Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., February 03, 2007 Shvat 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:21 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Yes, I've gone nuts
By Israel Harel

This week, a resident of Kochav Yaakov made racist comments to a security official. I was asked to respond to the incident right after it was reported on the radio. Agitated acquaintances, who say "we respect you even though we don't agree with your political opinions," also turned to me. It's terrible, they said; you have to condemn it. Silence is also a statement. You weren't heard responding to the female settler's curses in Hebron either. Have you gone nuts, too?

On Tuesday, in the studio of the Politika television show, they whispered to me: "Slip something in about that racist." (The show's discussion was on a bill that would prevent the Supreme Court from overturning Knesset laws.) Then, too, I didn't agree to discuss it.

The cursing woman and the racist man do, of course, anger me no less than they anger those who spoke to me about it. But something in my sense of justice - yes, justice - revolts against the prominence given to two negative and regretful, yet unfortunately routine and commonplace, incidents, just because they took place in Hebron and Kochav Yaakov.

Advertisement

The incidents took on the dimensions of a national rift, and those responsible were regarded as damaging the foundation of Jewish and Israeli ethics. All the women of the settlements seemed to become the cursing woman from Hebron. Otherwise, what public interest - as indicated by the incident's place as the leading news story on several television broadcasts - was there in the cursing, which is a routine matter among many other people in many other places?

The fact that the media came out against these two people specifically - and is not demanding similar treatment in hundreds and thousands of similar or worse instances that take place all the time - is a vicious phenomenon. That's why I refused to take part in this distorted attack.

No one is asking others to denounce people from their "camp" who carry out acts of murder, rape, or sexual or physical assault; who traffic in drugs or women; or who are involved in disputes with their neighbors that end in violence, not just curses. It is only with the settlers that the entire camp - more than a quarter of a million people - is responsible for the actions of all its individuals.

This week, for instance, three youths from the center of the country cruelly abused an elderly woman for three hours. They then robbed her and stole her jewelry. Of course, no one is considered an authority figure in the "social and ideological environment" of these sadists, who have since been caught. Although others have thus explained that I have a responsibility and obligation to apologize and acknowledge a moral deterioration among the settlers, and of course to condemn it, no one is regarded as having such authority over these youths. Only the cursing woman from Hebron, the racist from Kochav Yaakov and the children who throw stones at Arabs have a clear and defined geographic, religious, social, political and leadership "address."

A year has passed since the traumatic events at Amona. The day of the evacuation, I was at Jerusalem's Hadassah University Hospital, Ein Karem. The radio stations incessantly reported the harsh violence of the settlers, who seriously wounded dozens of police officers, some of whom were taken by helicopter to Hadassah Ein Karem. The message was clear: The settlers are acting violently toward the police officers. After all, only the seriously wounded are taken to hospital by helicopter. Upon hearing the news, I left the patient I was visiting and rushed to the emergency room. All the wounded who had arrived there, some of whom I knew, were good kids from Ofra and other communities. I didn't find any police officers there. I moved on to the trauma ward, thinking that maybe they were there, but found not a single police officer. Perhaps in intensive care? Only a youth with a smashed cranium was lying there.

That time, I initiated the call to the media. Although Army Radio was able to identify me, they refused to accept the information. We'll check and get back to you, they said. When they didn't get back to me, I contacted them again, saying: "You're broadcasting mistaken information. Please fix it." To no avail. The same thing happened with Israel Radio's Reshet Bet. As for the television stations, whose presenters read from texts describing police officers whose skulls had been shattered, even as the images showed mounted police cruelly using batons on young men and women, I gave up from the outset.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Lost in translation
For Anglo readers hungry for modern Hebrew literature, here is a literary feast.
Detective Holmes
The mystery of Sherlock Holmes isn't resolved in Michael Handelzalts's new book.
  1.   It Isn`t About Race: It`s About Arab Murderers 10:12  |  Yishai Kohen 01/02/07
  2.   settlers .... 10:26  |  Yana 01/02/07
  3.   can you domesticate A WOLF ? 10:31  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 01/02/07
  4.   it is not the sound 10:39  |  cool 01/02/07
  5.   Have you Ever Been to Hebron?? 11:04  |  Obviously Not !! 01/02/07
  6.   Militant Settlers . . . . 11:22  |  revoltop 01/02/07
  7.   Yishai the raving lunatic at it again 11:25  |  Marilyn 01/02/07
  8.   Should all Arabs in Hebron be tarred also 11:28  |  ash 01/02/07
  9.   double standard 11:29  |  mark 01/02/07
  10.   IT`S IMPOSSIBLE TO CATCH ALL THE 11:32  |  Robert 01/02/07
  11.   Don`t Blame The Settlers... 11:40  |  anat 01/02/07
  12.   israel harel you are quite right 11:42  |  flashman 01/02/07
  13.   Marilyn Clearly Can`t Read English: Madrassa "Education" Lacking 12:00  |  Yishai Kohen 01/02/07
  14.   281 million has to leave USA NOW! 12:07  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  15.   Question for Ash, the Settler! 12:09  |  fulusteen 01/02/07
  16.   Marilyn 12:10  |  Baruch 01/02/07
  17.   You`re right...all of Israel should be held to account 12:32  |  peacelover 01/02/07
  18.   # The author: Nuts? Perhaps not. Intelligent? Even less so. 12:33  |  zmogus 01/02/07
  19.   come on mr harel, u can do better 12:44  |  cristina 01/02/07
  20.   Pali land 12:47  |  Dror 01/02/07
  21.   Racist settler vs average criminal - big difference 12:58  |  Tom Spender 01/02/07
  22.   The history as I see it 13:06  |  Ilan 01/02/07
  23.   #7 Marilyn 13:11  |  Avi 01/02/07
  24.   #2 Yana 13:17  |  Avi 01/02/07
  25.   Sorry harel - all settlers are racists because the enterprise is 13:18  |  dana 01/02/07
  26.   #14 Mozart 13:24  |  Avi 01/02/07
  27.   Dana 13:32  |  rich 01/02/07
  28.   #19 cristina 13:43  |  Avi 01/02/07
  29.   about racists 13:50  |  clod 01/02/07
  30.   #26 AVI: Yes. Do you act accordingly? 13:53  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  31.   #12, flashman. Here`s the answer to your rethorical question 14:21  |  zmogus 01/02/07
  32.   @27 To Rich, a landthief 14:27  |  Jeroen 01/02/07
  33.   I am talking about this month not the 15th bloody century 14:31  |  Marilyn 01/02/07
  34.   Why hating settlers is fashionable 14:35  |  Shlomo 01/02/07
  35.   1 person`s racism??? 14:47  |  sd 01/02/07
  36.   ONE RACIST HELPING OTHER RACIST 14:52  |  indrajaya 01/02/07
  37.   Fulusteen 14:52  |  Shlomo 01/02/07
  38.   The Cat Fight .... Racist Propaganda for the Left 14:58  |  Klaudia 01/02/07
  39.   Nothing but Justification for Racism 15:04  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/02/07
  40.   Harel enages in the same equivalency game 15:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/02/07
  41.   they are all racists 15:12  |  michael 01/02/07
  42.   Marilyn # 33- 400 Jews in Hebron and 15,000 Soldiers 15:13  |  Klaudia 01/02/07
  43.   But it`s obvious, that Hebron is not a usual settlement 15:16  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 01/02/07
  44.   zmogus i agree with you.no question 15:16  |  flashman 01/02/07
  45.   Klaudia on the "poor Jews" #39 15:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/02/07
  46.   #42 15:38  |  loulou 01/02/07
  47.   The Palestinians and the settlers have one thing in common.... 15:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/02/07
  48.   The settlers 15:44  |  G. Ron 01/02/07
  49.   You got some point, but... 15:45  |  Simone 01/02/07
  50.   Shlomo - Land is neither Arab, or Jewish... 15:46  |  Fulusteen 01/02/07
  51.   LEFTISTS GETTING WEAK!!! 15:48  |  Anna Green 01/02/07
  52.   Settlers 15:48  |  G.RON 01/02/07
  53.   # 39 Klaudia: Protect & Occupy 15:49  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  54.   Wake up! To the "Palestinians" We`re all "settlers" 15:49  |  Ken 01/02/07
  55.   Captured? Videotaped? Oh well, let`s turn it into advantage then. 15:51  |  zmogus 01/02/07
  56.   Help protect Kosova! 15:57  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  57.   But ALL settlers are racist 16:06  |  Stephen Murray 01/02/07
  58.   Swiss(Dino) 16:14  |  ODP 01/02/07
  59.   col hakovod. Hoped someone would get up and say this. 16:19  |  bat yam 01/02/07
  60.   Israel Harel vs The Smear Campaign Against the Settlers 16:22  |  Klaudia 01/02/07
  61.   Mozart and the Serbs and Kosovars #56 16:25  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/02/07
  62.   # 53- Mozart 16:33  |  Klaudia 01/02/07
  63.   This story is a bit disingenuous. Everyone knows the difference 16:36  |  Apartheid 01/02/07
  64.   The suffering of the colour orange or a little completion to # 47 16:39  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/02/07
  65.   indrajaya when you hurry to deny you are javanese 16:43  |  tommy suharto 01/02/07
  66.   Eventually, Moslems will make their inevitable final push to... 16:44  |  curious 01/02/07
  67.   #62 Klaudia from Canada 16:46  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  68.   But she`s not just one isolated racist in Hebron is she? 16:47  |  Rebekah S 01/02/07
  69.   # 58 ODP 16:49  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/02/07
  70.   One Isolated Racist II 16:49  |  Rebekah S 01/02/07
  71.   One Isolated Racist III and final 16:50  |  Rebekah S 01/02/07
  72.   curious, I dont know about that but... #66 16:58  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/02/07
  73.   One is not one 17:02  |  Hanoman 01/02/07
  74.   # 67- Mozart 17:11  |  Klaudia 01/02/07
  75.   Perspective 17:20  |  Noek Keijzer 01/02/07
  76.   All of the above and "not just curses" 17:23  |  Simon 01/02/07
  77.   # 14 Mozart 17:49  |  Lynn 01/02/07
  78.   How to change the colonists mentality 17:54  |  the cohen brother 01/02/07
  79.   Agreed, not responsible for actions of one woman 18:09  |  John 01/02/07
  80.   To Noek Keijzer 18:12  |  ailton 01/02/07
  81.   stephen murray, have you ever been to israel? 18:12  |  SHIMON 01/02/07
  82.   City Slickers and Their Country Cousins 18:20  |  Klaudia 01/02/07
  83.   Swiss ( Dino) and Yaakov Sullivan 18:24  |  Chaval 01/02/07
  84.   What Utter Nonsense, Harel 18:28  |  Victor Smolinsky 01/02/07
  85.   Swiss(Dino) 18:49  |  ODP 01/02/07
  86.   21- Come and Meet the Citizens of Hebron 18:53  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/02/07
  87.   TO #80 Yes and No 19:00  |  Noek Keijzer 01/02/07
  88.   The problem is not whether it is a stand-alone 19:06  |  Noek Keijzer 01/02/07
  89.   Jeroen 19:13  |  rich 01/02/07
  90.   Cohen Brothers 19:14  |  rich 01/02/07
  91.   Repeal of Zionism = Racism; Remember? 19:15  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/02/07
  92.   Yaakov, Swiss and Victor Smolinsky 19:17  |  Chaval 01/02/07
  93.   Mozart #14 19:20  |  rak 01/02/07
  94.   Israel`s Enemies Want to Replace Israel with a Muslim Country 19:25  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/02/07
  95.   Avi 19:26  |  rak 01/02/07
  96.   Great article, Israel Harel 19:31  |  Polybios 01/02/07
  97.   50 - History Lesson 19:37  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/02/07
  98.   Are the Settlers ever held accountable? 19:38  |  Mark Lincoln 01/02/07
  99.   Islamic Fundmentalists War Against the Jews 19:46  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/02/07
  100.   Overgeneralizing again, Stephen Murray #57 19:48  |  Polybios 01/02/07
  101.   98 - Do you mean that Jews have no rights? 19:54  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/02/07
  102.   the most condemning part of the video 20:15  |  eric 01/02/07
  103.   Obviously not is obviously confused 20:25  |  bbl 01/02/07
  104.   #13 Yishai 20:43  |  Janice 01/02/07
  105.   Obviously not 20:46  |  Jasmine Murphy 01/02/07
  106.   Marilyn 20:47  |  Jasmine Murphy 01/02/07
  107.   How you change your tune , Fulusteen 21:09  |  Shlomo 01/02/07
  108.   Problem Is... 21:29  |  Yosemite 01/02/07
  109.   Israels social problems 21:29  |  Danite 01/02/07
  110.   Harel`s Indignation 21:30  |  dana 01/02/07
  111.   #74 Klaudia 21:31  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  112.   Chaval #92 21:31  |  Victor Smolinsky 01/02/07
  113.   mark Lincoln#98 21:36  |  Danite 01/02/07
  114.   Only ONE racist settler in Israel??? 21:43  |  margaret 01/02/07
  115.   #77 Lynn: recognize birth rights! 21:49  |  Mozart 01/02/07
  116.   #7 Maryln and #1 yishai 22:00  |  Labhras 01/02/07
  117.   victor smolinski and his frothing at israel 22:17  |  flashman 01/02/07
  118.   #106 Jasmine Murphy Maryln 22:21  |  Labhras 01/02/07
  119.   misuse of police force 22:56  |  Pssd Off American 01/02/07
  120.   11/12 judges violated Human rights in G.Katif ,Media? 22:56  |  sam 01/02/07
  121.   Jews are not supposed to have emotions 23:25  |  Schtarker Yid 01/02/07
  122.   Settlers = cancer 23:43  |  MPH 01/02/07
  123.   Hebron Settlers Must Be Removed 23:44  |  Schlomo Joe 01/02/07
  124.   #109 Schtarker yid 00:52  |  Lanhras 02/02/07
  125.   #34 Shlomo 00:52  |  KT 02/02/07
  126.   revoltop settlers - They`re Returnee`s 01:05  |  * BEN JABO 02/02/07
  127.   #14 Mozart - You`re quite correct. 01:13  |  * BEN JABO 02/02/07
  128.   Klaudia 01:15  |  Danite 02/02/07
  129.   Klaudia 01:15  |  Danite 02/02/07
  130.   Israel Harel-"Nuts." 01:15  |  Ed 02/02/07
  131.   Stop demonizing "THEM" 01:50  |  nunie 02/02/07
  132.   #98 Lincoln - why should they be held 02:49  |  * BEN JABO 02/02/07
  133.   #111 SCHLOMO JOE 03:04  |  Muhammud al-Swain 02/02/07
  134.   you have got to be kidding 03:11  |  H 02/02/07
  135.   Cogent Argument 03:13  |  Lazer Danzinger 02/02/07
  136.   B Sarah 03:18  |  John 02/02/07
  137.   Schlomo Joe 03:47  |  George Kaplan 02/02/07
  138.   eric 05:05  |  bev 02/02/07
  139.   To Avi 06:17  |  Dee Dubb 02/02/07
  140.   To Danite 06:48  |  Klaudia 02/02/07
  141.   # 118--- bev 06:49  |  eric 02/02/07
  142.   Settlers are a shame 07:34  |  Jews for peace 02/02/07
  143.   # 120 interesting thought ben j 08:08  |  eric 02/02/07
  144.   111, 121 Palestinian Double Standard: No Right of Return for Jews 08:53  |  Logician 02/02/07
  145.   Putting the blinders on. 09:11  |  Colin Wright 02/02/07
  146.   #134, Logician. How about "Sitting Bison" or "X-man"? 11:41  |  zmogus 02/02/07
  147.   #142 TV - Define pre-1967 border 05:16  |  * BEN JABO 03/02/07
  148.   #142 TV - Define pre-1967 border 05:16  |  * BEN JABO 03/02/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: I'm outing myself as a Zionist
Responses: 251
Rosner: Are Arab leaders using Mideast conflict as an excuse?
Responses: 110
Abbas, Meshal agree to truce as 25 die in clashes
Responses: 247
Shlomo Ben-Ami: No choice but int'l solution to Mideast conflict
Responses: 92
Joschka Fischer: Iran approach must focus on diplomacy
Responses: 56
Ze'ev Schiff: What Israel lacks is a grand strategy
Responses: 68


More Headlines
04:07 Abbas, Meshal agree to truce as 25 die in clashes
03:41 Rice: Peace efforts must go on despite Palestinian infighting
05:02 Sen. Clinton: We must not permit Iran to acquire nuclear weapons
04:55 In Sderot, N.Y. Mayor expresses solidarity with town's residents
18:31 IDF soldiers wound Palestinian near checkpoint in West Bank
20:56 Prime Minister's Office closing Diaspora Affairs department
19:12 Italian general formally takes command of UN force in Lebanon
05:01 Police arrest man, 51, suspected of raping his nieces for two years
18:33 PMO: Peretz has no authority to choose missile defense system
05:01 Halutz barred dissent by IDF top brass in front of cabinet during war
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved