Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., February 10, 2007 Shvat 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Protestors chanting slogans at a demonstration against the Temple Mount construction in Jerusalem on Thursday. (Pierre Terdjman / BauBau)
Last update - 19:40 08/02/2007
Egypt summons Israeli envoy over Temple Mount excavation
By Haaretz Staff and Reuters

Egypt summoned the Israeli ambassador to the Foreign Ministry in Cairo on Thursday to protest against the construction of a new bridge to the Temple Mount, a site holy to Jews and Muslims.

The Egyptian Foreign Ministry said in a statement it told the Israeli ambassador, Shalom Cohen, that the excavations could hurt efforts to revive the long-stalled Israeli-Palestinian peace process.

"The Foreign Ministry also stressed that the sacredness of the site makes any movement inside or around it a very sensitive issue for Arab and Muslim peoples, in a way that could cause the situation to explode," the statement said.

Advertisement

Earlier Thursday, hundreds of people gathered outside the Dung Gate in the Old City of Jerusalem to protest against the construction.

Sheikh Raed Salah, the head of the Islamic Movement's Northern Branch, arrived at the scene, but kept his distance due to a court order prohibiting from coming within 150 meters of the Old City for the next 10 days.

On Wednesday, police detained Salah and six of his supporters after they arrived at the Old City's Dung Gate and tried to break into the excavation site near the Mugrabi Gate. A violent confrontation developed.

The Jerusalem Magistrate's Court subsequently issued the order barring him and his supporters from the area.

The Prime Minister's Office said Wednesday that the work on the new bridge to the Temple Mount would not harm holy sites, in response to a written request by Defense Minister Amir Peretz that the work be halted immediately.

"As to the matter at hand," the statement said, "the restoration of the Mugrabi ascent after the place collapsed and was declared a dangerous structure was done in complete coordination with all parties, including foreign countries, relevant Muslim officials and international bodies.

"As has been explained, this work is being carried on outside the Temple Mount, and they [the repairs] do not constitute any damage to the Mount or Islamic holy places."

"The work is being carried out by professionals and with complete transparency, entirely for the safety of visitors to the Mount," the statement continued.

"A thorough examination of the matter would reveal that nothing about the work underway will harm anyone, and there is no truth in the contentions against the work."

In response to media reports on Peretz's letter, the Prime Minister's Bureau said: "The letter from the defense minister was received a few minutes before your paper approached us, and we are surprised at the fact that the letter found its way to the media so quickly. The Prime Minister's Office certainly does not see itself free to share correspondence on sensitive matters with the media."

Peretz attached to his request an opinion written by General (res.) Amos Gilad, head of the political-military bureau at the Defense Ministry. Gilad said in his letter the construction was causing considerable damage and would create foment in the Arab world, particularly at the present time, with Israel trying to initiate steps to calm things down with the Palestinians and the Arab world.

Gilad noted that Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas and PA Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh were close to an agreement in Mecca on a unity government, and that an Olmert-Abbas summit is to take place in about two weeks. He also mentioned the planned visit to the region of U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. Gilad also expressed concern that the project had not been coordinated with Jordan.

Peretz reportedly learned late in the day about the decision to begin work at the site. Apparently the move was not thoroughly coordinated with him.

On Wednesday, Olmert's military secretary, Major General Gad Shamni, and Peretz's military secretary, Brigadier General Eitan Dangot, discussed the project and Peretz's objections.

The Jerusalem police and other security officials preferred that a new bridge to the Mugrabi gate not be built, but rather that the existing walkway be restored, Haaretz has learned. The police were concerned that Muslim elements in Israel and abroad would use the work at the site to stir up accusations against Israel. Only when the ostensible complexities came to light of the engineering work to restore the ramp, which had been declared a dangerous structure, and only when the Israel Antiquities Authority made clear that even rehabilitation of the old structure would entail the construction of numerous concrete supports and would also require a salvage dig, did the authorities come to terms with and agree to the need for a new bridge.

The decision-making process went on for over a year.

Haaretz also learned that the Waqf (the Muslim religious trust), which so far has not been involved in the public disturbances over the new bridge, has been fully briefed by the police on the plan now underway, although not at the level of coordination or obtaining consent.

The Waqf, as opposed to the branches of the Islamic Movement, has made do meanwhile with verbal protests against the work.

An official involved in contacts said Israel is not confirming that the plans were presented to the Waqf so as not to cut off a channel of communication between the police and the Waqf that has been open for years.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
'Good Arabs'
Hillel Cohen's new book sheds light on Israel's dealings with its Arab citizens since 1948.
The trait of Sodom
How do the traits of Sodom and Gomorrah manifest in our day to day life?
  1.   He is right 04:02  |  dr danielito 08/02/07
  2.   under no circumstances stop work that was our mistake before 04:08  |  ralph 08/02/07
  3.   Peretz should quit 04:18  |  Brod 08/02/07
  4.   Temple Mount is Judaisms holiest site..ban Muslims 05:00  |  David 08/02/07
  5.   Peretz has to GGGGGGGGO! 05:01  |  A.K. 08/02/07
  6.   Terrorism in its true and ugly form 05:22  |  Jon 08/02/07
  7.   Is there anyone who will fire this idiot? 05:25  |  Sam Weinstein 08/02/07
  8.   Temple Mount: holiest to Judaism, 3rd holiest to Islam 05:26  |  Mr. Rabinowitz 08/02/07
  9.   If Jews aren`t.... 05:43  |  David Carmeli 08/02/07
  10.   To stop work immediately? - No, to throw out PERETZ immediately. 05:45  |  Vittorio 08/02/07
  11.   Peretz is a prisoner of the Arabs in his own party 05:52  |  Shalom Freedman 08/02/07
  12.   Peretz – resign you incompetent fool! 05:53  |  David 08/02/07
  13.   stop this madness 06:09  |  david 08/02/07
  14.   Peretz is stupid --constructing a pavement Endangers what ? 06:37  |  Sal 08/02/07
  15.   Halutz/Peretz Who is going to defend Israel? 06:39  |  Levi Ciatoni 08/02/07
  16.   The Bridge 06:56  |  Ariel 08/02/07
  17.   peretz. 06:57  |  colin 08/02/07
  18.   Stop nothing ,by any mean Insist on ,Assert Israel Sovereignty , 07:18  |  Joseph E . 08/02/07
  19.   Capitulation-Appeasement-Surrender 07:26  |  Ben Israel 08/02/07
  20.   Digging at Temple Mount 07:28  |  Tova 08/02/07
  21.   Assert Jewish Sovereignty on Temple Mount 07:29  |  Joseph E . 08/02/07
  22.   Peretz, Never Mind Shalom Freedman 07:34  |  Dutch 08/02/07
  23.   peretz must go. peretz must go! peretz must go! 07:54  |  ralph 08/02/07
  24.   #22 Daffy Dutch is at it again 08:00  |  * BEN JABO 08/02/07
  25.   Peretz: The Muslims Would Like Israel To Blink First ... 08:17  |  Lavi 08/02/07
  26.   Temple Mount 08:18  |  Esther 08/02/07
  27.   Peretz - appeasement doesn`t work ! 08:35  |  redmike 08/02/07
  28.   Let`s once again back down from the enemy threat and appear weak 08:43  |  BradL 08/02/07
  29.   Dutch, common, should we heed to these bullies? 09:16  |  Shlomo from Tel Aviv 08/02/07
  30.   Jerusalem should unify all religions 09:29  |  Adel 08/02/07
  31.   Mutual hypocrisy 09:29  |  Dani Reiss 08/02/07
  32.   Peretz Is A Dhimmi Or Is That Dummy? 10:00  |  Terry 08/02/07
  33.   Symbol of a catastrophy.. 10:15  |  Vital 08/02/07
  34.   Peretz is still in his Morocco and begs for a right to live 10:15  |  Absolute Sweden 08/02/07
  35.   CLEARLY this work should stop for the moment 10:17  |  Clickfool 08/02/07
  36.   Peretz - Stubborness 1 - 0 10:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  37.   Clickfool 10:33  |  Jerry D 08/02/07
  38.   PLAYING WITH FIRE FROM HELL 10:35  |  indrajaya 08/02/07
  39.   Give it a few days. 10:41  |  sg 08/02/07
  40.   #22 doris AND CYCLOPS PARTNERS IN SPECTACLES 10:58  |  paul harris 08/02/07
  41.   A BUFFOON DOESNT NEED TO PROVE IT BUT 11:00  |  paul harris 08/02/07
  42.   peretz the clown!!!! 11:08  |  Ben Uziel 08/02/07
  43.   PERETZ`S AMBITION 11:11  |  indrajaya 08/02/07
  44.   Another "one of those things". 11:37  |  S 08/02/07
  45.   A Minority Opinion 11:41  |  Avi Yerushalmi 08/02/07
  46.   Arsim & frechet (yet again) 11:54  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  47.   It Gets Worse ! 11:55  |  Klaudia 08/02/07
  48.   Why Dig? 12:08  |  Chris Linthwaite 08/02/07
  49.   #44, S 12:11  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  50.   Indra 12:15  |  Chiang 08/02/07
  51.   #35 Clickfool 12:19  |  Chiang 08/02/07
  52.   To Indrajaya 12:34  |  Klaudia 08/02/07
  53.   Peretz an PM 12:39  |  Ralph 08/02/07
  54.   #46 Hannah 12:43  |  Itsik 08/02/07
  55.   It is a simple question of sovereignty 13:06  |  Boris 08/02/07
  56.   It is a simple question of sovereignty 13:06  |  Boris 08/02/07
  57.   Everything must stop 13:13  |  A christian 08/02/07
  58.   # 49, CHIANG 13:17  |  indrajaya 08/02/07
  59.   # 45 A Correction 13:20  |  Avi Yerushalmi 08/02/07
  60.   # 52, KLAUDIA 13:26  |  indrajaya 08/02/07
  61.   Rebuilding the Temple will make Israel an economic superpower 13:26  |  AV 08/02/07
  62.   TEMPLE mount belongs to ISRAEL and Jews. 13:30  |  Ravi 08/02/07
  63.   #54, Itzik: Talking hubris while cowardly hiding in London 13:42  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  64.   A new bridge inorder to replace a "rickety wooden one..." 13:46  |  sandra chitayat 08/02/07
  65.   # 62 Hindu`s warship idols 13:55  |  Adel 08/02/07
  66.   The mosque has no meaning 13:55  |  JDM 08/02/07
  67.   Israel Beteinu thought of CCTV - Peretz said `stop`. 14:52  |  redmike 08/02/07
  68.   38 Indrajaya PLAYING WITH FIRE FROM HELL 14:58  |  chasaboy 08/02/07
  69.   Sharon`s walk all over again 14:59  |  James Stevens 08/02/07
  70.   #66 If you knew, you should`ve remained silent 14:59  |  Khaled 08/02/07
  71.   hannah you have no credibility 15:07  |  dizzy 08/02/07
  72.   to 63 Are you afraid of Israeli Attack over Iran? 15:07  |  mb 08/02/07
  73.   hannah you owe us an explanation 15:09  |  dizzy 08/02/07
  74.   hannah "please try and limit your discussion to germain 15:10  |  dizzy 08/02/07
  75.   This is just a big distraction from the real problems 15:11  |  albert amato 08/02/07
  76.   Hannah you`re hysterical 15:13  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  77.   The truth is.... 15:16  |  Willy 08/02/07
  78.   hannah it was not an inadvertant mistake 15:22  |  dizzy 08/02/07
  79.   hahahhah 15:23  |  Steven 08/02/07
  80.   khaled if you were truly the owner of knowledge 15:23  |  yirmiyahu 08/02/07
  81.   Boris #55 15:31  |  Avi Yerushalmi 08/02/07
  82.   Islamic Bakhshish 15:34  |  Rustam 08/02/07
  83.   choose your lie and stick to it- or come out with the truth 15:41  |  peacenik 08/02/07
  84.   defence minister peretz has to write letters 15:41  |  yahn goodey 08/02/07
  85.   THIS PROVES 100% THAT INTIFADA#2 HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH SHARON ! 15:43