Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 02, 2007 Iyyar 14, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:19 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Turkish alternative
By Pierre Besnainou

The Muslim world deserves a more respectable spokesman than Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the extremist and hateful president of Iran. That voice could well belong to Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

For almost half a century, the Muslim world has been witness to a variety of movements intended to unify it: nationalism that was a response to decolonization; the pan-Arabist ideologies of Gadhafi, Nasser and Saddam Hussein; and more recently, the Sunni version of Islamic radicalism typified by Al-Qaida, or the Shi'ite strain whose leader is the Islamic Republic of Iran. The dream of a unified Arab-Muslim world has imperceptibly metamorphized into the utopia of a unified Muslim world, bringing together the Umma, the community of believers. Today, the man who claims to personify this unity is President Ahmadinejad, even though he belongs to a minority within Islam, Shi'ism.

But that's not the worst of it. The type of rhetoric cultivated by the Iranian leader, which is based largely on the concept of jihad, "holy war," reflects an attitude of violence never before seen expressed toward the West, and specifically toward the United States and Israel, the latter of which he has threatened with annihilation. This warlike language is perceived as threatening even within the Muslim world, whose moderate regimes fear the creation of a Shi'ite crescent in the Middle East, one that could be a redoubtable force for destabilization. This impression is reinforced by the behavior of Iran's Lebanese client, Hezbollah, over the past few months.

Advertisement

On Iran's border, however, at the crossroads of West and East, is a country that manages to subtly maintain a balance between tradition and modernity: Turkey. Turkish society seems to have succeeded in making the transition to modernity by adapting Western values: secularism, freedom of thought and belief, and of course, democracy.

Here is a country that puts paid to all the theories characterizing Islam as incompatible with democracy. On the contrary, while clearly affirming its Muslim culture, Turkey manages to maintain a rights-based regime in the image of Western democracies.

Another measure of the openness of Muslim societies is gained by looking at the relations maintained by their governments with the United States, on the one hand, and Israel, on the other. Even if the Ankara government was in 2003 unwilling to have its territory used by the Anglo-American coalition against the Iraqi regime, partnership with the U.S. remains strong and of strategic importance.

In addition, Turkey was the first Muslim country to recognize Israel, in 1949, and for 30 years it was the only one as well. For several years now, Turkey has been an essential strategic partner to Israel's foreign policy. It is a partnership based on several pillars: a strong military alliance, a common cause of fighting terrorism, dynamic trade agreements, particularly on the very significant matter of water, not to mention the ongoing fact that the Anatolian peninsula is a favored tourist destination for many Israelis.

Some people believed that the rise to power of a party close to the Islamist movement, Erdogan's Justice and Development party, would bring that partnership to an end. The contrary is the case, however. Several years after Erdogan became prime minister, it can be said that the Israeli-Turkish alliance is still very much alive. Indeed, even if the speech or the tone sometimes changes, there has been no substantial modification of Turkish policy. In 2005, Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul visited Israel, with the purpose of strengthening bilateral relations, and a few months later, it was Prime Minister Erdogan's turn to visit, a reminder of the friendship of his country toward the Jewish state.

During my own recent visit to Ankara, I told Prime Minister Erdogan that I am convinced of the leading role he can play in the Middle East. Respected by the entire Muslim world, from the Gulf monarchies to the states of Central and Eastern Asia, from the Islamists of Hamas to the moderate Palestinians, Turkey has succeeded in maintaining a strong and loyal partnership with the United States and Israel as well. It thus has the legitimacy to be able to interact with all the influential participants in the area.

This position makes Turkey a natural choice to serve as regional leader, in place of the harmful influence of Iran. Prime Minister Erdogan, who agrees with this analysis, is, without any doubt, willing to work for rapprochement between Palestinians and Israelis. It is now up to us to take this friendly attitude into account, and to evaluate with an open mind the role that Turkey might be able to play in the peace process. This could finally lead to a significant weakening of President Ahmedinejad's leadership.

This is the reason why Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's visit in Ankara today is of special importance. That is the reason why the European Union should not brutally turn away from Turkey.

We can only hope that the next Nobel Peace Prize can be bestowed on someone who, within Islam, has succeeded in stopping the progression of hatred and resentment, bringing light and peace over an area plunged into the darkness of violence for too long a time.

The writer is president of the European Jewish Congress.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Olmert's honor student
A report on Dov Weisglass's time as head of Bezeq mirrors Winograd's findings on Olmert.
Secret pipeline
A list of the pipes dumping off of Israel's shores is one of the state's best-kept secrets.
  1.   DON`T WORRY JEWS CAN DO THAT 10:00  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  2.   Ahmadinejad: The President Who`s Really A Pauper! 10:36  |  Lavi 15/02/07
  3.   CORRECT THE VOICE OF SANITY !! TIME FOR THE 21ST CENTURY 10:38  |  paul harris 15/02/07
  4.   DETERMINATION IS NEEDED 10:38  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  5.   SOMEBODY without a "spcial light".Read memoirs of French F.M--- 11:33  |  PETER SM 15/02/07
  6.   thanks to ahmadinejad the world know`s the danger of islam 11:36  |  reuven 15/02/07
  7.   Indrajaya: 4 Stop the None sense. 11:36  |  Arab 15/02/07
  8.   Reuven: Najad doesn`t represent Islam and there are no dangers. 11:49  |  Arab 15/02/07
  9.   Some ignored points 11:58  |  Ali 15/02/07
  10.   Re: Jews can do it 12:10  |  Jairo 15/02/07
  11.   `What to do about the Muslims` 12:58  |  Spider 15/02/07
  12.   They are not all the same 13:00  |  Marilyn 15/02/07
  13.   indrajaya. 13:05  |  Rashti 15/02/07
  14.   To#1 Indrajaya 13:27  |  Angel of wind 15/02/07
  15.   The real monster is... 13:29  |  Maureen Ann 15/02/07
  16.   #Lavi, do you have something against... 13:48  |  Maureen Ann 15/02/07
  17.   # 13, RASHTI 13:59  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  18.   Ahmadinejad is the best man 13:59  |  Jonathan S 15/02/07
  19.   Can they hear Turkey? 14:05  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/02/07
  20.   JEWISH WORLD NEEDS A BETTER VOICE THAN OLMERT`S DEFEATISM 14:21  |  DAN ROSENTHAL 15/02/07
  21.   A message to Indrajaya the unconstructive 14:24  |  Rufus 15/02/07
  22.   #14 Angel of wind 14:24  |  Itsik 15/02/07
  23.   Jonathan S#18.... Ahmadinejad has his parallel in the West ! 14:26  |  Koko-Not 15/02/07
  24.   turkey? really? turkey?... 14:40  |  Marcelo 15/02/07
  25.   To #19: Ronnie 14:49  |  Angel of wind 15/02/07
  26.   # 21, RUFUS 14:57  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  27.   To #22 Itsik 15:00  |  Angel of wind 15/02/07
  28.   Israel is Europe 15:07  |  Anton Habiru 15/02/07
  29.   Darkness before dawn in the Arab world ?? 15:07  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/02/07
  30.   Angel of wind`s paradox.... 15:10  |  Rufus 15/02/07
  31.   # 4 Indrajaya 15:26  |  Lynn 15/02/07
  32.   Erdogan the Michael Melchior of the Muslim world 15:27  |  Profesora Isadora 15/02/07
  33.   # 23 Bush 15:33  |  Lynn 15/02/07
  34.   Erdoyan?? Really? 15:39  |  Maral 15/02/07
  35.   #20 - you are the reason that Orange settlers ar the most hated 15:41  |  Noam 15/02/07
  36.   To #30: Rufus 15:50  |  Angel of wind 15/02/07
  37.   # 31, LYNN 15:52  |  indrajaya 15/02/07
  38.   Angel of Wind: Ratios 15:55  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/02/07
  39.   Maral and the Armenian genocide 16:04  |  Nadav 15/02/07
  40.   Ahmadinejad is unrivalled #23 16:28  |  Jonathan S 15/02/07
  41.   A one sided article part 1 16:30  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 15/02/07
  42.   The Jewish certainly need a better voice than Israel. 16:38  |  Ibrahim 15/02/07
  43.   A one sided article part 2 16:41  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 15/02/07
  44.   A one sided article 16:41  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 15/02/07
  45.   Thanks for your sentiments, Nadav 16:42  |  Maral 15/02/07
  46.   # 37 Idrajaya 16:55  |  Lynn 15/02/07
  47.   By all means, criticize others while you whither within 16:55  |  Hannah 15/02/07
  48.   # 9 Ali from Istanbul 16:56  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 15/02/07
  49.   Maureen 16:59  |  Goz 15/02/07
  50.   # 48 Abu 17:04  |  Lynn 15/02/07
  51.   To # 38: I know that 17:07  |  Angel of wind 15/02/07
  52.   Democracy is not what impedes Turkish Islamification 17:29  |  bimmer 15/02/07
  53.   #11 Spider, #7 Arab - Together for Civilized Order 17:34  |  Civilized 15/02/07
  54.   ...and the Jewish world needs a better voice than Israel 17:39  |  Faggy Jew 15/02/07
  55.   The Turk and the Iranian 17:51  |  Sammy 15/02/07
  56.   They have lots of voices 18:02  |  bimmer 15/02/07
  57.   Swiss(Dino) 18:05  |  ODP 15/02/07
  58.   Indrajaya, you are right as the worlds most successful minority 18:08  |  Steve 15/02/07
  59.   Wide of the mark 18:25  |  The North Wind 15/02/07
  60.   The muslim word 18:28  |  Abby 15/02/07
  61.   Abby 19:05  |  Goz 15/02/07
  62.   #16 Maureen: Ahmadinejad Puffs Himself Up As ... 19:07  |  Lavi 15/02/07
  63.   # 57 ODP 19:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/02/07
  64.   Erdogan is good for Israel but I`m not complaining 19:24  |  Turkish Revolution 15/02/07
  65.   Lavi ..too much spin 19:28  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 15/02/07
  66.   ahmadinejad 19:45  |  clearthinking 15/02/07
  67.   nobel peace prize 19:49  |  real vision 15/02/07
  68.   Muslim world is waYYYY bigger than Pierre Thinks 19:49  |  omolll 15/02/07
  69.   How about King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia as VOTIW 20:08  |  Voice of Reason 15/02/07
  70.   #65 Abu Firas Al Qudsi 20:15  |  Goz 15/02/07
  71.   clearthinking 20:20  |  Goz 15/02/07
  72.   to arab # 8 then why are these terrorist groups commiting these 20:24  |  terrornator 15/02/07
  73.   DON`T BE FOOLED BY TURKEY 20:25  |  Arik Silverman 15/02/07
  74.   Swiss(Dino) 20:30  |  ODP 15/02/07
  75.   Angel of Wind: Breeze or Hurricane? 20:32  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/02/07
  76.   sorry maureen the "butcher of bagdad" has been reserved for 20:34  |  terrornator 15/02/07
  77.   to indrajaya # 17 we all knew a message of peace would never 20:37  |  terrornator 15/02/07
  78.   #73 "Don`t be fooled by Turkey" 20:39  |  Goz 15/02/07
  79.   Indrajaya -- insulting Muhammed yet again 20:55  |  bbl 15/02/07
  80.   Erdogan? NO JOKE! 21:00  |  Yuhanna Alqarmidi 15/02/07
  81.   Wrong perception 21:01  |  Gene 15/02/07
  82.   Truksh Alternative02/15/2007 21:38  |  guven 15/02/07
  83.   to indrajaya in general:listen,little man you better be glad 21:43  |  terrornator 15/02/07
  84.   #70 Goz in Dallas 22:02  |  Abu Firas AL Qudsi 15/02/07
  85.   #84 Abu Firas AL Qudsi 22:50  |  Goz 15/02/07
  86.   Ibrahim #42 23:20  |  David Israel 15/02/07
  87.   Mr. Besnainou - I respectfully disagree 23:31  |  David Israel 15/02/07
  88.   # 65 Abu: "Pauper In Mentality" As Claimed! 23:45  |  Lavi 15/02/07
  89.   I had no idea he spoke for Islam 23:48  |  Mark Lincoln 15/02/07
  90.   Please Ibrahim 23:57  |  Danite 15/02/07
  91.   To Abu Firas Al Qudsi-48 00:09  |  Ali 16/02/07
  92.   To David Israel-AKP-Armenian Diaspora-genocide? 00:14  |  Nazım Sorguç 16/02/07
  93.   #Goz in Dallas again 00:17  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 16/02/07
  94.   Lavi..You are obsessed with Uday 00:30  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 16/02/07
  95.   #91 Abu: US Soldiers Would Rather Be Back On California Beaches! 01:43  |  Lavi 16/02/07
  96.   Why does the muslim world need a spokesman? 02:16  |  Johnboy 16/02/07
  97.   #48 Abu 02:36  |  Osman 16/02/07
  98.   Islam needs a stronger culture of anti-terrorism 03:32  |  Ari 16/02/07
  99.   Silly Pierre 04:27  |  Paulo 16/02/07
  100.   Stop putting one in and other out. 05:01  |  Simon Mohammed 16/02/07
  101.   Dr. Ahmadinejad is the best 05:13  |  Guss 16/02/07
  102.   IF Ahmadinejad gets his nukes his influence will be very strong 05:17  |  PETER SM 16/02/07
  103.   Radicals Making All the Noise These Days 06:04  |  Jane 16/02/07
  104.   # 91 Abu: 06:28  |  Lavi 16/02/07
  105.   The Turkish Alternative 07:45  |  Ahmed M Ibrahim 16/02/07
  106.   Erdogan and Armenians 08:01  |  Mehmet 16/02/07
  107.   # 79, BBL 08:15  |  indrajaya 16/02/07
  108.   The Turkish alternative 08:16  |  Majed Elhewaihi 16/02/07
  109.   # 83, TERRORNATOR 08:17  |  indrajaya 16/02/07
  110.   Indrajaya Could Be A Great Muslim Leader Too If... 09:11  |  Yosemite 16/02/07
  111.   Rejectionist government in Israel 09:57  |  Michael 16/02/07
  112.   Ahminejad and Bush 10:01  |  Michael 16/02/07
  113.   American supporters of dictatorship 10:09  |  Michael 16/02/07
  114.   "A one sided article part 1" 10:14  |  Michael 16/02/07
  115.   What an insult to other victims of Genocide. 10:40  |  Steve D. 16/02/07
  116.   Lack of respect for human rights in the U.S. 10:50  |  Michael 16/02/07
  117.   re: Anton #28 10:59  |  Paulo 16/02/07
  118.   To Steve D 12:40  |  Ali 16/02/07
  119.   #114 Michael 14:34  |  Goz 16/02/07
  120.   To this lunatic indrajaya 16:19  |  german 16/02/07
  121.   Armenian Genocide and Turkish Archives 21:41  |  Hagop 16/02/07
  122.   Turkey needs Israel 02:29  |  Cheryl 17/02/07
  123.   1)Arabs problem: Empires can be build but not rebuilt 13:50  |  Akram Zekaria 17/02/07
  124.   2)Arab Proble:Empires can be built but not rebuilts. 14:59  |  Akram Zekaria 17/02/07
  125.   123# Pllease correct a typing error : 08:49  |  Akram Zekaria 18/02/07
  126.   Bush,saving Islam from the Infidels. 09:53  |  Akram Zekaria 18/02/07
  127.   Turks 17:43  |  Gokhan 21/02/07
  128.   Re: Turks have always been very tolerant to the other religions a 22:53  |  Constantino 27/02/07
  129.   To paolo 117 22:57  |  mitch 27/02/07
  130.   yes, Turkey, really.. 06:24  |  Ari 03/03/07
  131.   Yes, Turkey, really! 06:34  |  Ari 03/03/07
  132.   #48 - Misinformed, still under propaganda of Lawrence 07:24  |  Ari 03/03/07
  133.   #115 - typical cheap shot 07:42  |  Ari 03/03/07
  134.   #128 - please more information 07:54  |  Ari 03/03/07
  135.   Armenian genocide 10:06  |  Cousin2thejews 25/03/07
  136.   Armenian genocide 10:12  |  Cousin2thejews 25/03/07
  137.   So called Armenian genocide (!) 10:53  |  Dilek 25/03/07
  138.   Armenians 11:46  |  mert 25/03/07
  139.   Erdogan and Armenians 12:03  |  qwerty 25/03/07
  140.   DILEK READ THIS 12:10  |  qwerty 25/03/07
  141.   Bogus Genocide Songs 13:20  |  Brian 25/03/07
  142.   to Ari 20:19  |  Cousin2thejews 25/03/07
  143.   Israeli denial. 22:28  |  Vahe 25/03/07
  144.   Armenian Issue-2 02:05  |  Dilek 27/03/07
  145.   IF NOT TURKEY....THEN WHO? 15:00  |  Scott 29/03/07
  146.   Armenian tragedy and Jewish experience not close to being similar 15:37  |  Scott 29/03/07
  147.   Turkey is nothing today 16:31  |  Mohd Kashif 29/03/07
  148.   hi marcelo 02:16  |  yasin 06/04/07
  149.   Turkish secularism, money, gas, colanists 22:43  |  Eren 09/04/07
  150.   Turkey 20:45  |  nc 10/04/07
  151.   Armenia 21:03  |  ncayar 10/04/07
  152.   Armenian Reality 22:04  |  ncayar 10/04/07
  153.   The Big Picture1 22:04  |  mk 12/04/07
  154.   The Big Picture2 22:10  |  mk 12/04/07
  155.   Why genocide and holocaust don`t mix 20:14  |  Matt 02/05/07
 Today Online
Livni: Olmert must quit; opposes fresh elections
Responses: 123
Aides: Defense Minister Peretz could resign within hours
Responses: 58
Ex-MK Bishara suspected of treason and espionage
Responses: 42
Abbas: Location of BBC reporter known, raid could harm him
Responses: 44
Palestinian fined in N.Y. for hiding brother's terror plans
Responses: 33


More Headlines
20:04 Livni: Olmert must resign; opposes fresh elections
18:37 Ex-MK Bishara suspected of treason, passing data to Hezbollah
20:11 Yitzhaki quits as coalition chair after ultimatum to Olmert
18:41 Hearing ends on Katsav rape allegations; another hearing in two weeks
19:48 Nasrallah praises Israel for Winograd panel findings
16:59 Abbas: Location of kidnapped BBC reporter known, fear raid could harm him
18:44 Student strike protest ends with 32 demonstrators arrested
17:17 Egyptian official: Rice to meet with Syrian FM during Iraq conference
18:54 Aides: Defense Minister Peretz could resign within hours
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved