Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., February 05, 2007 Shvat 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:16 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 07:55 26/01/2007
State schools introduce religious studies despite gov't opposition
By Or Kashti, Haaretz Correspondent

Schools in Givatayim and Petah Tikva have introduced a new religious studies program to "strengthen Jewish identity," although the Education Ministry deemed it unfit for state schools. The ministry intends to issue instructions to these schools to stop operating the program.

The program is financed by ultra-Orthodox tycoon Lev Leviev and taught by religious and Haredi female students. It emphasizes the importance of prayers and Jewish history from a halakhic perspective.

The program is taught in 18 schools  17 in Petah Tikva and one in Givatayim, usually in first to sixth grades for two hours a week. It is considered the flagship of the Leviev Foundation for Education and Jewish Identity, which was founded by Leviev and his wife Olga.

Advertisement

The work book accompanying the program's classes says it "contributes to expanding the pupils' knowledge and provides them with universal values deriving from Jewish heritage and culture." However, Anat Zohar, the chairwoman of the Education Ministry's Pedagogic Secretariat, issued a special statement saying the program "is not at all suitable for state schools. On the one hand, it lacks a pluralistic worldview reflecting that of the pupils, most of whom come from secular homes... on the other hand, it emphasizes numerous halakhic and religious issues."

For example, the book instructs children to say morning prayers daily and wash their hands, and claims the prayer is capable of warding off evil and obtaining God's love.

"These points of view constitute preaching and could create conflicts between the worldview the child is taught at home and that of the studies in school," wrote Zohar. "In summary, my professional opinion is that the program is not suitable for teaching and learning in state schools."

The program's book for second grade teaches that it is important to love "every Jew" because "we're all one nation and God loves the fact that we're together."

The pupils are taught that the Temple Menorah "was very holy" and that "as long as the Israeli nation carried out God's will, the Menorah's western candle did not go out but continued burning in a wonderful holy light!"

Parents of pupils studying at Alon school in Givatayim are not pleased with the religious studies program.

"I sent my children to a secular school, not to a Leviev or Shas school," one mother said. "That program was introduced without our knowledge. It's proselytizing. In a state school I know more or less what they teach. If it's so important to expand Jewish studies, let them do it with an Education Ministry program, not Leviev's."

"Every time someone with money comes along [to the education system], they start teaching something he wants, at the expense of the already dwindling study hours," a father said.

He said that in the previous year the school had introduced Shari Arison's program "The essence of life," which had also not been authorized by the Education Ministry.

Education Ministry officials said only the ministry may authorize study programs and that, in any case, such programs must be taught in addition to the official studies, not at their expense.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
For the green toad
The green toad is undergoing hardship with the elimination of the winter pools it depends on.
Miscommunication
Many SMS messages stem from companies' mistakes, increasing consumers' cost.
  1.   state schools 03:33  |  mordechai 26/01/07
  2.   To Love Or Not To Love 03:52  |  Tony Anthony 26/01/07
  3.   good and bad 04:34  |  David G 26/01/07
  4.   If it`s an elective, there`s really no problem 06:59  |  AV 26/01/07
  5.   teachging judaism 07:48  |  ze`ev 26/01/07
  6.   Unofficial school curricula 08:04  |  Esther 26/01/07
  7.   Let the parents decide 08:40  |  manny 26/01/07
  8.   awful! they might learn something! 09:37  |  Gevalt! 26/01/07
  9.   Jewish education 09:41  |  Zappa 26/01/07
  10.   Yes to teach Jewish History, no to Religion 10:19  |  Martin 26/01/07
  11.   Why not? Israel is the only Jewish state in the world. 10:59  |  Yacov 26/01/07
  12.   and then... 11:37  |  Vitaliy 26/01/07
  13.   Martin you are just too scared. 11:52  |  Steven 26/01/07
  14.   No right to be there then! 12:22  |  Marilyn 26/01/07
  15.   Marilyn the anti-semite made a valid point. 12:59  |  Steven 26/01/07
  16.   jewish education 13:11  |  motel 26/01/07
  17.   to yaacov of Ashkelon and Motel 15:01  |  charles 26/01/07
  18.   Wonderful - not forceful, but wondeful and Jewish 15:08  |  S Judah 26/01/07
  19.   To Yacov 16:48  |  Shuky 26/01/07
  20.   Judaism is one thing, and Leviov is a totally different thing. 18:23  |  Ben Qor`ha (Baldwin) 26/01/07
  21.   Yuli Tamir is disappointing! 18:29  |  Ben Qor`ha (Baldwin) 26/01/07
  22.   Brain washing at an early age 12:39  |  SJ 27/01/07
  23.   #17 00:54  |  motel 28/01/07
  24.   to no. 23 hotel 06:36  |  Ben Qor`ha (Baldwin) 28/01/07
  25.   to #17 08:05  |  Sam 28/01/07
  26.   Marilyn, (14,15) an anti-semite? No way!! 20:04  |  Moshe 28/01/07
  27.   #24 23:36  |  shiff 28/01/07
  28.   Education Minstry is pathetic as always 05:51  |  Dani 30/01/07
  29.   To # 23 22:29  |  charles 30/01/07
  30.   motel 22:34  |  charles 30/01/07
  31.   Moshe of New York 22:44  |  charles 30/01/07
  32.   #31 23:32  |  dan 31/01/07
  33.   Teaching the Zohar to Ms. Zohar 00:52  |  HowrdMadris 01/02/07
  34.   Haaretz is garbage 20:32  |  Pam Beesly 01/02/07
  35.   Favorite subject... 07:37  |  Tanya 04/02/07
  36.   Israel is NOT AMERICA! Shocking... 07:38  |  Saul Tobin 04/02/07
  37.   school 15:07  |  wm 05/02/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Who will bring peace back from the dead?
Responses: 46
Meron Benvenisti: Break Israel's monopoly on J'lem
Responses: 46
Editorial: Recognize the Palestinians' humanitarian needs
Responses: 19
City of David tunnel dig proceeding without proper permit
Responses: 56
Eliahu Salpeter: Who really cares about this Carter guy?
Responses: 22
Olmert rejects Peretz plan to evacuate illegal outposts
Responses: 98
Rosner's Domain
* New Guest: On the Crisis of America's Israel Lobby
* Bush, a divider of the Jews
* Should America follow the linkage theory?
* Poll: Who's to blame for the clashes in Gaza?


More Headlines
13:44 Police: Six Defense Ministry officials confess to taking bribes
13:57 IDF locates and destroys suspicious device on northern border
13:53 Kadima minister Ezra: Free Barghouti for Abbas' sake
14:40 Abbas aides to meet with Rice in U.S. to discuss Mideast summit
13:33 Man suspected of intentionally running over policeman caught
07:54 PM rejects Peretz plan to evacuate illegal outposts
09:33 Official: Accountant General rigged tender in hiring cronies
10:14 IDF warns against hitchhiking, citing terror kidnapping alerts
14:15 City of David tunnel excavation proceeds without proper permit
07:58 New study: Iran seeks 'nuclear ambiguity,' likely to act 'logically'
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved