Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., January 31, 2007 Shvat 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The key lies in Gaza
By Danny Rubinstein

During the entire round of talks between Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) and his representatives with Hamas leaders regarding the establishment of a national unity government, there have been optimistic announcements made about progress, but the result in the final analysis has been the opposite: additional escalation in the "war between the camps," more street battles and more people killed, wounded and kidnapped. The headlines repeat themselves: a cease-fire between the sides that collapses overnight, and arguments over the distribution of portfolios in the unity government that apparently will not come into being, and if it does, will not last. Abu Mazen publishes an ultimatum to the effect that he will move up the elections, and one of the mediators, a Palestinian or an Egyptian, drafts a new and convoluted text that is supposed to bridge the gaps between the two sides' positions.

A cartoon published in the newspaper Palestinian Al-Ayyam shows a document of understanding that will serve as the basis for the establishment of a national unity government, in the form of a complicated maze. In its center: a Palestinian who has no idea where to go.

Many of the Palestinian spokesmen are despairing. Hafez Barghouti, the editor of the PA organ Al-Hayat al-Jadida, wrote on the first anniversary of the democratic elections won by Hamas that Palestinian democracy has turned into a democracy of blood, in which "the rule of blood" has replaced the "rule of the people." Last weekend Barghouti participated in a convention of Palestinian journalists in Jericho, which two journalists from Gaza also managed to attend. He said that he heard a journalist from the territories say to a journalist from East Jerusalem: "You at least have protection, since you live under the occupation." If such things are being published in an official Palestinian newspaper, that is a sign that the public in the territories is fed up.

Advertisement

The evil begins in Gaza. The statistics are familiar: a crowded and besieged strip of land, largely cut off from the world, with an impoverished population lacking any economic future, political horizon and social infrastructure. The Palestinians have not succeeded in creating a government of law and order in Gaza, with an economic foundation.

But Israeli governments are also to blame for what is happening in Gaza. The Israeli closure of the Gaza Strip began about 17 years ago, in the wake of vigilante knifings and the first Gulf War. In the Oslo Accords Israel promised to maintain territorial contiguity between Gaza and the West Bank. There were several attempts to create such contiguity, but they were not implemented. On the Israeli side this was a blatant violation of the accords. Because of security fears, Israel prevented the regular operation of the airport in Gaza, and piled obstacles in the way of the construction of the seaport. The result: Besieged and impoverished Gaza became an economic, social and political pressure cooker.

The partially open border between the Gaza Strip and Egypt does not help Gaza economically; its only chance is forging some kind of connection to Israel. A regular connection between Gaza and the West Bank is, in effect, the only way of restraining the power and influence of Hamas, which is strong in Gaza and weak in the West Bank. The more Gaza has become disconnected from the West Bank, the more the Hamas regime has become entrenched there.

The bloody battles between the factions in Gaza are affecting the entire region. From a fight for political power they have turned into struggles of an ethical, ideological nature. Hamas is identified with the steadfast front in the Arab world, which is very popular in the Arab street. This is a radical position that is hostile to Israel, and that views the Zionist state as a passing, neocolonialist entity, composed of various embattled ethnic groups with a foreign and immoral culture that preaches hatred of the Arabs and of Islam. Hamas adopts the same views as the Muslim Brotherhood and as many others in the Arab world, who reject recognition and contacts with Israel and at every opportunity condemn attempts at normalization. And on the other hand, Abu Mazen, his representative in Gaza Mohammed Dahlan, and their friends are identified in Gaza with rotten and corrupt regimes that serve American interests.

What is happening in Gaza therefore endangers not only the inhabitants of the Strip, but all of us, Israelis and Palestinians, who are sliding down the slippery slope of a cultural and religious battle.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
All questions answered
Bar-Ilan's online Responsa Project offers answers to Judaic questions.
Unknown Syrian soldier
Who is the Syrian soldier by the name of Mahmoud Ben Ali and what was his fate?
  1.   The "evil" is entirely in Tel Aviv 10:24  |  Clickfool 29/01/07
  2.   tosefta :abbas and hamas must get together 10:25  |  flashman 29/01/07
  3.   west side story gaza 2007 10:35  |  flashman 29/01/07
  4.   jeff northridge i gave serious thought to your suggestion 10:40  |  flashman 29/01/07
  5.   The battle between secular identity and religious fanaticism. 10:52  |  Marwan مروان خوري 29/01/07
  6.   clickfool 10:59  |  yirmi 29/01/07
  7.   A Chelomian advice 11:02  |  Xaxam 29/01/07
  8.   Clickfool, the revisionist liar, again misstating facts 11:02  |  Marwan مروان خوري 29/01/07
  9.   clickfool territorial continguity between the two 11:07  |  yirmi 29/01/07
  10.   Clickfool No. 1 is a FAKE Clickfool 11:14  |  Clickfool 29/01/07
  11.   Who is the criminal . . . . 11:16  |  revoltop 29/01/07
  12.   Let Egypt administer Gaza 11:23  |  Amos 29/01/07
  13.   The fruits of a bankrupt people 11:28  |  Star of David 29/01/07
  14.   Palestinian just deserts 11:42  |  Alan 29/01/07
  15.   Very distant Star of David 11:47  |  Tom Spender 29/01/07
  16.   Clickfool No10 is a FAKE fool 11:53  |  Clickfool 29/01/07
  17.   Paying the Price for Preaching Murder 12:10  |  Mike 29/01/07
  18.   Spender in ramallah 12:15  |  Star of David 29/01/07
  19.   The embarrassing star of David in Perth 12:30  |  Marilyn 29/01/07
  20.   # 19 Marilyn 12:50  |  ChanahS 29/01/07
  21.   marilyn 13:36  |  Star of David 29/01/07
  22.   Remove invading terrorists =shalom al Israel 13:38  |  sam 29/01/07
  23.   Chicken or egg 13:47  |  SAM 29/01/07
  24.   revoltop 13:48  |  Layla Sayedi 29/01/07
  25.   Shine on you crazy Star of David 13:53  |  Tom Spender 29/01/07
  26.   SAM #23 13:55  |  Layla Sayedi 29/01/07
  27.   Palis mess up again 14:03  |  JG 29/01/07
  28.   ethnic cleansing and democracy 14:41  |  Jan Gr?nholm 29/01/07
  29.   # 23- Sam 14:50  |  Klaudia 29/01/07
  30.   Hizbullah is terrorizing the West Bank and Gaza 15:26  |  Tamir Gaza 29/01/07
  31.   Layla Sayedi 15:29  |  Tamir Gaza 29/01/07
  32.   Klaudia is mad 15:54  |  Tom Spender 29/01/07
  33.   claims without proof 15:55  |  Jack Gilron 29/01/07
  34.   Kaludia #29 Here is a good reason 22:54  |  dana 29/01/07
  35.   # 30 Tamir - 22:55  |  Esther Thomas 29/01/07
  36.   My Palis are from Mars, yours are from Venus 03:59  |  Mircea 30/01/07
  37.   Spender is spent 04:50  |  Star of David 30/01/07
  38.   Tamir Gaza #31 04:59  |  Layla Sayedi 30/01/07
  39.   You at least have protection, since you live under the occupation 08:13  |  Logician 30/01/07
  40.   Marilyn of Australia 18:30  |  kimi 30/01/07
  41.   Lets put the responsibility where it belongs. 18:35  |  Tex 30/01/07
  42.   Comments By Tex 11:16  |  reductivesynthesis 31/01/07
 Today Online
PM okays eastward move for section of separation fence
Responses: 83
Demographer: Cede Palestinian areas of Jerusalem
Responses: 39
Amira Hass: The occupation is to blame for Gaza violence
Responses: 25
Livni's two-state rhetoric is little more than sloganeering
Responses: 5
Michalis Firillas: Iraq is not Vietnam
Responses: 3


More Headlines
08:43 PM approves eastward move of section of separation barrier
09:10 GOC Central Command clamps down on illegal settlements
09:11 Ex-secretary of state Baker: U.S-Syria talks could lead Hamas to recognize Israel
08:21 Verdict in Ramon's sexual harassment trial to be announced Wednesday
10:36 Government freezes mortgage grants for Ethiopian immigrants
02:16 IDF to strike Islamic Jihad, but wants to maintain Gaza 'calm'
07:44 Demographer: Israel should relinquish Palestinian areas of Jerusalem
03:12 Attorney: Katsav plans to move out of president's residence
10:05 Workers in fight against time to save remains of Auschwitz
11:26 Police investigate MK Ruhama Avraham over fraud allegations
05:22 Knesset to vote on animal testing ban, follow cue of new EU regulations
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved