Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., January 26, 2007 Shvat 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Former U.S. president Jimmy Carter speaking about his controversial book "Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid" to students at Brandeis University on Tuesday. (Reuters)
Last update - 16:25 24/01/2007
Carter defends 'apartheid' book, says attacks on character hurt
By News Agencies

Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter defended on Tuesday defended his controversial book on Israel's treatment of Palestinians, telling students at Brandeis University that his goal was to revive Middle East peace talks.

Carter also told students that rge attacks on his character following the release of his book had hurt him and his family.

Jewish groups have expressed outrage at "Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid," arguing that its comparison of Israel's treatment of Palestinians with South Africa's reviled apartheid system of racial segregation could undermine perceptions of Israel's legitimacy.

Advertisement

Brandeis, in the Boston suburb of Waltham, is a secular university founded by American Jewish leaders, and about half of its 5,300 students are Jewish. The school is named after Louis Brandeis, the first Jew on the Supreme Court and a robust defender of the right to free speech.

The former United States president, in his first direct address to Jewish Americans on his book, said the title referred to human rights in the Palestinian territories, not in Israel.

He said the word "apartheid" was intended to provoke debate on the rights of Palestinians, who he said were being treated unfairly by Israel.

He said he never asserted that Jewish money was controlling the U.S. media, as some critics have charged, but only that the pro-Israel lobby was strong.

"I've been hurt and so has my family by some of the reaction," Carter, who won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2002, told about 1,700 students at the university.

"I've been through political campaigns for state senator, governor and president, and I've been stigmatized and condemned by my political opponents. But this is the first time that I have ever been called a liar. And a bigot and an anti-Semite and a coward, and a plagiarist. This is hurtful," he said.

"I can take it," he added, joking that he could handle the attacks because as a former U.S. president he still had Secret Service protection.

Carter, 82, has been dogged by protests during a promotional tour. In the book, Carter traces the history of the Middle East from the 19th century to the present via the Camp David Accords in 1978, a year into his presidency.

He apologized for a passage that can be interpreted as supporting suicide bombings as a negotiating tactic, saying it was a "mistake" and would be removed from future editions.

But he said a full Israeli withdrawal from Palestinian territories was crucial for lasting peace.

The university originally invited Carter on the condition that he debate lawyer and Harvard Law School professor Alan Dershowitz, a critic of the book.

But Carter said he would only visit the campus without conditions. He later accepted an invitation from a committee of students and faculty to speak without taking part in a debate.

The event was tightly controlled and closed to the public, preventing Dershowitz, one of Carter's more scathing critics, from openly questioning him.

Dershowitz wanted to ask Carter why he had accepted money from Saudi Arabia and why the Carter Center, an Atlanta-based humanitarian organization, had criticized Israel while not looking into human rights abuses in Saudi Arabia.

Instead, a student asked those questions.

Carter responded in part by saying all donations were audited with Arab nations contributing a tiny fraction with most of the money going to humanitarian programs.

About 60 protesters, detractors and supporters, gathered outside, some holding Israeli or Palestinian signs and flags.

"We support what Jimmy Carter is saying," said Alan Meyers, 56, a Jewish doctor from Boston. "We feel that there is not enough attention being paid to dissenting Jewish voices in the United States."

Nearby, Israeli-American Gilend Ini, 29, handed out fliers identifying five portions of Carter's book that he said contained falsehoods. "We're trying to let the public know that much of what he said in his book was factually incorrect information."

In preparation for Carter's appearance, metal barricades were erected along the road leading to the athletic center, where Carter was to speak, and people entering the place had to go through a metal detector.

But a few hours before the appearance, only about two dozen demonstrators showed up, and most were carrying signs with a pro-Palestinian view. Among them: "Closing our eyes to injustice is not a Jewish value" and "Support Jimmy Carter. End the occupation now."

Carter's book has been criticized by some Jewish leaders as riddled with inaccuracies and distortions. Some have complained that it appears to equate South Africa's former apartheid system of racial segregation with Israeli treatment of the Palestinians.

Fifteen questions were selected ahead of time from a list of least 120 by the committee that invited Carter, according to the university.

"The whole idea was that everyone would benefit if there is a more focused way of getting questions to the president, not having 1,700 people raise their hands to ask questions," said university spokesman Dennis Nealon.

Critics were particularly frustrated that Dershowitz was not allowed to debate Carter. "It's puzzling because he said that he wants to have a discussion of his book and then refused to appear with Professor Dershowitz," said retired Brandeis history professor Morton Keller.

Gordon Fellman, a sociology professor and a member of the committee that arranged the visit, said Dershowitz is neither a student nor faculty member at Brandeis and therefore "he can't get in - and it's not anti-Dershowitz.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dishonorable President
In his speech on Wednesday, Katsav proved that he is not worthy of the presidency.
Demanding reform
A group of Jewish study centers will no longer refer candidates to Israeli courts.
  1.   not confronting.he is avoiding, words such as pygmy, hiding more 05:28  |  ralph 24/01/07
  2.   Well, there you go... 06:25  |  Johnboy 24/01/07
  3.   Jimmy Carter 06:27  |  Dr Bert Schenk 24/01/07
  4.   The only valid question should be , How much Arab Petro$$$$$ it 06:57  |  Victor_the_Egyptian 24/01/07
  5.   Brandeis = A Joke 07:00  |  Tod Zuckerman 24/01/07
  6.   Carter took over $15 Million from Arabs 07:24  |  Mee 24/01/07
  7.   Carter was thew worst president we ever had 07:33  |  Kipperraes 24/01/07
  8.   Brandeis University 08:17  |  Shmuelshachor 24/01/07
  9.   #1 Racist??? 08:18  |  jake 24/01/07
  10.   The end of Brandeis U.......... 08:22  |  NS 24/01/07
  11.   WHAT A PATHETIC PROTEST 08:22  |  Meir Weinstein 24/01/07
  12.   How much Arab Petro$$$$$ it takes for Carter to LIE 08:25  |  Victor_the_Egyptian 24/01/07
  13.   REASONS CAN`T ELIMINATE THE FACTS 08:26  |  indrajaya 24/01/07
  14.   Carter is a pig in silk. Anyway you dress it up, it remains a pig 08:26  |  Robert Blum 24/01/07
  15.   Metal Detectors? A Bunch Of Baloney! 08:29  |  Yosemite 24/01/07
  16.   Jews for Carter ? Disgusting 08:32  |  Tod Zuckerman 24/01/07
  17.   You`ve hurt him and his family. Are you happy now? 08:41  |  Timothy 24/01/07
  18.   Johnboy you`re right. Critics attack Carter to distract. 08:45  |  Timothy 24/01/07
  19.   Carter the origin of all calamities 08:52  |  Leon 24/01/07
  20.   YOU BETTER CHOSE CARTER 08:56  |  indrajaya 24/01/07
  21.   Carter.- and the economy 08:56  |  LDychter 24/01/07
  22.   carter an ignorant bigot 09:09  |  chris 24/01/07
  23.   So, Carter is hurt? 09:15  |  Somebody from Europe 24/01/07
  24.   Carter the old line antisemite 09:17  |  David Teich 24/01/07
  25.   "Defends"?? Not his intellectual honesty!.Questions preselected! 09:33  |  PETER SM 24/01/07
  26.   Carter pretends that he is impartial. His position is ........... 09:44  |  Vittorio 24/01/07
  27.   Carter mocks South Africans 09:45  |  Howard 24/01/07
  28.   Carter`s book on Israeli aparthide 09:48  |  charles 24/01/07
  29.   deborah lipstadt knows how it feels. 09:51  |  shegay k 24/01/07
  30.   Carter, the has-been, hiding behind ancient laurels of his title. 09:54  |  ZVI HERSCH 24/01/07
  31.   Mr. Carter, Political Activist 09:57  |  J of Hollywood 24/01/07
  32.   HATEFUL MOB 09:58  |  Cobran 24/01/07
  33.   Timothy, the whining racist 10:00  |  Ehud 24/01/07
  34.   Apology to Tod Zuckerman (Post No. 13) 10:03  |  Johnny Weintraub 24/01/07
  35.   Indrajaya 10:03  |  JonathanInTelAviv 24/01/07
  36.   Jimmy Carter allowed radical Islam to spawn 10:04  |  Eli G 24/01/07
  37.   We all need critics! 10:05  |  Deborah 24/01/07
  38.   Carter misses the point 10:06  |  whoopwhoop 24/01/07
  39.   what is wrong . . . 10:07  |  revoltop 24/01/07
  40.   # 12 Indrajaya 10:08  |  Josef 24/01/07
  41.   Carter: let me insult you, but do not say "hurtful" things to me 10:09  |  McQueen 24/01/07
  42.   Timothy, please stop persecuting us 10:13  |  McQueen 24/01/07
  43.   disingenuous 10:14  |  Vitaliy 24/01/07
  44.   Carter YOU BROUGHT US THE AYATOLLAHS in IRAN !!!!!!!!!! 10:18  |  amir 24/01/07
  45.   We all need critics! 10:19  |  Deborah 24/01/07
  46.   omg! Carter`s hurt! 10:20  |  Vitaliy 24/01/07
  47.   To Timothy, his book will hurt more than he does... 10:20  |  Tom 24/01/07
  48.   Carter 10:23  |  appreciative 24/01/07
  49.   Charles, what do you know of Arab democracy? 10:26  |  Vitaliy 24/01/07
  50.   Free the Native Americans! 10:30  |  Vitaliy 24/01/07
  51.   `Apartheid` book 10:42  |  Aussie 24/01/07
  52.   CARTER vs MIGHTY JEWISH LOBBIES 10:43  |  indrajaya 24/01/07
  53.   I am completely perplexed 10:46  |  British academic 24/01/07
  54.   Carter KGB stooge 10:57  |  un-pc 24/01/07
  55.   Cheers to Jimmy! 10:58  |  kooskoos 24/01/07
  56.   Why is it shocking? 10:59  |  Aman 24/01/07
  57.   Charles #28 11:08  |  sg 24/01/07
  58.   Carter-haters 11:11  |  Spider 24/01/07
  59.   Deborah Lipstadt`s article in WP 11:13  |  sg 24/01/07
  60.   Pres. Carter Is Doing WELL!. ...Dershowitz Has NO CREDIBILITY. 11:19  |  Proud Pal Defender 24/01/07
  61.   A PATHETIC LITTLE MAN IN HIS DOTAGE 11:32  |  paul harris 24/01/07
  62.   carter is a failed president 11:35  |  flashman 24/01/07
  63.   tosefta on arafat and the intifada 11:39  |  flashman 24/01/07
  64.   Carter or Katsav? 11:46  |  Duncan 24/01/07
  65.   If you can`t stand the heat... 11:47  |  JG 24/01/07
  66.   Aussie 11:48  |  JG 24/01/07
  67.   Indrajaya 11:50  |  JG 24/01/07
  68.   Book donations 11:51  |  David 24/01/07
  69.   shame on you to let a jew hater to speak 11:54  |  angry reuven 24/01/07
  70.   Carter for President 11:57  |  Duncan 24/01/07
  71.   tosefta and his policylite comments on arafat 12:01  |  flashman 24/01/07
  72.   PP.DEFENDER.Why duck Dershowitz if he has "no credibility"? 12:01  |  PETER SM 24/01/07
  73.   #61 Paul Harris, You have to change your worn out tune Paul. 12:02  |  Maureen Ann 24/01/07
  74.   varter a moron, worst president in19th century!!!!! 12:05  |  Wendy 24/01/07
  75.   #17 remarkable timonthy HAS HE HELPED 12:15  |  paul harris 24/01/07
  76.   2 wrongs don`t make a right 12:18  |  Edith 24/01/07
  77.   tosefta and zakaria zubeidi retired jenin terrorist 12:24  |  flashman 24/01/07
  78.   Duncan for class clown 12:32  |  HeeHaw 24/01/07
  79.   President Carters Book 12:38  |  Sam 24/01/07
  80.   The Peanut Farm in the Sky 12:40  |  Klaudia 24/01/07
  81.   Carter is leading light of the world 12:44  |  Don 24/01/07
  82.   Jewish left wingers disgust me! 12:45  |  Nechama 24/01/07
  83.   Altzheimers? 13:01  |  Meir 24/01/07
  84.   Interesting ... 13:05  |  Academic 24/01/07
  85.