Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., March 05, 2007 Adar 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:03 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:15 08/02/2007
Bush vs. Olmert
By Aluf Benn

The support of the U.S. administration is a central pillar of Ehud Olmert's government. The Americans are pleased with the prime minister, who makes sure to coordinate everything with them and helps their friends in the region, and they prefer him to Benjamin Netanyahu. That's why it's strange that Bush is preventing Olmert from taking the step that could rescue him from his political decline: a renewal of negotiations with Syria.

The precedents are familiar from the days of Ariel Sharon, who several times faced internal problems and a decline in the polls because of the increase in terror, the diplomatic freeze and the investigations. Each time Sharon was rescued when he adopted steps initiated by his political rivals. In 2002, under pressure from Netanyahu, he sent the Israel Defense Forces to capture the West Bank cities in Operation Defensive Shield. A few months later he began construction of the separation fence, which was initiated by Ehud Barak and his associates Uzi Dayan and Dan Meridor. At the end of 2003, Sharon stole the idea initiated by Amram Mitzna, who had lost to him in the elections, and announced his decision to withdraw from Gush Katif.

What all Sharon's changes in direction had in common was that none of them originated with him. The ideas were familiar; all he had to do was adopt them, while ignoring his previous viewpoints; and then he carried them out with typical persistence. Sharon bequeathed to Olmert the precedent that the prime minister is allowed to disregard the statements he made yesterday if he is convinced that doing so is in "the national interest."

Advertisement

Olmert's situation is more comfortable than Sharon's was. His party, Kadima, has no ideology or principles, only a desire to rule. This approach enabled Olmert to form the most stable coalition we have had here, after many years of crises and ups and downs. He is, however, paying the price in the loss of public support. The public appreciates political stability, but prefers leadership that radiates hope and shows the way.

Olmert gambled on a renewal of the negotiations with Mahmoud Abbas, as overseen by Condoleezza Rice. That looks good abroad and improves Israel's regional and international status. But on the home front, the talks with the Palestinians are of no value. Everyone knows that the meetings with Abbas will not lead anywhere, and the public does not believe in them or take any interest in them. Even if Olmert releases thousands of prisoners, opens dozens of checkpoints and transfers checks to Fatah in dollars, it is doubtful whether his position in the polls would improve even slightly. In the absence of a strong leader on the other side who can guarantee quiet, and a reliable system for intercepting the Qassams, which will protect the greater Tel Aviv area, Jerusalem and Ben-Gurion airport from the Palestinian rockets, Israel will not evacuate the West Bank and will not agree to the establishment of a Palestinian state.

The only thing that can increase support for Olmert is a renewal of the negotiations with Syria. Most of the public is in favor of a positive response to Bashar Assad. Talks with Syria will demonstrate diplomatic progress, even without Israel's evacuation of the Golan; that was the practice of Olmert's predecessors, from Yitzhak Shamir to Barak. More importantly, talks would improve stability in the North and distance the danger of another war this summer, a possibility that is becoming lodged in Israeli awareness as a type of unavoidable disaster.

But Olmert has a problem: Bush is not allowing him to talk to Assad. American officials who are asked about a revival of the Syrian channel respond by reading out the long list of crimes committed by Damascus, including its support for terror from Gaza to Baghdad. If the choice is between pursuing the ideological war against terror and a realistic policy that would preserve Olmert's government, Bush prefers the ideology.

But there may be another explanation, which is more worrisome for Olmert: that the Americans assume he cannot survive, and it's a waste to help a bankrupt enterprise.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Enter little citizen
The politician is under non-stop surveillance, but is it possible to run a country like this?
Heading to the net
The Yedioth Ahronoth group's new Internet brand for classified ads will be win-win.
  1.   It sounds bizarre..... 11:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  2.   Asad JUST yesterday affirmed his committment to Ham-ass and Hizbu 11:19  |  SLAVO 08/02/07
  3.   Angry men and Bloody games 11:43  |  Ibraheem 08/02/07
  4.   U.S, isn`t prohibiting Israel to talk to Syria. 12:03  |  Fortuna 08/02/07
  5.   Olmert and Bush 12:03  |  Dror 08/02/07
  6.   Why we failed in Lebanon 12:08  |  Dror 08/02/07
  7.   # 1 Swiss( Dino) Once again... 12:13  |  Edith 08/02/07
  8.   Exactly who is the dog and who is the tail? 12:39  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  9.   #3, Ibraheem 12:58  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  10.   #4, Edith 13:13  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  11.   Bush vs. Olmert 13:35  |  Marty 08/02/07
  12.   #11, Marty 13:50  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  13.   talking the Middle Eastern Style 14:17  |  Ibraheem 08/02/07
  14.   Ibraheem: Choices and the future 14:25  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/02/07
  15.   Diane Sawyer talked to Bashar Assad 14:28  |  Johnny Weintraub 08/02/07
  16.   Israel shouldn`t talk to SUCH SYRIA, that supports HEZBALLAH-NASR 14:41  |  Vittorio 08/02/07
  17.   The Money Talks 14:59  |  US Citizen 08/02/07
  18.   Where did integrity go? 15:04  |  david 08/02/07
  19.   #16, Vittorio 15:13  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  20.   # 7 Edith (2nd try) 15:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  21.   Syria is Being Squeezed Hard About Iraq 15:17  |  Jane 08/02/07
  22.   #18, David 15:30  |  Hannah 08/02/07
  23.   Very interesting 15:38  |  Maurizio 08/02/07
  24.   A Double Bill 15:46  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/02/07
  25.   Ronnie Wolman, Democracy, changes 15:53  |  Ibraheem 08/02/07
  26.   Bush vs Olmert against Aluf Benn vs Stupidity 15:57  |  Sal 08/02/07
  27.   # 2 It`s Alll About The Left Ear 16:04  |  Tony Anthony 08/02/07
  28.   Ibraheem: The Magic Carpet Trick 16:13  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/02/07
  29.   #21 Impossible for anyone to "control" Iraq-Syria border 16:20  |  Michael Korn 08/02/07
  30.   Swiss ( Dino) 16:24  |  Chaval 08/02/07
  31.   Ibraheem: What I mean by the `bad things` 16:32  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/02/07
  32.   Ibraheem: You might be right. 16:35  |  Michael Korn 08/02/07
  33.   Is the wishes of a warmonger in Israel`s best interest? 16:37  |  Mark Lincoln 08/02/07
  34.   Bush vs. Olmert 16:37  |  Chaval 08/02/07
  35.   # 30 Chaval 16:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  36.   # 27 Tony Anthony 16:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  37.   Bush: The stickman with no carrot 16:56  |  Tosefta 08/02/07
  38.   Mark Lincoln: The Democrats Agenda wont be different 17:03  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/02/07
  39.   Aluf Benn is a writer for the National Enquirer 17:11  |  bimmer 08/02/07
  40.   The Syria/Iraq border 17:41  |  Tosefta 08/02/07
  41.   Is Bush really stopping Olmert? 18:12  |  Tosefta 08/02/07
  42.   # 1 Swiss 18:54  |  Lynn 08/02/07
  43.   # 7 Edith in Belgium 19:01  |  Lynn 08/02/07
  44.   Talk is meaningless, only force and violence matter. 19:20  |  Voice of Reason 08/02/07
  45.   Bush Vs. Olmert 19:32  |  Qassem Lanki 08/02/07
  46.   Tosefta - Birds of a Feather? 20:10  |  Mark Lincoln 08/02/07
  47.   well done to ibraheem and ronnie for having an intelligent ... 20:39  |  Jonathan 08/02/07
  48.   # 42 Lynn 20:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  49.   Real Sovereignty? 21:16  |  ARTH 08/02/07
  50.   #48 Dino 21:43  |  tadchase 08/02/07
  51.   Bush forbids Olmert........ 21:47  |  tadchase 08/02/07
  52.   # 49 tadchase 22:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/02/07
  53.   Bush Vs. Olmert 22:40  |  P. J. Casey 08/02/07
  54.   #50 tadchase 23:53  |  KT 08/02/07
  55.   #50 tadchase (continued) 23:54  |  KT 08/02/07
  56.   Aluf Benn 00:15  |  Ginger Trevor 09/02/07
  57.   That makes 2 Bush supporters, by my count 00:21  |  Pssd Off American 09/02/07
  58.   tosefta the man with no stick 01:13  |  flashman 09/02/07
  59.   Birds of a feather (Mark Lincoln #46) 01:58  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  60.   Return of the shallow water, multi-headed hydra (aka "flushman") 02:03  |  Tosefta 09/02/07
  61.   What a dreadful, nonsensical analysis. 02:12  |  sk 09/02/07
  62.   Bush or Olmert 02:26  |  George from Canada 09/02/07
  63.   Hannah is right 03:24  |  Zeje 09/02/07
  64.   Tosefta - Birds of a Feather? 05:03  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  65.   Tosefta - they tried 05:06  |  Mark Lincoln 09/02/07
  66.   Madness 10:18  |  Deborah 09/02/07
  67.   Coming up - 50 years Independence 10:31  |  JW 09/02/07
  68.   well maybe it`s time then 08:32  |  eric 10/02/07
  69.   Who says so? 14:24  |  Hannah 05/03/07
 Today Online
Abbas: EU is pro-Israel, discriminates against PA
Responses: 95
Sheleg: Existential threats have rekindled classic Zionism
Responses: 28
Only ending the Arab-Israeli conflict will turn PM into a great leader
Responses: 23
Michael Melchior: Arab states slowly coming to terms with Israel
Responses: 40
Ben-Eliezer cancels Egypt visit amid row over '67 war charges
Responses: 34
Poll: Barak would trounce Peretz in Labor leadership race
Responses: 20
Rosner's Domain
* The White House, like the White Paper
* Factor notes: Why Clinton trumps Edwards
* Too many Jewish young adults remain single for too long


More Headlines
14:08 Home Front commander asks court to halt Comptroller's report
14:36 Haniyeh: No unity government deal before end of next week
13:47 Iran intelligence official said missing, may have defected
14:47 Detective charged with doing bidding of Israeli Arab crime family
14:45 Women's average salary in 2005 was less than half of that of men
12:23 Poll: Barak, Ayalon lead Peretz in the Labor leadership primaries
13:42 Police suspect murder-suicide in deaths of Ashdod couple
11:19 Ben-Eliezer cancels Egypt visit amid row over 1967 war charges
10:33 Bereaved parents: Tombstones must read that sons fell in war
14:30 Friedmann bid may sap Supreme Court clout on choosing judges
Previous Editions