Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., February 14, 2007 Shvat 26, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:35 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Workers digging Sunday at the Mugrabi Ascent in the Old City of Jerusalem, as part of the construction of a new bridge to the Temple Mount's Mugrabi Gate. (AP)
Last update - 18:40 12/02/2007
Majadele: Jerusalem mayor knew Mugrabi dig was illegal
By Jonathan Lis, Haaretz Correspondent, and Haaretz Service

Israel's first Arab minister, Ghaleb Majadele, on Monday accused Jerusalem Mayor Uri Lupolianski of approving controversial construction work in the Old City of the capital, even though he knew it was illegal.

The excavation and building work at the Mugrabi Ascent, some 60 meters away from the Al-Aqsa Mosque on the Temple Mount, has sparked demonstrations and criticism across the Muslim world.

Majadele, speaking at a stormy meeting of the Knesset Interior and Environment Committee, accused the mayor of agreeing to the work without first obtaining the correct authorization required by law.

Advertisement

The minister said that several days he had told the head of the Antiquities Authority that the dig was illegal, and had tried in vain to set up a meeting with Lupolianski.

The mayor announced late Sunday night that he had decided to postpone construction of the walkway at the Mugrabi Ascent until zoning authorities complete plans for the area.

"The Mayor of Jerusalem, Uri Lupolianski, together with Rabbi Shmuel Rabinowitz, Rabbi for the Kotel and Holy Places, decided last night to allow public discussion of the plans to construct the Mugrabi Bridge at the planning and construction committees," city spokesman Gideon Schmerling said in a statement.

"This is due to the sensitivity of the plan and following meetings and discussions with representatives from eastern Jerusalem who requested to look over the plans and voice their opinions."

Scmerling added that the archeological work conducted by the Antiquities Authority at the site would continue.

Over the past several days, Lupolianski held meetings and discussions with various representatives from eastern Jerusalem, together with Rabbi Rabinowitz, and Lupolianski assured them that he will allow open discussion with full disclosure in order to make it clear that there is no intention to enter the Temple Mount or cause any damage to it.

Lupolianski and Western Wall rabbi Shmuel Rabinovich drafted the decision Sunday following conversations with Attorney General Menachem Mazuz, municipal planning authorities, Muslim community leaders and other representatives of the Arab population of East Jerusalem, in order to allow the general public to review plans for the bridge and submit opposition.

Lupolianski announced that the measure reflects a desire for transparency and to foster a sense of cooperation with residents in the construction process. He also wanted to avoid the feeling among the public that the work constitutes some sort of an Israeli ambush.

In practice, the decision means that approval of the plan will be postponed until a hearing of all the letters of opposition filed by city residents. The salvage excavation being conducted by the Antiquities Authority is expected to continue at this stage, parallel to the public discussion of the zoning plan.

Jerusalem municipal sources said Sunday that the decision could in fact be postponed for months, and that there is no certainty the zoning authorities that hear the arguments of those opposed will actually approve the plan in the end.

Settlers to government: Don't give in to threats
The Yesha Council of Settlements voiced support of continued work at the site, urging the government not to "surrender to threats" and to open the Temple Mount to Jewish worship, Israel Radio reported Monday.

It quoted Yesha's Rabbinical Committee as saying that, "The violent events on the Temple Mount are the rotten fruit of the weakness that Israeli governments have demonstrated since the liberation of the Temple Mount in the [1967] Six-Day War.

"This is a direct result of the negation of the rights of the Jews at the site.

The council announced that it "backs the government, which is not surrendering to threats and fabrications," the radio said.

Many rabbis have ruled the Temple Mount site off-limits to Jews, citing prohibitions on entering the area where the Temple courtyard once lay, and the difficulty of fulfilling the ancient ritual requirement of cleansing with the ashes of a red heifer.

'Plan engendered wave of rumor'
Lupolianski told associates Sunday that "the plan to construct the walkway engendered a wave of rumor and speculation about Israeli intentions regarding the [Al-Aqsa] mosque."

"We therefore decided to be totally transparent with all residents about the walkway construction plan, so they will know clearly where it is to be built and to allow members of the public to express their positions to the zoning board," Lupolianski continued. "The move is slated to help people understand that the walkway is in no way injurious and does not enter the Temple Mount. It is important to us that there is no feeling that this was done covertly or sneakily."

The decision to draft a zoning plan for the walkway is controversial: City Hall has sufficed until now with issuing permits - a rapid process - rather than demanding a broad plan, since the walkway is intended to replace an existing bridge and does not involve construction of a new structure.

The city's legal counsel has said in recent months that a building permit is sufficient, but after the mayor's discussions with Mazuz and representatives of East Jerusalem, it was decided to create a zoning procedure and allow all residents to file reservations about the project.

Related articles

  • Head of northern Islamic Movement charged with attacking police
  • Bradley Burston: Save the Temple Mount - Lupolianski for PM
  • Olmert: Muslim opposition won't deter Jerusalem excavation

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    The curtain falls
    After 90 years in operation, the Habima National Theater will shut down for renovations.
    Let's get together
    Israel and Denmark hold leading and unique positions in both the life sciences and IT fields.
      1.   Throw rocks, suicide bomb get concessions 03:04  |  Jason 12/02/07
      2.   Dhimmi status again. 03:09  |  Yacov 12/02/07
      3.   Pictures of the Temple Mount! 03:09  |  Jew 12/02/07
      4.   Israel elects the weakest leftist leaders 03:10  |  Jason 12/02/07
      5.   Tikkun Olam 03:13  |  HonestAbe 12/02/07
      6.   Capitulation once more 03:16  |  Nik Miller 12/02/07
      7.   Walkway. 03:31  |  sandra chitayat 12/02/07
      8.   Violence worthwhile !!!!!!!! 03:46  |  Alberto 12/02/07
      9.   #2 Yacov the philosopher 04:01  |  Christian Australian 12/02/07
      10.   To Jason and Nick Miller 04:05  |  Otto Rand 12/02/07
      11.   Jerusalem Mayor 04:09  |  Nechama 12/02/07
      12.   Typical Threat and Typical Response 04:11  |  Tony Anthony 12/02/07
      13.   Maybe its time for Jews to riot. ( Just kiding). 04:13  |  Dr David I. Gross 12/02/07
      14.   Nice to see 04:15  |  Colin Wright 12/02/07
      15.   Have I become a leftist ? 04:16  |  Mike 12/02/07
      16.   Too late --what studies needed to repair the walkway ? 04:17  |  Sal 12/02/07
      17.   Why is drafting a zoning plan CONTROVERSIAL? 04:21  |  Johnboy 12/02/07
      18.   Muslim Transparancy Needed 04:30  |  William Kinney 12/02/07
      19.   Shame on the mayor! 04:39  |  Spoon 12/02/07
      20.   The Palestinian gangsters win again... 04:50  |  Al Awe 12/02/07
      21.   You fools, deceitful Muslim clerics will never approve 04:59  |  McQueen 12/02/07
      22.   wrong move. very big mistake 05:00  |  ralph 12/02/07
      23.   Afraid of Grenade Throwing Protesters 05:07  |  Efox 12/02/07
      24.   Christian in America: My perspective on this... 05:20  |  Mike 12/02/07
      25.   Would it take riots? 05:21  |  David 12/02/07
      26.   # 12 Mike 05:24  |  Lynn 12/02/07
      27.   J`lem Mayor postpones Temple Mt constr 05:28  |  Mandy 12/02/07
      28.   # 9 Tony Anthony 05:31  |  Lynn 12/02/07
      29.   Good for the Mayor 05:32  |  Lynn 12/02/07
      30.   I am jumping in with good intention 05:39  |  Simon Mohammed 12/02/07
      31.   Yacov 05:40  |  Lynn 12/02/07
      32.   If Israeli leaders reward Islamist violence, what do you expect? 05:45  |  Hal 12/02/07
      33.   temple mount construction 06:02  |  colin 12/02/07
      34.   RE: Have I become leftist 06:16  |  Shazni 12/02/07
      35.   Jewish Getto Mentallity 06:23  |  Lightmountain 12/02/07
      36.   Congrat`s Mayor of Jerusalem to postponment & consultations 06:29  |  Smadar 12/02/07
      37.   A world matter! 06:31  |  Burhan 12/02/07
      38.   Congrats to the Mayor of J`lem !! 07:14  |  Esther 12/02/07
      39.   Jews need to get over the "Temple Mount" 07:17  |  RA 12/02/07
      40.   USE YOUR HEAD FOR YOUR OWN SAKE 07:31  |  indrajaya 12/02/07
      41.   Lynn # 22 & 23 I Agree 07:50  |  Jeff Northridge 12/02/07
      42.   Israel is a sovereign state.... 07:53  |  Ben 12/02/07
      43.   Every project should be postponed - even the NEW MOSQUE 07:53  |  Lemmings Hotline 12/02/07
      44.   #25 David 07:57  |  Infidel 12/02/07
      45.   Rachelle 08:01  |  Connie 12/02/07
      46.   A CLEVER MOVE 08:08  |  indrajaya 12/02/07
      47.   #39 "getting over" G-d`s presence 08:10  |  Lemmings Hotline 12/02/07
      48.   Simon Mohammed # 30 Very Sensible 08:13  |  Jeff Northridge 12/02/07
      49.   The Walkway 08:14  |  Fredy Ross 12/02/07
      50.   I support this wise decision.... 08:15  |  Deborah 12/02/07
      51.   What A WIMP ! 08:19  |  Avraham 12/02/07
      52.   Shaky Bridge 08:20  |  Yoel Keren 12/02/07
      53.   to # 48 Mr Jeff, you are so right but relatively,thanks 08:40  |  Simon Mohammed 12/02/07
      54.   TIME TO BRING BACK LEHI & HAGANNAH 08:42  |  SAM(NEW YORK) 12/02/07
      55.   to 52 you are dealing with the insurance & you have a business in 08:43  |  Simon 12/02/07
      56.   Settlers 08:43  |  Yosemite 12/02/07
      57.   Trust Haaretz to get you all hot and bothered... 08:50  |  Not a Haaretz Fan 12/02/07
      58.   Indrajaya, Apparently You Didn`t Waste Your Time In Boston 08:53  |  Yosemite 12/02/07
      59.   Disgusting 08:57  |  David Teich 12/02/07
      60.   Irrational Arabs 09:16  |  Paddy 12/02/07
      61.   Dangerous Logic 09:20  |  Paul 12/02/07
      62.   shabtai 09:26  |  shabtai j 12/02/07
      63.   STUPIDITY BEFORE DURING AND AFTER THE EVENT!! 09:36  |  paul harris 12/02/07
      64.   # 52 Shaky Head not Shaky Bridge. 09:39  |  Abu Samra 12/02/07
      65.   Israel folds like a broken umbrella,no will to survive left 09:52  |  Absolute Sweden 12/02/07
      66.   The beauty of it all 09:55  |  FOX 12/02/07
      67.   mugrabi bridge 10:15  |  mike 12/02/07
      68.   Lupolianski postpones Temple Mount Construction 10:17  |  Joe Charlaff 12/02/07
      69.   J`lem Mayor postpones Temple Mt. construction 10:22  |  rin 12/02/07
      70.   Lupolianski versus the settelrs 10:30  |  Esther 12/02/07
      71.   The Illusion of humiliation 10:50  |  FOX 12/02/07
      72.   # 66 U R realy a fox. Workers dig to eat bread 10:58  |  Abu Samra 12/02/07
      73.   #9 Christian Australian: Xtians demands for dhimmi Jews 10:59  |  Yacov 12/02/07
      74.   Nechama, get yourself an education 11:01  |  Hani هاني 12/02/07
      75.   i agree with the decision 11:02  |  flashman 12/02/07
      76.   Lupolianski to Xtians and Muslims: We`ll stay in our shtetl. 11:04  |  Yacov 12/02/07
      77.   #64 Abu Samra تحياتي well said 11:07  |  Hani هاني 12/02/07
      78.   dana at casting central 11:10  |  marwan barghouti 12/02/07
      79.   Dhimmi Lupolianski Capitulates 11:16  |  Neshitma 12/02/07
      80.   dana at casting central 11:16  |  suha arafat 12/02/07
      81.   Abu Samra, I wonder if you would have written to Fox a similar... 11:19  |  Nadav 12/02/07
      82.   #39 RA: Xtians need to "get over the Vatican" 11:31  |  Yacov 12/02/07
      83.   #39 RA: Muslims need to "get over" Al Aqsa and Dome of the Rock 11:33  |  Yacov 12/02/07
      84.   The Mayor Knows The Truth-Why Did He Capitulate? 11:35  |  Ben Israel