Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., February 16, 2007 Shvat 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The hot-air summit
By Aluf Benn

Yitzhak Rabin would probably have called the three-way summit that will convene on Monday in Jerusalem by a term he favored, "bablat" (roughly "hot air"). Because nothing will come of this summit. Not peace negotiations, not a diplomatic agreement, and if Condoleezza Rice does not bang on the table, no easing of restrictions for the Palestinians either.

Ehud Olmert can enjoy the innovative aspect of a meeting with Rice and Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen), or of staying at a hotel in Jerusalem instead of on the shores of the Red Sea, as in the days of his predecessors. But what about Abu Mazen, who for years has been dragging from summit to summit and repeatedly hearing those same declarations about "beginning the negotiations" and about a better future? In May 1996, Abu Mazen headed the Palestinian delegation to the opening ceremony of the final status talks in Taba. At the time, he called for the establishment of a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders with East Jerusalem as its capital, and for a "just" solution to the refugee problem. Uri Savir, the head of the Israeli delegation, responded with a vague proposal about "separation between the nations, with the aim of achieving cooperation." Without borders, without refugees, without Jerusalem.

Exactly the same talk was heard prior to the present summit. As though nothing had happened in the 11 years that have since passed: neither Camp David nor the intifada and the suicide attacks, neither the disengagement nor the rise of Hamas. Abu Mazen continues to talk about a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders, and the changing Israeli leaders respond with vague slogans about a "diplomatic horizon."

Advertisement

Perhaps it's true that nothing has happened, and the sides are still trapped in the same basic positions, without flexibility or any understanding of the other side.

Olmert was dragged to the Jerusalem summit against his will. He had reservations about the initiative of the U.S. secretary of state and of Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni to skip over the obstacle of the road map and go straight to talks about the Palestinian state.

In recent weeks, the prime minister and his aides have been busy piling up difficulties on the summit agenda. They made it clear that Israel is opposed to American mediation and insists on direct negotiations; they explained that the discussions will be merely theoretical, and that implementation will be conditional on a return to the first stage of the road map and the dismantling of terror organizations; and, finally, they said Israel will not discuss the issues of the final-status arrangement, as Abbas is demanding.

And then came the "Mecca agreement" to form a national unity government between Fatah and Hamas, saving Olmert from great embarrassment. Abu Mazen embraced Khaled Meshal and proved, as Olmert has been claiming since the beginning of his term, that there is no partner on the Palestinian side. Rice insisted on coming to Jerusalem, and Olmert declared that he would turn the summit into a field trial. Ariel Sharon used to preach to Abbas that he should fight terror, and Olmert will demand fulfillment of the "Quartet conditions" and the release of Gilad Shalit, as well as the cessation of the firing of Qassams and the smuggling of arms into Gaza. As a partner of Hamas, Abu Mazen will find it difficult to claim political weakness as an excuse for inaction.

Sharon based his policy on his fear of the "corrals" of the final-status agreement. He knew that after Ehud Barak's proposals to the Syrians and the Palestinians, any future negotiations would begin from the shores of Lake Kinneret and the wall of the Temple Mount. Sharon was opposed to such a withdrawal and did everything possible not to enter the conference room. He kept pulling out new conditions: He demanded "seven days of quiet" from the Palestinians and waved the "six crimes of Damascus" in front of Assad. The maneuver was successful, and the international community adopted Israel's threshold demands, despite its support for the essential positions of the Arabs.

Olmert is the great successor of Sharon, and he is even more successful than his predecessor at presenting inflexible positions behind a mask of moderation and openness. He is sensitive to the nuances of the international community, woos its leaders and enlists them in imposing his conditions on the Palestinians. The Jerusalem summit will go down as another tactical victory for Olmert's "yes, but" policy, but will in no way bring us closer to a solution to the conflict. The only consolation is that Rice will come to the region this time in a small plane, thus cutting down on fuel and air pollution on her way to another unnecessary journey.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
'Cultural Attache'
The 3rd season of Dov Alfon's program is dedicated to rebels who buck Israeli conservatism.
A wise investment
Over the last 15 years, the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange has increased in value by 900%.
  1.   I agree 10:15  |  rose 15/02/07
  2.   Monday`s pointless Zionist gab-fest 10:20  |  Clickfool 15/02/07
  3.   OSLO COMES HOME TO ROOST !! STUPIDITY REVISITED !! 10:44  |  paul harris 15/02/07
  4.   THIS IS THE REASON 10:44  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  5.   Not only that 11:18  |  S 15/02/07
  6.   Abbas & Co planning to attack Israel, soon; does not matter..... 11:38  |  Pavel 15/02/07
  7.   Our sad reality... 11:41  |  Zeev 15/02/07
  8.   So true 12:37  |  Spider 15/02/07
  9.   For once I agree 12:56  |  Gee 15/02/07
  10.   what "peace" are you drooling about anyway? 13:29  |  Z Lando 15/02/07
  11.   # Hot Air and Waste of Time... 13:31  |  Kath` 15/02/07
  12.   America`s Plan 13:44  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/02/07
  13.   5 million refugees back...or there will be no peace 13:50  |  Palestinian 15/02/07
  14.   Definition of the word "peace"? 13:50  |  Celine Marchant 15/02/07
  15.   Victory is not an option for 13:50  |  JW 15/02/07
  16.   Palestinian, I do not know how many Palestinian Arab refugees.... 14:14  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  17.   OLMERTS DEFEATISM AND LEFTIST POLICIES WILL NEVER BRING PEACE 14:27  |  DAN ROSENTHAL 15/02/07
  18.   The Whole Thing Is A Sham 14:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  19.   # 14, CELINE MARCHANT 14:46  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  20.   Dog and pony show? 14:51  |  Mark Lincoln 15/02/07
  21.   To Dan Rosenthal 14:53  |  Anne 15/02/07
  22.   arab armies defeated 40 years ago 15:02  |  michael 15/02/07
  23.   Indrajaya # 19 - I agree with you for once 15:18  |  ChanahS 15/02/07
  24.   ChanaS, If this claptrap is really your view #23 15:26  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  25.   # 23, CHANAH.S. 15:30  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  26.   Anne, but this is the paradox #21 15:31  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  27.   Y. Sullivan vs. HannaS 15:45  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  28.   # 26, YAAKOV SULLIVAN 15:48  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  29.   #27 My position is clear.It doesnt need distortions #27 16:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  30.   indrajaya on #28 16:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  31.   Not a waste of time 16:14  |  Jonathan S 15/02/07
  32.   Hot Air- 16:20  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  33.   Nadav #16 16:28  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  34.   Where is Maimonides, now that you need him? 16:50  |  Hannah 15/02/07
  35.   Olmerts Obscurantism 16:50  |  Danite 15/02/07
  36.   Nadav 16:53  |  Danite 15/02/07
  37.   Gabe 1, I`ll tell you why discussing the subject is important. 17:08  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  38.   # 2 Clickfool, I partially agree 17:13  |  The Equalizer 15/02/07
  39.   Danite, if you mean the note regarding Likud etc., I have. I am 17:23  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  40.   Nadav #37 17:29  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  41.   Hanna #34 17:38  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  42.   # 28 - to Sullivan 17:40  |  ChanahS 15/02/07
  43.   Hanna #34 17:40  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  44.   # 24 Sullivan 17:41  |  ChanahS 15/02/07
  45.   Yaakov Sullivan # 29 The Two-State Solution 17:43  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  46.   Gabe 1, I am with you, I do think the world should disband UNRWA, 17:45  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  47.   # 29 Sullivan 17:46  |  ChanahS 15/02/07
  48.   Kath#11 17:46  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  49.   very Obvious that nothing will come out.. 17:50  |  Brad 15/02/07
  50.   # 30 Sullivan 17:51  |  Chanah 15/02/07
  51.   Nadav #46 17:51  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  52.   Thanks Jeff (end) 17:51  |  Chanah 15/02/07
  53.   # 37 Nadav.re:Gabe1............. 17:51  |  Kath` 15/02/07
  54.   Sadly to have Peace in this region we need....... 18:02  |  The observer 15/02/07
  55.   There will come a day 18:10  |  Baz Mann 15/02/07
  56.   Thank you Gabe and Kath` for your kind words. Does that mean that 18:11  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  57.   ChanahS on Apartheid #47 18:36  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  58.   clickfool and "zionist gabfest" 18:47  |  harzion 15/02/07
  59.   Nadav & Gabe 1 The UNRWA 18:53  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  60.   # 55 Baz Mann - geological depth?? 18:57  |  ChanahS 15/02/07
  61.   Buzz Mann # and analogies # 55 19:03  |  ChanahS 15/02/07
  62.   Why discuss Arafats "final solution" for Israel? 19:05  |  Yacov 15/02/07
  63.   An end to the illegal occupation of Palestine is the only hope 19:09  |  Stephen Murray 15/02/07
  64.   Jeff Northridge #59 19:17  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  65.   Goals vs. Means 19:23  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  66.   Stephen Murray, I agree completely, unfortunately..#63 19:25  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  67.   Advice to Abbas 19:35  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  68.   No Stephen, #63, Until... 20:11  |  Polybios 15/02/07
  69.   Hamas & Fatah Agree to Destroy Israel via Mecca pact 20:26  |  Bruriah Sarah 15/02/07
  70.   63 - Settlements are Legal 20:28  |  Bruriah Sarah 15/02/07
  71.   Stephen Murray # 63 What`s "Illegal" About It? 20:30  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  72.   63 - History of the Land 20:33  |  Bruriah Sarah 15/02/07
  73.   The US and Israel and Shallit 20:43  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/02/07
  74.   Tosefta #67 20:43  |  Gabe1 15/02/07
  75.   Stephen Murray , thank G-D ,jews take no orders 20:44  |  KJJ 15/02/07
  76.   Yaakov Sullivan Jews don`t take orders from 20:45  |  KJJ 15/02/07
  77.   # 45 Jeff Northridge..love the 2 state solution with a couple of 20:47  |  albert amato 15/02/07
  78.   Occupation & illegality (Murray #63; Sullivan#66; Northridge #71) 20:52  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  79.   57 - Apartheid Lie 21:00  |  Bruriah Sarah 15/02/07
  80.   To Tosefta..advice..have you trayed take for a walk with Dumbite? 21:15  |  soldier 15/02/07
  81.   Tosefta # 65 Flush Them 21:44  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  82.   #74 Gabe1 and logic 21:51  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  83.   Bruriah Sarah, As I said, it is a different variety #79 21:53  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  84.   tosefta and un resolutions 21:59  |  flashman 15/02/07
  85.   Drawing conclusions on Shalit (Ronnie Wolman #73) 22:00  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  86.   Aluf Benn, I intend to bang on many tables 22:02  |  Dutch 15/02/07
  87.   will israel do anything for peace? 22:06  |  flashman 15/02/07