Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., February 13, 2007 Shvat 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A potential turning point
By Haaretz Editorial

The agreement signed in Mecca between Hamas and Fatah will not realize Israel's dream. It does not explicitly recognize Israel and there is no mention of ending terror. It greatly reinforces Hamas' grip on the Palestinian unity government in the making, leaves Ismail Haniyeh in the office of the prime minister and gives Hamas - more precisely, its political leader, Khaled Meshal - veto power over the decisions of the chairman of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas. Ostensibly, the right-wing extremists in the Israeli government can point to the agreement as proof that not only is there no common ground for discussions with Hamas, but in addition, Fatah has accepted this more radical direction.

This simplistic view of the agreement, however, is misleading. Hamas has come a long way along two important roads: The organization is willing to honor - even if it has not promised to implement - the agreements signed by the Palestine Liberation Organization and the PA with Israel, and it had adopted the international and Arab League resolutions, including the latter's Beirut Declaration of 2002. This resolution can be interpreted as accepting, in effect, all of the Quartet's conditions. Those who honor the international agreements and adopt the Beirut resolution are in any event honoring the Oslo Accords, which include recognition of Israel and an end to warfare against it.

Hamas is also willing to accept the principle contained in the Beirut Declaration, according to which Arab states agree to form an alliance of peace with Israel and to normalize relations with it if Israel withdraws to the 1967 borders and achieves a just solution to the refugee problem, in accordance with UN General Assembly Resolution 194.

Advertisement

It could be argued that this theoretical acceptance must be put to a test on the ground. Indeed, that is the position adopted by the Quartet itself in light of the results of the Palestinian summit. The Palestinian unity government has not yet been formed. When it does, it will be possible to determine whether it intends to break through the political paralysis that is affecting the region.

On the other hand, the agreement allows Israel and the Quartet to begin considering genuine amelioration of the economic boycott on the approximately 3 million Palestinians living in the territories, in an effort to nullify the democratic elections to the Palestinian parliament. Those who believe the boycott was effective because it led to the Mecca agreement must also honor its political byproduct. Those who believe, in contrast, that the Mecca agreement is bad for Israel cannot boast of the effectiveness of the sanctions, if that is their result.

It is, therefore, best to look squarely at the reality that created the Mecca agreement and to hope that it will be translated into a practical and moderate platform for the Palestinian unity government. Meanwhile, it is appropriate to move to a practical step: to ease the sanctions, to permit the inflow of money to rehabilitate the economy and services in the territories, and to hold direct talks with the Palestinian government over the prisoner exchange and begin building a relationship of trust with it. This is not an untenable demand. It is inscribed on the same road map that U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice will attempt to further this week.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Bebop gave me life
U.S. jazz singer Sheila Jordan, influenced by Charlie Parker, will appear in Israel this week.
A coffee venture
More people are escaping the distractions of home for virtual offices in cafes.
  1.   Haaretz stop lying 09:39  |  Joe 11/02/07
  2.   The delusional left strikes again!!!! 09:48  |  Ben Uziel 11/02/07
  3.   Haaretz Editorial: Mecca Pact 10:03  |  Michael 11/02/07
  4.   Diluted Hamas or Radical Fatah? 10:14  |  Tzfonit 11/02/07
  5.   you guys are blind and so wrong. but also typical 10:23  |  ralph 11/02/07
  6.   STANDARD ISSUE AT HAARETZ. ROSE COLOURED SPECTACLES 10:37  |  paul harris 11/02/07
  7.   Mecca agreement 10:42  |  Keith T. 11/02/07
  8.   Burston the Zionist manipulating & deceiving as usual 10:45  |  Yacov 11/02/07
  9.   It took Israel almost 50 years to accept a Palestinian state.... 11:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  10.   A step in the right direction. 11:17  |  Deborah 11/02/07
  11.   Retarded point of view 11:34  |  SLAVO 11/02/07
  12.   editor i suggest you listen to aumann 12:00  |  flashman 11/02/07
  13.   Swiss (Dino) #9 12:11  |  Tim R 11/02/07
  14.   No, Swiss, Israel accepted a Palestinian Arab state back in 1947 12:13  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  15.   Deborah #10 What Has Israel Done...???!! 12:18  |  Tim R 11/02/07
  16.   Why"theoretical"attributions.NO Recognition by unity Govt clear 12:19  |  PETER SM 11/02/07
  17.   #9 Israel accepted Pal. state 60 years ago 12:21  |  just the facts 11/02/07
  18.   FATAH hasn`t meet Quartet conditions 12:29  |  just the facts 11/02/07
  19.   # 13 Tim R 12:44  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  20.   # 14 Nadav 12:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  21.   Swiss, do you know what the Palestinian Arab leadership has said 13:26  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  22.   # 21 Nadav 13:40  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  23.   SWISS 1948 Israel accepted partition into Arab& Israeli states 13:51  |  PETER SM 11/02/07
  24.   Swiss (Dino) #19 14:01  |  Tim R 11/02/07
  25.   Swiss, Begin and Sadat proposal was to lead to autonomy and ..... 14:04  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  26.   # 23 Peter SM 14:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  27.   Mecca... A Pact With the Devils 14:07  |  Klaudia 11/02/07
  28.   Potnetial turning point 14:23  |  Mohammed najumuddin 11/02/07
  29.   Hamas Covenant: ALL Jews Must Die Before Day of Judgement 14:39  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 11/02/07
  30.   #22 swiss 14:43  |  duncan 11/02/07
  31.   Deborah: Israel Did Recognize Them When The Roles Were Reversed 14:47  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 11/02/07
  32.   Letr them prove that they have change 14:51  |  Ian 11/02/07
  33.   The Blessed Saudi Peacemakers 15:03  |  Klaudia 11/02/07
  34.   # 30 duncan 15:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  35.   You are such total fools 15:21  |  Shalom Freedman 11/02/07
  36.   #20 swiss 15:21  |  duncan 11/02/07
  37.   Riyadh has told Washington Hamas will not honor Fatah agreements 15:26  |  Shalom Freedman 11/02/07
  38.   #9 swiss 15:30  |  duncan 11/02/07
  39.   Nadav, sorry for having to molest you once in a while..... 15:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  40.   Drive a Hummer... Help Put the Saudis Out of Business ! 15:54  |  Klaudia 11/02/07
  41.   # 36 duncan 15:54  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  42.   #34 swiss 15:55  |  duncan 11/02/07
  43.   #30 swiss 16:01  |  duncan 11/02/07
  44.   # 38 duncan 16:02  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  45.   Long way theories of turning point by Haaretz Arabs 16:04  |  Sal 11/02/07
  46.   Tzfonit: Another Opportunity? 16:09  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  47.   Everybody still the same? 16:14  |  christoph 11/02/07
  48.   #41 swiss 16:21  |  duncan 11/02/07
  49.   Swiss, indeed, I am a good example of an Israeli who demands .... 16:24  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  50.   #44 swiss 16:28  |  duncan 11/02/07
  51.   # 42 duncan 16:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  52.   # 43 duncan 16:37  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  53.   # 49 Nadav, you will get your answer...... 16:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  54.   #46 Ronnie Wolman: At What Point do We Trust? 17:05  |  Tzfonit 11/02/07
  55.   # 48 duncan 17:08  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  56.   Klaudia: Better the Fundamentalists we Know 17:19  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  57.   Look into the future 17:28  |  Elie 11/02/07
  58.   # 46 Ronnie Wolman 17:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  59.   # 44 duncan 17:37  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  60.   Swiss Dino, you are very naive 17:41  |  albert amato 11/02/07
  61.   Swiss (Dino), does the Jewish people have the right of national 17:41  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  62.   Of course it won`t 17:46  |  Mark Lincoln 11/02/07
  63.   PS: this doesn`t say hamantaschen shouldn`t be taken seriously 17:54  |  christoph 11/02/07
  64.   Pals should be united 17:58  |  Rupert 11/02/07
  65.   #51 swiss 18:01  |  duncan 11/02/07
  66.   Don`t be fools: HAMAS admits 10-year hudna. It is not a peace. 18:02  |  Vittorio 11/02/07
  67.   Swiss: When Politics meets the Boys behind the Goal 18:07  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  68.   Swiss: Perhaps one was asleep in late `60s and early 70`s 18:07  |  Michael Korn 11/02/07
  69.   Mecca Accord 18:08  |  Colin Nelson 11/02/07
  70.   #57 swiss 18:09  |  duncan 11/02/07
  71.   # 54- Ronnie 18:11  |  Klaudia 11/02/07
  72.   # 58 Not naive, Albert, just realistic..... 18:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  73.   Swiss (Dino), I sent to you a list of questions and I hope to see 18:12  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  74.   #52 swiss 18:16  |  duncan 11/02/07
  75.   Mark Lincoln:I should take advil before I read your posts 18:19  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  76.   # 60 Nadav 18:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  77.   #52 Swiss--Palestinians could have had state over 30 years ago. 18:32  |  Dov 11/02/07
  78.   Klaudia: I thought you studied Objectivism 18:36  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  79.   Tzfonit #4 18:41  |  Dov 11/02/07
  80.   #53 swiss 18:42  |  duncan 11/02/07
  81.   #40 Klaudia 18:51  |  Dov 11/02/07
  82.   # 66 Vittorio 18:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  83.   Haaretz editorial is perverted logic 19:04  |  Nat Weinstein 11/02/07
  84.   The Arabs are laughing about Israel 19:06  |  Jonathan S 11/02/07
  85.   # 68 Michael Korn 19:08  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  86.   Okay guys, I am sorry to say, but I have to get out now..... 19:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  87.   Temporary reprieve for warring factions 19:15  |  Passerby 11/02/07
  88.   # 77 Dov 19:21  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  89.   Klaudia - Are the Saudis beyond redemption or 19:21  |  Najdt 11/02/07
  90.   Moderation of Hamas; past, present, and future 19:23  |  Tosefta 11/02/07
  91.   #85 swiss. bye, enjoyed exchange of views 19:25  |  duncan 11/02/07
  92.   Haaretz`s Editorial - Tragicomic and Very Predictable 19:29  |  Tod Zuckerman 11/02/07
  93.   Swiss (Dino), I thank you for your response to my questions. 19:54  |  Nadav 11/02/07
  94.   #77 Ronnie 19:54  |  Dov 11/02/07
  95.   # 72 Swiss Dino...if you are still here..Dialogue is good, I agre 20:00  |  albert amato 11/02/07
  96.   i am amazed how seriously posters take the palestinian 20:11  |  ahmedinejad 11/02/07
  97.   honestly tofesta it is the most amazing thing 20:16  |  flashman 11/02/07
  98.   tosefta "hamas wants to regain israel proper 20:17  |  flashman 11/02/07
  99.   tosefta "hamas moderation in action" 20:22  |  flashman 11/02/07
  100.   tosefta "hamas has gone a long way" 20:23  |  flashman 11/02/07
  101.   Swiss (Dino) #26 Actually You Didn`t Handle It 20:25  |  Tim R 11/02/07
  102.   if tosefta were a paid agent for hamas would he do a better job 20:27  |  flashman 11/02/07
  103.   Dov: We all have simplistic views 20:29  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  104.   tosefta "with peace conditions there will be less appetite 20:31  |  flashman 11/02/07
  105.   tosefta "hamas will exercise further moderation" 20:32  |  flashman 11/02/07
  106.   tosefta loses no opportunity to make comparsions 20:35  |  flashman 11/02/07
  107.   Tosefta (# 90): Ridiculous argument 20:36  |  Fortuna 11/02/07
  108.   It is true ... 20:43  |  Ernie 11/02/07
  109.   tosefta "our father darwin still lives" 20:43  |  flashman 11/02/07
  110.   tosefta "and in time they will have their own exhamas 20:44  |  flashman 11/02/07
  111.   tosefta is good man 20:56  |  ahmedinejad 11/02/07
  112.   the north koreans are very clever 20:59  |  ahmedinejad 11/02/07
  113.   ronnie wolman 21:04  |  steve wynn 11/02/07
  114.   Our verbally diarrhetic "flushman"; aka The Hydra 21:13  |  Tosefta 11/02/07
  115.   Swiss (Dino) Oh And One More Thing: How Do I Know..... 21:16  |  Tim R 11/02/07
  116.   ayatollah hussain you must make sure to make tosefta 21:37  |  ahmedinejad 11/02/07
  117.   Fortuna #90; and bad luck 21:38  |  Tosefta 11/02/07
  118.   Dov: Lines in the Sand 21:38  |  Ronnie Wolman 11/02/07
  119.   tosefta and that "powem" 22:06  |  flashman 11/02/07
  120.   reading more 22:18  |  ron 11/02/07
  121.   Dov #79 Thank you but no... 22:29  |  Tzfonit 11/02/07
  122.   Ronnie- Labels versus Interests 23:01  |  Dov 11/02/07
  123.   #117 Get Orff! 23:06  |  sh 11/02/07
  124.   # 101 / 115 Tim R 23:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 11/02/07
  125.   Haaretz Editorial 23:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/02/07
  126.   IRAN IS THE ANSWER 23:50  |  Arik Silverman 11/02/07
  127.   Swiss (Dino) #124 00:23  |  Tim R 12/02/07
  128.   tosefta i love the idea of us uniting 00:57  |  haniya 12/02/07
  129.   Thank You Swiss (Dino) 01:09  |  A Lebanese 12/02/07
  130.   #123 SH; on Orff 01:22  |  Tosefta 12/02/07
  131.   Dov: Fans and fanatics 01:30  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/02/07
  132.   To Tim R. 01:36  |  Deborah 12/02/07
  133.   Tzfonit #4 01:41  |  Gabe1 12/02/07
  134.   Fortuna And T O S E F T A 01:51  |  Gabe1 12/02/07
  135.   Sheer stupidity 01:55  |  rich 12/02/07
  136.   # 129 Lebanese 02:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  137.   Haaretz Editorial 02:07  |  Otto Rand 12/02/07
  138.   Let`s Fight 02:10  |  John 12/02/07
  139.   Recognition of Israel 02:18  |  Otto Rand 12/02/07
  140.   Lebanese #129 02:19  |  Tim R 12/02/07
  141.   To Swiss (Dino) 02:22  |  KT 12/02/07
  142.   Is Hamas unreformable? 02:32  |  Otto Rand 12/02/07
  143.   #123 SH; on Orff 03:22  |  Tosefta 12/02/07
  144.   What editorial would you expect from a german-owned newspaper? 03:33  |  Observer 12/02/07
  145.   To Gabe 1 regarding Tzfonit 04:15  |  Otto Rand 12/02/07
  146.   a point 05:04  |  Shmuelshachor 12/02/07
  147.   Mecca Agreement: full speed for abyss... 05:38  |  Ed 12/02/07
  148.   #15. Tim R. 07:56  |  Deborah 12/02/07
  149.   #125 Cipora 08:55  |  S 12/02/07
  150.   # 141 KT 09:38  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/02/07
  151.   Beyond all declarations I would expect Haaretz editors to suggest 10:34  |  Nadav 12/02/07
  152.   ..a long way, my foot ! 11:04  |  Akram Zekaria 12/02/07
  153.   125# Cipora. Time for raw truth with the Palestinians. 13:30  |  Akram Zekaria 12/02/07
  154.   Illogic of Haaretz editorial 19:28  |  Martin K 12/02/07
  155.   Right Wing Extremists 22:51  |  Sam 12/02/07
  156.   hamas 22:52  |  john simhi 12/02/07
 Today Online
Majadele: Jerusalem mayor knew Mugrabi dig was illegal
Responses: 270
Steinitz: Arrow test gives Israel advantage over Syria, Iran
Responses: 141
Bar-Ilan prof. defiant on blood libel book 'even if crucified'
Responses: 177
Rubinstein: Israel should recognize PA unity government
Responses: 131
Burston: Save the Temple Mount - Lupolianski for PM
Responses: 70
'Life under occupation just like life under Pinochet'
Responses: 145


More Headlines
03:17 Olmert, Abbas clash over agenda of trilateral summit
04:11 Hamas lawmaker: Egypt offers swap of 1,400 prisoners for Shalit
04:57 Bar-Ilan resists pressure to fire author of book on blood libels
05:48 Olmert aides chide Lupolianski over decision to stop bridge work
00:43 Ban backs PA unity deal, urges recognition of Israel
02:27 Paris Archbishop in Israel, renewing French church's links to country
05:40 Immigrant youth to be given easier testing conditions after arrival
03:06 Lebanon, UN to work on marking Israel border after border clash
06:34 Egyptian MP: Nothing will work with Israel except nuclear bomb
06:36 German defense chief Jung says skeptical of Mecca agreement
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved