Torah seeks to found Jewish society on the notions of justice and humanity.
  1.   olmert was servile in turkey 11:47  |  flashman 16/02/07
  2.   israel is friendly to those who want an equal 11:49  |  flashman 16/02/07
  3.   the worst part of the visit 12:07  |  flashman 16/02/07
  4.   ONLY ISRAEL SHOULD ADMINISTER THE TEMPLE MOUNT ?? 13:01  |  Bill. 16/02/07
  5.   A WRONG MOVE AGAIN BY ISRAEL 13:08  |  indrajaya 16/02/07
  6.   A WRONG MOVE AGAIN BY ISRAEL 13:08  |  indrajaya 16/02/07
  7.   ottoman turks coming back?and also 13:50  |  yahn goodey 16/02/07
  8.   "An allegedly radical Islamic entity like Turkey"??? 14:37  |  Mirqa 16/02/07
  9.   indrajaya hates the white man because 15:12  |  tommy suharto 16/02/07
  10.   Turkish Delegation To#7yahn goodey 15:20  |  Rob 16/02/07
  11.   Formation of International Overseers 15:27  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/02/07
  12.   Ro # 7 yahn goodey again! 15:32  |  Rob 16/02/07
  13.   Like a pair of kids bickering 15:52  |  Mark Lincoln 16/02/07
  14.   OLMERT TALKING TURKEY AGAIN ?? FIRST LEARN SENSE 16:28  |  paul harris 16/02/07
  15.   Temple Mount 16:40  |  Ralph 16/02/07
  16.   Olmert`s double whammy 16:54  |  Tosefta 16/02/07
  17.   flashman #3 17:24  |  Polybios 16/02/07
  18.   Another gem from that illustrious master diplomat Olmert... 17:36  |  bat yam 16/02/07
  19.   International Administration as the only solution 17:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/02/07
  20.   Yaakov -- so strange 18:07  |  bbl 16/02/07
  21.   Yaakov: Your Bias is showing 18:08  |  Polybios 16/02/07
  22.   Web-cam - Sincere? 18:09  |  Just Curious 16/02/07
  23.   Indrajaya -- are you an ostrich ? 18:17  |  bbl 16/02/07
  24.   Exactly How Long Is Islam Going To Let Us Dig There? 18:21  |  Yosemite 16/02/07
  25.   re:rob in australia concerning turkey`s 19:24  |  yahn goodey 16/02/07
  26.   Of course, let`s analyse this closely #20 19:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/02/07
  27.   bbl, Part II on the Temple Mount 19:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/02/07
  28.   Polybios and his visions of grandeur #21 19:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/02/07
  29.   Including Turkey good move 20:08  |  Moises 16/02/07
  30.   Yaakov Sullivan 20:25  |  ODP 16/02/07
  31.   ODP, I only wish you were right #26 21:07  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/02/07
  32.   Yaakov 22:05  |  ODP 16/02/07
  33.   Yaakov #28 22:08  |  ODP 16/02/07
  34.   re #9 `Indrajaya hates the white man because...` 22:35  |  Colin Wright 16/02/07
  35.   #29 Moises 22:43  |  * BEN JABO 16/02/07
  36.   re #20 `Yaakov -- so strange` 22:45  |  Colin Wright 16/02/07
  37.   # 24 Yosemite 23:04  |  Lynn 16/02/07
  38.   Byzantine Mosaics uncovered 23:09  |  Lynn 16/02/07
  39.   TO Lynn #38 23:18  |  Persian Kitty 16/02/07
  40.   # 34 Colin Wright 23:19  |  Lynn 16/02/07
  41.   Yaakov read you own postings 23:51  |  bbl 16/02/07
  42.   you too Colin Wright? 23:58  |  bbl 16/02/07
  43.   Temple Mount will be split 23:59  |  Kahan Yedidiyah Hawk 16/02/07
  44.   colin wright i think tommy suharto 00:29  |  bong bong 17/02/07
  45.   Can you answer my question??? 00:33  |  Sharif Hafez 17/02/07
  46.   colin wright why do you feel qualified to judge the situation 00:45  |  edmund burke 17/02/07
  47.   # 43 Sharif 01:18  |  Lynn 17/02/07
  48.   Colin Wright 01:29  |  TM 17/02/07
  49.   Yaakov Sullivan 01:33  |  Where`s waldo 17/02/07
  50.   ODP re Sullivan 02:21  |  TT 17/02/07
  51.   Those curious muslims... 02:35  |  Jordan 17/02/07
  52.   Turkey, a radical islamic country? 04:09  |  ErdemK 17/02/07
  53.   Of course, noone qualifies as `white` in Colin Wright`s world 04:17  |  Jake 17/02/07
  54.   # 23, BBL 04:44  |  indrajaya 17/02/07
  55.   # 44, BONG BONG 05:41  |  indrajaya 17/02/07
  56.   Radical Islamic Turkey 06:13  |  Gordon 17/02/07
  57.   Flashman 07:02  |  danite 17/02/07
  58.   ErdemK 10:45  |  Tulip 17/02/07
  59.   Smiling Erdogan 11:16  |  Ali 17/02/07
  60.   Temple Mount 11:26  |  Moshe 17/02/07
  61.   Plmert move puts Temple Mt under indirect Hamas control 11:43  |  Michael Green 17/02/07
  62.   To Tulip. Secularism? What is it? 13:40  |  Fatih 17/02/07
  63.   #56 Gordon - Turkey is changing 15:14  |  * BEN JABO 17/02/07
  64.   #36 - Colin Wright pontificates from the U.S. RAPE CAPITOL 15:48  |  * BEN JABO 17/02/07
  65.   danite i do agree partly but 16:49  |  flashman 17/02/07
  66.   indrajaya 16:51  |  tommy suharto 17/02/07
  67.   # 16 Tosefta. re:Turkey.QUITE CORRECT...... 17:00  |  Kath` 17/02/07
  68.   Where was the World b4 1967? 18:44  |  Stright 2 the point 17/02/07
  69.   Israel, ignore them 19:40  |  KUTW 17/02/07
  70.   Let?s launch a christian intifada 19:42  |  KUTW 17/02/07
  71.   Jerusalem belong to the Jews 19:46  |  KUTW 17/02/07
  72.   No due process (Kathy #67) 19:59  |  Tosefta 17/02/07
  73.   Turkish government, radical Islamist 20:05  |  KUTW 17/02/07
  74.   Indrajaya 21:17  |  Lynn 17/02/07
  75.   Turkey has no place in this 21:19  |  Psalm 17/02/07
  76.   Iknow flashman I know 21:27  |  Danite 17/02/07
  77.   Mark Lincoln 21:43  |  Lynn 17/02/07
  78.   Faith , what a faith you have 21:50  |  Tulip 17/02/07
  79.   Lynn, you are amazingly ignorant! 21:58  |  Matthew 17/02/07
  80.   # 71 Tosefta. POINT TAKEN,THANK YOU,BUT... 22:05  |  Kath` 17/02/07
  81.   43. Kahan Yedidiyah Hawk: It shouldnt 22:13  |  KUTW 17/02/07
  82.   The bridge, and more (Kathy#80) 23:19  |  Tosefta 17/02/07
  83.   Erdogan, a moderate? 23:55  |  KUTW 17/02/07
  84.   Matthew 01:35  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  85.   I apologize to Lynn 01:39  |  Matthew 18/02/07
  86.   # 80 Kath 01:40  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  87.   # 82 Tosefta 01:43  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  88.   #10 Rob from Australia 01:47  |  MR 18/02/07
  89.   Matthew 03:31  |  Lynn 18/02/07
  90.   # 82 Tosefta. QUICK REPLY.