Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., February 11, 2007 Shvat 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
From left: PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, Saudi King Abdullah and Hamas leader Khaled Meshal at the signing ceremony in Mecca. (AP)
Last update - 07:20 09/02/2007
ANALYSIS: Unity deal is minimum required to remove the siege
By Zvi Bar'el, Haaretz Correspondent

For a while it seemed that Khaled Meshal, not Mahmoud Abbas, was the Palestinian Authority chairman.

In his speech in Mecca on Thursday, Meshal stressed the commitment to stop the bloodshed among the Palestinian factions and the cooperation with Abbas. He did not say a word on the political issues the two had agreed upon.

In a letter on appointing the government, Abbas called on Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh to honor (not to commit to) the signed agreements (without saying with whom), and to honor the international decisions and the Arab League's resolutions.

Advertisement

There is no commitment in the letter to keep past agreements and no direct recognition of Israel. But its wording is sufficient, at least for Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah, to lift the siege from the Palestinian Authority. Because it holds the essential turning point in Hamas' position: the acceptance in theory of the agreements and resolutions, including the Oslo Accords and the Arab League resolutions, such as those adopted by the Arab summit conference in Beirut in 2002, dealing with terms of normalization with Israel.

On the other hand, Hamas' insistence on the term "to honor" instead of "to commit to" turns the theoretical recognition into something impractical and appears to limit Abbas' ability to negotiate with Israel. For a government that cannot commit to uphold past agreements will not want to take part in drafting future ones.

Abbas will be appointing a cabinet which is not committed to the resolutions from which he derives his power and authority.

All the parties, including Saudi Arabia and Egypt, seem to understand that in view of the political situation in Israel and Washington's lack of interest in advancing the political process, it is better to make do with managing the internal Palestinian crisis.

Another question is whether the national unity government would be able to function. The portfolio allocation was agreed on before the Mecca gathering, following the monetary temptation the king had offered the Palestinians if they set up a unity government.

Arab sources say the new government will get half a billion dollars now for "routine maintenance" and additional large sums for rehabilitation and development later.

It is not clear, however, whether it will be possible to merge the armed Hamas and Fatah forces into one.

Various clauses of the agreement, such as Mohammed Dahlan's authorities as deputy prime minister, have yet to be agreed upon, but Saudi Arabia still has good cause for satisfaction. The agreement will not only enable it to lift the economic siege and funnel money to the PA, but also - and primarily - to block Iranian involvement in the Palestinian problem and keep it in Arab hands.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
Yair Mau and Liat Carmi, new immigrants from Brazil, came to Israel two years ago.
Topic of cancer
If you're talented like Rachel Talshir, cancer can result in a book filled with humor.
  1.   "To keep in Arab hands" 23:52  |  Joke 08/02/07
  2.   Israeli Lefties& EU prepared to to accept not recognising Israel 00:03  |  Absolute Sweden 09/02/07
  3.   Unity deal. 00:22  |  sandra chitayat 09/02/07
  4.   so will the US start a rift with the Saudis 00:30  |  Tom Hunter 09/02/07
  5.   As in all Palestinian agreements 00:43  |  * BEN JABO 09/02/07
  6.   Unity Government formation means progress to diplomacy 00:44  |  Smadar 09/02/07
  7.   So what? 00:48  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  8.   this does not meet a mimium 00:54  |  vik 09/02/07
  9.   The great danger ahead 01:21  |  Jonathan S 09/02/07
  10.   With Fatah in the PA the US/Israeli partnership have run aground 02:02  |  Scott Rider 09/02/07
  11.   Yes Mark, I do. 02:14  |  Frank Gable 09/02/07
  12.   positives and negatives 02:18  |  Palestinians 09/02/07
  13.   my prediction for the future 02:24  |  Palestinian 09/02/07
  14.   Why bother to draft new agreements? 02:29  |  Gina 09/02/07
  15.   Honor and Commitment 02:37  |  David Erlichman 09/02/07
  16.   Saudi Arabia is now an accomplice to Hamas` terrorism 02:39  |  Jon 09/02/07
  17.   Intended incompleteness? 02:46  |  Lizard 09/02/07
  18.   Agreed 02:48  |  Chris Linthwaite 09/02/07
  19.   peace deal 02:49  |  colin 09/02/07
  20.   Excuse me everyone 02:50  |  Chris Linthwaite 09/02/07
  21.   So What if They Don`t "Accept" Israel? 02:54  |  Jane 09/02/07
  22.   The US Will Not Break with Saudi Arabia 02:58  |  Jane 09/02/07
  23.   All somke and mirrors 03:05  |  Adrian de Klerk 09/02/07
  24.   Short of... 03:28  |  Baz Mann 09/02/07
  25.   The great compromise and a victory for Bush admin 03:32  |  Voice of Reason 09/02/07
  26.   Say yes to the Saudi peace plan 03:51  |  Harris 09/02/07
  27.   For the palestinian people = Mazel tov . 04:37  |  Hami 09/02/07
  28.   The Mecca agreement doesn`t relief 3 quartet demands 04:52  |  Joseph E . 09/02/07
  29.   Frank Gable 04:58  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  30.   Harris - no matter what Israelis want 04:59  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  31.   so will the US start a rift with the Saudis? 05:10  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  32.   All the Mecca agreement that you call unity deal 05:26  |  Joseph E . 09/02/07
  33.   Unity deal in Palestine 05:31  |  Beryl Shannon 09/02/07
  34.   Unity deal 05:37  |  Beryl Shannon 09/02/07
  35.   analysis of agreement bet. fatah & hammas. 05:50  |  amir 09/02/07
  36.   What a show --Don`t believe even one word Pals are saying 05:56  |  Sal 09/02/07
  37.   Meshal: You Had Poison Running Through Your Veins ... 06:04  |  Lavi 09/02/07
  38.   #13 Palestinian`s prediction for the future 06:04  |  AA 09/02/07
  39.   one step in the right direction but another is needed 06:30  |  David G 09/02/07
  40.   Unity is not the minimum required to remove the siege!!! The 06:34  |  Nadav 09/02/07
  41.   Just Like Israel 06:36  |  Paulo 09/02/07
  42.   A PERFECT DEAL, NOBODY GET HURT 06:46  |  indrajaya 09/02/07
  43.   So what indeed Mark 06:47  |  Jacob Blues 09/02/07
  44.   re #2 `Israeli lefties...` 06:50  |  Colin Wright 09/02/07
  45.   To Frank #11 06:54  |  Mike 09/02/07
  46.   re #8 `this does not meet a mimium.` 06:56  |  Colin Wright 09/02/07
  47.   Frank Gable - sorry, the censor has blocked 06:56  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  48.   re #17 `For the Palestinian People...` 07:00  |  Colin Wright 09/02/07
  49.   AA in LA 07:04  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  50.   If this "unity" is to be legitimate, Hamas has to accept all 07:06  |  Marwan مروان خو 09/02/07
  51.   Paulo, the critique of Israel who refuses to recognize Israel`s 07:09  |  Nadav 09/02/07
  52.   re #21 `Just like Israel` 07:10  |  Colin Wright 09/02/07
  53.   #23. What "Road Map" they one the Palestinians have done nothing 07:21  |  Marwan مروان خو 09/02/07
  54.   cont.other commitments of Road Map violated by Palesti.leadership 07:35  |  Marwan مروان خو 09/02/07
  55.   part 3 commitments of Road Map violated by Palesti.leadership 07:42  |  Marwan مروان خو 09/02/07
  56.   part 4 commitments of Road Map violated by Palesti.leadership 07:44  |  Marwan مروان خو 09/02/07
  57.   why are you people so optimistic over this? 08:16  |  vik 09/02/07
  58.   Unity deal is minimum required to remove the siege 08:20  |  Majed Elhewaihi 09/02/07
  59.   None of the three demands have been met 08:36  |  redmike 09/02/07
  60.   Paulo #23 09:03  |  Michael 09/02/07
  61.   palestinians, be realistic, they are only dreams 09:29  |  LDychter 09/02/07
  62.   mr. portugues, you are dumb 09:44  |  LDychter 09/02/07
  63.   #23 09:45  |  Grootkak 09/02/07
  64.   For Absolute Sweden # 2 09:59  |  Clickfool 09/02/07
  65.   #10 Scott Rider, The unmentionables 10:03  |  Dutch 09/02/07
  66.   Saudi agreement is simply to stop the Palestinian killing 10:04  |  Clickfool 09/02/07
  67.   That`s it, Paulo! 10:09  |  Martino 09/02/07
  68.   Scott Rider 10:21  |  Willy 09/02/07
  69.   #16 LES LOCOS ALSO WANTS SCRAMBLED EGGS FOR BREAKFAST. 10:25  |  paul harris 09/02/07
  70.   mark lincoln you have been out of the loop 10:55  |  saul 09/02/07
  71.   mark lincoln tells us he is an old geezer 10:57  |  saul 09/02/07
  72.   ml "the king said politely" 11:00  |  saul 09/02/07
  73.   mark lincoln "at this point the bush junta" 11:03  |  saul 09/02/07
  74.   mark lincoln why would you think we are remotely 11:05  |  saul 09/02/07
  75.   clickfool apart from abuse 11:08  |  harzion 09/02/07
  76.   mark lincoln what siege is that? 11:12  |  saul 09/02/07
  77.   What Israel can expect and what she can`t..... 11:16  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/02/07
  78.   why does mark lincoln insist israel 11:26  |  saul 09/02/07
  79.   mark lincoln was told yesterday that 11:34  |  saul 09/02/07
  80.   ml syria uses hizb to protect its flank 11:38  |  saul 09/02/07
  81.   Rider:"His unmentionables in a twist" 13:04  |  Terence Young 09/02/07
  82.   the acceptance in theory of the agreements and resolutions 13:41  |  Zev 09/02/07
  83.   Camels, Horses, and Agreements 14:55  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  84.   Saudis will handle it # 59 15:16  |  Lynn 09/02/07
  85.   Clickfool # 64 Something For Nothing 15:28  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  86.   # 82 Camels and Horses 16:15  |  Lynn 09/02/07
  87.   # 58 Majed 16:18  |  Lynn 09/02/07
  88.   Less than the minimum required, but also good 16:21  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  89.   # 24 Baz Man 16:22  |  Lynn 09/02/07
  90.   Prospects for the siege 16:35  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  91.   Tosefta # 86 Chaos 17:43  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  92.   Saudi focus 18:01  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/02/07
  93.   tosefta the man with no stick 18:12  |  flashman 09/02/07
  94.   Theories and facts (Jeff Northridge #91) 18:14  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  95.   does tosefta at least have a carrot? 18:17  |  flashman 09/02/07
  96.   tosefta "i would have gotten(sic) hamas to do a little more" 18:20  |  flashman 09/02/07
  97.   Tosefta # 89 The Siege 18:27  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  98.   tosefta "the saudis are rich enough to be able 18:28  |  flashman 09/02/07
  99.   tosefta the man with no stick and not much grey matter 18:33  |  flashman 09/02/07
  100.   ANOTHER FRIDAY AGREEMENT PULLED OFF 18:47  |  paul harris 09/02/07
  101.   Useless definition again? (Jeff Northridge #97) 19:16  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  102.   Re to Mr Wrigth # 48 20:16  |  Hami 09/02/07
  103.   Tosefta # 94 The Saudi Arabians 20:25  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  104.   Reality and law (Jeff Northridge #103) 21:20  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  105.   #104, "the `siege` of Hamas is not because Hamas is terroristic" 21:38  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/02/07
  106.   Tosefta # 101 The Conditions Have Not Been Met 21:53  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  107.   CLICKFOOL 22:44  |  Lynn 09/02/07
  108.   Tosefta # 104 You Idiot! 22:54  |  Jeff Northridge 09/02/07
  109.   #106, Jeff Northridge 23:28  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/02/07
  110.   Physics for idiots (Jeff Northridge #106) 23:49  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  111.   the charity of tveira 00:04  |  flashman 10/02/07
  112.   tosefta "the siege was made to force hamas 00:29  |  flashman 10/02/07
  113.   tosefta "the europeans would start contributing 00:36  |  flashman 10/02/07
  114.   tosefta f=ma 00:39  |  flashman 10/02/07
  115.   what martin kramer said at the herziliya thing 01:16  |  flashman 10/02/07
  116.   Logic for the birds (#105) 03:16  |  Tosefta 10/02/07
  117.   Useless definition, again! (Jeff Northridge #106) 03:33  |  Tosefta 10/02/07
  118.   Tosefta # 110 Wrong! 03:48  |  Jeff Northridge 10/02/07
  119.   Oy vey, Physics for kids (Jeff Northridge #118) 04:35  |  Tosefta 10/02/07
  120.   Tosefta # 116 What Rot! 04:41  |  Jeff Northridge 10/02/07
  121.   #116, logic for Tosefta 05:20  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/02/07
  122.   Tosefta # 119 Let`s Drop It 07:05  |  Jeff Northridge 10/02/07
  123.   silly logic in tveira 11:19  |  flashman 10/02/07
  124.   The Starvation Blockade is ended 11:23  |  Clickfool 10/02/07
  125.   tosefta "why would spain give them money if they had not 11:24  |  flashman 10/02/07
  126.   eyeless in tveira 11:28  |  flashman 10/02/07
  127.   in short i ask the site to judge tosefta`s 11:32  |  flashman 10/02/07
  128.   we can only compare tosefta`s bad mouthing 11:35  |  flashman 10/02/07
  129.   spanish help for hamas 11:45  |  flashman 10/02/07
  130.   #122 jeff .Do you think the QUARTET`s conditions are one sided 11:48  |  Tom 10/02/07
  131.   # 115 flashman 12:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 10/02/07
  132.   #130 THE SIDES ARE NOT EQUAL TOM 13:20  |  paul harris 10/02/07
  133.   For Tom in NYC # 130 14:11  |  Clickfool 10/02/07
  134.   swiss your views reflect your personal 14:25  |  flashman 10/02/07
  135.   swiss the syrians have been killing the lebanese 14:27  |  flashman 10/02/07
  136.   swiss you in europe went through verdun and the somme 14:32  |  flashpoint 10/02/07
  137.   swiss the region is also chopping of hands and heads 14:34  |  flashman 10/02/07
  138.   swiss and iraq? 14:42  |  flashman 10/02/07
  139.   swiss "a majority of palestinians are for peace" 14:45  |  flashman 10/02/07
  140.   swiss "their leaders have failed them" 14:47  |  flashman 10/02/07
  141.   swiss "marginalise the extremists" 14:48  |  flashman 10/02/07
  142.   swiss "give up the west bank" 14:52  |  flashman 10/02/07
  143.   swiss "a good word for tosefta" 14:57  |  flashman 10/02/07
  144.   swiss "if there were more toseftas" 15:11  |  flashman 10/02/07
  145.   T O S E F T A 15:40  |  Gabe1 10/02/07
  146.   Tom # 130 Of Course They`re One-Sided 17:30  |  Jeff Northridge 10/02/07
  147.   My Idea For Peace 18:13  |  PeaceMaker 10/02/07
  148.   To Jeff Northridge about physics 18:20  |  Jonathan S 10/02/07
  149.   Cipora re Tosefta 18:24  |  TM 10/02/07
  150.   Jonathan S # 134 Physical Reality 20:15  |  Jeff Northridge 10/02/07
  151.   A question to Jeff Northridge 21:46  |  Jonathan S 10/02/07
  152.   The responses are clear - nothing to argue about 02:01  |  Mark Lincoln 11/02/07
  153.   Frank Gable - this story looked very different 02:05  |  Mark Lincoln 11/02/07
  154.   News flash, flashman 02:07  |  Mark Lincoln 11/02/07
  155.   Hard to understand why this story is still here 02:10  |  Mark Lincoln 11/02/07
  156.   Frank Gable - today`s Arab News 02:18  |  Mark Lincoln 11/02/07
  157.   Logic for birds (TM #138; Bird from Outerspace #121) 03:24  |  Tosefta 11/02/07
  158.   Logic for birds (TM #138; Bird from Outerspace #121) 05:40  |  Tosefta 11/02/07
  159.   Logic for birds (TM #138; Bird from Outerspace #121) 06:12  |  Tosefta 11/02/07
  160.   #151Johnathon, excuse me for... 08:21  |  Maureen Ann 11/02/07
  161.   TOSEFTA 10:27  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/02/07
  162.   An answer and a question for Maureen Ann 12:46  |  Jonathan S 11/02/07
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: Two murdered girls, 1 Israeli, 1 Palestinian
Responses: 24
Editorial: The Mecca pact - Hamas has come a long way
Responses: 19
Shragai: Great Muslim denial of Jewish ties to Temple Mount
Responses: 4
Zvi Bar'el: Khaled Meshal for president
Responses: 5
Bar-Ilan historian's allegations on blood libels spark outrage
Responses: 65
Israel rejects Mecca deal as failing to meet Quartet terms
Responses: 61
Rosner's Domain
* Blog and Poll: Is financial aid to Israel in America's best interest?
* What can one do with so many new Jews?
* FAQ on the state of affairs in the Middle East
* On the Crisis of America's Israel Lobby


More Headlines
11:24 PM: No stance taken on Hamas-Fatah pact as yet
11:50 Dichter: Old City renovations to continue despite objections
07:56 PM's bureau chief suspended amid allegations of bribery
12:19 Ahmadinejad: Iran wants talks, but won't suspend atomic work
09:47 Bar-Ilan historian's allegations on blood libels spark outrage
08:56 Israel demanding right to buy Greek Orthodox church property
11:22 Van driver in multiple-fatality Negev crash may be Palestinian
02:17 Polish Jews to reopen synagogue in prewar yeshiva Chachmei Lublin
02:18 Islamic Movement leader to attend forum on anti-Semitism
05:30 Study: 13% of Israeli childen suffer from disabilities, chronic illnesses
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved