Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 08, 2007 Shvat 20, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Checkpoint comradeship
By Amira Hass

Anyone who wants to become acquainted with Israeli society should go to the checkpoints. Not for a quarter of an hour, under the guidance of commanders who will glory in the pavilion they built for the people waiting in line and will explain that the upgrading and the expansion of the checkpoint are intended to benefit the locals. Those who really want to know the checkpoints should rather dwell here for hours, during several days. When you observe the soldiers, you will discover many Israeli characteristics among them, characteristics in which we have always taken pride.

Comradeship, for example. The comradeship is so strong that there are those who feel they can even deviate from the norms that have been created at the checkpoint, which are perverted in any case. At the Taysir checkpoint, for example, in two cases documented during the past two weeks, a soldier urinated in public, and in the presence of women. Perhaps it was the same soldier both times, or perhaps two different soldiers. This was but an extreme manifestation of the scorn the soldiers at the checkpoint demonstrate for the people who are at their mercy and must pass through there - teachers, farmers, merchants, schoolchildren, workers at the settlements. But this is also an expression of the soldiers' self-confidence, of the knowledge that none of their comrades will prevent them from doing things they would not do in Binyamina or Bnei Brak.

The willingness to help is also an Israeli trait. The very same soldier helped a policeman ensconced in his jeep at this remote checkpoint, located at the end of the Jordan Valley. On Tuesday last week, this soldier collected the identity cards of a number of drivers, gave them to the policeman in the jeep and returned to the drivers with the ID cards and with traffic violation tickets and a payment of a fine of NIS 100 each, which they would have to pay for the benefit of the state treasury, for not wearing seat belts. And incidentally, they were wearing seat belts, although their cars had already been waiting for half an hour or more.

Advertisement

Inventiveness is another blessed Israeli trait. A military order prohibits all Palestinians from entering and sojourning in the Jordan Valley, except for those who live there and work for the most part at Jewish settlements. In recent weeks, the soldiers at the Taysir checkpoint have told inhabitants of the Jordan Valley who "dared" to spend the night outside the valley and return to it in the morning that "this is forbidden." A year and a half ago they decided that it was "forbidden" for farmers to bring their produce through this checkpoint - as a result, these farmers had to make a detour of about 30 kilometers and pass through a different checkpoint. When it was made clear to the soldiers that there was no such order, they found a method to keep drivers away from the checkpoint: They obligated those who transport vegetables into the West Bank to unload all crates before the checkpoint, supposedly for inspection, and to reload them.

Tenacity is also considered to be an admirable trait, especially in the army. Brigade commanders come and go, soldiers are replaced and yet, during the past two years, the reports about the distant Taysir checkpoint have remained the same: soldiers who invent harassments, waiting times way beyond what is justified, on various false excuses (one time it is construction work at the checkpoint, another time forged documents and yet another time a security warning), and reports of people who were made to pass through a different checkpoint.

It is easy to claim that Taysir is exceptional. It is a fact that the reported behavior of that particular soldier was seen by his commanders as very grave, and he was suspended from his position. The brigade also denied the veracity of reports by inhabitants that the specific soldier was present and "served" at the checkpoint even after he was suspended for about two hours on one day and three hours on another. Brigade officials stressed that the suspension of this soldier is still in force, with the same assertiveness as those people who said they had seen him again at the checkpoint. In any case, in the past, too, after this kind of information was brought to the attention of the commanders, the situation at the checkpoint improved for several days and the waiting time was shorter, and then everything returned to the status quo ante. Each of the many dozens of checkpoints has developed its own methods of harassment over the years. They derive from the implicit order behind the existence of every checkpoint: Prevent Palestinian freedom of movement for the sake of the welfare of the Jewish settlements; that is to say - Israel. One gets sick of reading about the checkpoints. One gets even sicker of writing about them. And the most sickening thing of all is to pass through them. But because the Palestinians have no alternative but to continue to pass through them, these checkpoints will continue to be the representatives of Israeli society.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Survival mission
Maccabi coach Neven Spahija is on a mission to survive after his team's shocking loss.
A developing market
Three new galleries, with completely different styles, are joining the local art scene.
  1.   ITS JUST LIKE FLYING !! SECURITY SECURITY 11:41  |  paul harris 24/01/07
  2.   the perversion is amira haas`s mind 11:56  |  flashman 24/01/07
  3.   Who would fly with "IDF Air", Paul? 12:00  |  David McC 24/01/07
  4.   Amira Hass 12:22  |  S 24/01/07
  5.   security #1 12:26  |  nina 24/01/07
  6.   Amira this is really sad 12:29  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 24/01/07
  7.   Amira Hass is a MIRROR 12:37  |  Israeli Society 24/01/07
  8.   OCCUPATION = JUDAISM??? 12:37  |  Cobran 24/01/07
  9.   Urination question 12:42  |  nevermind 24/01/07
  10.   #3 YES MAC BUT I WOULD WITH EL AL THE SAFEST AIRLINE IN THE WORLD 12:45  |  paul harris 24/01/07
  11.   #6 Margie in Tel Aviv 12:48  |  Boycott 24/01/07
  12.   If the Palestinians want freedom, they have to give up terror 12:50  |  Israeli mother 24/01/07
  13.   As usual, shoot the messenger! 12:52  |  EhadHaAm 24/01/07
  14.   Enough with the tongue-in-cheek irony 12:59  |  Tzfonit 24/01/07
  15.   The occupation is totally immoral... 13:01  |  Stephen Murray 24/01/07
  16.   Amira Hass strikes again 13:28  |  Hastaroth 24/01/07
  17.   The horror of zionist greed 13:42  |  Hannah 24/01/07
  18.   Then Israelis wonder why 13:42  |  Chris Linthwaite 24/01/07
  19.   #13, Ehad 14:05  |  Hannah 24/01/07
  20.   boycott 14:07  |  bev 24/01/07
  21.   #13 14:10  |  bev 24/01/07
  22.   #18 OK Chris Linthwaite,now explain please... 14:49  |  Hastaroth 24/01/07
  23.   to chris #18 14:56  |  Stayin Alive 24/01/07
  24.   to #13 shame on you for invoking the holocaust 14:59  |  SLAVO 24/01/07
  25.   To Bev in Bangkok 15:01  |  EhadHaAm 24/01/07
  26.   #10 PAUL HARRIS -- And Saudi has lowest rape ...so what 15:03  |  elroy 24/01/07
  27.   #22 Thats simple 15:04  |  Chris Linthwaite 24/01/07
  28.   ENOUGH OF CHECKPOINTS says Haass 15:05  |  B 24/01/07
  29.   # 12 - israeli mother i have questions 15:05  |  elroy 24/01/07
  30.   Boycott 15:17  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 24/01/07
  31.   Sooner or later 15:38  |  Guy From NYC 24/01/07
  32.   #26 ELROY IS SAUDI ARABIA ACOUNTRY ?? 15:40  |  paul harris 24/01/07
  33.   Amira Hass is a traitor.To follow her advice means to harm Israel 15:42  |  Vittorio 24/01/07
  34.   Video footage? 15:56  |  Dutch Dirk 24/01/07
  35.   No exploding grandmas – no checkpoints 16:06  |  Jonathan S 24/01/07
  36.   It is a pity reading many of the talkbacks 16:13  |  Noek 24/01/07
  37.   There is no nice way to have a checkpoint. 16:14  |  Marwan مروان خوري 24/01/07
  38.   Common Sense 16:16  |  Tamisan 24/01/07
  39.   5Previous entry contained an error) 16:16  |  Noek 24/01/07
  40.   Bev, WHAT fabricated storIES? 16:18  |  Angela 24/01/07
  41.   Again evidence of Israel`s apartheid policies. 16:20  |  anti-racist 24/01/07
  42.   The IDF Really Gets Off On This Crap! 16:22  |  Yaakov Sullivan 24/01/07
  43.   Slavo` convenience 16:22  |  Skandar 24/01/07
  44.   The IDF is no longer an army 16:24  |  SD 24/01/07
  45.   Haass and URINATION ETIQUETTE 16:31  |  B 24/01/07
  46.   #36, Noek 16:42  |  Hannah 24/01/07
  47.   Bev and Angela 16:44  |  Hannah 24/01/07
  48.   #41, Yaakov 16:54  |  Hannah 24/01/07
  49.   Marwan 16:58  |  Skandar 24/01/07
  50.   #27, Chris Linthwaite, next question: 17:00  |  Eugene 24/01/07
  51.   Enough with checkpoints already! 17:00  |  Omri 24/01/07
  52.   Dutch Dirk - video footage 17:01  |  SD 24/01/07
  53.   It`s endemic.. 17:06  |  Edithann 24/01/07
  54.   Morals grow short everywhere in this world. 17:06  |  Angel 24/01/07
  55.   AMIRA HASS 17:09  |  Gabe1 24/01/07
  56.   Blaming the Victims, Inability to accept responsibility 17:16  |  Ibrahim 24/01/07
  57.   Skandar, regarding Marwan 17:20  |  Ibrahim 24/01/07
  58.   Dutch-Dirk, good call on video footage 17:22  |  Ibrahim 24/01/07
  59.   angela 17:24  |  bev 24/01/07
  60.   What has this to do with SECURITY? 17:32  |  Arnie 24/01/07
  61.   hannah 17:34  |  bev 24/01/07
  62.   Amira`s attitude 17:36  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  63.   #49 Skandar. I am a proud Arab and a Zionist, thank you 17:37  |  Marwan مروان خوري 24/01/07
  64.   #30 Margie in Tel Aviv 17:38  |  Boycott 24/01/07
  65.   Jews were expelled from Arab lands 17:41  |  Bruriah Sarah 24/01/07
  66.   checkpoint 17:43  |  solemnman 24/01/07
  67.   #17 Hannah`s concerns 17:44  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  68.   CheckPoint Hell & humiliation 17:45  |  Ave 24/01/07
  69.   341 YOU KNOW ANTI RACIST THE ANTI SEMITES HAVE BEEN SAYING IT FOR 17:45  |  paul harris 24/01/07
  70.   Noek 36. You`re partly right. But Marwan is right too. 17:45  |  Polybios 24/01/07
  71.   US-Mexican Border - Legality of 17:47  |  Bruriah Sarah 24/01/07
  72.   #35 Jonathan S 17:49  |  Chris Linthwaite 24/01/07
  73.   #18 Linthwaite - Pals voted for Hamas - ISRAEL DIDN`T 17:52  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  74.   #38 Tamisan 17:56  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  75.   #37 your Lebanon will become Iran2 18:01  |  Tamir Gaza 24/01/07
  76.   Checkpoints 18:06  |  Salty 24/01/07
  77.   IDF and hasbarah 18:09  |  David 24/01/07
  78.   i billion marwans 18:21  |  bounce 24/01/07
  79.   #55 we all agree on Israel has the right to exist 18:23  |  Tamir Gaza 24/01/07
  80.   Boycott 18:25  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 24/01/07
  81.   Marwan Shifting with the wind - P1 18:28  |  Skandar 24/01/07
  82.   the point of the article 18:37  |  kobi 24/01/07
  83.   I love what the Israelis are doing! 18:39  |  Wiktor 24/01/07
  84.   To Linthwaite and his wrong equation 18:44  |  Jonathan S 24/01/07
  85.   Marwan Shifting with the wind - P2 18:46  |  Skandar 24/01/07
  86.   To Polybios, Marwan and Amira 18:47  |  Noek Keijzer 24/01/07
  87.   #73 Ben Jabo 18:48  |  Chris Linthwaite 24/01/07
  88.   #80 Margie in Tel Aviv 18:54  |  Boycott 24/01/07
  89.   Tamir`s right to vent 18:56  |  Skandar 24/01/07
  90.   Noek #87 I laud your sentiment, but... 19:13  |  Polybios 24/01/07
  91.   Boycott 19:18  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 24/01/07
  92.   #84 Jonathan S 19:21  |  Chris Linthwaite 24/01/07
  93.   #58 Ibrahim - If the Pali`s weren`t trying 19:25  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  94.   #58 Ibrahim - If the Pali`s weren`t trying 19:25  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  95.   By the way just because I support Israel does not mean I am not 19:25  |  Marwan مروان خوري 24/01/07
  96.   Israel is a DEMOCRACY. EVIL is a majority vote 19:29  |  Syd 24/01/07
  97.   RE:Marwan: There is no nice way to have a checkpoint 19:30  |  Guy From NYC ôìàôì 24/01/07
  98.   Amira is not deviating from already perverted love of terror 19:32  |  Johnny 24/01/07
  99.   Nice revisionism, Wiktor #83 19:33  |  Polybios 24/01/07
  100.   to #90 Polybios 19:39  |  Noek Keijzer 24/01/07
  101.   #12: occupation breads terror, terror was used by jews first 19:53  |  Jon 24/01/07
  102.   A `preverted` people require `preverted` checkpoints 19:54  |  Bimmer 24/01/07
  103.   Amira Hass?!?!?! 20:01  |  Adrian de Klerk 24/01/07
  104.   Marwan 20:03  |  Nizo the Palestinian 24/01/07
  105.   @ Guy from NYC 20:05  |  Adrian de Klerk 24/01/07
  106.   wiktor go and play with yourself 20:15  |  franksinatra 24/01/07
  107.   The conclusion 20:16  |  Yasar 24/01/07
  108.   Skandar re Marwan, he can`t go to lebanon 20:21  |  Tamir Gaza 24/01/07
  109.   #91 Margie in Tel Aviv 20:23  |  Boycott 24/01/07
  110.   appartheid??? 20:23  |  wasn`t me 24/01/07
  111.   Buriah - the result of a sectarian education 20:46  |  Tim 24/01/07
  112.   Marwan - Way off the subject 20:47  |  Najdt 24/01/07
  113.   boycott 20:51  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 24/01/07
  114.   Who`s the editor on duty tonight? 21:00  |  JB 24/01/07
  115.   #110 21:01  |  Metatron 24/01/07
  116.   27 - Settlements existed in 1973 as well 21:01  |  Bruriah Sarah 24/01/07
  117.   YOU SAID IT ALL STAYING ALIVE 21:04  |  TOBIA 24/01/07
  118.   Critics of Amira Hass 21:05  |  Justice Pundit 24/01/07
  119.   Israeli mother, You are my hero 21:08  |  TOMY 24/01/07
  120.   EhadHAam, you are right with a twist 21:18  |  TOMY 24/01/07
  121.   #106 21:26  |  alan 24/01/07
  122.   Adrian de Klerk 21:27  |  Guy From NYC 24/01/07
  123.   Israelis should have to go through checkpoints 21:34  |  Tiffany 24/01/07
  124.   #103 21:36  |  alan 24/01/07
  125.   Israel a democracy? 21:38  |  alan 24/01/07
  126.   Marwan - Way off the subject 21:41  |  Najdt 24/01/07
  127.   Noek #100. You misunderstand me, I guess 21:43  |  Polybios 24/01/07
  128.   #6 21:44  |  alan 24/01/07
  129.   Roadblocks are an unfortunate neccesity 21:46  |  Conolly Ryan 24/01/07
  130.   One sure does get sick 21:49  |  Daisy 24/01/07
  131.   Thanks to Hizbullah 21:53  |  Ali 24/01/07
  132.   113 Justice Pundit, et tu ad hominem? 22:12  |  Polybios 24/01/07
  133.   Evidence 22:26  |  Myles 24/01/07
  134.   #112 Margie in Tel Aviv 22:31  |  Boycott 24/01/07
  135.   Margie and aipac. 22:37  |  Billy Jack 24/01/07
  136.   to nizo 22:58  |  bounce 24/01/07
  137.   The usual topic: checkpoints 23:21  |  KUTW 24/01/07
  138.   Now tell us where to learn about Palestinian society! 23:23  |  McQueen 24/01/07
  139.   Force is the only option 23:24  |  Raed 24/01/07
  140.   #97 Guy from NYC (so he sez) 23:27  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  141.   #125 Alan - why are your British police 23:31  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  142.   I wonder if Amira Hass 23:34  |  KUTW 24/01/07
  143.   #134 - Boycott - It`s not Occupation it`s 23:34  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  144.   Vittorio - Amira Hass is a traitor?? 23:41  |  Stephen Connor 24/01/07
  145.   No. 15,Stephen Murray 23:47  |  j 24/01/07
  146.   #123 Tiffany`s checkpoints 23:49  |  * BEN JABO 24/01/07
  147.   15. Stephen Murray: Which occupation? 23:58  |  KUTW 24/01/07
  148.   17. Hannah: the horror 00:04  |  KUTW 25/01/07
  149.   Thank to Hizbullah indead # 131 Ali 00:04  |  Red 25/01/07
  150.   In the words of that illustrious American President Ronald Reagan 00:25  |  bat yam 25/01/07
  151.   #SD & Ibrahim; Video footage 00:47  |  Dutch Dirk 25/01/07
  152.   Thank you Amira 01:15  |  Larry Saltzman 25/01/07
  153.   HAARETZ COMRADESHIP 01:30  |  Harry 25/01/07
  154.   Perhaps rude at worst 01:38  |  Schtarker Yid 25/01/07
  155.   Amira Hass 01:59  |  KT 25/01/07
  156.   Dutch Dirk 02:00  |  KT 25/01/07
  157.   Thank you for this great article 02:19  |  Frederique 25/01/07
  158.   Response to checkpoint criticism 02:51  |  Noam 25/01/07
  159.   The Occupation is Destroying Israel 02:53  |  Jane 25/01/07
  160.   #34 Video footage 02:59  |  Lynn 25/01/07
  161.   #41 Just one question 03:05  |  Lynn 25/01/07
  162.   Reported opinion - re #6 03:22  |  JJ 25/01/07
  163.   checkpoints 03:38  |  hipolito dormal 25/01/07
  164.   Checkpoints, walls and whatever else may be necessary 03:58  |  Jacques-military Cdn 25/01/07
  165.   #151 Dutch Dirk 03:59  |  * BEN JABO 25/01/07
  166.   #17 Hey Hannah, the Discovery 04:02  |  ballistic 25/01/07
  167.   #21 Bev; what about the IDF soldier 04:09  |  ballistic 25/01/07
  168.   #140 I am from where I sez. 04:26  |  Larry 25/01/07
  169.   #2 Flashman 04:30  |  Harry D 25/01/07
  170.   Hannah-Continue Your Self- Delusions 04:43  |  Harry D 25/01/07
  171.   No Different.. before the Holocoust 04:50  |  An Honest American 25/01/07
  172.   gOD BLESS iSRAEL 04:52  |  JOEY 25/01/07
  173.   I sent before a responce, Haaretz didnot 04:57  |  TOMY 25/01/07
  174.   to Hastaroth #16 - an answer from the past 05:02  |  zeev 25/01/07
  175.   Not so schtarket yid! 05:23  |  Wiktor 25/01/07
  176.   to Jonathan S #35 05:30  |  zeev 25/01/07
  177.   Haas and Hamas. 05:37  |  Pierre 25/01/07
  178.   on Margie #113 06:27  |  zeev 25/01/07
  179.   #17 The Horror of Palestinian Kids Terror 06:34  |  * BEN JABO 25/01/07
  180.   Waiting at checkpoints. 06:34  |  Jack 25/01/07
  181.   If the Palestinians do not give or are not given a state of their 06:43  |  Jack 25/01/07
  182.   #169 - Jacks` checkpoints 06:52  |  * BEN JABO 25/01/07
  183.   #172 Jack`s Palestinian State 06:55  |  * BEN JABO 25/01/07
  184.   Checkpoints sure were starting to pop up in 1982. 07:02  |  Jack 25/01/07
  185.   #26 07:05  |  maria 25/01/07
  186.   circumvention of checkpoints 07:24  |  jack 25/01/07
  187.   concern for security 07:43  |  david 25/01/07
  188.   amir hass the antisemite 07:46  |  Ephraim 25/01/07
  189.   In the U.S. men who expose themselves are put in jail. 08:27  |  Timothy 25/01/07
  190.   We all love you. We all read you. Keep writing. 08:30  |  Timothy 25/01/07
  191.   Occupation mentality still prevails 08:37  |  isratinian 25/01/07
  192.   Boycott 09:05  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 25/01/07
  193.   #122 THE GUY FROM NY IS UTTERLY CONFUSED 09:21  |  paul harris 25/01/07
  194.   #95 MARWAN, WHAT????? 10:17  |  VIPER 25/01/07
  195.   #184 Jack`s checkpoint fixation 17:08  |  * BEN JABO 25/01/07
  196.   JACK 17:15  |  * BEN JABO 25/01/07
  197.   Amira, the checkpoints 23:29  |  Dutch 25/01/07
  198.   Question 23:59  |  Noam 25/01/07
  199.   on Ben Jabo #195 00:16  |  zeev 26/01/07
  200.   6 Margie in Tel Aviv, It`s so easy to blame others 00:18  |  Dutch 26/01/07
  201.   to Noam #198 - an answer 00:52  |  zeev 26/01/07
  202.   6 Margie, It`s always so much easier to blame others 00:53  |  Dutch 26/01/07
  203.   #166ballistic-here you go again 01:35  |  Ronnie J Pike II 26/01/07
  204.   on Ben Jabo #195 02:17  |  zeev 26/01/07
  205.   Dutch opposes checkpoints 04:55  |  * BEN JABO 26/01/07
  206.   Let us be just as stubborn in disbelief as the 06:59  |  Jason/FreddiemeetMo 26/01/07
  207.   #204 Zeev & Checkpoints 14:21  |  * BEN JABO 26/01/07
  208.   Daily ,more torture at check points 16:27  |  George 26/01/07
  209.   Zeev #199 # 204 Wake UP 16:32  |  * BEN JABO 26/01/07
  210.   too easy to make the "blanche colombe" 19:04  |  luccia 08/02/07
 Today Online
Siniora blasts 'violation' of Lebanese sovereignty
Responses: 197
Hundreds protest Temple Mount construction in J'lem
Responses: 150
Syrian President vows to keep supporting Hezbollah, Hamas
Responses: 85
Rosner: What does it matter how many U.S. Jews there are?
Responses: 52
Israel, U.S. begin talks on renewal of foreign aid package
Responses: 99
Aluf Benn: Bush forbidding Olmert from talking to Syria
Responses: 41


More Headlines
19:08 Egypt summons Israeli envoy over construction near Temple Mount
19:15 Siniora denounces IDF 'violation' of Lebanese sovereignty
16:38 Fatah source: Deal struck with Hamas on divvying up cabinet posts
18:22 Airports Authority confirms near-miss at Ben-Gurion Airport
16:50 Iran says it uncovered U.S.-Israeli spy network, detained suspects
19:07 New Justice Min.: Cheshin's comments don't warrant criminal probe
16:16 Beinisch: Gov't can do better job of fortifying schools near Gaza
18:13 Court reduces Klagsbald's jail term for causing fatal crash
17:12 PM to U.K.: Enact law prohibiting IDF officers' arrest in Britain
15:02 Natalie Portman considers directing film version of Amos Oz memoirs
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved