Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., February 16, 2007 Shvat 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:12 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
What a strange 'abroad'
By Amira Hass

Now it is official: The Gaza Strip is "abroad." As of February 1, the few Israelis whose entry into the Strip is approved by the army have had to present a passport at the Erez crossing, and they are listed on the Interior Ministry's computer as having crossed the country's borders.

The Gaza Strip is "abroad" in a strange way. Israelis need a passport to get there, and Palestinian Jerusalemites need a laissez passer - the same one they need to present when they fly to Paris via Ben-Gurion International Airport. But when these same Jerusalemites go to Jordan via the Allenby Bridge, they use a Jordanian passport. And the Palestinians who live in that "abroad" - the Gazans - are, for the meantime, exempt from crossing with a Palestinian passport; this exemption also applies to residents of the West Bank, by order of the interior minister.

The confusing multiplicity of procedures is still more remarkable in light of the fact that Israel allows only a few people to enter and leave the Strip. Only a small number of Israelis receive this permission - mainly those with relatives in Gaza or people, primarily women, who have been married to Gaza residents for years. Receiving a permit requires prior coordination, which is very cumbersome, and it sometimes takes days until the request for a permit or a permit extension finds a fax line without a busy signal at the "office for Israeli affairs" in the Civil Administration, a military body to which the interior minister has granted the authority to continue operating the crossing.

Advertisement

Crossing the approximately half a kilometer that separates the Palestinian side from the Israeli one requires additional coordination, on the phone, and an hours-long wait until the soldiers and clerks on the Israeli side allow permit holders to walk through. But this is not what makes the strangeness of the Gazan "abroad" unique; to many, this is simply reminiscent of the difficulties that totalitarian regimes imposed on travel between countries in Eastern Europe.

The "abroad" of Gaza is strange primarily for a different reason, a more fundamental one: All its residents are listed in the same population registry as residents of the West Bank, which is not "abroad," and the entire list is controlled by Israel's Interior Ministry. This control gives Interior Ministry representatives in the Civil Administration authority that the Palestinian interior minister lacks. This control allowed Israel to deprive hundreds of thousands of Palestinians of their residency status after 1967. It allowed the continuation of marital, social, economic, religious and cultural ties between Gaza and the West Bank until 1991 - and then, it severed those ties. This control allows Israel to prevent the addition of foreign residents to the population registry; it allows Israel to intervene in, and even decide, the choice of a partner, place of study, type of medical treatment, address, quality time with children, participation in celebrations and funerals, the writing of wills and distribution of family property. Israel has the authority to ban the entry of friends or family members who are not Palestinian residents - not just their entry into Israel, but also into the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Since October 2000, the ban has been comprehensive.

Only Palestinians registered as residents in the Israeli computer system can cross at the Rafah terminal, when it is open. Israel has the authority to ban Gazans from traveling to the West Bank or living there, and has been doing so with increasing fervor since 1991, when it began implementing the closure policy. This is the "abroad" that Israelis require a passport to enter. This is the "abroad" for which Israel argues that it has no responsibility. And this is the greatness of the Israeli occupation: It manages to present itself as nonexistent, while its authority reaches all the way to the bedroom.

No, this is not a recommendation to take another unilateral step and erase the Gazans from the Palestinian population registry, which is under Israeli control, in addition to the geographic and human separation. On the contrary! It is preferable for Israel to continue snooping around in their bedrooms than to take a step that would finally complete the separation between Gaza residents and their brothers in the West Bank.

There is reason for concern. A move such as erasing the Gazans from the registry fits the thought process that has characterized Israeli policy toward the Strip since 1991. Over the past 16 years, residents of the crowded, 360-square-kilometer Strip have been ordered to get used to its transformation into a kind of isolated autarkic economy and make do with the little it produces: increasingly little (and increasingly polluted) water; diminishing land; declining sources of income; industry and agriculture with no markets; and inferior educational and health institutions, due to their isolation from the world and the West Bank.

The peak of this policy, so far, was the disengagement in 2005. This is a policy that contradicts what is written in the Oslo Accords, which call the Strip and the West Bank a single territorial unit, as well as international resolutions about the solution for peace. But evacuating a few thousand settlers from the Strip was successfully marketed as Israeli moderation, even as Israel strengthened all its methods of control over the West Bank. Israel is also liable to market the deletion of Gazan names from the population registry as some kind of goodwill gesture. But such a move would only intensify the human distress of Gaza's 1.4 million residents, as well as their separation from the world. And that is a proven recipe for keeping a reasonable peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians at a distance.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Asking the right questions
The Winograd Committee should carefully weigh the options before meting out the punishment.
A dangerous coalition
Advocates of economic liberalism are standing united to defend the government from destroyers.
  1.   Gaza needs to be completely separate 11:15  |  Avner 14/02/07
  2.   What DO you want?? 11:17  |  nina 14/02/07
  3.   Surely such cruelty must end soon! 11:19  |  Maureen Ann 14/02/07
  4.   Amira = Princess in Arabic 11:27  |  faysal 14/02/07
  5.   #3 Maureen Ann: Christians must end cruelty to Aborigines 11:31  |  Avner 14/02/07
  6.   gaza = isreali concentration camp 11:39  |  palestinian in exile 14/02/07
  7.   Hi Avner, 11:40  |  Michael 14/02/07
  8.   faisal loves amira 11:42  |  leviev 14/02/07
  9.   AMIRA, strength to you 11:49  |  RAFI 14/02/07
  10.   pal in exile 11:50  |  leviev 14/02/07
  11.   Hi Michael 11:53  |  Avner 14/02/07
  12.   amira gaas 11:58  |  leviev 14/02/07
  13.   amira gaas "simplify the border procedures" 12:00  |  leviev 14/02/07
  14.   amira gaas "a reasonable peace agreement" 12:07  |  leviev 14/02/07
  15.   every land outside green/blue line should be treated as Gaza 12:07  |  John 14/02/07
  16.   amira gaas"diminishing land" 12:08  |  leviev 14/02/07
  17.   #5Avner Your pathetic attempt to justify Israeli... 12:15  |  Maureen Ann 14/02/07
  18.   the story of the glass houses 12:17  |  leviev 14/02/07
  19.   #3 M AUREEN AND THE VOICE ARABS DONT WANT WOMENS VOICES 12:18  |  paul harris 14/02/07
  20.   "snooping in their bedrooms" 12:19  |  leviev 14/02/07
  21.   amira "let gazans take missiles technology to the west bank" 12:22  |  leviev 14/02/07
  22.   What Amira wants (to Nina) 12:23  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 14/02/07
  23.   amira listen carefully 12:24  |  leviev 14/02/07
  24.   is amira haas a proponent of the 12:28  |  leviev 14/02/07
  25.   One more thing, Avner, #5, 12:31  |  Michael 14/02/07
  26.   Paul Harris 12:32  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 14/02/07
  27.   leviev 12:35  |  palestinian in exile 14/02/07
  28.   Maureen Anne 12:37  |  Zelkha 14/02/07
  29.   well done amira 12:39  |  editor guardian uk 14/02/07
  30.   No. 8 - Leviev 12:40  |  faysal 14/02/07
  31.   take my hat off to you amira 12:40  |  robert fisk obese 14/02/07
  32.   another winner amira 12:43  |  editor indie 14/02/07
  33.   pal in exile 12:45  |  leviev 14/02/07
  34.   pal in exile 12:48  |  yirmi 14/02/07
  35.   Leviev, there is no need to worry 12:49  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 14/02/07
  36.   faysal dubai 12:52  |  leviev 14/02/07
  37.   amira you can be of even more help 12:56  |  princesaud 14/02/07
  38.   amira haas 12:58  |  haniyah 14/02/07
  39.   Avner 12:59  |  Walid 14/02/07
  40.   berlin cord 13:01  |  leviev 14/02/07
  41.   leviev 13:02  |  palestinian in exile 14/02/07
  42.   Amira Hass 13:02  |  Aliza 14/02/07
  43.   berlin cord "is amira a self hating jew" 13:03  |  leviev 14/02/07
  44.   berlin cord "amira seems to have a different impression" 13:05  |  leviev 14/02/07
  45.   berlin cord "amira has heard of the qassems as well " 13:08  |  lviev 14/02/07
  46.   berlin cord "israeli domination" 13:10  |  lviev 14/02/07
  47.   berlin cord "perhaps amira digs deeper" 13:11  |  leviev 14/02/07
  48.   yirmi 13:19  |  palestinian in exile 14/02/07
  49.   pal in exile 13:25  |  leviev 14/02/07
  50.   Liviev Liveiv 13:25  |  faysal 14/02/07
  51.   Problems in Accepting Amira 13:26  |  Walid 14/02/07
  52.   To Aliza 13:30  |  Lena 14/02/07
  53.   Given the Task of Keeping Israel Terror Free What Would You Do? 13:58  |  Jane 14/02/07
  54.   Historian Walid from Beirut, who is being fed 14:13  |  Yehiel Shalev 14/02/07
  55.   Broadminded and narrowminded Hass 14:15  |  Philip 14/02/07
  56.   ...to Palestinian in exile#6...It is a war, Stupid 14:16  |  soldier 14/02/07
  57.   Guardian`s Editor 14:24  |  Michel Assayag 14/02/07
  58.   Amira Hass-Hess is a traitor (as well as Gideon Levy) 14:24  |  Vittorio 14/02/07
  59.   Right on!! Avner #1 14:25  |  Dror 14/02/07
  60.   gaza strip 14:33  |  habakook 14/02/07
  61.   To Phillip 14:58  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 14/02/07
  62.   soldier 15:01  |  palestinian in exile 14/02/07
  63.   What a strange `abroad`? What a strange broad! 15:02  |  Ronnie Wolman 14/02/07
  64.   #26 CORD STRIKES ANOTE OF DISCORD 15:08  |  paul harris 14/02/07
  65.   Ms. Hass this what they demanded 15:08  |  Gee 14/02/07
  66.   Avner/Dror 15:11  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 14/02/07
  67.   This is Ruinous for Israel 15:14  |  Yigal 14/02/07
  68.   to Vitorio#58,a little difference,Amira pro-pal and Gideon strons 15:19  |  UGY the she camel 14/02/07
  69.   Tap-Tap-Tap-TapTap-Tap-Tap 15:23  |  Tony Anthony 14/02/07
  70.   Create a ghetto and call it liberation 15:25  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/02/07
  71.   Abroad 15:32  |  Mitch Cohen 14/02/07
  72.   And the Crowds Screamed 15:36  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/02/07
  73.   faisal enjoying dubai and talking big 15:38  |  leviev 14/02/07
  74.   faisal and israeli pilots 15:42  |  leviev 14/02/07
  75.   so whats the answer amira ??WHAT ARE YOUR ALTERNATIVES ?? 15:45  |  paul harris 14/02/07
  76.   faisal i have found that you all resort to 15:48  |  leviev 14/02/07
  77.   faisal and "ignorance" 15:51  |  leviev 14/02/07
  78.   #64 Cord: So why did you waste our time with your silly posting? 15:54  |  Avner 14/02/07
  79.   we in israel left gaza years ago 15:56  |  leviev 14/02/07
  80.   we are no longer in gaza 15:59  |  leviev 14/02/07
  81.   Censors:So Amira is not a broad? 16:03  |  Ronnie Wolman 14/02/07
  82.   michael assayag 16:04  |  editor guardian uk 14/02/07
  83.   why is yaakov sullivan so bitchy 16:07  |  hispsychiatrist 14/02/07
  84.   Cemsors Thank you! 16:08  |  Ronnie Wolman 14/02/07
  85.   you think you know what it`s like? read our 16:13  |  www.machsomwatch.org 14/02/07
  86.   Censors: theres an advertising and promo fee you know! 16:18  |  Ronnie Wolman 14/02/07
  87.   Haaretz Censors: Don`t be ridiculous and show my message to Walid 16:23  |  MR 14/02/07
  88.   ask the gazans where they would look for work? 16:24  |  sense 14/02/07
  89.   amira haas is something between abroad 16:25  |  jack ezer 14/02/07
  90.   Amira Hass for Prime Minister of Palestine! 16:50  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 14/02/07
  91.   In Guardian We Trust 16:53  |  Ronnie Wolman 14/02/07
  92.   "Israelis" must obtain passports from Belarus and Moldova 17:04  |  Amin Nusseibeh 14/02/07
  93.   Haas finally checked the map --Gaza is in Egypt 17:07  |  Sal 14/02/07
  94.   Amira 17:08  |  Ahmed 14/02/07
  95.   Fail to see the criticism of official move towards independence? 17:10  |  Smadar 14/02/07
  96.   Faysal 17:32  |  Harry 14/02/07
  97.   Is this really too bad for you to post? 17:41  |  Nik Miller 14/02/07
  98.   Walid 17:48  |  ODP 14/02/07
  99.   Yehiel Shalev and MR 17:50  |  Walid 14/02/07
  100.   Paul Harris 17:53  |  Abby 14/02/07
  101.   Welcome back # 92, Amin Nusseibeh, haven`t heard from you for 18:08  |  Smadar 14/02/07
  102.   Yaakov Sullivan 18:25  |  Marco Poletti 14/02/07
  103.   Our extremist interior minister 18:26  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  104.   Gaza is still legally "occupied" 18:38  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  105.   Ami Goldman 18:52  |  Walid 14/02/07
  106.   i do wish all would stop using the words censors 18:53  |  notanotherone 14/02/07
  107.   Thank you Marco Poletti #98 19:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/02/07
  108.   Needn`t go to E. Europe for totalitarian regimes 19:30  |  bimmer 14/02/07
  109.   Counterproductive Arguments 19:36  |  Mark of Lewiston 14/02/07
  110.   Amira Hass= Honesty Truthfulness. 19:54  |  Angelina 14/02/07
  111.   Tosefta # 100 Control of Borders Is Not an Occupation 20:00  |  Jeff Northridge 14/02/07
  112.   Stop the stupid scolding on Amira Hass 20:01  |  Reflection 14/02/07
  113.   Yehiel Shalev and MR 20:21  |  Walid 14/02/07
  114.   Anyone want peace? 20:28  |  Dana G 14/02/07
  115.   Amin Nusseibeh # 92 If That`s the Choice, Then 20:34  |  Jeff Northridge 14/02/07
  116.   Jeff Northridge and his definitions #105 20:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/02/07
  117.   The logic of occupation (Jeff Northridge #105) 20:53  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  118.   Israel aqlso believes Gaza is occupied (Jeff Northridge #105) 21:01  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  119.   #83 hispsychiatrast, bitchiness could have many 21:04  |  TOMY 14/02/07
  120.   Ronnie Wolman 21:07  |  Gabe1 14/02/07
  121.   Ronnie Wolman 21:09  |  Gabe1 14/02/07
  122.   #92 Amin Nusseibeh,so you saing, we can 21:13  |  TOMY 14/02/07
  123.   wow - one would think the pals would stop terror 21:21  |  matt 14/02/07
  124.   judgement from tveira 21:27  |  flashman 14/02/07
  125.   Maureen Ann -- It wasn`t just 200 years ago. 21:28  |  bbl 14/02/07
  126.   charity from tveira 21:30  |  flashman 14/02/07
  127.   is tosefta putting us on? 21:32  |  flashman 14/02/07
  128.   Gaza and the West Bank remain Occupied AND 21:33  |  Ibrahim 14/02/07
  129.   tosefta 21:34  |  flashman 14/02/07
  130.   tosefta"so why complicate life" 21:35  |  flashman 14/02/07
  131.   grin and bear it tosefta 21:38  |  flashman 14/02/07
  132.   Maureen Ann doesn`t know her own country is notriously racists 21:38  |  bbl 14/02/07
  133.   tosefta i have to say that i find your charity quite unbelievable 21:43  |  flashman 14/02/07
  134.   Dana G #108 21:53  |  Abby 14/02/07
  135.   Israel also believes Gaza is occupied (Jeff Northridge #105) 21:53  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  136.   tosefta "crossing into egypt is under israeli remote control" 22:06  |  flashman 14/02/07
  137.   Our verbally diarrhetic "flushman"; aka The Hydra 22:08  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  138.   tosefta "hint it is not what you thought" 22:08  |  flashman 14/02/07
  139.   tosefta "by what right does israel control the waters of gaza" 22:10  |  flashman 14/02/07
  140.   No, flashman, it`s just that he doesnt provide a cover #119 22:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/02/07
  141.   to cord kaldrack#22 22:11  |  nina 14/02/07
  142.   Walid my friend, you seem to know very little 22:17  |  Fawaz 14/02/07
  143.   Ronnie Wolman 22:19  |  Gabe1 14/02/07
  144.   tosefta this is too easy 22:21  |  flashman 14/02/07
  145.   Another Country: Perhaps Gaza is from another planet 22:21  |  Larry Levine 14/02/07
  146.   tosefta"israel controls the egypt border with gaza by threats" 22:23  |  flashman 14/02/07
  147.   tosefta "the swiss think that it is occupation" 22:26  |  flashman 14/02/07
  148.   tosefta "the swiss have legal people who know better" 22:29  |  flashman 14/02/07
  149.   #113 - #120 Flashman, stop nitpicking after Tosefta`s posts 22:31  |  Smadar 14/02/07
  150.   so this is the logic of tosefta 22:31  |  flashman 14/02/07
  151.   Tosefta # 111 & Yaakov Sullivan # 110 22:43  |  Jeff Northridge 14/02/07
  152.   ...to poor palestine in exile..mass detention centre... 23:06  |  soldier 14/02/07
  153.   # 119 Ibrahim 23:14  |  ChanahS 14/02/07
  154.   Ibrahim # 116 A Seige Is Not an Occupation 23:16  |  Jeff Northridge 14/02/07
  155.   tosefta and the answer is? 23:17  |  flashman 14/02/07
  156.   to zeev schiff on the ashkenazi article 23:30  |  flashman 14/02/07
  157.   zeev schiff is quite right in saying that no cos would have 23:34  |  flashman 14/02/07
  158.   Logic (Jeff Northridge #142) 23:45  |  Tosefta 14/02/07
  159.   ...to pal in exile#62...OK...it is occupation... 23:46  |  soldier 14/02/07
  160.   #136 .Larry Gaza, ,the last place on Earth??? 00:16  |  Brad 15/02/07
  161.   FOUL Language 00:35  |  T. Newcomer 15/02/07
  162.   Jeff Northridge # 142 and other posts 00:52  |  albert amato 15/02/07
  163.   #63 Ronnie Wolman 00:56  |  Boycott 15/02/07
  164.   Logic (Jeff Northridge #142) 01:13  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  165.   #127 Flashman and the Rafah crossing 01:13  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  166.   Walid in Gaza article? why you care eh 01:18  |  Tamir Gaza 15/02/07
  167.   #141 No, flashman, the logic is quite different 01:19  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  168.   Tosefta # 126 It`s Still Not an "Occupation" 01:29  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  169.   #105 Jeff Northridge and which side of the border Israel controls 01:30  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  170.   Gabe: Free and not so Free Press 01:47  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/02/07
  171.   last place on earth 02:49  |  Larry 15/02/07
  172.   last place on earth 02:52  |  larry levine 15/02/07
  173.   Tosefta # 144 And It Ended In Sept., 2005 03:13  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  174.   Still not thinking (lJeff Northridge #148) 03:25  |  Tosefta 15/02/07
  175.   Gaza different from West Bank-no israeli civilians in gaza 03:39  |  Voice of Reason 15/02/07
  176.   Tosefta # 144 Your So-Called "Logical" Points (part 1) 03:49  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  177.   larry levine--last place on earth 04:03  |  bewert 15/02/07
  178.   Palestinian Muslim leaders are the worst leaders in the world 04:07  |  Objective 15/02/07
  179.   Tosefta # 144 Your So-Called "Logical" Points (part 2) 04:09  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  180.   You`re OK ... 04:22  |  Harry 15/02/07
  181.   Tosefta # 152 I Have Thought About It 04:42  |  Jeff Northridge 15/02/07
  182.   #153 Voice of Reason 05:49  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  183.   Amira Hass 05:52  |  connie 15/02/07
  184.   #154 Jeff Northridge - two points 06:01  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  185.   #155 Jeff Northridge and incursions 06:15  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  186.   Amira Rewrites History - Bad Journalism 06:46  |  Headly 15/02/07
  187.   #28 Zelka, Old British Colonialism. 06:48  |  Maureen Ann 15/02/07
  188.   #19 Paul Harris, The photo of the elderly Bedouin man. 07:05  |  Maureen Ann 15/02/07
  189.   They wanted autonomy 07:50  |  Efox 15/02/07
  190.   #140, Smadar 09:06  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 15/02/07
  191.   #157 Jeff and Rafah 09:15  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  192.   #168 Efox, gee, what a pity.... 09:25  |  Johnboy 15/02/07
  193.   Gaza first 09:43  |  Haytham 15/02/07
  194.   Amira Hass "What a strange "abroad" 18:16  |  Tony 15/02/07
  195.   Amira, Isn`t this both ironic and disgraceul? 02:29  |  Dutch 16/02/07
  196.   #181 Jeff Nortridge and "economic blockade" 03:41  |  Johnboy 16/02/07
 Today Online
Salah calls for intifada to defend Al-Aqsa Mosque
Responses: 249
S. Rosner: Jewish voters want to be convinced on Obama
Responses: 102
Jerome Segal: Grab the chance for a final-status deal with Abbas
Responses: 89
N. Shragai: Turkey visit opens door to more Temple Mt. meddling
Responses: 38
Lebanon war failed to deal with Hezbollah short-range rockets
Responses: 36


More Headlines
20:22 Nasrallah says entitled to move arms to fight Israel
20:09 Salah calls for intifada against Temple Mount construction
21:50 Report: Russia expects Israel-PA summit to yield fresh peace talks
21:47 Haniyeh says hopes to form new government within three weeks
15:50 Sen. Obama: U.S. must support Israel's right to self defense
18:56 Justice Min. Friedmann holds secret meeting with Haim Ramon
18:55 IDF soldier, three Israelis lightly hurt at Bil'in anti-fence protest
13:07 Olmert backs transfer of four prisoners to Jordanian custody
12:17 Zeiler commission to slam police chief, recommend dismissals
21:32 Israeli film Sweet Mud awarded top youth prize at Berlin Film Festival
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved