Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., January 31, 2007 Shvat 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:29 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 13:03 28/01/2007
The silence when Arabs kill other Arabs
By Bradley Burston


In the newsroom, we wait for it every morning, hoping that it won't come.

Then it does. Same time, every morning. The first notice from the wire service is as economically laconic as it is horrifying. A car bomb. A bus bomb. A truck bomb. An open market. A mosque. Dozens feared dead. Some days, scores.

The world can live with it. The world has nothing to say about it. Many Americans, even those who want an immediate end to the U.S. military presence, can live with it.

Perhaps most troubling, Muslim holy men can live with it.

"It's hard to know what's more disturbing: the barbaric sectarian murders by Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq, or the deafening silence with which these mass murders are received in the Muslim world," Thomas Friedman wrote in the New York Times last week.

"Where is the Muslim Martin Luther King? Where is the 'Million Muslim March' under the banner: 'No Shiites, No Sunnis: We are all children of the Prophet Muhammad.'"

Closer to home, in the space of a long weekend, 24 people were killed in fighting between Hamas and Fatah gunmen, among them a two-year-old and a six-year-old.

Spiritual leaders have done little to calm tension. In fact, it may be argued that if there is one element in the Holy Land that has kept compromise at arm's length, it has been the uncompromising radical rigidity of influential religious figures.

Where, indeed, are the clerical voices preaching for rapprochement, for understanding, for compromise?

Instead, we have the Islamic Resistance Movement Hamas speaking with pride - barely audible over the weekend assassinations, drive-bys, mortar, rocket and assault rifle fire - of the Palestinians' refusal to offer any compromise whatsoever, even at the cost of additional suffering in the humanitarian catastrophe zone of the Gaza Strip.

Though Hamas claimed a moral victory over international sanctions, turnout was sparse at the Gaza rally marking the first anniversary of their election victory, and Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh had to pass up the event, fearing for his safety amid the ongoing bloodshed.

When Hamas did address the violence, all that they had to promise, was more.

"Following the awful massacres committed today in Gaza and northern Gaza" Hamas spokesman Ismail Radwan said on Friday, "we have decided to postpone all dialogue with Fatah."

Religious leaders, not incidentally, also pushed for the 1936 intifada, which, as analyst Guy Bechor has noted, eventually turned on itself, costing 5,000 Arab lives and robbing the Holy Land's Arabs of their leadership, paving the way for the 1948 defeat at the hands of the Jews.

Where, indeed, is the religious voice akin to that of Dr. King, who is willing to speak forthrightly against the desecration of the Holy Land, the slaughter of its children, the sanctification of war, the consecration of intransigence?

"The Koran describes the Prophet Muhammad as a Prophet of Mercy," Friedman quotes Husain Haqqani, the Pakistani-born director of Boston University's Center for International Relations, as saying. "Muslims begin all their acts, including worship, with the words: 'In the name of God, the compassionate, the merciful.' The Koran also says, 'To you, your faith, and to me, mine.' But unfortunately, these mercy-focused, peacemaking ideas are lost [today] in the overall discourse in the Muslim world about reviving lost glory and setting right the injustice of Western domination."

"For a Muslim Martin Luther King to emerge, Muslim discourse would have to shift away from the focus on power and glory and include taking responsibility as a community for our own situation."

And, lest we for a moment conclude that we Jews are not a part of this ...

On neither side do mainstream religious movements and spiritual figures campaign for peace, exhort for compromise, hand down clerical rulings that favor peace, that help to forge peace, or force peace.

For 40 years, we have had rabbis from Brooklyn issuing blanket bans absolutely prohibiting so much as an inch of compromise in the territories.

For decades, we have had radical rabbis excusing, interpreting, justifying, explicating human rights abuses against Palestinians.

The intifada marked a low point for religious Judaism, with a new mitzvah proclaimed in street signs urging total war against the Palestinians, and yeshiva students skipping class to pass out bumper stickers calling for the full might of the IDF to be unleashed in the territories.

Holy men have failed the Holy Land.

Holy men have ruined the Holy Land.

A holy man who sanctifies killing, who lobbies for war, is not fighting God's war. He is fighting God.

That holy man's word is not God's word. The moment the holy man mixes religion and war, he declares war on religion.

The moment the holy man mixes religion and politics, he casts a decisive vote against religion itself. Religion cannot co-opt politics. Outward appearances notwithstanding, when religion and politics meet, religion is always the loser. Politics by its nature always corrupts religion, bending it into something else. Breaking the good in it. Milking the bad in it.

Our holy men have failed us. All of us. We need prophets, and are stuck with self-adoring politicians.

Our holy men have failed God. May God have mercy on us. May God find some way to replace them.


___________________



Recent blogs:

Occupation: It's horrid, but it's not apartheid
Leave the U.S. embassy where it is
Jimmy Carter's offensive against U.S. Jewry
Next year in Palestine

___________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
All questions answered
Bar-Ilan's online Responsa Project offers answers to Judaic questions.
Unknown Syrian soldier
Who is the Syrian soldier by the name of Mahmoud Ben Ali and what was his fate?
  1.   Ahh, may you be heard! 11:50  |  Simone 28/01/07
  2.   Who are you? 11:53  |  Nik Miller 28/01/07
  3.   It`s A Simple Equation And Hate Is Not Even A Part Of It! (Part 1 12:09  |  Tim 28/01/07
  4.   There are peaceful Muslim groups as well 12:10  |  Paul Henzen 28/01/07
  5.   when they massacre each other 12:15  |  trumpeldor 28/01/07
  6.   Duality and God`s laws 12:18  |  Dror 28/01/07
  7.   Holy Land 12:21  |  Dror 28/01/07
  8.   A Chance that only Comes once in 10 Generations(Part 2) 12:24  |  Tim 28/01/07
  9.   when a palestinian is killed by israel 12:32  |  haim lipschitz 28/01/07
  10.   in fact iraq needs help from israel 12:34  |  haim lipschitz 28/01/07
  11.   not just for muslims, but... 12:36  |  VIPER 28/01/07
  12.   Arabs all over the world kill other Arabs 12:37  |  Steven 28/01/07
  13.   And when Israeli`s shoot down children? 12:47  |  Marilyn 28/01/07
  14.   Owners of the Truth 12:51  |  Albert Edelson 28/01/07
  15.   all wars are not evil, Bradley 12:55  |  Proud Zionist 28/01/07
  16.   Viper spewing poison...again 13:07  |  For those who hate 28/01/07
  17.   DEMOCRACY AND KILL EACH OTHER 13:08  |  indrajaya 28/01/07
  18.   Mis-use of the word `Holy` Bradley 13:09  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 28/01/07
  19.   Marilyn, ignorance shows 13:13  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 28/01/07
  20.   # 13, an eye for ah eye, get some REAL, information, damn!! 13:13  |  Simone 28/01/07
  21.   # 11 Viper 13:14  |  ChanahS 28/01/07
  22.   I LOVE THIS FRIEDMAN WAY 13:15  |  indrajaya 28/01/07
  23.   Haim you are priceless, really and truly 13:17  |  Marilyn 28/01/07
  24.   Boy, Is Burston Naive ....To The Point Of Foolishness. 13:18  |  Terry 28/01/07
  25.   # 14 Indrajaya 13:22  |  ChanahS 28/01/07
  26.   # 13 Marilyn - "I am told" 13:26  |  ChanahS 28/01/07
  27.   Great Article! 13:27  |  Karam 28/01/07
  28.   Marilyn-so many errors, so little time 13:31  |  Ash 28/01/07
  29.   Erekat 13:31  |  Superswede 28/01/07
  30.   # 25, CHANAH.S 13:53  |  indrajaya 28/01/07
  31.   racism by any other name 14:02  |  the shaigetz 28/01/07
  32.   # 25, CHANAH.S 14:05  |  indrajaya 28/01/07
  33.   UH-HOLY 14:11  |  ISHMAEL ISHMAEL 28/01/07
  34.   Mankind`s only example of ALWAYS Holy is 14:12  |  Virginia 28/01/07
  35.   #32 indrajaya Evade and prevaricate 14:20  |  Zardos 28/01/07
  36.   #13, where to start??? 14:29  |  Danny - Israeli one 28/01/07
  37.   Paul Henzen 14:38  |  charles 28/01/07
  38.   Why be Silent? 14:41  |  Ronnie Wolman 28/01/07
  39.   Arabs Love Violence 14:45  |  CHGODMK 28/01/07
  40.   #35, ZARDOS 14:54  |  indrajaya 28/01/07
  41.   gIVE THEM ENOUGH ROPE AND THEY WILL HANG THEMSELVES 15:01  |  paul harris 28/01/07
  42.   Final Solution 15:02  |  AK 28/01/07
  43.   Nicely done. What you say is essentially true, though 15:02  |  Apartheid 28/01/07
  44.   #39 15:15  |  AK 28/01/07
  45.   Marylyn , the Torah and the Bible 15:17  |  Avrum 28/01/07
  46.   # 37 charles 15:32  |  Paul Henzen 28/01/07
  47.   To Bradley Burston.IF I MAY.I WILL REFER YOU TO......... 15:33  |  Kath` 28/01/07
  48.   AK #44 15:36  |  CHGODMK 28/01/07
  49.   Intrigues And Civil Wars 15:38  |  Arik 28/01/07
  50.   ...to Mr Bradley Burston...don`t worry... 15:39  |  abraham...mico 28/01/07
  51.   Our silence bears witness to our shame. 15:48  |  Nick Ferriman 28/01/07
  52.   Indrajaya 15:49  |  Avrum 28/01/07
  53.   Arabs Love Violence...toCHGODMK#39...it is not truth... 15:50  |  soldier 28/01/07
  54.   You still manage to accuse the Jews Burston 15:55  |  Shalom Freedman 28/01/07
  55.   Evil doers mimic "Allahu Akbar" but only glorify themselves 16:01  |  Robert FinkelStein 28/01/07
  56.   Nick Ferriman: OUR Genocidal Tendencies?! 16:02  |  CHGODMK 28/01/07
  57.   # 38 Ronnie Wolman 16:04  |  Nick Ferriman 28/01/07
  58.   Leftist Idiots March In The Streets To Protest Bush 16:06  |  Yosemite 28/01/07
  59.   6# Dror: Duality and God`s Laws 16:07  |  Arik 28/01/07
  60.   Palestinians killed 40, Israel over 4,000 16:09  |  Marilyn 28/01/07
  61.   Soldier. Really? 16:10  |  CHGODMK 28/01/07
  62.   It`s Always Somebody Else`s Fault 16:10  |  Tony Anthony 28/01/07
  63.   # 51 Nick Ferriman 16:14  |  ChanahS 28/01/07
  64.   I Will NOT Worship Bradley`s God ! 16:15  |  Klaudia 28/01/07
  65.   #49 16:18  |  j10 28/01/07
  66.   # 19 Marilyn`s Answer 16:19  |  Tony Anthony 28/01/07
  67.   Marilyn as usual goes wild :-) 16:20  |  France 28/01/07
  68.   Marilyn, I could not help but taking a few 16:22  |  Anat 28/01/07
  69.   Marylyn 16:26  |  Walid 28/01/07
  70.   Paul Harris 16:30  |  Walid 28/01/07
  71.   Israel`s existence Vs. Muslim fratricide 16:39  |  HonestAbe 28/01/07
  72.   Who is to `blame`? 16:39  |  Michael N 28/01/07
  73.   Me and George Bush and Tony Anthony 16:41  |  Marilyn 28/01/07
  74.   69Walid So now bible is recorded history? 16:43  |  Logician 28/01/07
  75.   65` j10: Sorry, But You Did Not Even Understand One Pixel 16:44  |  Arik 28/01/07
  76.   Anat I answered you already 16:44  |  Marilyn 28/01/07
  77.   Walid agrees Gaza is Jewish land 16:48  |  Avrum 28/01/07
  78.   69. Walid: Samson 16:48  |  KUTW 28/01/07
  79.   Walid what rot 16:49  |  Marilyn 28/01/07
  80.   13. Marilyn: And when pals shoot down children? 16:52  |  KUTW 28/01/07
  81.   Like a football match 16:53  |  Steven A. 28/01/07
  82.   Plestinians killing Palestinians, etc... 16:54  |  Rami 28/01/07
  83.   CHGODMK #39 16:55  |  Gabe1 28/01/07
  84.   # 56 CHGODMK 16:58  |  Nick Ferriman 28/01/07
  85.