Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 13, 2007 Shvat 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:12 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
PM Ehud Olmert, left, and MK Tzahi Hanegbi talking Monday at a meeting of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee in Jerusalem. (Kobi Gideon / BauBau)
Last update - 18:54 12/02/2007
PM: Ceding entire Golan is price of peace with Syria
By Gideon Alon, Haaretz Correspondent

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee on Monday that peace with Syria would mean giving up the Golan Heights, seized by Israel in the 1967 Six-Day War and annexed in 1981.

"The whole world knows that in any future negotiations, if they are renewed, we will have to give up on the entire Golan Heights," Olmert said during a heated exchange with oppposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu (Likud).

Netanyahu had reacted angrily to Olmert's assertion that three of his predeccessors, Netanyahu included, had held talks with Syria on a complete Israeli withdrawal from the Golan Heights.

Advertisement

Olmert told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee that, according to documents, the prime ministers from 1993 to 2001 (a reference to Yitzhak Rabin, Netanyahu and Ehud Barak) - had all held negotiations with Syria during which it had been clear that any agreement would entail Israel completely ceding the Golan and withdrawing to the 1967 border.

But Netanyahu interrupted Olmert's remarks, saying, "You know that's not right."

"You know it's true," replied Olmert. "Don't try to hide the truth."

Later in the discussion, the prime minister reiterated his opposition to negotiations with Damascus, on the grounds "Syria is interested in the industry of peace, rather than real peace."

Olmert: Netanyahu gave life to Hamas
Olmert also told the committee that it was during Netanyahu who had given life to Hamas during his tenure as prime minister.

"Netanyahu established Hamas, gave it life, freed Sheikh Yassin and gave him the option to blossom," he said, adding that the current political in the Palestinian Authority was "because of the nonsense that was done while Netanyahu was prime minister."

He was referring to Netanyahu's release of jailed Hamas founder and mentor Ahmed Yassin in 1997 - a move to mollify Jordan after Israeli agents mounted, and botched, an attempt on the life of Hamas politburo chief Khaled Meshal in Amman.

In response to Olmert's comments, Netanyahu said "This is a failed government, and there is only one thing it must do and that is to go home."

Speaking at a Likud faction meeting, the opposition leader added that Olmert had apparently not learned anything from his tenure in government and was trying to cover up his own failures with empty accusations.

"We know it was the same prime minister that let Hamas hold elections in Jerusalem and allows it now to receive money and break the barriers of its isolation. He cannot stand up to these things and has been exposed in his lack of leadership," Netanyahu said.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The curtain falls
After 90 years in operation, the Habima National Theater will shut down for renovations.
Let's get together
Israel and Denmark hold leading and unique positions in both the life sciences and IT fields.
  1.   The international border, as defined in 1922 15:02  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 12/02/07
  2.   more common sense!!! What`s happening????? 15:06  |  SD 12/02/07
  3.   We have peace with Syria already- because we control the Golan 15:07  |  Dani 12/02/07
  4.   Peace with Syria 15:12  |  Marty 12/02/07
  5.   Didn`t Assad confirm his support to Hamas/Hezbollah? 15:16  |  Hastaroth 12/02/07
  6.   What does peace with Syria mean? 15:19  |  Sam 12/02/07
  7.   why is there always talk of territory? 15:19  |  malek 12/02/07
  8.   "Children of Sderot" Movie!! 15:21  |  Jew 12/02/07
  9.   Ghetto mentality asserting itself,Olmert unable to shed it 15:25  |  Absolute Sweden 12/02/07
  10.   given of the golan 15:27  |  Massein 12/02/07
  11.   Syria must pay a price, too 15:29  |  Ken 12/02/07
  12.   Along with Golan, Write Suicide Note 15:29  |  Zalman Velvel 12/02/07
  13.   # 3 Syria 15:31  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  14.   international border, not 67 border 15:32  |  border 12/02/07
  15.   absolutely not. A person must be insane to give up the Golan 15:34  |  David G 12/02/07
  16.   SD, I`ll tell you what`s happening 15:35  |  Judith in Haifa 12/02/07
  17.   stop with this territory for peace... 15:37  |  arie 12/02/07
  18.   Israel is run by non-Jews!!! 15:38  |  Ron 12/02/07
  19.   The Price for Olmert`s Position 15:52  |  Kate 12/02/07
  20.   Golan/Syria/Peace? 15:53  |  Len Cohen 12/02/07
  21.   Golan 16:03  |  alonitzafoni 12/02/07
  22.   Full relations with Zionist entity is price of Golan to Syria 16:05  |  JPS 12/02/07
  23.   Not so common sense 16:06  |  Paul Freedman 12/02/07
  24.   Shlomo#1 FAIR is FAIR, my friend.. 16:07  |  Amnon 12/02/07
  25.   NEVER GIVE Ramat Ha`Golan back!!! 16:09  |  Paolo Ortenzi 12/02/07
  26.   Giving up the Golan, J`lem and all occupied land since 1948 ... 16:17  |  Yankelowitz 12/02/07
  27.   No land for peace 16:20  |  steve 12/02/07
  28.   Judith in Haifa (#16) is right 16:27  |  Yonatan 12/02/07
  29.   Hastaroth of Athens, this is the reason why Israelis. 16:32  |  Brad 12/02/07
  30.   12 Along with Golan 16:36  |  Mahona 12/02/07
  31.   Olmert Blinked: Now Bibi Is In the Game 16:36  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 12/02/07
  32.   Malek"use your Brain 4 once" Agree 16:38  |  Arik 12/02/07
  33.   When will this idiot learn? 16:45  |  Allon 12/02/07
  34.   Massein #10 wrong wrong wrong 16:45  |  Phil. Cheung 12/02/07
  35.   Land = Peace: Give Up Land = Give Up Peace 16:52  |  Yishai Kohen 12/02/07
  36.   the price of peace--piece by8 piece by piece 16:55  |  bob 12/02/07
  37.   advanced studies on Syria 16:59  |  christoph 12/02/07
  38.   #34 very wrong Phil 17:06  |  Itsik 12/02/07
  39.   #20 Len 17:17  |  Joseph 12/02/07
  40.   olmert/netanyahu 17:19  |  roni 12/02/07
  41.   Allowing elections. 17:30  |  sandra chitayat 12/02/07
  42.   To #1 - Pick and Choose 17:33  |  Ah 12/02/07
  43.   Olmert sounds like a Euro or American commentator, not an Israeli 17:34  |  bimmer 12/02/07
  44.   #42 Ah 17:43  |  Joseph 12/02/07
  45.   Are we at war? 17:45  |  Gene 12/02/07
  46.   #43 bimmer 17:47  |  Joseph 12/02/07
  47.   The Golan is already lost 17:48  |  Phillies Wright 12/02/07
  48.   Syrian "peace", like they have with Lebanon? 18:00  |  Dr. L. Brnd 12/02/07
  49.   #1 the new reality DOES NOT RECOGNISE THE SAN REMO BORDER 18:05  |  paul harris 12/02/07
  50.   Further Evidence Golan is Arab Property 18:09  |  Hani 12/02/07
  51.   Olmert`s political footballs 18:14  |  Polybios 12/02/07
  52.   Peace with Syria is easy 18:14  |  Cat 12/02/07
  53.   Golan Syrian territory 18:16  |  Esther 12/02/07
  54.   The Golan 18:16  |  Otto Rand 12/02/07
  55.   P Wright 18:18  |  Roger Bannister 12/02/07
  56.   If Olmert Gave The Ggolan Heights Back To Syria 18:19  |  Kipperraes 12/02/07
  57.   Sooner or Later 18:31  |  Palestinian 12/02/07
  58.   wars change borders. So... 18:44  |  Ed 12/02/07
  59.   Recognition of Israel is simply an Illusion 18:44  |  Dov 12/02/07
  60.   count the missiles, compare the differences 18:45  |  Ernst 12/02/07
  61.   Otto Rand 18:48  |  Cat 12/02/07
  62.   Re #45 Gene 18:58  |  Ernst 12/02/07
  63.   Response for KIpper #56 18:59  |  Esther 12/02/07
  64.   The rules changed no 58 19:01  |  Marilyn 12/02/07
  65.   Why must Israel pay for Arab oil to Europe and the US 19:01  |  Yacov 12/02/07
  66.   Olmert forgot 19:05  |  Brod 12/02/07
  67.   #34 Phil on the war path 19:05  |  Kate 12/02/07
  68.   You think than is peace? 19:07  |  Sarah 12/02/07
  69.   #46 Joesph - this is how I read it 19:08  |  bimmer 12/02/07
  70.   Golan WAS Syrian territory once- not any more 19:09  |  Aaron 12/02/07
  71.   OLMERT MUST GO!!!!!!!! 19:17  |  Bob 12/02/07
  72.   Olmert and Peretz your have Zero credibility - Resign at once 19:20  |  Norman 12/02/07
  73.   JPS from Efrat 19:24  |  David Israel 12/02/07
  74.   If it was legal.. 19:25  |  GregD 12/02/07
  75.   #1, Shlomo from TA 19:30  |  Fritz 12/02/07
  76.   Ceding The Golan...Why Not 19:40  |  Tony Anthony 12/02/07
  77.   I really feel that peace is near 19:47  |  G. 12/02/07
  78.   Giving up 19:51  |  DovBer 12/02/07
  79.   #76, What next? What would do you expect? 19:55  |  Franklin 12/02/07
  80.   75 posts and only one 19:56  |  Persian Kitty 12/02/07
  81.   so what about Tibet Marylin 20:04  |  Cat 12/02/07
  82.   answer to no.1 20:14  |  rf 12/02/07
  83.   The Main Reason That Israel Shouldn`t Give Up The Golan 20:32  |  Yosemite 12/02/07
  84.   all borders should be a matter of negotiation 20:38  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 12/02/07
  85.   it`s about time 20:39  |  Jeff 12/02/07
  86.   #54, Otto Rand 20:43  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 12/02/07
  87.   So many choosing war and death 20:48  |  spyguy 12/02/07