Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 15, 2007 Shvat 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A chance to change direction
By Danny Rubinstein

The Israeli government can and should recognize the Palestinian unity government. Can recognize - because in his letter of appointment, Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas calls on Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh "to honor the legitimate Arab and international resolutions and to honor the agreements signed by the Palestine Liberation Organization." This could be seen as a call to abide by the Oslo Accords, including the three demands leveled by the Quartet (recognizing Israel, honoring prior agreements and denouncing violence). Should recognize - because recognition of the new government is the only way now to renew negotiations with PA head Abbas, who has received the backing of all the Palestinian factions to conduct the talks.

Out of the plethora of declarations and reactions at the end of the Mecca conference, it was important to notice one headline, prominent in several media channels - the one concerning the comments by Hamas leader Khaled Meshal on the letter of appointment that Abbas wrote to Haniyeh. After promising that Hamas will be committed to this letter, Meshal added: "Hamas is adopting new political language."

This does not mark a political turnaround in Hamas. No revolution of clear and official recognition of Israel occurred or will occur, certainly not in the near future. But there is some change. Meshal himself testifies to this change, though no political figure hastens to admit that he is changing his position. The change is evident in the route Hamas has traveled this year - a route that, for many Israelis, was not particularly dramatic, but for the Hamas leadership can be seen as a change in direction.

Advertisement

More than a year ago Hamas agreed, with the other Palestinian factions, to a cease-fire with Israel. This agreement was not so simple for an organization that has made its motto the principle of violent, uncompromising struggle against Israel. Hamas activists more or less maintained the cease-fire for most of the time. Later the movement agreed to participate in PA elections, first for local government and later for the Palestinian parliament. The parliament was created by and operates according to the Oslo Accords.

The decision to participate in elections was not easy for Hamas, as it meant the group was tacitly agreeing to operate as a political party and not as a military organization fighting Israel. Later, there were Hamas government decisions on a willingness to talk, on practical matters, with Israeli government ministries. Later came declarations of willingness for a long-term cease-fire, hudna, with Israel, that would be maintained by the Palestinian state to be established in 1967 borders. And now comes the decision to honor past agreements, which means "adopting new political language," according to Meshal.

The Israeli government also should recognize the Palestinian unity government because it is now the only chance to stop the bloodshed in Gaza. Despite the Mecca deal, there is no certainty that the unity government will be able to function. Strong feelings of hatred and vengeance surfaced among the rival groups over the recent months, and it is hard to know how to handle them.

In an East Jerusalem meeting held over the weekend, a former senior Fatah official from Gaza, Sufian Abu Zaida, described the difficult situations he and his colleagues have recently endured. It has reached the point that Hamas members call him, Mohammed Dahlan and others "murtadi." The meaning of this term is something like "heretic." In practice, it means it is okay to spill his blood. Israeli recognition of the unity government will marginally boost its chances of imposing law and order in the Gaza Strip, and that is not important only to the Palestinians - but to us, too.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
They might be right
The 'mobility' reform may force insurers to dramatically improve the terms they offer clients.
Parking meter test
It appears that Israeli society is changing its attitude toward equality between the sexes.
  1.   Danny Rubinstein, talk is very, very cheap among Arabs, and you.. 10:07  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  2.   recognition gose both ways 10:13  |  David G 12/02/07
  3.   Recognise Israel or Piss Off! 10:16  |  ATLAS 12/02/07
  4.   No double standards, please...... 10:26  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  5.   DANNY STICK TO PLAYING THE PIANO 10:42  |  paul harris 12/02/07
  6.   David G, recognition, indeed, must go both ways, but you must ... 10:44  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  7.   Swiss (Dino), enough already with the Liberman business. By you 11:04  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  8.   Mashal 11:09  |  Israel Kastoriano 12/02/07
  9.   Nadav I am well aware 11:11  |  David G 12/02/07
  10.   recognise not recognise is immaterial 11:20  |  flashman 12/02/07
  11.   # 7 Nadav Come on, Nadav, I am not in a mood...... 11:23  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  12.   Danny move to Gaza and leave us alone 11:33  |  Steven 12/02/07
  13.   Swiss, Hamas is not a faction within the Palestinian Authority... 11:36  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  14.   # 13 Nadav, you are totally correct with your.... 11:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  15.   Israel should never recognize terrorist governments 11:53  |  Jonathan S 12/02/07
  16.   all Mecca shows is that Saudi = Hamas = Terrorist 11:54  |  Pavel 12/02/07
  17.   How abour the word"respect" 11:58  |  Willy 12/02/07
  18.   On Nadaz and Swiss debate here... 12:15  |  Willy 12/02/07
  19.   Willy and terror 12:27  |  Steven 12/02/07
  20.   Nadav - Simple question 12:28  |  Skandar 12/02/07
  21.   I call your attention to my post No. 1 in which I expressed hope 12:28  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  22.   Time to stick to the facts 12:43  |  Gee 12/02/07
  23.   # 18 Willy 12:48  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  24.   Skandar, my name is Nadav so please use it properly. And as for.. 12:57  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  25.   Will, thank you for your kind words! 12:59  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  26.   Nadav - I do, I do, I do, I do 13:25  |  Skandar 12/02/07
  27.   About double standards #4 13:34  |  Jonathan S 12/02/07
  28.   #11 Steven L 13:37  |  Willy 12/02/07
  29.   # 1 Nadav A time To Wish And A Tme Not To Wish 13:49  |  Tony Anthony 12/02/07
  30.   swiss you can be sure 13:51  |  flashman 12/02/07
  31.   swiss look at iraq 13:52  |  flashman 12/02/07
  32.   Skandar, I will not go away. This is my home, this is my country, 13:56  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  33.   # 27 Jonathan S a bit off the road...... 13:57  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  34.   Danny is right, the ball is back inside the Israeli square 14:19  |  Tamir Gaza 12/02/07
  35.   Maybe we can honor the unity government without recognizing it. 14:23  |  Zev 12/02/07
  36.   # 4 Swiss 14:34  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  37.   Nadav 14:36  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  38.   Clichés for Willy to learn 14:39  |  Steven 12/02/07
  39.   #11 Swiss 14:42  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  40.   Tamir Gaza either an idiot or moron 14:51  |  Steven 12/02/07
  41.   And out trot the facists 1, 2 and 3 14:58  |  Marilyn 12/02/07
  42.   # 30 / 31 flashman 15:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  43.   # 36 / 39 Lynn 15:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  44.   Jonathan S 15:15  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  45.   Rubinstein what planet are you on? 15:18  |  Dr. Allan 12/02/07
  46.   TAMIR 15:18  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  47.   Skandar 15:24  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  48.   Marilyn for people that starve they throw rocks really well 15:24  |  Steven 12/02/07
  49.   Keep Looking! Use your Imagination! 15:24  |  Tony Anthony 12/02/07
  50.   For Swiss who fantasizes about mirages 15:52  |  Jonathan S 12/02/07
  51.   An answer for Lynn 15:55  |  Jonathan S 12/02/07
  52.   Changing the wrong direction 16:09  |  Rufus 12/02/07
  53.   Wait!!!! 16:15  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/02/07
  54.   #22 Gee 16:21  |  ballistic 12/02/07
  55.   think for just 1 second 16:31  |  albert 12/02/07
  56.   It Is Imperative That Israel Respond 16:34  |  Yaakov Sullivan 12/02/07
  57.   swiss you are right 16:37  |  flashman 12/02/07
  58.   Tzfonit 16:41  |  Gabe1 12/02/07
  59.   @34 Tamir how can Israel talk to Fatah if they are heretics... 16:56  |  Karl 12/02/07
  60.   # 50 Jonathans S wrong on (at least) 2 points..... 17:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  61.   # 57 flashman and his modesty 17:34  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  62.   Swiss (Dino) vs. Jonathan S, Hamas should be responsible for all 17:35  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  63.   NADAV 17:42  |  Gabe1 12/02/07
  64.   # 62 Nadav, once again, nothing to criticize... 17:50  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  65.   # 56 Yaakov Sullivan 17:54  |  Lynn 12/02/07
  66.   Wait a Minute.... 18:11  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/02/07
  67.   32 - Nadav - Funny coincidence 18:12  |  Skandar 12/02/07
  68.   #47 - Lynn the new Emam of the faithfull 18:17  |  Skandar 12/02/07
  69.   Swiss (Dino), I guess you don`t will as much authority in certain 18:17  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  70.   #1 Nadav 18:20  |  slugfest 12/02/07
  71.   ballistic #54 18:28  |  Gee 12/02/07
  72.   #56 yacoov 18:35  |  JOJo 12/02/07
  73.   Gabe 1: Faith in the Situation 18:36  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/02/07
  74.   Apologists whining about rocks 18:41  |  Marilyn 12/02/07
  75.   Israel should not recognize the PA 18:42  |  KUTW 12/02/07
  76.   Pre conditions 18:45  |  Par Excellence 12/02/07
  77.   The only way to get Hamas to behave as a responsible Government i 18:51  |  Amnon 12/02/07
  78.   Haaretz put my reply 18:58  |  Tamir Gaza 12/02/07
  79.   Ronnie Wolman #73 19:01  |  Gabe1 12/02/07
  80.   Tamir Gaza 90% of what I say they do not print 19:02  |  Steven 12/02/07
  81.   Yaakov Sullivan #56 I Agree 19:06  |  Tzfonit 12/02/07
  82.   Swiss and his double standards again 19:13  |  Jonathan S 12/02/07
  83.   34. Tamir Gaza: The ball still on pal ground 19:21  |  KUTW 12/02/07
  84.   #72 Jo jo 19:22  |  Par Excellence 12/02/07
  85.   swiss modest i aint 19:23  |  flashman 12/02/07
  86.   swiss israel`s nukes 19:24  |  flashman 12/02/07
  87.   swiss 19:26  |  flashman 12/02/07
  88.   # 80 Jonathan take a deep breath and read my post # 64..... 19:34  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  89.   # 69 Nadav, hope is a good thing..... 19:40  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  90.   # 66 Ronnie Wolman, not only waiting for Hamas.... 19:48  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  91.   # 85 - 87 flashman 19:55  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  92.   Gabe: the First Order of Business 20:03  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/02/07
  93.   and england should have recognized nazi germany and sued for peac 20:10  |  ralph 12/02/07
  94.   May I propose a deal for Mr. Rubinstein? 20:20  |  bimmer 12/02/07
  95.   swiss the gazans have had regular thrashings 20:29  |  flashman 12/02/07
  96.   Swiss:Its Fundamental,Dino,Fundamental 20:29  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/02/07
  97.   deterrence may work when there is no fanatiicim 20:32  |  flashman 12/02/07
  98.   #61, Dino 21:28  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 12/02/07
  99.   The hamas government is illegitimate 21:42  |  KUTW 12/02/07
  100.   The so-called ceasefire 21:43  |  KUTW 12/02/07
  101.   Swiss Dino #4 Yes to "No double standards" 22:24  |  Polybios 12/02/07
  102.   Another Stellar Accomplishment 22:54  |  Danite 12/02/07
  103.   Support the murderers else they`ll murder themselves,that`s Rub 22:55  |  Absolute Sweden 12/02/07
  104.   # 95 / # 97 flashman 23:19  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  105.   Swiss Dino 23:26  |  Danite 12/02/07
  106.   # 98 Cipora Julianna Kohn 23:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  107.   # 101 Polybios 23:35  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  108.   Polybios #101 23:43  |  Gee 12/02/07
  109.   swiss flowers for ramallah 00:08  |  flashman 13/02/07
  110.   Haaretz 00:09  |  Danite 13/02/07
  111.   if everyone recognized 00:23  |  michael 13/02/07
  112.   Swiss (Dino) #103 00:26  |  Gee 13/02/07
  113.   marilyn 01:26  |  ephraim 13/02/07
  114.   marilyn 01:31  |  ephraim 13/02/07
  115.   PAL.Unity government should recognise the Israeli government 01:37  |  PETER SM 13/02/07
  116.   RE: MARILYN 01:43  |  Gabe1 13/02/07
  117.   Marylin and rock throwing 01:58  |  Cat 13/02/07
  118.   # 104 flashman/ # 107 Gee 02:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/02/07
  119.   Yeah,right! 02:12  |  Salty 13/02/07
  120.   The Russians are for it, The UN is for it and the EU is coming 02:17  |  Dr Gustav Holmert 13/02/07
  121.   War for the past 60 years 02:19  |  GG 13/02/07
  122.   Swiss (Dino) 02:58  |  KT 13/02/07
  123.   # 68 Skandar 03:06  |  Lynn 13/02/07
  124.   # 103 Swiss 03:15  |  Lynn 13/02/07
  125.   basic preconditions 03:18  |  gregoiro 13/02/07
  126.   gg....read good history books 03:20  |  maria 13/02/07
  127.   #111 Dr Gustav Holmert. 03:24  |  Par excellence 13/02/07
  128.   Recognition Is A Two Way Street 03:40  |  Abe 13/02/07
  129.   Just like the Hamilton-Baker report it fails to recognize the 04:02  |  Marwan مروان خو 13/02/07
  130.   A chance to change direction 05:35  |  Ed 13/02/07
  131.   Good analysis & recommendation by Rubinstein 06:22  |  Smadar 13/02/07
  132.   ephraim in Australia 07:14  |  Marilyn 13/02/07
  133.   #106, Dino 08:00  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/02/07
  134.   FYI - Unity deal includes acceptance of Beirut Resoultion 09:16  |  A Bethlehemite 13/02/07
  135.   This editorial sends a wrong massage. 03:20  |  Akram Zekaria 15/02/07
 Today Online
Israel to review ties with Abbas due to Mecca deal
Responses: 136
French envoy: Iran's nuclear program 'threat to the world'
Responses: 89
Amira Hass: Gaza Strip is 'abroad' in a strange way
Responses: 152
Arab couple appeals ban on residency in mainly Jewish town
Responses: 140
Rosner: Israel's well-being not dependent on American aid
Responses: 52


More Headlines
03:03 4 Jordanians who killed IDF soldier may be freed
02:57 Abbas postpones declaring formation of unity government
23:26 PM visit to Turkey to focus on reining in Iran nukes program
01:44 Jerusalem police prepared for violence around Temple Mount
20:10 U.S. Congress freezes transfer of $86 million in aid to Abbas
03:29 Jewish group: Muslims carrying out illegal dig on Temple Mount
03:20 Furor in Addis Ababa camp over rejected immigrants
23:26 Author of blood libel book holds distribution to make changes
02:37 Four Arab law students refused entry and taunted at Netanya mall
00:20 Letters reveal Anne Frank's father sought U.S. visa in 1941
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved