Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., February 05, 2007 Shvat 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:26 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The gospel according to Abdullah
By Zvi Bar'el

"The mutual slaughter taking place between Fatah and Hamas does not stem from the clash of these two movements' foreign-policy positions, and it has no connection to the issue of recognizing 'the Zionist enemy,'" wrote Saleh al-Qalab, the former Jordanian minister of information, in an incisive op-ed in the Saudi daily Asharq Al Awsat. In his opinion, the source of the conflict lies in the government of the Palestinian Authority. "Everyone [Fatah, Hamas and others] recognizes Israel as a fait accompli, after all, and no one thinks that Palestine, from the [Jordan] river to the [Mediterranean] sea, is an inviolable Muslim holy site, and everyone shares a single strategic goal of creating a Palestinian state in the territories that were occupied in 1967," Qalab wrote.

The crystal-clear logic of this statement, which reflects the Arab consensus that has existed since at least 2002, is likely to be put to the test this week when Hamas and Fatah leaders, including PA Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas political chief Khaled Meshal and PA Chair Mahmoud Abbas meet in the holy city of Mecca, together with Saudi King Abdullah, in an effort to find a magic formula. After the abortive meeting in Damascus last month, whose only winner was Syrian President Bashar Assad, and the previous meeting in Saudi Arabia, during Id al-Adha, which left even more victims behind, Saudi Arabia decided to step out of the shadows in which its foreign-policy maneuvers have always been cloaked, to try to succeed where Egypt's efforts have failed.

Two main obstacles will once again grace the royal conference table: How to give Fatah honorary ministerial portfolios without challenging the fact that it was Hamas that won the elections; and the need to find a foreign-policy formula that would finally free the territories from the economic sanctions imposed on them.

Advertisement

It would appear that the chances are better this time for ending the ideological disagreement. Saudi Arabia is now willing to recognize what has been obvious all along: There is no diplomatic or political solution without Hamas. In addition, Saudi Arabia, in contrast to Israel, Egypt and Jordan, does not have to constantly check back with Washington to decide on the "correct" policy. And so, just as Washington benefits from the fact that Saudi Arabia is waging an open and finely honed campaign against Iran and against that country's activities in Iraq - so, too, the U.S. and its Quartet colleagues will also have to adopt the "Saudi formula" on the question of Palestine. This formula apparently determines that it is sufficient for Hamas to "respect" the agreements signed between the PA and Israel, rather than being obliged to commit to them. Abbas still opposes this formula, but Egypt and Saudi Arabia are already willing to adopt it.

What is the real meaning of this formula? Legally, it is meaningless, just as all the agreements that were not signed as a binding contract have no legal meaning, such as the crumbling road map. But it could have great political and diplomatic significance. It will join Meshal's statement recognizing Israel as a "fact," the fact that Hamas is observing its tahadiya (cease-fire) with Israel and has been saying for some time that its goal is to establish a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders, and the fact that Hamas is, by implication, presenting its recognition of Israel as a condition for Israel's recognition of it.

Saudi Arabia, in a smart and sober step, is giving Haniyeh and Abbas equal status in the deliberations. From its perspective, the story in which Abbas is the good guy and Haniyeh the bad guy, Fatah the peacemaker and Hamas the warmongering organization, is over. For Saudi Arabia (and other Arab states), both are killing each other in equal measure. Thus, if they reach an agreement, if they accept Abdullah's formula, no one, and that includes Israel and the U.S., will be able to prevent the wholesale Arab recognition of the Palestinian government.

The formula also affects Israel directly. When the government in Israel is incapable of making itself available to address the peace process, then what is left of it, at least, would be well advised to understand that a corner has been turned. One year after the parliamentary elections that put Hamas into power, not only is the organization's failure not guaranteed but just the opposite is the case. The Palestinian prime minister and his master in Syria have become, in the eyes of Arab leaders, a legitimate part of the solution.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
For the green toad
The green toad is undergoing hardship with the elimination of the winter pools it depends on.
Miscommunication
Many SMS messages stem from companies' mistakes, increasing consumers' cost.
  1.   THE OLD GAME IF YOU HAVE APROBLEM 08:47  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  2.   Bar`el rationalizing, as usual 09:02  |  David Teich 04/02/07
  3.   Name on agreement Israel has honoured 09:24  |  Marilyn 04/02/07
  4.   This Guy Is Nuts 09:28  |  Tod Zuckerman 04/02/07
  5.   FORGET IT. 10:38  |  Terry 04/02/07
  6.   JEW HATER Marilyn pretends that she doesn`t know agreements 11:28  |  Vittorio 04/02/07
  7.   Liar Zvi Barel "forgets" to mention Saudi insistence on "right 11:36  |  Absolute Sweden 04/02/07
  8.   Good Luck! 11:59  |  Ben Azai 04/02/07
  9.   #3 MARYLIN FAILS THE JEWISH TEST THAT 30% ARE REALLY NUTS 12:13  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  10.   Saudi Moves 12:42  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/02/07
  11.   Turn the tables for a try. 12:56  |  H.H.M 04/02/07
  12.   saudi does not care about israel 14:01  |  sassoon 04/02/07
  13.   some of them are already planning 14:04  |  sassoon 04/02/07
  14.   Let me remind Vittorio 14:42  |  Klas 04/02/07
  15.   # 3 Marilyn - Israel honours agreements with EU 14:54  |  Paul Henzen 04/02/07
  16.   OLMERT IS A DEFEATIST WHO CAVES INTO BOTH TERRORIST GROUPS 15:46  |  DAN ROSENTHAL 04/02/07
  17.   Mr. Zvi Bar`el`s Gospel 15:48  |  Ricardo Kolbe 04/02/07
  18.   Israeli Delusions About Saudi Arabia 16:16  |  Carlo 04/02/07
  19.   Bar`el is dreaming again far from the ground of Gaza 16:52  |  Shalom Freedman 04/02/07
  20.   Zvi Bar`el gospel 17:08  |  Keith T. 04/02/07
  21.   marilyn 17:23  |  eva 04/02/07
  22.   Ceasefire only for 20 years 18:37  |  A.K. 04/02/07
  23.   Saudi Arabia behind the dark forces 18:43  |  Brod 04/02/07
  24.   #3, off the top of my head... 19:22  |  Danny - Israeli one 04/02/07
  25.   Peace in our times, again 20:11  |  John 04/02/07
  26.   Absolute Sweeden -- there is some wiggle room in the language 20:18  |  bbl 04/02/07
  27.   Marylin what say ye to #6, #9, #15, #21, and #24 20:22  |  bbl 04/02/07
  28.   Comment on #2 20:38  |  stella 04/02/07
  29.   BBl,it`s nonsensense,none of assumptions of arab flexibility 00:16  |  Absolute Sweden 05/02/07
  30.   The Gospel according to Zvi Bar`el 04:52  |  Joseph E . 05/02/07
  31.   King Abdulla... 06:03  |  Giles Martin 05/02/07
  32.   Israel wasn`t told that after the desastrous Oslo marriage 06:59  |  Joseph E . 05/02/07
  33.   Giles: Arguement w/o logic p1 09:20  |  David Teich 05/02/07
  34.   Giles: Arguement w/o logic p2 09:24  |  David Teich 05/02/07
  35.   16: Dan, to bad you have neither a point 09:36  |  David Teich 05/02/07
  36.   #Maryllin 10:55  |  manny.b 05/02/07
  37.   Marily When will you return the land to the aborigines 14:56  |  Joseph 05/02/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Who will bring peace back from the dead?
Responses: 50
Meron Benvenisti: Break Israel's monopoly on J'lem
Responses: 48
Editorial: Recognize the Palestinians' humanitarian needs
Responses: 22
City of David tunnel dig proceeding without proper permit
Responses: 60
Eliahu Salpeter: Who really cares about this Carter guy?
Responses: 24
Olmert rejects Peretz plan to evacuate illegal outposts
Responses: 100


More Headlines
13:44 Police: Six Defense Ministry officials confess to taking bribes
13:57 IDF locates and destroys suspicious device on northern border
13:53 Kadima minister Ezra: Free Barghouti for Abbas' sake
14:40 Abbas aides to meet with Rice in U.S. to discuss Mideast summit
13:33 Man suspected of intentionally running over policeman caught
07:54 PM rejects Peretz plan to evacuate illegal outposts
09:33 Official: Accountant General rigged tender in hiring cronies
10:14 IDF warns against hitchhiking, citing terror kidnapping alerts
14:15 City of David tunnel excavation proceeds without proper permit
07:58 New study: Iran seeks 'nuclear ambiguity,' likely to act 'logically'
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved