Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., February 04, 2007 Shvat 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:08 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Getting killed for an illusion
By Amira Hass

For years Gaza has been identified with rifles held aloft, with mothers expressing joy at the fact that their sons have committed suicide in an attack against Israelis, and with pleading looks by people who have nothing to eat at home. Not only Israelis see these television scenes as representing reality in its entirety, so do those Palestinians living in the West Bank who have never entered Gaza - certainly not during the past 16 years, since Israel began to prevent free entry and exit from this impoverished and crowded strip of land.

Only a prolonged stay among the residents of Gaza can add other nuances to the televised version. The jokes and the rumors, the talent for self-mockery, the power of endurance that alternates with fatalism, the frankness, the generosity, the ability to be both emotional and tough at once, the common sense acquired over 60 years of exile and loss, the shouting and the silence, the pain over the fact that education was once the highest priority. These are only some of the character traits that endear the residents of Gaza to those who know them well.

And these are the nuances that have been erased in recent weeks, as Gaza has come to be identified first and foremost with lethal internecine battles between armed men from two hostile political movements, with mutual killing that everyone says is insane but which they are unable to stop.

Advertisement

To the point that two days ago, after the terror attack in Eilat, residents of Gaza were hoping that the Israel Defense Forces would invade the Strip and detain some of the armed men and chase others out of the streets. The clear signals that the IDF does not intend to do so are additional proof for them that Israel wants this internal war to continue.

Despite the new cease-firesigned early yesterday morning, there is a fear in Gaza that many families are still seeking revenge for their children's blood, and will act at some point. The fear hints at another certainty: the fact that there is no chance that there will be a political, national leadership that will be able to restrain dangerous hamula (extended family) traditions in the foreseeable future.

Fatah is interested in emphasizing the danger of a civil war in order to undermine the legitimacy of the Hamas government. However, there are some who express hope that in spite of everything, the war of the security organizations will not deteriorate into an overall civil war. In one typical Gaza home, we were told, one brother is the driver of a senior member of the Fatah security organizations, and another brother is the driver of a senior Hamas minister. Members of Hamas and Fatah, who have been friends since their school days, sit together in the evening and openly discuss the seriousness of the situation.

All this is in contrast to the 1980s. Back then, when members of the Islamic movement (the Muslim Brotherhood) confronted leftist and Fatah activists, they would not speak to one another, but felt and behaved like two mutually antagonistic nations. Today the lethal hostility is limited to the armed men on both sides. Those who are unarmed continue to support their own political streams and to justify the behavior of the different security organs, but not at the price of personal quarrels. They are all afraid of being caught in an exchange of fire, of being hit by a bullet or an RPG bomb.

The Palestinians are right in placing the overall blame for the present situation on the occupation: It is the occupation that determines the framework of an economic siege (which also existed before the intifada and before the establishment of the Hamas government), it is the occupation that has imprisoned the residents of Gaza in a huge holding pen since 1991, without any opportunities and without hope for improvement. The imprisonment is the cause of the widespread ignorance. The severance from the rest of the world only reinforces the loyalty to hamulas, including such acts as blood revenge, because in the absence of political and economic hope, the only source of support for the individual is once again the hamula.

But those Palestinians who are tired of hearing that the occupation is to blame are also right. A war of the security organs and a civil war are also the product of decisions and instructions by those who see themselves as leaders, and must therefore be aware of the results of their acts.

There is no point in asking "Who started?" (Fatah started with the armed provocations). In any case, the lethal confrontation stems from two ills both rivals share.

One is the cult of armed men and weapons, which has spread in Palestinian society and has silenced any attempt to discuss the huge damage the use of weapons has caused the struggle against the Israeli occupation. The other is the illusion that the Oslo process (or "democratic" elections in the shadow of the occupation) can enable a Palestinian party to govern, and that a Palestinian party is able to form a respectable government as is the case in an independent state.

The armed security organs of Fatah and Hamas were sent to fight, to kill and to endanger the welfare of the entire public in order to uphold the illusion of self-government under a foreign occupier, disguised as a concerned neighbor.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Bursting into song
New books show the place Hebrew songs held in the development of Israeli culture.
Burnt offerings
Israel has offered the Greek patriarch transfer of Church property for recognition.
  1.   How predictable! 09:48  |  Hastaroth 31/01/07
  2.   Occupation is to blame, but not the only thing 09:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 31/01/07
  3.   Some other character traits of Pals 09:59  |  marcus aurelius 31/01/07
  4.   Amira Haas silence,2 innocent children killed by Hamas & Fatah 10:09  |  GF 31/01/07
  5.   Amira`s Eyes are Dry and Her Heart is Hardened 10:10  |  Klaudia 31/01/07
  6.   Yawn.... 10:12  |  Rufus 31/01/07
  7.   Amira,Blame the Palestinian Authority militias, not Israel 10:19  |  GF 31/01/07
  8.   Ahh hass did you miss something 10:20  |  Adrian de Klerk 31/01/07
  9.   unrwa is to blame for the culture of dependency 10:26  |  flashman 31/01/07
  10.   did you miss something hass 10:26  |  Adrian de Klerk 31/01/07
  11.   isnt amira haas ridiculous 10:37  |  flashman 31/01/07
  12.   Not so bad Amira 10:38  |  Gina 31/01/07
  13.   "hamas and fatah kill each during the day" 10:39  |  flashman 31/01/07
  14.   Amira Hass (hatred in German) twisting as usual 10:44  |  Allon 31/01/07
  15.   "the palestinians are right to blame the overall 10:45  |  flashman 31/01/07
  16.   Has Hass hassled the right people? 10:47  |  Star of David 31/01/07
  17.   WHERE DO WE START AMIRA CRUSADES 10:59  |  paul harris 31/01/07
  18.   Where were Ms. Hass and Co. during the 10:59  |  Geula Hovav 31/01/07
  19.   Amira : wrong analysis, as usual 11:01  |  Arima 31/01/07
  20.   Arabs blame Israel for not retaking Gaza.Conspiracy gone beserk 11:02  |  PETER SM 31/01/07
  21.   Amira Just Doenst Get It 11:09  |  True Say 31/01/07
  22.   Lots that could be done. 11:11  |  Ibraheem 31/01/07
  23.   #2 THE PUNDIT DINO WINDS UP THE CUCKOO CLOCK AGAIN 11:15  |  paul harris 31/01/07
  24.   Admiration for Amira Hass 11:19  |  Paul 31/01/07
  25.   Hass` paid rubbish 11:23  |  Alan Lockyer 31/01/07
  26.   What about publishing the names from the 2 assasinated children? 11:24  |  GF 31/01/07
  27.   Fights in Genocide Format 11:26  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 31/01/07
  28.   Marcus Aurelius 11:27  |  S 31/01/07
  29.   #18 Khovav is right 11:29  |  Alan Lockyer 31/01/07
  30.   Amira`s attitude problem 11:29  |  Dani Reiss 31/01/07
  31.   To paul harris: Hear, hear!! 11:31  |  Amelia Andover 31/01/07
  32.   Correct Geula, why didn`t Jordan give the pals a state 11:40  |  Judith in Haifa 31/01/07
  33.   Only Solution for Gazans is to Spread To Sinai 11:43  |  Ben Israel 31/01/07
  34.   Hass sympathy is with the suicide- bomber people 11:46  |  Shalom Freedman 31/01/07
  35.   Getting killed for an illusion 12:15  |  Mitch Cohen 31/01/07
  36.   # 23 paul harris 12:16  |  Swiss (Dino) 31/01/07
  37.   Amira Hass is out of control 12:16  |  Jonathan S 31/01/07
  38.   To Shalom Freedman... I`ll Answer Your Question 12:24  |  Klaudia 31/01/07
  39.   Amira Hass, a Great People! 12:38  |  Arik 31/01/07
  40.   #36 THEY HAVE HAARETZ ??????????????? 12:44  |  paul harris 31/01/07
  41.   Who`s idea was it, suicide bombing? 12:51  |  Virginia 31/01/07
  42.   #22 Well said 12:56  |  Hastaroth 31/01/07
  43.   Seeing through the other`s eyes. 12:56  |  Virginia 31/01/07
  44.   Gaza is part of Egypt 13:01  |  Herbert Kaine 31/01/07
  45.   RE: Ibraheem - dialog 13:02  |  Nahum 31/01/07
  46.   Judaism and humanism 13:08  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 31/01/07
  47.   To Klaudia 13:29  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 31/01/07
  48.   Appropriate 13:32  |  Choni Davidowitz 31/01/07
  49.   NOT-Violence is the result of the condition of the heart. 13:33  |  Common Sense 31/01/07
  50.   Haas is a pathological liar 13:44  |  naro 31/01/07
  51.   Klaudia #4 - we would take your concern more seriously if 13:45  |  dana 31/01/07
  52.   Hass hides the truth: Is Israel responsible for violence in Irak? 13:46  |  Andre 31/01/07
  53.   Ibraheem from Beirut. Thank you!!! 13:51  |  Geula Hovav 31/01/07
  54.   To Nahum #45 13:54  |  Shalom-Salaam 31/01/07
  55.   Obnoxious. Deluded reasoning 14:07  |  Oren 31/01/07
  56.   getting killed 14:09  |  Mikki 31/01/07
  57.   For #46 Cord H. Kaldrack 14:14  |  Star of David 31/01/07
  58.   AMIRA HASS: THE BEST SUPPORT FOR ISRAELI OCCUPATION 14:16  |  MOSHE 31/01/07
  59.   Amira Hass do you realize you are demented? 14:16  |  Steven 31/01/07
  60.   # 51- Dana....Liar, Liar ...Lefty Liar! 14:23  |  Klaudia 31/01/07
  61.   All the more reason to stay out of Gaza 14:24  |  Tzfonit 31/01/07
  62.   Amira,its time you asked for responsibility 14:25  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/01/07
  63.   Amira,its time you asked for responsibility 14:26  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/01/07
  64.   Dana dicing with the truth 14:31  |  Dina Farhi 31/01/07
  65.   to Mrs Amira Hass...Illusions?...no, only hatred and fear..a pity 15:02  |  UGY the she camel 31/01/07
  66.   Nothing as warped as Hass 15:04  |  Mike 31/01/07
  67.   Amirah-When Your So Predictable Its Clear TO Ignore You 15:13  |  Me 31/01/07
  68.   Atilla Karagozoglu: TV 15:13  |  CHGODMK 31/01/07
  69.   Nahum: Shalom-Salaam 15:16  |  Jew 31/01/07
  70.   when will Israel ever learn 15:17  |  margaret 31/01/07
  71.   Mike 66 Hass is not Jewish. Hass = Erev rov 15:23  |  Steven 31/01/07
  72.   AMIRA`S DANGEROUS ILLUSIONS 15:39  |  Wendy 31/01/07
  73.   Stephen Murray: Where Are You? 15:44  |  CHGODMK 31/01/07
  74.   "over 60 years of exile and loss" 15:44  |  Zev 31/01/07
  75.   peter sm totally agree 15:49  |  bev 31/01/07
  76.   Hass, you`ve outdone your own absurdity 15:50  |  McQueen 31/01/07
  77.   And the children of Israel have bloody tanks 15:52  |  Marilyn 31/01/07
  78.   "Members of Hamas and Fatah, who have been friends... 15:55  |  curious 31/01/07
  79.   # 40 Haaretz Is Just The Messenger 16:14  |  Tony Anthony 31/01/07
  80.   israel`s responsibility for intra-palestinian violence 16:22  |  dd 31/01/07
  81.   Well said Amira. US and EU also to blame. 16:28  |  Nick Ferriman 31/01/07
  82.   Marilyn and friends about land 16:31  |  Geula Hovav 31/01/07
  83.   This article. 16:38  |  jon Fre 31/01/07
  84.   How wise and sad 16:48  |  Dennis Gordon 31/01/07
  85.   The terrorists are never responsible 16:50  |  KUTW 31/01/07
  86.   Shalom Freedman: Re: Who is more inhumane ? 16:50  |  Dutch 31/01/07
  87.