Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., January 27, 2007 Shvat 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Captive Audience / Dishonorable president
By Avirama Golan

For a full hour yesterday, all the Israeli broadcast channels were the voluntary captives of the country's No. 1 citizen, who presented his defense arguments, a character statement in his own defense and a summation for a trial that has yet to begin. And he did this while engaging in an agitated, scathing and excoriating defamation of the vehicle that allowed him to bring his unusual performance to the nation.

Moshe Katsav was fighting for his life yesterday, as well as for his dignity and the trust he wants his family and friends to continue to place in him. He also used the opportunity to trample whatever remaining justification he may have had in continuing to remain in his post.

One can assume that there are people outside the media for whom Katsav's speech did strike a chord. His advisers, and perhaps Katsav himself, were aiming for the most populist effect, with the use of the term "the hostile media": a powerful institution with an elitist, destructive and arrogant agenda that exerts extortionist power over the police, prosecution and attorney general.

Advertisement

Katsav used the cameras of the journalists to speak directly to the "citizens of Israel" and portray himself over and over as a victim of an elitist, well-orchestrated plot.

Katsav did not hesitate to present himself as both a simple citizen whose basic rights have been denied him and as the president and a key figure in the Jewish world. This dual discourse was accompanied by an additional split: Half the time he was full of threatening descriptions of the ties between the media and law-enforcement authorities, and half the time he was pleading.

Katsav addressed the public as though cruel police investigators had tackled him one day as he was innocently walking in the street, dumped him and his friends in a room full of prosecutors and framed him. Katsav portrayed the women who testified against him as part of a witch hunt, who were taking revenge because they were fired.

Unfortunately, the latent message of Katsav's speech was that he is nothing but an innocent boy from the Kastina transit camp, whom no one wants to see in the President's Residence.

It wasn't the allegations of rape that were at the center of Katsav's heated tongue-lashing. It was the good versus the bad, the light-skinned versus the dark-skinned, the elite versus the undesirable others. Not since former Shas leader Aryeh Deri's "I am innocent" comments has there been such blatant manipulation by someone who reached the top and then, with the help of his lawyers and media consultants, depicted himself as a miserable victim of the arrogant elite, and in so doing terrorized the public.

The question isn't whether Katsav from Kiryat Malachi was wanted at the President's Residence in the upscale Jerusalem neighborhood of Rehavia, but whether he did what he is accused of doing. Either way, the honorable president proved yesterday exactly what he suspects people think about him: that he is not worthy of the exalted position.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Hail to the (mis)chief
A reflection, anecdote and quote may be food for thought for the chief-of-staff-to-be.
Home sweet home
Adi Nes' unique photography combines classical art, biblical heroes and an urban backdrop.
  1.   ALL ISRAELI CITIZENS ARE THE CAPTIVES OF THE POLICE 00:49  |  DOV 26/01/07
  2.   WHO WAS THAT STINKER FROM RESHET 2 WHO .. 00:51  |  Arnold 26/01/07
  3.   So Israeli police intimidate religeous women now?? 00:52  |  Ron 26/01/07
  4.   Why did Mazuz open his mouth trap?? 00:53  |  David 26/01/07
  5.   Poor Man`s Gideon Levy,Avirama Golan 00:54  |  Absolute Sweden 26/01/07
  6.   OK. So give Israel back to the Europeans if 00:56  |  John 26/01/07
  7.   So what will the pals do with the million bullets you .. 00:57  |  Jerry 26/01/07
  8.   Keep tearing down your own country all you madmen 00:59  |  Peter J 26/01/07
  9.   Why did t israeli police throw out widow and her children in the 01:01  |  Scott 26/01/07
  10.   katsav 01:16  |  samuel 26/01/07
  11.   Shame on "our" press, leave us alone already! 01:55  |  Gabi 26/01/07
  12.   katsav the rapist 02:10  |  sympathetic 26/01/07
  13.   Israel`s LEFTIST MEDIA is CORRUPT & EVIL ! 03:22  |  amir 26/01/07
  14.   Yet another 03:58  |  David 26/01/07
  15.   Would you say the same if he is exonerated? 07:06  |  AA 26/01/07
  16.   the president 07:11  |  esther sherman 26/01/07
  17.   What does exactly "voluntary Captive" mean? Nonsense 07:20  |  AA 26/01/07
  18.   Katsav,YOU dishonor us all. 07:21  |  Zuriel 26/01/07
  19.   katsav???? 07:29  |  eli 26/01/07
  20.   The writer has it all wrong--not dishonorable at all............ 09:34  |  Dutch 26/01/07
  21.   missing logic 09:54  |  kobi 26/01/07
  22.   Katsav 10:57  |  Zappa 26/01/07
  23.   This case stinks 11:06  |  krystal 26/01/07
  24.   #1 Dov,nobody forces you to stay in Israel.... 13:11  |  Hastaroth 26/01/07
  25.   Two camps 13:34  |  Vital 26/01/07
  26.   Proofs. 13:43  |  Vital 26/01/07
  27.   Katsav is but a man,not the conscience of Israel 13:54  |  hala 26/01/07
  28.   Avirama is Speaking on.. 13:58  |  BenAbuzaglo 26/01/07
  29.   23 "This lady obviously did not object to it" 14:41  |  Fritz 26/01/07
  30.   In despair. 16:17  |  Ron Caris 26/01/07
  31.   What bothers me about Katsav"s speech 17:24  |  Yonatan 26/01/07
  32.   All men are Innocent until proven guilty? Women too! 17:28  |  Neil Golan 26/01/07
  33.   Katzav 20:24  |  Emile Tubiana 26/01/07
  34.   Free Our Persian King 21:44  |  Zahra Ghasemy 26/01/07
  35.   you are a machoist, "sympathetic 23:30  |  Cristobal 26/01/07
  36.   Katzav balagan 02:57  |  Stanley 27/01/07
  37.   binational state 14:11  |  demonastir 27/01/07
 Today Online
Schiff: Israel's Arab leaders have shot themselves in the foot
Responses: 198
Tony Karon: Olmert is outsourcing Israel's strategic decisions to a bungling Bush
Responses: 84
Shmuel Rosner: Kerry, Carter, Clinton - all biased against Israel?
Responses: 152
World Jewry is losing its interest in Israel
Responses: 125
PM: We must ensure Lebanon war failures are not repeated
Responses: 128
Report: Iran preparing to launch spy satellite into space
Responses: 230


More Headlines
14:55 17 die in weekend of infighting in Gaza Strip
14:58 Abbas to pay salaries using tax rebates transferred by Israel
07:23 UN adopts resolution condemning Holocaust denial
22:12 Haniyeh: Deal for Shalit's release still long way off
04:48 IDF destroys 2 Hezbollah bunkers on Israeli side of Lebanon border
15:08 Lebanon's army commander calls for efforts to end political crisis
14:34 Jordanian court upholds death sentence for female bomber
09:01 North Korea denies allegations of nuclear cooperation with Iran
19:27 Report: Iran almost ready to launch spy satellite into space
23:14 State prosecution: New IDF chief appointment mustn't be delayed
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved