Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., May 12, 2007 Iyyar 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
PM Ehud Olmert arriving at the Winograd Committee offices in Tel Aviv on Thursday. (GPO)
Last update - 00:18 02/02/2007
Official: PM delivered 'detailed, focused' testimony to Winograd
By Aluf Benn and Nir Hasson, Haaretz Correspondents

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert on Thursday delivered a "focused and detailed" testimony to the Winograd Committee, which is investigating the conduct of the second Lebanon, an Israeli official said.

"The prime minister did not blame others. His purpose was to explain the various considerations at the most crucial decision-making points during the campaign," the official said without giving further details.

In his testimony before the Winograd Committee, Olmert explained why the decisions he made in the course of the war were correct in light of the information available to him at the time. That was the main message that Olmert tried to get across to the committee members. He sought to describe what he was up against at every stage of the war, what data he was working with, which proposals had been submitted to him and why the decision that was adopted was a reasonable one.

Advertisement

Olmert's testimony went on for six and a half hours, including two half-hour breaks. He appeared before the committee alone, without aides or an attorney. All five members of the panel asked questions, demonstrating great familiarity with the details of the events. The prime minister brought a binder filled with documents, but barely referred to it.

The two main issues under discussion were the decision to go to war in the wake of the kidnapping of two soldiers along the Lebanon border on July 12, and the decision to expand the ground campaign in the last two days of the fighting despite the fact that a draft resolution on a cease-fire was already being discussed in United Nations channels.

According to a highly-placed source in Jerusalem, during his testimony Olmert did not place blame on others and did not criticize his subordinates - cabinet ministers of IDF officers. He stuck to the positions he has presented in the past. The defense strategy employed by Olmert, with the aid of his attorney, Eli Zohar, and his chief of staff, Yoram Turbowicz, focuses on the reasonableness of his decisions, and on accepting responsibility for his own actions.

Olmert was the final witness to appear before the committee before it begins writing its interim report, publication of which is not expected before mid-March.

It is not known whether the committee asked Olmert about his decision to appoint Amir Peretz defense minister.

The Prime Minister's Office refused to comment on Olmert's testimony, but remarks since the war indicate the testimony may have included the following:

* Israel won the war, succeeding in pushing Hezbollah away from Israel's northern border, bringing about the deployment of the Lebanese army and UN peacekeeping forces and destroying Hezbollah's long-range rocket arsenal.

* Israel's decisive response to the abductions was appropriate and was supported by all cabinet ministers, including those with extensive military experience.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
By default
Whatever sins we commit, the reality of our life will mete out the deserved punishment.
Almost famous
Though her parents are actors, opera seemed an unlikely choice for Alma Moshonov.
  1.   Loser has to defend his rear.... 04:40  |  Universal Truth 01/02/07
  2.   Aluf Benn and Amos Harel, as well as Nir Hasson. 04:49  |  Like it is 01/02/07
  3.   Captain Olmert, reporting to accounting, sir! 07:10  |  Hannah 01/02/07
  4.   Olmert, how did Israel win the war? 07:18  |  David G 01/02/07
  5.   We want our soldiers back. 07:24  |  Spoon 01/02/07
  6.   Israel won the war ( LOL ) 07:50  |  massein 01/02/07
  7.   Pigs can fly 08:28  |  Michael 01/02/07
  8.   Israel won the Lebanon war 08:32  |  Ami 01/02/07
  9.   Israel, of course, won the war 08:34  |  Shlomo from Tel Aviv 01/02/07
  10.   Jew`s stupidity 08:45  |  Mark 01/02/07
  11.   Olmert - The Crown Prince of BS 08:56  |  Tod Zuckerman 01/02/07
  12.   on the long term 09:09  |  Abed 01/02/07
  13.   Don`t forget to tell them ur the best PM Israel ever had too! 09:17  |  Guy From NYC 01/02/07
  14.   Olmert sent men to their deaths...That`s MURDER 09:30  |  Dr Dave 01/02/07
  15.   Military experts. 10:11  |  David Nigel Braham 01/02/07
  16.   Doesn`t look like a comedian, does he? 10:19  |  JW 01/02/07
  17.   State of denial 10:44  |  Al 01/02/07
  18.   V-Day 11:02  |  Cpt. Yossarian 01/02/07
  19.   re: Shlomo #9 11:05  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  20.   SOORY PAULO.The Arabs did not manage to kill enough Israelis 11:26  |  PETER SM 01/02/07
  21.   quite right 11:29  |  flashman 01/02/07
  22.   and senoira`s words to la republica the italian newspaper 11:31  |  flashman 01/02/07
  23.   PMSL, is this guy a joke ? 11:31  |  VIPER 01/02/07
  24.   hizballah on august 3rd 2006 11:32  |  flashman 01/02/07
  25.   13000 thousand infidels now in the territory of the army of Allah 11:33  |  PETER SM 01/02/07
  26.   the suburb of dahiya beirut hizb headquarters 11:34  |  flashman 01/02/07
  27.   We WON! 11:41  |  ron 01/02/07
  28.   LIKE BUSH WON WAR IN IRAQ 11:45  |  SCOT 01/02/07
  29.   Olmert is a failure........... 11:47  |  Avraham 01/02/07
  30.   # 14 11:54  |  Avraham 01/02/07
  31.   israel id not do as well as we should have but there had 12:13  |  flashman 01/02/07
  32.   The relevent debate 12:14  |  Najdt 01/02/07
  33.   we had massive fire power 12:15  |  flashman 01/02/07
  34.   compare the american treatment of the city of faluja 12:16  |  flashman 01/02/07
  35.   Just a Question to... 12:18  |  Lebanese Communist 01/02/07
  36.   That`s winning the war, Olmert? 12:21  |  Tzfonit 01/02/07
  37.   Paulo.... 12:31  |  Mimi 01/02/07
  38.   hizballah won like nasser won in 1967 12:36  |  flashman 01/02/07
  39.   battle of karameh 1968 12:39  |  flashman 01/02/07
  40.   lebanese communist i love (truly) your sober 12:49  |  flashman 01/02/07
  41.   About the INFIDELS ! 12:56  |  Mimi 01/02/07
  42.   We won!?!? 13:00  |  Avram 01/02/07
  43.   Paulo makes valid point 13:07  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 01/02/07
  44.   Olmert and Bush, what fond war memories they have... 13:10  |  Maureen Ann 01/02/07
  45.   A 30 DAY SKIRMISH IS NOT A WAR.!!! 13:13  |  paul harris 01/02/07
  46.   To Lebanese Communist 13:14  |  Tzfonit 01/02/07
  47.   #28 IN REVERSE SCOT DID HE LOSE ??? 13:15  |  paul harris 01/02/07
  48.   In the memory of the dead footsoldiers. 13:25  |  PETER SM 01/02/07
  49.   19 to Salazar 13:39  |  mb 01/02/07
  50.   MAUREEN ANN.Using "dogs" interesting.Dogs and infidels 13:53  |  PETER SM 01/02/07
  51.   Olmert is just trying to safe face. So what ?? 13:54  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/02/07
  52.   # 4 David G 13:57  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/02/07
  53.   IN OLMERT`S DREAM 14:07  |  indrajaya 01/02/07
  54.   One Question For Olmert ! 14:14  |  nathan 01/02/07
  55.   portuguese seletive memory - 19 14:27  |  mb 01/02/07
  56.   re: Peter SM #20 14:34  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  57.   Message for Olmert 14:35  |  Clickfool 01/02/07
  58.   re: Mimi #37 14:36  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  59.   Winners,Losers and Reality 14:38  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/02/07
  60.   I agree with Peter SM # 48 14:42  |  Clickfool 01/02/07
  61.   re: Shlomo #43 14:43  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  62.   Sickening,sickening, sickening 14:50  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/02/07
  63.   Paulo.. 14:53  |  Mimi 01/02/07
  64.   indrajaya your arshe? 14:56  |  tommy suharto 01/02/07
  65.   PAULO. 14:56  |  PETER SM 01/02/07
  66.   re: Mb #49 14:57  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  67.   MESSAGE for FOOL.The Pals do not listen to your advice 14:59  |  PETER SM 01/02/07
  68.   clickfool to olmert 15:01  |  flashman 01/02/07
  69.   #55 - to you mb 15:01  |  Mimi 01/02/07
  70.   If Hizbullah won the war then why he can`t win on Siniora? 15:05  |  Tamir 01/02/07
  71.   We did WHAT??? 15:16  |  M.Singer 01/02/07
  72.   TO LEBANESE communist , Clickfool, Indaraja, Paul Harris. 15:23  |  Gabriel 01/02/07
  73.   56 and 55 - corr.naval base name is in Açores 15:31  |  mb 01/02/07
  74.   # 69,TAMIR 15:38  |  indrajaya 01/02/07
  75.   # 72, GABRIEL 15:43  |  indrajaya 01/02/07
  76.   re: Peter SM #65 15:52  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  77.   to mimi 65 - know very much about portugal, every jew know! 15:55  |  mb 01/02/07
  78.   indrajaya, I have a nice logic for you 16:00  |  Tamir 01/02/07
  79.   re: Mb #55 16:01  |  Paulo 01/02/07
  80.   true media conspiracies 16:02  |  danny 01/02/07
  81.   Contradictions, contradictions and more contradictions... 16:03  |  bat yam 01/02/07
  82.   to mimi -65 16:04  |  mb 01/02/07
  83.   Flashman 16:05  |  Lebanese Communist 01/02/07
  84.   # 78, TAMIR 16:09  |  indrajaya 01/02/07
  85.   # 77 - Is that all you know about Portugal MB? 16:11  |  Mimi