Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., February 05, 2007 Shvat 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:32 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
It was not the last kiss
By Gideon Levy

No, it was not the last kiss, despite the new chorus that has arisen to frighten us: The ways of the world have changed. It is the death knell for courtship, the end of kissing. Eitan Haber wrote in Yedioth Ahronoth's editorial: "No one has yet been born who would risk his freedom for a kiss - in its decision, the court will forge a new nature of relationships and will apparently intervene in the work of the Creator." Journalist Meirav Batito-Fried said on television: "The culture of flirting has been outlawed." These two, together with another respected band of fearmongers, men and women alike, employed cheap populist demagoguery to undermine the important ruling in the trial of Haim Ramon.

Israel should take pride in this ruling, even if, as a public figure, Ramon pays a steep personal price for it. Just as the public figures among us enjoy a nearly endless list of extravagant benefits citizens can only dream about - much more so than in many other countries - the price they should pay when they stumble must also be heavy. The sadness many feel in light of Ramon's personal tragedy (but not toward the complainant against him) is understandable and justified, but it must not blur the value of the ruling that convicted him.

The ways of the world that are liable to change, one would hope, as a result of this ruling are those that should have disappeared long ago. Courtship will not end and the kiss will not die. The court acted with noteworthy courage when it ruled contrary to widespread public sentiment and set clear limits that must not be crossed.

Advertisement

The permissive society in which we live will not be hurt at all. We, the men, will be able to continue to court and kiss unabated under the condition that the other party consents to our actions. It is a shame that we needed the court in order to arrive at this situation. There are countries in which a government minister would never dream of kissing a female soldier, but in the wanton atmosphere that prevails here, there is no alternative to mobilizing the justice system, as is the case for other matters.

This ruling will barely affect the average man. Even before the verdict, he knew the limits of the permissible and the forbidden in the relations between the sexes. Whether they are government ministers or simple citizens, there are many men to whom it would never occur to stick their tongue in the mouth of a female soldier when they barely know each other. The unruly men, those who thought until a few days ago that almost anything was permissible for them - to grope, kiss, embrace, rub against, pinch and harass - are the only ones who will be a little more cautious now, and that is a good thing.

But the verdict's main impact will actually be on women. From now on, each Israeli woman will know it is her right to resist and her duty to complain if a man intrudes upon her body, in any way, without her consent. No love will die as a result of this, and no courtship will be harmed. On the contrary.

Perhaps there was no need to put Ramon on trial. He himself could have prevented this outcome if he had acted with wisdom, compassion and integrity immediately after the incident. But since he failed to do so, and the complaint was submitted, the court was obliged to convict him. Not because of Ramon, but because of the ramifications his acquittal would have had on gender relations in Israeli society. By acquitting him, the court would have sent an unequivocal message to society: A woman's body is the property of the man, who is free to decide when to intrude upon it and when not to. If the court had allowed the kiss, women would no longer have been able to complain about similar or more serious cases. True, Ramon's crime is light, and cannot be compared to acts of rape or indecent acts that are much more grievous. But the argument that now there will no longer be any distinction between one act and another, between one little kiss and serial sexual abuse, is ridiculous. The court will know how to distinguish between these acts and will determine the seriousness of punishment accordingly, just as the punishment for a slap is not the same as for a severe beating, even if they are based on the same article of law.

It is difficult to predict how greatly the ruling will influence women's readiness to submit complaints. Hopefully, it will encourage more and more women to defend their dignity and their rights over their bodies. Even if some women may exploit the new situation to submit false complaints, this is still preferable to the status quo ante. It is better to have an excess of complaining women than to have terrified, submissive and humiliated women. Perhaps the pendulum will swing for a moment from one extreme situation to its opposite extreme, but it will quickly reach equilibrium in a place that is immeasurably better than the situation that has existed until now. Secretaries, waitresses, female soldiers and housekeepers, who until now have experienced sexual harassment and indecent acts on a regular basis, who have kept silent and helplessly forgave, will now know that the state will protect them when necessary. Thus, the justice system fulfilled its role in defending the rights of the weak - and of weak women in particular.

Free love will continue to blossom, and women and men will follow their hearts' desires. The "work of the Creator" will not suffer one bit, despite all the angry prophecies. But the court established an important foundation for change: From now on, a woman will also have to express her consent - what a sensational change - before we dispatch our organs toward her body and her dignity.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
For the green toad
The green toad is undergoing hardship with the elimination of the winter pools it depends on.
Miscommunication
Many SMS messages stem from companies' mistakes, increasing consumers' cost.
  1.   Gideon wont write about the Pal children killed this week 08:45  |  Ken Jurist 04/02/07
  2.   Not the last kiss 08:49  |  tbora 04/02/07
  3.   A WASTE OF TIME IN ASERIOUS WORLD 08:55  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  4.   No way! Not true! 09:00  |  S 04/02/07
  5.   Old men and young women 09:10  |  Fritz 04/02/07
  6.   New contract: Signed and witnessed "Consent to Contact" 09:11  |  Lemmings Hotline 04/02/07
  7.   CLOSEDOWN TINSEL TOWN ! ALL IS LOST 09:21  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  8.   Censure? 09:43  |  S 04/02/07
  9.   Exit-Film Noir 10:37  |  FOX 04/02/07
  10.   A form of terror has been dramatically reduced 10:41  |  lisa 04/02/07
  11.   Dirty old men and silly young women 10:57  |  SuzyQ 04/02/07
  12.   Israeli belief: women are saints, men are devils. 11:10  |  Brian 04/02/07
  13.   The Ramon kiss 11:13  |  Big Al 04/02/07
  14.   Need for sexual equality 11:36  |  Ben Azai 04/02/07
  15.   You`re right, Big Al # 13 12:06  |  Clickfool 04/02/07
  16.   Hey! Hang on! Did you say... 12:22  |  D Hirod 04/02/07
  17.   Sharia Levy at it again :"wanton atmosphere prevailing here 12:28  |  Absolute Sweden 04/02/07
  18.   PS: precising 13:50  |  christoph 04/02/07
  19.   Great article, thank you! 14:03  |  A Woman 04/02/07
  20.   What about the right of Palestinian kids to Life? 14:03  |  GF 04/02/07
  21.   Thank you Gideon 14:18  |  A 04/02/07
  22.   Great Article 14:21  |  Ariadne 04/02/07
  23.   & in result we get... 14:29  |  Jack 04/02/07
  24.   last kiss 15:14  |  Ralph 04/02/07
  25.   wow 15:35  |  gabriela 04/02/07
  26.   Compassion and integrety! 15:40  |  Charlie Benlolo 04/02/07
  27.   Great News - But change is slow - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etiquette 16:49  |  Student of Man 04/02/07
  28.   It was an assault 17:06  |  Marilyn 04/02/07
  29.   Hey GF 17:08  |  Marilyn 04/02/07
  30.   #28 MARYLIN AT THE FOREFRONT FOR MUSLIMS WOMEN S FREEDOM 17:28  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  31.   the "kiss" 17:30  |  Rose Johnstone 04/02/07
  32.   #29 MARYLIN IGNORES THE CHILDREN OF AFRICA 17:30  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  33.   Paul are you hard of hearing and blind to boot 17:58  |  Marilyn 04/02/07
  34.   Gideon Levy, the charge.... 20:04  |  dutch 04/02/07
  35.   Well Its Time To Sell... 20:16  |  Yosemite 04/02/07
  36.   A Classic Leftist 20:51  |  Tomy Anthony 04/02/07
  37.   Ramon Conviction is Progress 21:01  |  Ed 04/02/07
  38.   on losing the perks of high office 22:10  |  robin 04/02/07
  39.   #33 MARYLIN SAYS BABIES NEED OXYGEN TUBES 23:31  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  40.   #34 doris you cant be acriminal UNTIL CONVICTED 23:36  |  paul harris 04/02/07
  41.   Is this OUR Gideon Levy? 23:39  |  Yoram 04/02/07
  42.   understanding a publication 23:44  |  Maria 04/02/07
  43.   To Tomy #36 - Open your mind 23:56  |  Rational Discourse 04/02/07
  44.   #32 Hey Paul Harris, speaking of Africans 01:15  |  ballistic 05/02/07
  45.   #38 Well, all rightee!!! 01:16  |  ballistic 05/02/07
  46.   That`s true, but... 01:38  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  47.   re #17 `Sharia Levy at it again...` 01:44  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  48.   Re #29 `Marilyn ignores the children of Africa` 01:47  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  49.   Whom the jewish mother is more pissed off at,Ramon or the soldier 01:47  |  Joseph E . 05/02/07
  50.   re #33 `Paul are you hard of hearing...` 01:56  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  51.   #37 `Ramon conviction is progress` 02:04  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  52.   re #10 `a form of terror has been reduced` 02:23  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  53.   Actually Ballistic 02:36  |  ChanahS 05/02/07
  54.   re #38 `on losing the perks of high office` 03:12  |  Colin Wright 05/02/07
  55.   before the hire a women 03:32  |  dr danielito 05/02/07
  56.   marilyn 03:42  |  Danite 05/02/07
  57.   A victory for Israeli democracy 03:48  |  Brian 05/02/07
  58.   Click, i suspect you envy "these old toads", bec u`re one of them 05:41  |  romeo 05/02/07
  59.   Clickfool Have You Ever Considered This One 08:46  |  Yosemite 05/02/07
  60.   harris 12:29  |  A.M 05/02/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Who will bring peace back from the dead?
Responses: 28
Meron Benvenisti: Break Israel's monopoly on J'lem
Responses: 21
Editorial: Recognize the Palestinians' humanitarian needs
Responses: 7
D. Rubinstein: Only dramatic diplomacy can curb Hamas
Responses: 6
Eliahu Salpeter: Who really cares about this Carter guy?
Responses: 9
Olmert rejects Peretz plan to evacuate illegal outposts
Responses: 72


More Headlines
07:54 PM rejects Peretz plan to evacuate illegal outposts
07:57 Fatah official: Abbas, Meshal to clinch unity gov't deal Tuesday
10:14 IDF warns against hitchhiking, citing terror kidnapping alerts
10:36 City of David tunnel excavation proceeds without proper permit
07:58 New study: Iran seeks 'nuclear ambiguity,' likely to act 'logically'
09:33 Official: Accountant General rigged tender in hiring cronies
11:38 Police urge indictment of Israel Railways head for fatal crash
05:05 Doctor convicted of taking ova without his patients' knowledge
10:49 2 men flee from police after injuring officer in hit-and-run incident
06:54 Sharansky: A Diaspora minister is vital to fight anti-Semitism
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved