Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., March 05, 2007 Adar 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:35 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 11:11 12/02/2007
Save the Temple Mount - Lupolianski for PM
By Bradley Burston


Consensus is near unknown in Jerusalem. One thing is agreed, however: Ehud Olmert was an execrable mayor. He kowtowed to fatcats, kowtowed to ultra-Orthodox apparatchiks, lined his pockets at the expense of constituents whose pockets were worn to holes.

His successor, by contrast, has proven a leader of estimable skill and rare compassion. There were fears that when Uri Lupolianski, the ultra-Orthodox founder of the Yad Sarah organization - a grass-roots phenomenon which aids thousands of individuals and families with special and serious physical needs - he would be unable to meet the demands of one of the world's most contentious cities, a city so crucial to the world that it effectively has a foreign policy all its own.

But Lupolianski has shown again and again, in his efforts to encourage secular students to move to the city, in his efforts to aid the homeless, in his moderate approach to gay-haredi strife, that he has a unique ability to find solutions to an impossible reality.

So it was this week, with the government ham-handling the restoration work near the Temple Mount, and militant Muslim leaders doing their best to put their faces in the center of the television screen with incitement and inflammatory untruths accusing Israel of being out to destroy Al-Aqsa.

On Sunday night, with the prime minister and Defense Minister Amir Peretz trading kindergarten insults over the handling of the decision to go ahead with excavations aimed at rebuilding a bridge entrance to the Temple Mount, and with Public Security Minister Avi Dichter pooh-poohing the protests at the site as less than serious, Lupolianski took action.

Lupolianski and the rabbi of the Western Wall, Shmuel Rabinovich, discussed the issue the way Olmert and Peretz should have. They spoke with Attorney General Menachem Mazuz, municipal planning authorities, Muslim community leaders and other representatives of the Arab population of East Jerusalem.

They then drafted a plan which would allow the general public to review plans for the bridge and submit opposition, announcing that construction of the walkway at the Mugrabi Ascent would be suspended until zoning authorities complete plans for the area, a procedure which could take months, perhaps years.

The decision recognizes the sensitivity of the site which, if not addressed, could easily turn it into the Chernobyl of the powderkeg Mideast.

In taking the decision, Lupolianski was up against enormous pressure, not only from the government, but from the religious right. MK Aryeh Eldad of the National Union called it "a surrender to the Arabs."

The Yesha settlers council, meanwhile, chose the opportunity to announce that for once - perhaps for the only time - it is backing the government, "which is not caving in to threats and fabrications," and urged Olmert's cabinet to allow Jews to worship on the Temple Mount.

Yesha's Rabbinical Committee added "The violent events on the Temple Mount are the rotten fruit of the weakness that Israeli governments have demonstrated since the liberation of the Temple Mount in the Six Day War.

"This is a direct result of the negation of the rights of the Jews at the site.

Many rabbis - including Rabinovich - have ruled the Temple Mount site off-limits to Jews, citing halachic prohibitions on entering the area where the Temple courtyard once lay, and the difficulty of fulfilling the ancient ritual requirement of cleansing with the ashes of a red heifer.

Lupolianski's most risky, most radical move may have been his explanation for the decision: transparency, proper procedure, and consideration for the sensitivities of the public.

He told associates Sunday that "the plan to construct the walkway engendered a wave of rumor and speculation about Israeli intentions regarding the [Al-Aqsa] mosque."

"We therefore decided to be totally transparent with all residents about the walkway construction plan, so they will know clearly where it is to be built and to allow members of the public to express their positions to the zoning board," Lupolianski continued.

In a step of truly remarkable courage, given the local propensity for macho displays of assertiveness through brute force and unethical cunning, Lupoliansky said he also wanted to avoid the feeling among the public that the work constitutes some sort of an Israeli ambush.

"The move is slated to help people understand that the walkway is in no way injurious and does not enter the Temple Mount. It is important to us that there is no feeling that this was done covertly or sneakily."

With crackpot, defeatist, traitorous, unmanly thinking like this, Lupolianski may well save the Temple Mount. He may well stave off World War III.

It would be shame to lose a man like that in City Hall. But it may be time to think about having him follow Olmert one bus ride across town. It could be that just as Lupolianski, not Olmert, was the right man as mayor, Lupolianski - certainly not Olmert - may be just the man for the Prime Minister's Office.


___________________


Recent blogs:

Al-Aqsa Mosque is good for the Jews
Who will bring peace back from the dead?
When did Ehud Olmert turn into George Bush?
Zionists out

___________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Matza Refuge
Passover will see thousands of Israeli families taking off for trips in hot spots abroad.
One street, two worlds
Just a few meters distance can alter real estate prices radically in some Israeli cities.
  1.   Losing the battle, but winning the (PR) war.... 09:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  2.   win win 10:14  |  hapalo 12/02/07
  3.   two questions 10:31  |  gabriela 12/02/07
  4.   # 2 hapalo 10:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  5.   Lupolianski to Xtians and Muslims: We`ll stay in our shtetl. 11:08  |  Yacov 12/02/07
  6.   Israel must fix the ramp and if they arabs do not like it ... 11:36  |  Steven 12/02/07
  7.   Swiss (Dino) and PR 11:40  |  Steven 12/02/07
  8.   is common sense breaking out in the middle east? 11:42  |  SD 12/02/07
  9.   # 7 Steven The difference 12:00  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  10.   It is called a DELAY not CANCELLATION 12:08  |  Dror 12/02/07
  11.   shalom al yerushalayim 12:15  |  charles 12/02/07
  12.   Swiss (Dino) the turth is 12:17  |  Steven 12/02/07
  13.   the mufti is unmollified 12:19  |  ted 12/02/07
  14.   #9 the difference 12:19  |  Swiss (Uri) 12/02/07
  15.   # 10- Dror 12:29  |  Klaudia 12/02/07
  16.   # 14 Swiss (Uri) 12:35  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  17.   stephen # 7 12:52  |  dubious 12/02/07
  18.   To Swiss (Dino): in regard of PR 13:21  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 12/02/07
  19.   Another provocatuer for PM? 13:26  |  Meridith 12/02/07
  20.   Buston the Zionist`s blatant hypocrisy 13:29  |  Yacov 12/02/07
  21.   #1 Swiss Dino: We won the PR battle, lost the war after Gaza 13:33  |  Yacov 12/02/07
  22.   Will the musis blame us? 13:50  |  Dror 12/02/07
  23.   Let it collapse! 14:00  |  Nik Miller 12/02/07
  24.   # 5 Yacov: You`re totally wrong!! 14:07  |  Simone 12/02/07
  25.   Well, yes... 14:14  |  Nyctamere 12/02/07
  26.   Burston took the words right out of my mouth 14:30  |  Yonatan 12/02/07
  27.   Simone = ignorant fool 14:36  |  Steven 12/02/07
  28.   #7 dubious - I`m dubious too 14:36  |  Yonatan 12/02/07
  29.   In the Best Tradition of Teddy Kollek 14:44  |  Jane 12/02/07
  30.   It is Jerusalem all around the world, 14:44  |  Steven 12/02/07
  31.   # 18 Shlomo from Tel Aviv 14:47  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  32.   # 21 Yacov 14:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  33.   # 27 Steven: So what? 14:53  |  Simone 12/02/07
  34.   Swiss (Dino) i will explain you the uproar 14:53  |  Steven 12/02/07
  35.   # 34 Steven 15:23  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  36.   Swiss dino sadly you are wrong 15:31  |  Steven 12/02/07
  37.   Simone unlike you I am not a racist 15:42  |  Steven 12/02/07
  38.   Lupolianski--man of integrity 15:56  |  bob 12/02/07
  39.   STATE of ISRAELO-RACISIM 16:07  |  Mark 12/02/07
  40.   #36 Steven 16:10  |  Infidel 12/02/07
  41.   Hurray for Mayor Lupolianski 16:30  |  Concerned citizen 12/02/07
  42.   # 36 Steven 16:38  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  43.   Dino do you acutally understand what goes on Israel? 16:52  |  Steven 12/02/07
  44.   Infidel, I agree, we can learn from our arab cousins 16:53  |  Steven 12/02/07
  45.   Mark #39 False, wrong, and oversimplistic 17:33  |  Polybios 12/02/07
  46.   yonatan # 28 17:49  |  dubious 12/02/07
  47.   Jerusalem mayor knew Mugrabi dig was illegal 18:20  |  Monica Weiss 12/02/07
  48.   Wasn`t there review previously? 18:35  |  Yisrael Medad 12/02/07
  49.   # 43 Steven 18:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  50.   For sure, for sure.... 19:41  |  Blogowitz 12/02/07
  51.   In the course of a few hours... 19:58  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 12/02/07
  52.   #39, Mark, Israel allows all to pray, Arabs dont 20:11  |  David 12/02/07
  53.   #46 dubious, you`re being dubious again 20:28  |  Yonatan 12/02/07
  54.   Jews have a right to worship freely on the Temple Mount 20:41  |  AV 12/02/07
  55.   The Temple Mount is holy to Jews only. 20:43  |  AV 12/02/07
  56.   Face It Steven 20:46  |  Artie 12/02/07
  57.   The mayor is an honorary Englishman 21:12  |  Joseph 12/02/07
  58.   How awesome is this place! It is none other than... 21:18  |  Joe 12/02/07
  59.   Due process 21:23  |  Sherlock Holmes 12/02/07
  60.   Reply to AV #54 21:27  |  Joe 12/02/07
  61.   Reply to Steven - 3. 21:36  |  James 12/02/07
  62.   Reply to Steven - 12. 21:58  |  James 12/02/07
  63.   Muslims Are Going Ape Because of Israel`s Existence 22:18  |  massaraksh 12/02/07
  64.   61 United Kingdom 22:21  |  Steven 12/02/07
  65.   re #55 `The Temple Mount is holy to Jews only.` 22:55  |  Colin Wright 12/02/07
  66.   Leaders not Legislators 23:35  |  Don 12/02/07
  67.   Haredi politicians 23:49  |  NP 12/02/07
  68.   yonatan # 53 00:37  |  dubious 13/02/07
  69.   The Dayan Blunder, The Lupolianski Blunder 01:40  |  Yacov 13/02/07
  70.   The Temple Mount is holy to Jews only. 05:06  |  AV 13/02/07
  71.   What a positive article, Bradley Burston....all`s well that ends 06:08  |  Smadar 13/02/07
  72.   Good post Dino 09:26  |  Dov 13/02/07
  73.   yonatan # 53 15:08  |  dubious 13/02/07
  74.   Lupolianski and Olmert...... 15:48  |  Esther 13/02/07
  75.   lupolianski 23:07  |  rabbi 05/03/07
 Today Online
Abbas: EU is pro-Israel, discriminates against PA
Responses: 248
Sheleg: Existential threats have rekindled classic Zionism
Responses: 71
Only ending the Arab-Israeli conflict will turn PM into a great leader
Responses: 78
Michael Melchior: Arab states slowly coming to terms with Israel
Responses: 114
Ben-Eliezer cancels Egypt visit amid row over '67 war charges
Responses: 84
Rosner's Domain
*More Americans have an opinion: they support Israel
* The White House, like the White Paper
* Obama supports Israel. Period