Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., February 10, 2007 Shvat 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:37 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 17:12 21/01/2007
Leave the U.S. embassy where it is
By Bradley Burston


My daughter's passport is part of the longest-running ruse in modern American politics.

Where other U.S. passports list place of birth as the name of a country, hers says, simply, Jerusalem.

No country. Certainly not Israel. Her passport, in a sense, is a non-paper.

Just as Washington's legation in West Jerusalem is a non-embassy. Despite explicit legislation to the contrary, the Bush White House and the Rice State Department have succeeded for years in ducking, evading, and stonewalling efforts to grant concrete form to recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital.

Taking the lead, George Bush has played fast and loose with Federal law - and with his own explicit campaign promises - in a six-year effort to resist moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem.

And, for once, George Bush has got something right.

He did it again last month. Hours before hosting American Jewish leaders for a lavishly photographed Hanukkah celebration, he signed an order deferring until mid-2007 the legally mandated transfer of the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.

From Bush's standpoint, the Jewish leaders took it well. Or, at least, quietly. With one exception. Morton Klein, national president of the Zionist Organization of America suggested that Bush's signing a six-month waiver to delay moving the embassy, as he has now done more than 10 times, would "give a victory to the forces of terror."

"We dare not be intimidated by and appease these terrorist bullies," Klein said in a statement, which directed much of its criticism against the silence of the other American Jewish dignitaries who attended the Hanukkah observance.

"We are also deeply disappointed that American Jewish organizations have been frozen into silence about this important issue. We also urge pro-Israel Christian groups like Reverend John Hagee's Christians United for Israel to speak out. Such failure may send another harmful message - that American Jewry does not care sufficiently about Jerusalem as Judaism's holiest place."

Moving the embassy, it should be noted, is one of Klein's signature issues. In July, 1999, as then-Texas governor Bush was raising funds in Newark, New Jersey for his run at the presidency, Klein approached Bush, citing Congress' overwhelming passage of the Jerusalem Embassy Act, which states:

"Jerusalem should be recognized as the capital of the State of Israel; and the United States Embassy in Israel should be established in Jerusalem no later than May 31, 1999."

Klein said to Bush "The Clinton administration has refused to honor pre-existing U.S. law and move the embassy to Jerusalem. Will you as president follow U.S. law and move the American Embassy to Jersualem immediately?"

"I'm afraid that might screw up the peace process," Bush replied, aware that the Israeli government had opposed the 1995 legislation. "I don't want to screw up the peace process."

His frat boy clumsiness notwithstanding, Bush was on to something. The embassy should stay where it is. Although Bush would later vow to make moving the embassy one of his first acts as president, his initial instincts were right. When there is a solution to the conflict, moving the embassy will be a certain result. In the absence of a solution, moving the embassy will move the peace process even further back.

In the cratered moonscape of diplomacy on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the White House has a special responsibility to act as a mediating and moderating influence. No other party can marshal the resources that the United States can, in acting as close as it can manage to the role of honest broker.

It's no longer a matter of policy. It's a matter of life and death.

The Palestinian movement for independence may now be in its worst state ever, its inability to provide for its needy at an all-time low, its international standing compromised as never before, its internal infighting spilling over into the targeting of Palestinian children.

Morton Klein's position, and that of the hardline ZOA, is that the Palestinians should be kicked when they are down.

The ZOA, which proudly opposes compromise, negotiation, and concession, believes that the only change in Israel's policy should be kicking the Palestinians harder, or finding a spot in which the Palestinians have yet to be kicked.

The real reason that the office of the U.S. ambassador continues to face the Mediterranean and not the Knesset, has everything to do with the difference between public service and lip service.

When the Embassy Act was first proposed, the Rabin government was against the legislation, which, as then-AIPAC executive director Neal Sher has noted, was also in direct contravention of AIPAC policy.

It wasn't meant to help Israel score points, it was meant to help the Republicans retake the Clinton White House. The new speaker of the house, Newt Gingrinch, saw the issue as a way to siphon pro-Israel support and campaign donations away from the Democrats. And the Republican front runner, Senator Robert Dole, who in the past had opposed legislation to relocate the embassy, was suddenly in the driver's seat of the moving van.

True, Israel needs recognition. But Israel and its western half of Jerusalem have survived, and thrived, without it for nearly 60 years. Recognition can wait.

What cannot wait is the possibility of diplomacy between Israel and the Palestinians. Every passing week, every Israeli and Palestinian casualty, every new settlement enterprise, makes a solution that much more pressing, and that much more remote.

Most Jewish leaders know that. Even AIPAC knows that.

Moving the embassy would not be a victory for Israel. Morton Klein wants Bush to move the embassy not as a victory for Israel, but as a victory for Morton Klein.

The United States knows very well that the capital of Israel is Jerusalem. Federal law has said so explicitly for more than a decade. But Washington also knows what Israel knows:

West Jerusalem will not be recognized as the capital of the Jewish state, until East Jerusalem becomes the capital of an independent Palestine.

There will not be a solution without a Palestinian state. There will be no Palestinian state without a share of Jerusalem as a recognized capital.

Washington has a unique and urgent responsibility to see to it that Israel follows through on commitments to ease the plight of Palestinian non-combatants, to truly remove checkpoints and allow freer movement of people and goods, rather than announcing counterfeit concessions the IDF has no intention of implementing.

Washington must press Israel to reduce to the lowest possible minimum, harm to Palestinian civilians in the context of fighting between the IDF and gunmen.

Washington must see to it that the route and the nature of the West Bank fence does not do harm to non-combatant Palestinians, that it does not keep them from their land and their livelihoods, that it does not divide between their children and an education, a future.

Just as Washington has a unique and urgent responsibility to see to it that Palestinian non-combatants stop suffering at the hands of their armed and irrational compatriots, whose actions are keeping international aid from reaching a growing number of the desperately needy in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

These are the tasks that Washington should be addressing, and with every measure of vigor, creativity, and intelligence that this administration can muster. If only for the sake of the legacy that George Bush will leave.

What Washington does not need to do, is to stage a provocation. That, at this stage, is the only real significance of moving the embassy.

The White House must explore every opportunity to work for a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians. Time is running out. For Israel, for the Palestinians, and perhaps most crucially, for George Bush.

___________________


Recent blogs:

Jimmy Carter's offensive against U.S. Jewry
Next year in Palestine
What's wrong with Israelis
The Archbishop's guide to Muslim intolerance

___________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.


Bookmark to del.icio.us
'Good Arabs'
Hillel Cohen's new book sheds light on Israel's dealings with its Arab citizens since 1948.
The trait of Sodom
How do the traits of Sodom and Gomorrah manifest in our day to day life?
  1.   Time is running out??? 10:47  |  Dror 21/01/07
  2.   MOVE THE ISRAELI EMBASSY TO NEW YORK 10:55  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  3.   The Palestinians should decide where Israel`s capital is? 11:12  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  4.   Foolish 11:35  |  Choni Davidowitz 21/01/07
  5.   WHAT BUSH CAN DO? 11:43  |  indrajaya 21/01/07
  6.   survival of the state 11:44  |  Dror 21/01/07
  7.   Resolution 181 11:52  |  Marilyn 21/01/07
  8.   Jerusalem the eternal capital of the Jewish State 11:58  |  Ben Uziel 21/01/07
  9.   # 2 move the Embassy to New York 12:02  |  Leb 21/01/07
  10.   7 MARYLIN ALL SUPERCEDED BY 242 12:06  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  11.   # 7 Marilyn - We all know that all force counts in Israel not law 12:08  |  Leb 21/01/07
  12.   you can`t steal my capital and claim as yours 12:11  |  Khalid 21/01/07
  13.   Chni Davidowitz: The same God will give to the Muslims again 12:17  |  Khalid 21/01/07
  14.   Regarding al-Quds 12:29  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  15.   Paralyzed by fear 12:30  |  Seth Greenberg 21/01/07
  16.   #12 FUNNY KHALID THE QURAN DOESNT MENTION IT 12:31  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  17.   #8, ben Uziel 12:53  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  18.   Khalid: Your capital is in Mecca. You stole Jerusalem 13:02  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  19.   242 does not supersede 181 13:02  |  Marilyn 21/01/07
  20.   #12, Khalid 13:04  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  21.   So all those Jews are Palestinians? 13:06  |  Marilyn 21/01/07
  22.   Marilyn: Lecturing Jews from Australia you stole from Aborigines 13:06  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  23.   Arabs around centuries before Jews 13:09  |  Marilyn 21/01/07
  24.   Provocation? 13:10  |  dov epstein 21/01/07
  25.   #15, Seth 13:11  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  26.   #19 I SUGGEST YOU DOWNLOAD LORD CARADON 13:17  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  27.   THIS is a very sensible article. 13:24  |  Marge 21/01/07
  28.   DURING " PARTICION of PALESTINE" 13:39  |  Paula 21/01/07
  29.   Ramallah forever 13:42  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  30.   ##22, Yaakov 13:44  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  31.   #27, Marge 13:47  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  32.   Jerusalem the capital 13:51  |  Abby 21/01/07
  33.   Which country would want an Embassy 13:59  |  Choni Davidowitz 21/01/07
  34.   #28 EH WHICH LEAGUE OF NATIONS WAS THIS ??? 14:07  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  35.   The planet continues to revolve and evolve 14:22  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  36.   yakov # 18 14:24  |  Mohammed 21/01/07
  37.   #30 Hannah: Using Jews & Israel to change the topic 14:24  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  38.   #28, Yonatan 14:27  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  39.   Hannah, why should we take your views seriously in light of the 14:29  |  Yechiel 21/01/07
  40.   #28, Paula 14:29  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  41.   Marilyn 14:34  |  Jonathan Wortman 21/01/07
  42.   I would love to see how Hannah and Marilyn fare in Gaza. 14:41  |  albert amato 21/01/07
  43.   # 14 Hannah 14:42  |  christa 21/01/07
  44.   bush does not care about Israel 14:45  |  Lori Cowan 21/01/07
  45.   #32, Yaakov 15:00  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  46.   #32 Mohammed: History according to Moslem propaganda & revision 15:01  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  47.   Is Bradley Burston Complicit 15:07  |  Donald Duck 21/01/07
  48.   #43, Christa 15:09  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  49.   # 46 Yakov 15:17  |  Mohammed 21/01/07
  50.   #13: khalid: don`t hold your breath! 15:17  |  wasn`t me 21/01/07
  51.   Move the embassy to Jerusalem 15:22  |  Steven 21/01/07
  52.   Is what Yehiel writes about you true, Hannah? 15:25  |  Galit 21/01/07
  53.   The whole of Jerusalem should be governed by the UN 15:35  |  John 21/01/07
  54.   ...to Khalid #12first try to get Gaza clean..IDF stolen the soap? 15:35  |  UGY the she camel 21/01/07
  55.   Hannah: You can`t take the heat of the truth. 15:47  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  56.   Hannah #35...you know nothing about US politics. 16:03  |  albert amato 21/01/07
  57.   #12 KHALID, NONSENSE 16:13  |  Steven 21/01/07
  58.   Yaccove..if Mecca is my capital then Warsaw is yours 16:17  |  Palestinian 21/01/07
  59.   #50, Steven 16:18  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  60.   #38 Hannah - from your mouth to God`s ears 16:22  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  61.   Morton Klein 16:23  |  LL 21/01/07
  62.   #56, LL 16:47  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  63.   The Writing Is On The Wall 16:47  |  Danny Boy 21/01/07
  64.   Marilyn 16:51  |  George 21/01/07
  65.   Force is indeed the only law 17:02  |  George 21/01/07
  66.   #63, Danny Boy 17:04  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  67.   Hannah 17:06  |  LL 21/01/07
  68.   US Embassy in Sderot 17:07  |  Nora 21/01/07
  69.   Speaking of land theft... 17:12  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  70.   Jerusalem`s G-d given sanctity 17:18  |  Ben Azai 21/01/07
  71.   Not interested in kicking Arabs, interested in establishing Jewis 17:18  |  B 21/01/07
  72.   Embassy solution 17:22  |  Joe 21/01/07
  73.   Next year in Belorusia 17:23  |  Nora 21/01/07
  74.   John # 53 West Jerusalem 17:26  |  Jeff Northridge 21/01/07
  75.   #7 Marilyn 17:28  |  Joe 21/01/07
  76.   #68, Joe 17:29  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  77.   George #64 17:32  |  Sarah 21/01/07
  78.   Reply to Khalid #12 17:33  |  Sherlock Holmes 21/01/07
  79.   palestinian:warsaw is yours 17:34  |  wh 21/01/07
  80.   Good Idea 17:35  |  Mark Lincoln 21/01/07
  81.   #66 Hannah 17:36  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  82.   #49 Mohammed: Thank you for your admission. 17:39  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  83.   Hannah. let`s make a deal 17:42  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  84.   "Most crucially, for George Bush"? 17:43  |  Efox 21/01/07
  85.   #67, LL 17:44  |  Hannah 21/01/07
  86.   Nora vs. Hannah 17:46  |  Yechiel 21/01/07
  87.   #58 Palestinian: Your Golden Nipple is on my Temple Mount 17:47  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  88.   Pal State? 17:53  |  Shmuel 21/01/07
  89.   The Real Reason 17:53  |  Jeff Northridge 21/01/07
  90.   Khalid, i doubt that anything will be changed if you get 17:55  |  dzone 21/01/07
  91.   Checkpoints and terrorism 17:57  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  92.   What should be done to avoid harming pal ?civilians? 18:01  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  93.   Move it to Chernobyl 18:08  |  Amin Nusseibeh 21/01/07
  94.   Jerusalem is the Jews? capital 18:09  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  95.   ..to Hannah... 18:18  |  UGY the she camel 21/01/07
  96.   Bradley seems to take pro pal stance 18:22  |  Joseph E . 21/01/07
  97.   7. Marilyn: The Arabs stole the land 18:52  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  98.   12. Khalid: The Jordanians did 19:05  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  99.   My Jerusalem is a city of Peace , , , 19:09  |  Joseph E . 21/01/07
  100.   14. Hannah : Regarding Jerusalem 19:10  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  101.   20 Hannah re #12, Khalid 19:15  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  102.   Jeff Northridge # 78 19:22  |  Danny Boy 21/01/07
  103.   Actually... 19:22  |  Yosemite 21/01/07
  104.   #58 Palestinian: Your lies 19:36  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  105.   KUTW: the evangelical bin laden 19:45  |  Christian 21/01/07
  106.   97Christian and Bin Laden 19:58  |  KUTW 21/01/07
  107.   Reply to Hannah #35 20:10  |  Joe 21/01/07
  108.   U.S.A. President:His Frat Boy Clumsiness 20:23  |  Wise Syrian 21/01/07
  109.   Hannah struck dumb? 20:25  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  110.   #93 Amin Nusseibeh 20:33  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  111.   Danny Boy # 99 It Doesn`t Mean Much 20:50  |  Jeff Northridge 21/01/07
  112.   Read `em and weep, O mine enemies! 21:19  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  113.   Saudis may divide their Mecca and Medina with Iran-Shi`ite & pals 21:20  |  Joseph E . 21/01/07
  114.   no mention of jerusalem in entire koran!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 21:29  |  Jim 21/01/07
  115.   #87 speaking of genes, er, what 21:31  |  ballistic 21/01/07
  116.   #19, of COURSE 242 supercedes 181 21:36  |  goliath 21/01/07
  117.   #115 ballistic - you got something against Ethiopians? 22:07  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  118.   A two-meter "share of Jerusalem" 22:21  |  Yonatan 21/01/07
  119.   Yonatan # 109 Complicated Stuff 22:30  |  Jeff Northridge 21/01/07
  120.   U.S. Embassy 22:37  |  n_erber 21/01/07
  121.   Yonatan 23:18  |  David 21/01/07
  122.   Hannah 23:39  |  LL 21/01/07
  123.   #26 Paul Harris and Lord Caradon 23:47  |  Johnboy 21/01/07
  124.   Another seperate standard for Jews 00:13  |  Dr David I Gross 22/01/07
  125.   ballistic hate monger @115 00:14  |  Conolly Ryan 22/01/07
  126.   Johnboy # 123 Aha! 01:20  |  Jeff Northridge 22/01/07
  127.   @110, yonatan on nusseibe 01:22  |  vladimir 22/01/07
  128.   @112, yonatan 01:29  |  vladimir 22/01/07
  129.   Moving Embassy sticking point in peace process? I think not! 01:42  |  Gili 22/01/07
  130.   Conolly Ryan # 125 DNA 02:05  |  Jeff Northridge 22/01/07
  131.   Over US`ed Embassy? 02:28  |  jean bourgeot 22/01/07
  132.   Burston`s Personal Attacks 02:31  |  HowrdMadris 22/01/07
  133.   #37 Yacov--er, are you suggesting that 02:38  |  ballistic 22/01/07
  134.   #117 Yonatan; er, you really don`t know what you are talking 02:47  |  ballistic 22/01/07
  135.   #125 that`s some name you have as a rah 02:56  |  ballistic 22/01/07
  136.   #130 Jeff, I`d like to add, given what 03:04  |  ballistic 22/01/07
  137.   #129 "Israel should do as it damn pleases 04:19  |  ballistic 22/01/07
  138.   80# Mark Lincoln & ellipsis of history. 04:37  |  Akram Zekaria 22/01/07
  139.   114#Jim Would you believe it !? 04:52  |  Akram Zekaria 22/01/07
  140.   #126 Jeff Northridge Part 1 04:52  |  Johnboy 22/01/07
  141.   ballistic # 136 Judaism Is a Religion Not a Race 06:27  |  Jeff Northridge 22/01/07
  142.   Palestinian Rights And Peace 06:41  |  Tim 22/01/07
  143.   113#Joseph E. Well done my boy ! 06:52  |  Akram Zekaria 22/01/07
  144.   Johnboy # 140 Backpedaling Are You? 06:58  |  Jeff Northridge 22/01/07
  145.   Why Bush delays on moving embassy- 08:17  |  Voice of Reason 22/01/07
  146.   #123 JOHNBOYand confusion LORD CARADN SAID 08:47  |  paul harris 22/01/07
  147.   #141, Jeff and #136, Ballistic 08:55  |  Hannah 22/01/07
  148.   #144 Jeff, it can advance any claim it wants 08:58  |  Johnboy 22/01/07
  149.   #142 Tim 09:03  |  Johnboy 22/01/07
  150.   bush`s message is clear 09:20  |  eric 22/01/07
  151.   Johnboy #149 Read What Who Said It! It Was A Palestinian 09:59  |  Tim 22/01/07
  152.   Johnboy #149 This Is Another Rule of The GC 11:01  |  Tim 22/01/07
  153.   Not one constructive thought 11:52  |  disgusted 22/01/07
  154.   US embassy already being built in jerusalem 16:37  |  concerned 22/01/07
  155.   #154 Just fluff, just fluff 16:46  |  ballistic 22/01/07
  156.   PALESTINIAN PROPAGANDA RULES ISRAEL 17:08  |  BMT 22/01/07
  157.   # 96 Josheph E. SIMPLU PUT.DISTASTEFUL ARTICLE,AND BUSH`S ETERNAL 17:43  |  Kathy 22/01/07
  158.   to 114 - a question 20:36  |  Blinky the Fish 22/01/07
  159.   Moving the U.S. Embassy 21:42  |  Thomas Lowinger 22/01/07
  160.   peace process??? 22:14  |  adam 22/01/07
  161.   Israel`s one and only capital - JERUSALEM! 23:51  |  RA 22/01/07
  162.   #151 Tim 00:42  |  Johnboy 23/01/07
  163.   #152 Tim tries the OTHER zionist SOP 00:46  |  Johnboy 23/01/07
  164.   #146 Paul Harris, no, I understand Caradon perfectly well 01:01  |  Johnboy 23/01/07
  165.   #125 wht do you know about this, Conolly Ryan 03:32  |  ballistic 23/01/07
  166.   #65 Hey George--that`s the same 03:37  |  ballistic 23/01/07
  167.   Johnboy #163 On SOP 07:02  |  Tim 23/01/07
  168.   #167 Tim, yep, moral equivalence 03:11  |  Johnboy 24/01/07
  169.   as if the arabs would care 02:54  |  John 30/01/07
  170.   Johnboy #168 You Obviously Don`t Kapish 07:32  |  Tim 10/02/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: The Al-Aqsa Mosque is good for the Jews
Responses: 119
Shmuel Rosner: How much U.S. money should Israel ask for?
Responses: 96
Yoel Marcus: Temple Mount construction is worse than a crime
Responses: 125
Amira Hass: Israel plays role in sparking anti-Fatah bitterness
Responses: 129
Abbas and Meshal reach unity deal in Mecca meet
Responses: 172
Zvi Bar'el: Unity deal is minimum required to remove the siege
Responses: 122
Rosner's Domain
* Blog and Poll: Is helping Israel financially in the best interest of the United States?
* What can one do with so many new Jews?
* FAQ on the state of affairs in the Middle East
* On the Crisis of America's Israel Lobby


More Headlines
03:10 Russia welcomes Mecca deal, urges lifting freeze
02:49 Rioters leave Temple Mount peacefully after clashes over dig
03:50 Livni: Peace with Palestinians feasible, violence must end first
07:12 Elie Wiesel says he escaped kidnap attempt in U.S. hotel
18:37 Hundreds attend reinterment of murdered French Jewish man
03:23 IAEA suspends nearly half of technical aid projects with Tehran
18:31 Four Qassams strike western Negev, no damage reported
19:16 Russia jails five teenagers for killing Jewish man
18:24 Lebanese minister: Seized Hezbollah arms will be used by army
13:34 Security sources: Mecca truce may speed up Shalit's release
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved