Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., February 16, 2007 Shvat 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:19 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Who did you say needs recognition?
By Yoel Marcus

Negotiations on the establishment of a Palestinian state will begin February 19, the U.S. State Department spokesman announced in a laconic tone. On that day, which is next Monday, Condoleezza Rice will host Ehud Olmert and Mahmoud Abbas in Washington for talks on how to promote a "political horizon." This, Rice said, will give the Palestinians an idea of what their future state, alongside Israel, is going to look like.

By laying this "political horizon" (a hatchling of the Bush plan) on the table, she is aiming for the opposite of violence on the horizon. Above all, the intention is to end the bloody civil war between Hamas and Fatah in Gaza, which decreases the chance for an agreement with Israel on establishing a Palestinian state, the longer it goes on.

The ghastly pictures from Gaza, which the world watches on television, once again bring to mind Abba Eban's famous dictum that the Palestinians have never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity. It is the kind of bloodbath that only helps the Greater Israel fanatics dig in their heels and say no to an agreement based on withdrawal to the 1967 borders.

Advertisement

In the wake of Bush's request, or arm-twisting, Saudi Arabia has become a mediator. In return for a billion-dollar donation to the territories and a possible renewal of global aid, it has produced a peace plan - not with Israel, but between Hamas and Fatah. According to the plan, the Mecca agreement, Mahmoud Abbas will continue to chair the Palestinian Authority and Hamas' Ismael Haniyeh will remain prime minister. Portfolios have been divvied up Israel-style, but with one difference: We don't murder one another, starve our citizens or make life miserable for an entire people in order to put together a coalition.

Bush is known for his short fuse, and presumably this is not the baby he was waiting for. The Saudis have pulled a half-baked plan out of their oven. The missing ingredients include the principles of the Bush plan and the road map, in which recognizing Israel is a chief component; putting a stop to terror; and honoring all previous agreements.

Not that the promises of the Palestinians mean very much: As soon as Arafat pocketed the Nobel Peace Prize, he launched a wave of terror, allowing Islamic militants to carry out suicide bombings in Israel. In the end, he instigated the al-Aqsa Intifada, which left a heap of bodies on both sides.

But now we are dealing with Hamas, part and parcel of a bloodthirsty Islamic movement that regards America as the big Satan and Israel as the little Satan. Hamas has no problem killing its Arab brothers, and is eager to see Israel's demise. It can hardly wait for the day when Iran has the bomb and Ahmadinejad keeps his word.

The Mecca agreement, which has no clause recognizing Israel or on abstaining from terror, is a farce in the eyes of the U.S. administration and Israel. The immediate response of the Prime Minister's Office was that Israel has no intention of recognizing a Palestinian unity government as long as Hamas refuses to recognize Israel.

What I can't figure out is what all this "recognition of Israel" business is about. What kind of obsession is this, getting up every other day and demanding that our bitter enemies recognize us? The way things stand today, who needs their recognition?

Israel was one of the first countries in the world to rebel against imperialism and seek national independence. It was one of the first countries to join the United Nations: Israel is number 52 out of 190 countries that belong today. On May 10, 1949, MK David Hacohen unfurled the Israeli flag over the building then housing the UN. This insistence on being recognized, when Israel was one of the first states to be born after World War II, is plain masochism.

The State of Israel does not need recognition. It is already recognized as one of the wonders of the world - by the very dint of its existence, after seven Arab countries tried to wipe it off the map, by what it has managed to create, by what it has accomplished in the span of 59 years.

Israel is a political and geopolitical fact, as well as a household name. If there is anyone who needs recognition, it is not Israel but the Palestinians, who will need ours, if they ever have the brains to adopt the UN resolution passed 60 years ago and get around to establishing a state of their own.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
'Cultural Attache'
The 3rd season of Dov Alfon's program is dedicated to rebels who buck Israeli conservatism.
A wise investment
Over the last 15 years, the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange has increased in value by 900%.
  1.   Not sure 09:35  |  JP 13/02/07
  2.   if you wish for aconcession YOU MUST RECOGNISE WHO IS MAKING IT 09:37  |  paul harris 13/02/07
  3.   Yoel Marcus, we Israelis and Jews do not need anyone`s .......... 09:41  |  Nadav 13/02/07
  4.   SEMANTICS 09:50  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/02/07
  5.   Yoel`s Israel. 09:50  |  sandra chitayat 13/02/07
  6.   Wait A Minute! Do The Arabs Recognize The Palestinians? 09:55  |  Yosemite 13/02/07
  7.   When did Israel agree to recognise Palestine? 09:59  |  Johny 13/02/07
  8.   to JP 10:22  |  Y 13/02/07
  9.   name of game is "occupation" 10:24  |  Khalid 13/02/07
  10.   to johny 10:24  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  11.   True Miracle 10:26  |  ML 13/02/07
  12.   For god`s sake most of this is tripe 10:28  |  Marilyn 13/02/07
  13.   to jp 10:31  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  14.   to khalid 10:41  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  15.   Khalid 10:50  |  Yosemite 13/02/07
  16.   to marilyn 10:50  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  17.   Can anybody stop difamation? 11:17  |  alberto 13/02/07
  18.   # 9 Khalid 11:18  |  Josef 13/02/07
  19.   Israels dilemma 11:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/02/07
  20.   #13 he wants to harm you because you murdered 11:43  |  KA 13/02/07
  21.   Johnoy, Israel never recognized Palestine`s right 11:44  |  American living here 13/02/07
  22.   Let`s start unrecognizing Israel 12:21  |  John 13/02/07
  23.   Totally in agreement with your assessment. 12:22  |  Observer from London 13/02/07
  24.   ISRAEL: PLEASE GIVE THE WEST BANK BACK TO JORDAN 12:23  |  US Citizen 13/02/07
  25.   If recognition not important,why Marcus&Lefties extolled Arafat 12:26  |  Absolute Sweden 13/02/07
  26.   Recognition 12:38  |  Marty 13/02/07
  27.   It is not our problem what the Palestinians need 12:50  |  Steven 13/02/07
  28.   American living here 12:56  |  Israeli 13/02/07
  29.   to ka 12:59  |  mb 13/02/07
  30.   does Saudi Arabia recognize Israel? 13:14  |  cool 13/02/07
  31.   Yoel Marcus is angry 13:19  |  Lars Hansen 13/02/07
  32.   to ka 13:19  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  33.   The way of the pen 13:22  |  Elizabeth 13/02/07
  34.   to swiss (dino) 13:23  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  35.   "does Saudi Arabia recognize Israel?" 13:30  |  Henry Moore 13/02/07
  36.   Poor Lars Hansen,Denmark didn`t get a wholehearted support during 13:33  |  Absolute Sweden 13/02/07
  37.   The end of Israel 13:46  |  Brigitte Meier 13/02/07
  38.   Marilyn part of the big four 13:56  |  myxamatosis 13/02/07
  39.   Dino the problem is much more complex 14:01  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/02/07
  40.   to the east n west strategist Briigitte Meier 14:05  |  Anubhav 13/02/07
  41.   To Margie 14:09  |  Stellan 13/02/07
  42.   #6, Palestinians 14:10  |  nina 13/02/07
  43.   Brigitte Meier 14:11  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/02/07
  44.   # 34 saul a. readner 14:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/02/07
  45.   # 39 Margie in Tel Aviv 14:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/02/07
  46.   And Israel bores the world now 14:29  |  Marilyn 13/02/07
  47.   Stellan 14:33  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/02/07
  48.   marilyn 14:36  |  myxamatosis 13/02/07
  49.   Joseph, don`t attack Islam which protected Jews 14:39  |  Khalid 13/02/07
  50.   Brigitte Meier, I wish to share with you and others a simple fact 14:43  |  Nadav 13/02/07
  51.   Yosef: another student of Mirkaz ha`rav 14:45  |  palestinian 13/02/07
  52.   Swiss (Dino) #45 14:47  |  Gee 13/02/07
  53.   Khalid 14:48  |  CHGODMK 13/02/07
  54.   Stellan vs. Margie in Tel-Aviv 14:49  |  Nadav 13/02/07
  55.   Israel is more than apartheid..much more 14:50  |  Khalid 13/02/07
  56.   MB...Israel didn`t get out of Gaza, Israel controlls gaza 14:52  |  KA 13/02/07
  57.   Nadav, ahi 14:53  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/02/07
  58.   Khalid duh 14:55  |  Graham Greene 13/02/07
  59.   #32...go to the the houses in Sfad, Malcha, 14:55  |  KA 13/02/07
  60.   Khalid and Your Treasure Chest of Lies 15:02  |  CHGODMK 13/02/07
  61.   Yosemite.This is why they need to have their State. 15:14  |  Brad 13/02/07
  62.   Can We Talk??? 15:15  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/02/07
  63.   Recognition is the last thing we need 15:37  |  Tzfonit 13/02/07
  64.   # 52 Gee and the flower-trip to Ramallah 15:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/02/07
  65.   Israel has no need of terrorists` recognition 15:52  |  Chaim 13/02/07
  66.   RECOGNIZED FOR WHAT THEY ARE OR WHAT WANT THEM TO BE 16:08  |  B 13/02/07
  67.   again to ka 16:09  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  68.   Tzfonit #63 16:13  |  Gabe1 13/02/07
  69.   again to swiss (dino) 16:20  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  70.   recognition 16:28  |  michael 13/02/07
  71.   To Margie, to Nadav 16:34  |  Anne 13/02/07
  72.   Israel is a miracle 16:36  |  Somebody from Europe 13/02/07
  73.   only palestinians have the legitimacy israel needs 16:37  |  arab 13/02/07
  74.   Marilyn in sleepy Australia 16:46  |  Somebody from Europe 13/02/07
  75.   Anne bruha habaa l`Israel 16:48  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/02/07
  76.   Arab 16:50  |  myxamatosis 13/02/07
  77.   Marilyn`s fantasy 17:20  |  Jack 13/02/07
  78.   Jack and mixy 17:30  |  Marilyn 13/02/07
  79.   Recognition and an End to the Conflict 17:33  |  Jack 13/02/07
  80.   #46 Marylins idealism CONDEMNS THE OTHERS 17:50  |  paul harris 13/02/07
  81.   # 4 SEMANTICS 18:00  |  Traude 13/02/07
  82.   JACK AND RECONITION 18:25  |  michael 13/02/07
  83.   #38 Myxatosis.Contrary to your WE 18:30  |  Rab. 13/02/07
  84.   #47 Margie. Simple Ans. "JORDAN" wanted it for themselves. 18:40  |  Brad 13/02/07
  85.   Brad 18:42  |  Yosemite 13/02/07
  86.   No Yaakov Sullivan! We Can`t Talk! 18:45  |  Yosemite 13/02/07
  87.   yoel marcus is a racist!!! 18:49  |  ahmed`s alter ego 13/02/07
  88.   NO FALSE PEACE IS WORTH THE PAPER ITS 18:57  |  SAM(NEW YORK) 13/02/07
  89.   short span of attention, Rab? 19:05  |  myxamatosis 13/02/07
  90.   Jack #79 Hamas can keep hoping 19:06  |  Tzfonit 13/02/07
  91.   #23 observer 19:09  |  michael 13/02/07
  92.   Fraeulein Brigitte Meier 19:14  |  Somebody from Europe 13/02/07
  93.   Saul A. Readner / KA 19:19  |  Somebody from Europe 13/02/07
  94.   #85 Yosemite 19:23  |  Brad 13/02/07
  95.   Brad 19:34  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/02/07
  96.   Tzfonit,#90.How nice it would be to see 19:45  |  Brad 13/02/07
  97.   KA - Israel controls 19:47  |  Somebody from Europe 13/02/07
  98.   Yoel has no original ideas, rehash of lies and propaganda 20:20  |  Joe 13/02/07
  99.   # 95 Margie in Tel Aviv - You should stay up to date 20:24  |  Traude 13/02/07
  100.   To Sau a ReadNer 20:26  |  Jim 13/02/07
  101.   Anne, if I understand your note the way you meant it, I think you 20:37  |  Nadav 13/02/07
  102.   98 - Are you spewing your propoganda again? 20:41  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/02/07
  103.   Khalid 20:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/02/07
  104.   #55, Khalid 20:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/02/07
  105.   #71 Anne 20:59  |  Par excellence 13/02/07
  106.   to jim - responses 21:04  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  107.   to jim - two questions 21:05  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  108.   Acceptance of past agreement is the issue. 21:18  |  Voice of Reason 13/02/07
  109.   Cipora...Nazism was also viewed as National 21:19  |  Khalid 13/02/07
  110.   How can amorphous states be recognized 21:21  |  Khalid 13/02/07
  111.   Khalid, 55, I truly suggest that you review Israel`s Declaration 21:31  |  Nadav 13/02/07
  112.   the conflict is so easy to solve...yet 21:35  |  Cat 13/02/07
  113.   Marilyn, to be right you must leave Australia 21:55  |  David 13/02/07
  114.   War 22:24  |  Nechama 13/02/07
  115.   #109,# 110 22:32  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/02/07
  116.   Who did you say needs recognition? 22:37  |  Leon Rogson 13/02/07
  117.   israel gave up 90% of Palestine already 22:37  |  dr eric 13/02/07
  118.   to david 23:22  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  119.   to somebody from europe 23:22  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  120.   to nechama 23:24  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  121.   to cipora juliana kohn 23:25  |  saul a. readner 13/02/07
  122.   Old Israeli contempt for PR is overdue. 23:35  |  Fortuna 13/02/07
  123.   US citizen 00:08  |  KT 14/02/07
  124.   MUTUAL RECOGNITION 00:24  |  Louis 14/02/07
  125.   1967 was legit self defense 00:42  |  Michaelangelo 14/02/07
  126.   Jack re Marilyn`s fantasy #77 00:43  |  KT 14/02/07
  127.   1948, 1956, 1967, 1973, 1988, 2000, and on and on 00:50  |  KT 14/02/07
  128.   #94 Brad 01:04  |  KT 14/02/07
  129.   #96 Brad 01:09  |  KT 14/02/07
  130.   Mr. Yoel Markus needs recognition. 01:49  |  Ricardo Kolbe 14/02/07
  131.   Impossible! Yoel Marcus writes a sensible column! 02:00  |  sk 14/02/07
  132.   Way To Go Yoel Marcus 03:03  |  Jane 14/02/07
  133.   Yoel Marcus "Who needs recognition? 03:06  |  Ezra Zeitune 14/02/07
  134.   #22 John - Let`s start unrecognizing 03:20  |  * BEN JABO 14/02/07
  135.   #62 Turncoat Sullivan "`Wants to talk" 03:23  |  * BEN JABO 14/02/07
  136.   #125 Michaelangelo keeps forgetting... 03:57  |  Johnboy 14/02/07
  137.   to Saul a Readner 04:29  |  Jim 14/02/07
  138.   Marilyn, Maureen Ann and tutti quanti 04:45  |  Maurice 14/02/07
  139.   Israel`s ego is too big for its borders! 05:19  |  Maureen Ann 14/02/07
  140.   #137 Jim, Did really the Irgun bomb a synagogue to frighten Jews? 05:45  |  Smadar 14/02/07
  141.   #140 Smadar - Just where did you hear that 06:19  |  * BEN JABO 14/02/07
  142.   #46 Marilyn - Nobody is more boring 06:21  |  * BEN JABO 14/02/07
  143.   WOMEN - VIPERS: MAUREEN ANN, MARILYN - JEW-HATERS, LEFTIES 06:25  |  Vittorio 14/02/07
  144.   @94, brad in houston, please study english first 06:42  |  vladimir 14/02/07
  145.   I suggest you review Israel`s Declaration No. 111 06:45  |  Marlene 14/02/07
  146.   #141 Ben Jabo - heard it only from posting #137 this talkback 06:53  |  Smadar 14/02/07
  147.   Marlene - Declaration of Independence 08:54  |  Somebody from Europe 14/02/07
  148.   again to jim - part 1 09:18  |  saul a. readner 14/02/07
  149.   again to jim - part 2 09:20  |  saul a. readner 14/02/07
  150.   Marlene Marilyn & MoronAnn the hellsisters 09:50  |  myxamatosis 14/02/07
  151.   Jim in Ottawa 09:53  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 14/02/07
  152.   It`s mine 10:00  |  David Lucier 14/02/07
  153.   Margie in Tel-Aviv re. 600,000 11:12  |  Nadav 14/02/07
  154.   #146 Smadar 16:40  |  * BEN JABO 14/02/07
  155.   #137 Jim 16:43  |  * BEN JABO 14/02/07
  156.   Somebody From Europe #147 00:28  |  Jill Friedman 15/02/07
  157.   Yoel Marcus, Israel doesn`t have a leg to stand on 19:05  |  Dutch 15/02/07
  158.   #142 - Marilyn, my apologies 01:14  |  * BEN JABO 16/02/07
 Today Online
Rosner: Diaspora Jews should show special loyalty to Israel
Responses: 234
Chirac backs easing pressure on Iran to protect UNIFIL troops
Responses: 207
Aluf Benn: Three-way summit won't bring us closer to peace
Responses: 114
PM agrees to let Turkey inspect Jerusalem dig site
Responses: 165
The Muslim world needs a better voice than Ahmadinejad
Responses: 105
Diplomats: EU still divided on approach to Holocaust denial
Responses: 95


More Headlines
08:38 Obama: U.S. must help Israel defend itself
08:03 Police preparing for more violence around Temple Mount
07:14 Olmert backs transfer of four prisoners to Jordan
07:40 Rice: PA unity gov't complicates U.S. peacemaking efforts
07:13 Zeiler commission to slam police chief, recommend dismissals
07:16 Maccabi Tel Aviv winning streak ends with 11-point defeat to Tau Vitoria
07:16 Pelosi: Bush needs Congress' approval in order to invade Iran
07:16 Greater Tel Aviv area riddled with serious groundwater pollution
07:16 Experts work to open secret Nazi archive for research
07:15 Group seeks apology for memo linking evolution theory to Kabbalah
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved