Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., February 16, 2007 Shvat 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A Bailey bridge on the ramp
By Meron Benvenisti

The Mugrabi bridge fiasco is the object of such misunderstanding, criticism and derision that the most important point has been blurred: Our national and security interests are best served by preserving safe and easy access to the Mugrabi Gate, with the keys in the hands of the Israel Police.

Any renunciation of this would severely violate the status quo on the Temple Mount and its surroundings, thus increasing the danger of future bloodshed.

In other times, when other leaders ruled in Israel, the crisis would have been solved in one day. The defense minister would order the Engineering Corps to set up a portable Bailey bridge on the existing ramp, after bolstering it. Only then would the fighting over the desirable architectural form begin.

Advertisement

But when the Mugrabi Gate and the access to it become a ball in the game of people with political, religious, architectural and archaeological agendas, and no single body is responsible or able to make decisions, everything gets complicated.

A decade ago, Sheikh Raad Salah detected the rift in the Israeli establishment and its weak position on Temple Mount. He started a revolution on and beneath the mount plaza. Now Salah sees the divisions over the Western Wall plaza and is challenging the status quo there, too.

His obvious intention is to restore exclusive control of Temple Mount to the Muslim authorities and revoke the arrangements that have existed there since 1967. These arrangements have withstood bloody tests and are accepted as a stable status quo.

To judge by Israel's reactions, Salah is succeeding. Those who will pay the price for the militant national religious incitement are the residents of East Jerusalem, most of them bystanders, and Israel's Arab citizens, for his deliberate radicalization will foil efforts for a Jewish-Arab dialogue.

Salah's provocation is too blatant to be left without a harsh government reaction. But the Western Wall rabbi and the mayor of Jerusalem have already taken fright and hastened to put off the bridge's erection until the city master plan is confirmed. For years they have been exerting pressure to get rid of the Mugrabi ramp irritation. Removing it would expand the prayer area in the Western Wall plaza. It would also stop what they see as the "disgrace" of Jews violating the Torah prohibition to go to Temple Mount from the Western Wall plaza.

The people represented by the Western Wall rabbi and mayor have no interest in preserving free access for Jews and tourists to the Temple Mount. If the legal procedures take a long time now and Jews do not visit the mount - so much the better. There would be fewer people violating the Torah prohibition.

This attitude explains why the bridge was planned to be so long and begins at the Dung Gate. It cuts off the rise to the Temple Mount from the Western Wall plaza.

The plan of the new bridge, which stretches like a thin spider web along the massive Western Wall layers, justifiably provoked the wrath of the planners and archaeologists. The excavation for the bridge posts provided a focus for Muslim protests. The resulting political, bureaucratic and religious entanglements have little to do with the Mugrabi Gate itself.

We could continue wallowing in this mud, or we could take swift and resolute action. We could return the earth dug out of the Mugrabi ramp, reinforce its walls, instruct the Engineering Corps to immediately put up a Bailey bridge to replace the rickety one and dispatch police forces for protection from the zealots. If, of course, someone capable of acting quick-wittedly and firmly could be found.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
'Cultural Attache'
The 3rd season of Dov Alfon's program is dedicated to rebels who buck Israeli conservatism.
A wise investment
Over the last 15 years, the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange has increased in value by 900%.
  1.   This is what is really happening on Temple Mount 10:31  |  Judith, Haifa 15/02/07
  2.   From someone who put up a biley bridge 10:36  |  Israel Israeli 15/02/07
  3.   REALITY CHECKS CALLED FOR !! THE MYSTERY OF AL AKSA 10:41  |  paul harris 15/02/07
  4.   holy bridge walked by... 12:18  |  mary 15/02/07
  5.   Excellent Article: Rambam Visited Temple Mount 12:27  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 15/02/07
  6.   The Dayan Blunder, The Lupolianski Blunder 12:35  |  Yacov 15/02/07
  7.   The Mugrabi Gate Access Restoration Project 14:05  |  Educateyourself 15/02/07
  8.   Mary,a propos Mohamed and the toilets 14:29  |  Absolute Sweden 15/02/07
  9.   How About Putting The Average Citizen First 14:47  |  Tony Anthony 15/02/07
  10.   Perhaps the solution lies in the following 14:52  |  Yaakov Sullivan 15/02/07
  11.   #3 Paul Harris. People in glass houses 16:03  |  Rami 15/02/07
  12.   Tony in the US 16:40  |  Marilyn 15/02/07
  13.   The real issue is the Western Wall 17:11  |  Herbert Kaine 15/02/07
  14.   Judith.#1 What IS happening? 17:11  |  Rami 15/02/07
  15.   I have the best solution 17:13  |  Rabbi Toni Jutner 15/02/07
  16.   Marilyn Dear: Time to Take Your Meds 17:45  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 15/02/07
  17.   #12 22:53  |  Moshe 15/02/07
 Today Online
Rosner: Diaspora Jews should show special loyalty to Israel
Responses: 197
Chirac backs easing pressure on Iran to protect UNIFIL troops
Responses: 194
Aluf Benn: Three-way summit won't bring us closer to peace
Responses: 103
PM agrees to let Turkey inspect Jerusalem dig site
Responses: 149
The Muslim world needs a better voice than Ahmadinejad
Responses: 91
Diplomats: EU still divided on approach to Holocaust denial
Responses: 86


More Headlines
21:10 Officials: U.S. will boycott new Palestinian unity government
23:13 Hamas ministers resign to pave way for Fatah-Hamas coalition
21:45 Diplomats: EU still divided over how to handle Holocaust denial
20:04 PM agrees to let Turkey inspect Temple Mount construction site
23:46 Pelosi: Bush needs Congress' approval in order to invade Iran
02:25 Experts work to open secret Nazi archive for research
21:34 Employment Service: Israelis can replace all foreign workers
20:29 Jerusalem court extends restraining order barring Salah from Old City
02:12 Group seeks apology for memo linking evolution theory to Kabbalah
20:29 Tel Aviv District Court rejects use of cellular pinpointing as evidence
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved