Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., January 25, 2007 Shvat 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:46 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 08:31 21/01/2007
Carter defends controversial book as 'accurate and needed'
By The Associated Press

ATHENS, GEORGIA - Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter said the storm of criticism he has faced for his recent book has not weakened his resolve for fair treatment of Israelis and Palestinians.

"I have been called a liar," Carter said at a town hall meeting on Saturday, the second day of a three-day symposium on his presidency at the University of Georgia.

"I have been called an anti-Semite," he said. "I have been called a bigot. I have been called a plagiarist. I have been called a coward. Those kind of accusations, they concern me, but they don't detract from the fact the book is accurate and is needed."

Advertisement

Following the publication of the book: "Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid," 14 members of an advisory board to his Carter Center resigned in protest. Those former board members and other critics contend the book is unfairly critical of Israel.

"Not one of the critics of my book has contradicted any of the basic premises ... that is the horrible persecution and oppression of the Palestinian people and secondly that the formula for finding peace in the Middle East already exists," the 82-year-old Carter said.

Carter said he was pleased the book has stimulated discussion of an issue that has been "omitted from the public consciousness" for at least the last six years.

"Israel needs peace and the Palestinian people need peace and justice and I hope my limited influence will help to precipitate some steps," he said.

Also Saturday, Carter, at times emotional, told his audience how he saved the 1978 Camp David peace talks when it appeared Egyptian president Anwar Sadat would leave.

Carter said in the first three days of the talks Sadat and Israeli prime minister Menachem Begin often argued. After about a week, Carter said, Sadat reached a breaking point and packed his bags to return to Egypt - and Carter "knelt down and prayed and I asked God to help me."

Carter said he then walked to Sadat's cabin.

"Sadat and I stood with our noses almost touching and I told him that he had betrayed me and betrayed his own people and if he left our, friendship was severed forever and the relationship between the United States and Egypt would suffer."

Sadat agreed to stay, and the Camp David Accords were signed after 12 days of negotiations.

The three-day conference was arranged to mark the 30th anniversary of Carter's 1977 inauguration.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Someplace like home
Recently Israel has witnessed a boom of small hotels, each with its own unique charm.
Free cell
New companies are planning to offer technologies that will reduce our cell phone bills.
  1.   Allergy to Peanuts 08:54  |  FOX 21/01/07
  2.   By now, Carter should appologize to all Israelis and for that 09:23  |  Nadav 21/01/07
  3.   old foool is as relevant as yesterday`s rain.. 09:44  |  Mike 21/01/07
  4.   carter "i told sadat he had betrayed me" 09:56  |  absalom 21/01/07
  5.   the lying candidate and president haS NOT REFORMED 10:00  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  6.   Denial, the story of Jimmy Carter 10:05  |  Josue 21/01/07
  7.   I wonder why he did not comment on assisting an SS guard 10:07  |  Martin 21/01/07
  8.   Put carter`s book alongside Walt & Mearsheimer`s Harvard Report 10:10  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  9.   hey fox 10:14  |  cool 21/01/07
  10.   Yeah right 10:18  |  Sherman 21/01/07
  11.   to #1 FOX 10:18  |  Archangel 21/01/07
  12.   "Follow the money" - Will Do, FOX 10:20  |  Victor Smolinsky 21/01/07
  13.   If you think he`s wrong, address his point 10:24  |  Victor 21/01/07
  14.   Well said, Jimmy Carter. 10:24  |  Nick Ferriman 21/01/07
  15.   better peanuts than pipelines 10:27  |  ori 21/01/07
  16.   OH FOX, REALLY!!! 10:32  |  VIPER 21/01/07
  17.   President Carter 10:33  |  Charles Frith 21/01/07
  18.   Read this 10:36  |  Oh please 21/01/07
  19.   Carter should either agree that he is a liar, anti-semite, bigot, 10:37  |  Vittorio 21/01/07
  20.   As the Queen of Sheba might say . . . 10:45  |  JW 21/01/07
  21.   Carter 10:46  |  English Resident 21/01/07
  22.   "How he save the peace talks" 10:49  |  James Stevens 21/01/07
  23.   "omitted from the public conscious"? 11:02  |  Toma P 21/01/07
  24.   Arab oil money bought and paid for Carter the harem boy 11:05  |  Yacov 21/01/07
  25.   Palestinians 11:07  |  Were`s Waldo 21/01/07
  26.   Carter 11:07  |  S 21/01/07
  27.   victor smolensky 11:27  |  flashman 21/01/07
  28.   not to worry smolensky old bean 11:29  |  flashman 21/01/07
  29.   CARTER IS A GREAT MAN - ISRAELIS CAN LEARN FROM HIM 11:38  |  Markus 21/01/07
  30.   Jimbo Carter 11:39  |  Dror 21/01/07
  31.   Flashman # 27 11:43  |  Victor Smolinsky 21/01/07
  32.   #17 BUT THE BOOK DOES THE REVERSE AND IS NOT FOR PEACE 11:52  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  33.   CARTER`S SERVICE FOR PEACE WAS UNQUESTIONABLE 11:56  |  indrajaya 21/01/07
  34.   He Most Certainly IS A Liar 11:58  |  Ben Israel 21/01/07
  35.   i read the book 12:09  |  fadi 21/01/07
  36.   to the most ungrateful bunch of sob the world has ever sem 12:09  |  niccolo machiavelli 21/01/07
  37.   Carter 12:12  |  Paul 21/01/07
  38.   #29 IS MARKUS TALKING ABOUT THE US A 12:18  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  39.   FOOL&bilge.Like making "smart" comments about an eye operation 12:22  |  PETER SM 21/01/07
  40.   THANK YOU President Carter. KEEP UP The Good Work! 12:22  |  Proud Pal Defender 21/01/07
  41.   FOOL What "Harvard" report? 12:32  |  PETER SM 21/01/07
  42.   #11 Archangel re FOX#1 12:39  |  eve 21/01/07
  43.   Cool re #9 12:48  |  FOX 21/01/07
  44.   For Peter SM # 39 12:50  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  45.   OH VIPER REALLY 12:51  |  eve 21/01/07
  46.   how the Jews squeal... 12:58  |  Mike 21/01/07
  47.   N.Machiavelli.Ungrateful you mean Pal terror in Egypt or Jordan? 12:59  |  PETER SM 21/01/07
  48.   Too much fuss about Carter 13:02  |  Sidney 21/01/07
  49.   Carter`s Book 13:12  |  Tony 21/01/07
  50.   You shouldn`t go there, Peter SM # 41 13:13  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  51.   FOOL and ptosis.Garbage!Maybe on the 2 bit National `elff 13:21  |  PETER SM 21/01/07
  52.   The arab paradox 13:22  |  Marilyn 21/01/07
  53.   Hey Victor #12 13:23  |  FOX 21/01/07
  54.   FOOL #41.Ignoring most of my points and answering with a diatribe 13:31  |  PETER SM 21/01/07
  55.   # 49, TONY 13:32  |  indrajaya 21/01/07
  56.   What Israelis can`t stomach is 13:34  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/01/07
  57.   Archangel #11 13:35  |  FOX 21/01/07
  58.   For Peter SM # 54 on the Harvard Study 14:00  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  59.   Good Advice from Sidney (Post No. 48) 14:09  |  Johnny Weintraub 21/01/07
  60.   To Indrajaya re: neocons 14:15  |  David James Vickery 21/01/07
  61.   #56 WHICH POINTS CHRIS ? HE HASNT MADE ANY 14:15  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  62.   Don`t knock the National Health Service, Peter SM # 51 14:17  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  63.   Dr. Kenneth W. Stein refutes Carter on every point 14:18  |  albert amato 21/01/07
  64.   #52 MARYLIN DENIES HISTORY AND GETS IT WRONG AGAIN 14:21  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  65.   Hey, FOX #53 14:24  |  Victor Smolinsky 21/01/07
  66.   Carter lie on page 184 of the book.. 14:32  |  albert amato 21/01/07
  67.   Arafat`s Ghostwriter 14:42  |  Klaudia 21/01/07
  68.   Jimmy big lip Carter 14:45  |  Chaim Gorenstein 21/01/07
  69.   the only fact that counts 14:55  |  Dude 21/01/07
  70.   #61 Paul 15:01  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/01/07
  71.   Clicfool #62 National Health a joke and my colleagues agree 15:07  |  albert amato 21/01/07
  72.   # 60 David James Vickery, Chenney was elected for a 4 year term 15:16  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 21/01/07
  73.   For Albert Amato - on the NHS # 71 15:21  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  74.   Another Carter lie about Resolution 242 15:21  |  albert amato 21/01/07
  75.   WHO CARES ABOUT CARTER. WE KNEW ALL ALONG. 15:27  |  Bob 21/01/07
  76.   Apartheid: A strange word for a strange time 15:32  |  Ronnie Wolman 21/01/07
  77.   Jimmy The Dhimmi 15:43  |  Klaudia 21/01/07
  78.   #12 The Jews are a philantropic people 15:49  |  Sidney 21/01/07
  79.   #75 Ronnie Wolman 16:00  |  Chris Linthwaite 21/01/07
  80.   Debate 16:04  |  Marco 21/01/07
  81.   Debate 16:04  |  Marco 21/01/07
  82.   fadi #35 Higher standards for Israel 16:11  |  TM 21/01/07
  83.   NICE ARTICLE... I SEE DISCUSSION CONTINUES... 16:17  |  Smadar 21/01/07
  84.   "omitted from the public conscious"? 16:19  |  Tomas P 21/01/07
  85.   How could People 16:33  |  Mary 21/01/07
  86.   Marilyn @52 16:36  |  the arab paradox 21/01/07
  87.   For Albert Amato 16:40  |  Clickfool 21/01/07
  88.   victor smolensky as i expected could not 16:51  |  flashman