Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., January 22, 2007 Shvat 3, 5767 | | Israel Time: 00:44 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A view of Maskiot. (Archives)
Last update - 17:20 19/01/2007
Likud MK: Annexation is solution to flip-flop on new settlement
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent, and Haaretz Service

MK Yisrael Katz (Likud) has submitted a bill calling on Israel to annex the Jordan Valley, in response to Defense Minister Amir Peretz's decision to freeze a controversial plan to establish a new settlement there, Israel Radio reported Friday.

Imposing Israeli sovereignty on the Jordan Valley is the solution to Peretz's waffling, Israel Radio quoted Katz as saying. He said the Jordan Valley is Israel's eastern security zone and must be strengthened and settled.

Peretz retracted his approval of the construction of 100 housing units after the December announcement of a new settlement, Maskiot, sparked criticism from the United States and Europe as well as Peretz's fellow Labor Party members. Now he faces criticism from the Israeli left and right for failing to set a consistent policy on settlements.

Advertisement

A Defense Ministry representative informed the Jordan Valley regional council Thursday that the construction was suspended until further notice, Israel Radio reported. It had been slated to begin in a few days.

The housing, which was going to be used for families from the evacuated Gaza settlement bloc of Gush Katif, would have made Maskiot the first new settlement in more than a decade.

"Peretz is trying to win political gains at the expense of the evacuees," the Gush Katif Settlers Council said Friday. "The defense minister is doing everything to prevent the rehabilitation of the people of Gush Katif and their return to a normal life."

Dubi Tal, head of the Jordan Valley regional council, said he would appeal the decision to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. He told Israel Radio on Friday that Peretz's decision demonstrates that the upcoming Labor Party primaries are more important than settling the Jordan Valley.

Dror Etkes, coordinator of Peace Now's settlement monitoring division, said Peretz's reversal shows that the government is incapable of formulating a long-term policy on the settlement issue.

"Peretz's zigzagging in the Maskiot case reflects the confusion on the political level, which reacts to pressure - one time from the settlers and one time from the world - but does not formulate an organized policy on the matter," he said.

Shortly after the construction was publicized, the U.S. State Department condemned the decision, and foreign embassies in Israel, including those of European Union countries, demanded clarifications from the government.


Bookmark to del.icio.us
Jerusalem of soul
The Jerusalem jazz scene is blossoming as people become open to the music.
Jumping for joy
Jumping on a trampoline has recently been recognized as an official Olympic event.
  1.   Maskiot WILL Be Built 09:49  |  Yishai Kohen 19/01/07
  2.   Finally wisdom prevails! 10:06  |  Bandar Michaels 19/01/07
  3.   Peretz and a freeze 10:09  |  jeremy 19/01/07
  4.   #1, Yishai Kohen 10:19  |  Fritz 19/01/07
  5.   Peretz again sells out. Supports Judenrein and ethnic cleansing. 10:34  |  Yacov 19/01/07
  6.   USA`s 51st state 10:34  |  Ben Uziel 19/01/07
  7.   For Yishai Kohen # 1 re Maskiot 10:38  |  Clickfool 19/01/07
  8.   Peretz has a stronger personality than Olmert 10:44  |  Tamir Gaza 19/01/07
  9.   #8 Tamir - So why did he approve it in the first place? 11:19  |  krystal 19/01/07
  10.   #4 Fritz 11:23  |  Yishai Kohen 19/01/07
  11.   THIS IS WHY LABOR CAN NEVER BE IN A COALITION 11:28  |  paul harris 19/01/07
  12.   For Clickfool #7: You Never Learn, Do You? 11:30  |  Yishai Kohen 19/01/07
  13.   clickfool we do not go to foreign lands 11:30  |  flashman 19/01/07
  14.   BLINDED BY UNLIMITED GREED 11:45  |  indrajaya 19/01/07
  15.   Peretz and the freeze 11:52  |  joelle finkelstein 19/01/07
  16.   Fear of George W. Bush 12:04  |  Monk 19/01/07
  17.   To Yishai Kohen 12:21  |  Jonathan S 19/01/07
  18.   indrajaya you are in urgent need of english 12:21  |  bong bong 19/01/07
  19.   7 To Clickfool 12:26  |  Jurgi 19/01/07
  20.   Who belives 12:32  |  Jurgi 19/01/07
  21.   #10, Yishai Kohen 12:37  |  Fritz 19/01/07
  22.   DM Peretz political manipulation 12:40  |  Joseph E . 19/01/07
  23.   Yishai Kohen . . . . 12:57  |  revoltop 19/01/07
  24.   Yishai Kohen 13:03  |  Axel 19/01/07
  25.   # 7 clickfool 13:07  |  Axel 19/01/07
  26.   # 6 Ben Uziel 13:14  |  Axel 19/01/07
  27.   Yishai Kohen, no one else interprets international law like this! 13:14  |  tuairimiocht 19/01/07
  28.   Number 7 13:19  |  tuairimiocht 19/01/07
  29.   FRITZ needs to learn some truth 13:42  |  Penny 19/01/07
  30.   The US did not condemn it ! This is an HaAretz slant on things ! 13:45  |  redmike 19/01/07
  31.   For Yishai Kohen 14:01  |  Michele 19/01/07
  32.   Keep it frozen and don`t thaw it out 14:10  |  Tzfonit 19/01/07
  33.   Axel: You Clearly Don`t Know History 14:11  |  Yishai Kohen 19/01/07
  34.   #12 Yishai Kohen - Wrong. Clickfool - Right. Part 2 14:17  |  Johnboy 19/01/07
  35.   And # 12, Yishai, with regard to 14:27  |  Axel 19/01/07
  36.   #13 flashman: been asleep, I see.. 14:31  |  Johnboy 19/01/07
  37.   # 13 flashman 14:35  |  Axel 19/01/07
  38.   krystal, maybe he appoved it because of Israel`s pressure 14:41  |  Tamir Gaza 19/01/07
  39.   Kohen #1 14:54  |  JJ 19/01/07
  40.   Johnboy: Wrong- Period/Axel: Learn English 14:55  |  Yishai Kohen 19/01/07
  41.   BRACHA/Tzfonit #57 14:57  |  Gabe1 19/01/07
  42.   #4. Fritz (Unique as his HITLER): Covenant is valid. Hitler isn`t 14:59  |  Vittorio 19/01/07
  43.   Freeze the Worthless Road Map 15:01  |  Marcel 19/01/07
  44.   Too Public. AGamble and Israel Lost 15:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/01/07
  45.   The United States State Department Rules Israel? 15:15  |  Johnny Weintraub 19/01/07
  46.   #24 HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE AXEL WHEN JORDAN BELONGS TO ISRAEL 15:16  |  paul harris 19/01/07
  47.   The territories belong to Israel 15:17  |  Brod 19/01/07
  48.   Yacov Ashkelon: Ethnic cleasing`s the word 15:21  |  Andreas 19/01/07
  49.   #35 BECAUSE AXEL IN THE END IT WILL BE THE ONLY VIABLE SOLUTION 15:24  |  paul harris 19/01/07
  50.   ...to Clickfool #7...we kill them... 15:28  |  abraham...mico 19/01/07
  51.   The US says "NO" 15:29  |  Howard Green 19/01/07
  52.   Forget Maskiot 15:29  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  53.   Religious fanatism obstacle to peace 15:34  |  Andreas 19/01/07
  54.   #29 Penny 15:38  |  Baal 19/01/07
  55.   For Yishai Kohen and his sleekit post # 12 15:47  |  Clickfool 19/01/07
  56.   axel: I couldn`t agree with u more!!!! 15:50  |  Ben Uziel 19/01/07
  57.   johnboy the foreign land we beat the crap out of 15:51  |  flashman 19/01/07
  58.   Axel vs. Yishai Kohen 15:54  |  Na`amah 19/01/07
  59.   johnboy using schoolyard toilet humour 15:55  |  flashman 19/01/07
  60.   # 19 Jurgi 15:56  |  Lynn 19/01/07
  61.   johnboy misunderstands the yom kippur war in 1973 16:00  |  flashman 19/01/07
  62.   #34 16:02  |  Lynn 19/01/07
  63.   johnboy "wee little nap in lebanon" 16:06  |  flashman 19/01/07
  64.   Yacov Ashkelon is one of millions #42 16:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/01/07
  65.   #39 Hey Paul; you are awake, say 16:09  |  ballistic 19/01/07
  66.   johnboy you do not make yourself clear 16:09  |  flashman 19/01/07
  67.   johnboy "fitful dreams" 16:11  |  flashman 19/01/07
  68.   #40 more delusional BS 16:15  |  ballistic 19/01/07
  69.   Jurgi #19 16:16  |  albert amato 19/01/07
  70.   #46 Tosefta @ Tveria / Israel 16:18  |  Joseph E . 19/01/07
  71.   #30 hey Red mike---you guys are 16:20  |  ballistic 19/01/07
  72.   Margie and Jasmine, were are you? 16:20  |  Leb 19/01/07
  73.   tosefta policy-lite 16:21  |  flashman 19/01/07
  74.   #42 Andreas: Goyim always excuse ethnic cleansing of Jews 16:24  |  Yacov 19/01/07
  75.   #12 Yishai Kohen - Wrong. Clickfool - Right. Part 1 16:24  |  Johnboy 19/01/07
  76.   #45 Howard 16:25  |  Leb 19/01/07
  77.   BRACHA/Tsfonit #32 16:32  |  Gabe1 19/01/07
  78.   Misinterpretation: The Palestinians "gave up" claims to West Bank 16:33  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  79.   The reason why Jordan Valley remains quiet 16:34  |  StopTheMessianics 19/01/07
  80.   #28 tuairmiocht 16:40  |  Space 19/01/07
  81.   Please annex the Jordan Valley! 16:41  |  SD 19/01/07
  82.   ...to Tosefta, from Tveria..(why no...Israel) 16:59  |  UGY the she camel 19/01/07
  83.   johnboy do you taunt israel on the yom kippur war? 17:03  |  flashman 19/01/07
  84.   Flashman, you couldn`t have done it without the USA welfare 17:12  |  Ibrahim 19/01/07
  85.   johnboy does not think much of jewish warriors 17:12  |  flashman 19/01/07
  86.   Quick Dr. Watson, the X-ray machine! 17:13  |  Mark Lincoln 19/01/07
  87.   johnboy doubts jewish military capability 17:16  |  flashman 19/01/07
  88.   Jordna Valley not needed by Israel (UGY the beautiful camel #67) 17:36  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  89.   Settlements are Legal 17:40  |  Bruriah Sarah 19/01/07
  90.   Kohen #1 17:40  |  JJ 19/01/07
  91.   Tosefta #65 17:43  |  Gabe1 19/01/07
  92.   ...to Ibrahim..do you know what guts means? 17:44  |  abraham...mico 19/01/07
  93.   19 - Hamas & Fatah Want to Destroy Israel 17:47  |  Bruriah Sarah 19/01/07
  94.   No evidence of a spine (Mark Lincoln #80) 17:51  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  95.   66- PA has no legal rights to the land 17:56  |  Bruriah Sarah 19/01/07
  96.   67 - Response 18:04  |  Bruriah Sarah 19/01/07
  97.   ...to Tosefta...I planted a tree in Jordan Valley...reason enough 18:05  |  abraham...mico 19/01/07
  98.   # 58 Na`amah 18:09  |  Axel 19/01/07
  99.   #94 Tosefta: Due credit to Peretz "the spine" 18:14  |  Axel 19/01/07
  100.   # 58 Na`amah 18:30  |  Axel 19/01/07
  101.   A well known Jewish joke (Axel #99) 18:30  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  102.   tosefta is an amoeba who loved peretz 18:35  |  flashman 19/01/07
  103.   tosefta peretz "plan lacking details" 18:38  |  flashman 19/01/07
  104.   Gush katif people DESERVE the mess they are in 18:38  |  Moses 19/01/07
  105.   Yacov: Had you read my posting #53.. 18:40  |  Andreas 19/01/07
  106.   Anexed fields of war 18:51  |  Peter Ganz 19/01/07
  107.   Return of the Hydra, II 19:00  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  108.   tosefta whenever someone is about to tell me a joke 19:04  |  gal 19/01/07
  109.   #108 Gal, I had no intention 19:17  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  110.   Indrajaya and unlimited greed 19:17  |  jc 19/01/07
  111.   The other wisdom, please build more! 19:22  |  Bandar Michael 19/01/07
  112.   104 - Moses, Learn from Moses 19:25  |  Bruriah Sarah 19/01/07
  113.   Palestinian state without Jews is racist! 19:25  |  Gili 19/01/07
  114.   ballistic "bush didnt use plain vulgar language" 19:26  |  keats 19/01/07
  115.   All we need is PEACE 19:47  |  JR. 19/01/07
  116.   Katz is right, best move is to issue an ultimatum to US, EU: 19:48  |  Dr. L. Brnd 19/01/07
  117.   One look at the image of Maskiot above... 19:58  |  unclicked/unfooled 19/01/07
  118.   Return of the Hydra, I 20:10  |  Tosefta 19/01/07
  119.   Annexation is a right step. 20:11  |  Vital 19/01/07
  120.   #21.Fritz is right 20:12  |  William 19/01/07
  121.   Yishai Kohen - The same for Germany 20:18  |  Otto 19/01/07
  122.   Jewish Mythology as Fact 20:21  |  Madness 19/01/07
  123.   For "Unclicked" #117 20:22  |  Clickfool 19/01/07
  124.   To 14 Indra- Greedy? 20:25  |  Vital 19/01/07
  125.   Re# 88 Tosefta - You miss the point 20:31  |  Meir Weinstein 19/01/07
  126.   to #80 (spacer) 20:36  |  tuairimiocht 19/01/07
  127.   #40 Yishai Kohen - transfers illegal 20:44  |  Boycott 19/01/07
  128.   Gili 20:46  |  Lynn 19/01/07
  129.   #113 .Equal Opportunities O YES 20:58  |  Ben 19/01/07
  130.   APPEASEMENENT 21:03  |  Bracha/Tzfonit 19/01/07
  131.   #89 BS 21:03  |  Boycott 19/01/07
  132.   The 10 year old girl shot by Border Police has died 21:05  |  Clickfool 19/01/07
  133.   Unclicked/Unfooled #117 - not all were built on fallow land. 21:06  |  Tzfonit 19/01/07
  134.   Stop pussyfooting! Annex all of the promised land! 21:17  |  Toronto`s Finest 19/01/07
  135.   #89 Sarah B ????? 21:25  |  Joe 19/01/07
  136.   #132. This 10 y.o.must have been a tickinhg bomb 21:30  |  Georgina 19/01/07
  137.   #104. More compensations money!!! 21:34  |  Amir 19/01/07
  138.   89. Bruriah Sarah - illegal 21:40  |  justajew 19/01/07
  139.   # 117 unfooled 21:42  |  Axel 19/01/07
  140.   #119. Agree with you man.ANNEXATION 21:45  |  Dr. Y 19/01/07
  141.   "The 10 year old girl shot by Border Police has died" 21:47  |  jewboy 19/01/07
  142.   Clickfool, why didn`t you mention there was no live ammunition? 21:51  |  Jake 19/01/07
  143.   Their True Intentions (1) 22:04  |  Someone 19/01/07
  144.   Their True Intentions (2) 22:12  |  Someone 19/01/07
  145.   Their True Intentions (3) 22:23  |  Someone 19/01/07
  146.   To 139, Dr. Y - Hard land for Annexation. 22:26  |  Vital 19/01/07
  147.   The Value of Haaretz Talkback 22:29  |  Pavel 19/01/07
  148.   Peretz - True partner for peace? 22:30  |  Blinky the Fish 19/01/07
  149.   to jewboy 141 22:35  |  Blinky the Fish 19/01/07
  150.   29 Penny 22:41  |  Daniel Cohen 19/01/07
  151.   Flashman 22:44  |  John 19/01/07
  152.   #114 Bush uses vulgar language, yessirree 22:49  |  ballistic 19/01/07
  153.   response to clickfool from sussex 22:50  |  Nissim 19/01/07
  154.   #116 another mad hatter 22:51  |  ballistic 19/01/07
  155.   settlement was CANCELLED 23:03  |  Paul Freedman 19/01/07
  156.   Where did I read this, IDF destroyed millions of Olive/frit trees 23:03  |  Bengi 19/01/07
  157.   #65 BALISTIC GRADUATED IN 1978 IN TOTAL B/S 23:30  |  paul harris 19/01/07
  158.   #154 BALLISTIC STUCK IN THE NEVADA SAND 23:35  |  paul harris 19/01/07
  159.   crazy people 23:43  |  robert 19/01/07
  160.   JOHNBOY YOU ARE A DISGRACE TO OZ 00:00  |  paul harris 20/01/07
  161.   Hey DANIEL 00:03  |  Penny 20/01/07
  162.   #40 Yishai Kohen, back atcha` Part 1 00:11  |  Johnboy 20/01/07
  163.   #40 Yishai Kohen, back atcha` Part 2 00:28  |  Johnboy 20/01/07
  164.   paul harris # 11 01:11  |  dubious 20/01/07
  165.   actually #87 is right 03:12  |  bob pivarnick 20/01/07
  166.   To #1 Yishai 06:26  |  Michael 20/01/07
  167.   #132 10 year-old Abir Aramin 09:49  |  hala 20/01/07
  168.   #42, Vittorio - Prove me wrong! 11:12  |  Fritz 20/01/07
  169.   # 110, JC 13:16  |  indrajaya 20/01/07
  170.   #I Indon Man 15:17  |  Ben 20/01/07
  171.   # 170, BEN, LEARN FROM US 15:47  |  indrajaya 20/01/07
  172.   To Yishai Kohen 16:59  |  Choni Davidowitz 20/01/07
  173.   Is Los Angeles a settlement? 17:38  |  Jonathan S 20/01/07
  174.   An encouraging first step that must be followed by many others. 17:41  |  Timothy 20/01/07
  175.   indrajaya "our greed was humane" 17:59  |  bong bong 20/01/07
  176.   indrajaya "our greed was humane" 17:59  |  bong bong 20/01/07
  177.   #130 19:15  |  shalom-salaam.net 20/01/07
  178.   #168 Fritz UR dead right 19:23  |  Aaron 20/01/07
  179.   #159 -"crazy people". 19:26  |  Vital 20/01/07
  180.   For Jake # 142 20:10  |  Clickfool 20/01/07
  181.   # 172 Choni Davidowitz 20:46  |  Axel 20/01/07
  182.   Peretz 2 freeze his Defence Ministry 20:50  |  sam 20/01/07
  183.   #130 `Tzfonit` 21:06  |  shalom-salaam.net 20/01/07
  184.   Choni,once again ..... 21:37  |  John 20/01/07
  185.   Choni, actually ... 22:20  |  Axel 20/01/07
  186.   PAUL HARRIS AND IRONY 22:39  |  Stephen Connor 20/01/07
  187.   Paul Harris - 160 and the British 22:47  |  Stephen Connor 20/01/07
  188.   #164 dubiuous HAS NO IDEA OF WHAT HE WRITES 23:33  |  paul harris 20/01/07
  189.   #168 FRITZ MY TELEPHONE TO HEAVEN HAS BROKEN DOWN 23:35  |  paul harris 20/01/07
  190.   Trained to lose wars 23:56  |  stella 20/01/07
  191.   To Choni Davidowitz #172 00:54  |  Ari ben Yisrael 21/01/07
  192.   Axel #185 01:01  |  Ari ben Yisrael 21/01/07
  193.   #170 Indon Man 02:01  |  Ben 21/01/07
  194.   shalom-salaam.net #177/183 03:04  |  Gabe1 21/01/07
  195.   Ari Ben Israel #190 03:09  |  Benni Bitton 21/01/07
  196.   Paul Harris - 187 04:32  |  Stephen Connor 21/01/07
  197.   #158 Paul you THINK YOU KNOW 06:37  |  ballistic 21/01/07
  198.   #145 and also 07:50  |  Tom 21/01/07
  199.   Robert We are not crazy like you 08:53  |  Aby 21/01/07
  200.   Benni Boy #195 Tilmad Yediat Ha`Aretz 09:28  |  Ari ben Yisrael 21/01/07
  201.   Axel and the Geneva convention 09:29  |  jc 21/01/07
  202.   3197 ballistic GOES BALLISTIC ONCE MORE 09:29  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  203.   #186 REALLYCONNOR YOUR IRISH GOT 09:32  |  paul harris 21/01/07
  204.   # 197 paul a bigot?...lol...oh no...no way my friend... 10:38  |  eric 21/01/07
  205.   DONT BUILD ILLEGAL SETTLEMENT!!! 21:42  |  Johnathan 21/01/07
  206.   #205 Johnathon 00:10  |  Johnboy 23/01/07
 Today Online
Richard Perle: U.S. will attack Iran if it obtains nukes
Responses: 186
Danny Rubinstein: The settler state of the West Bank
Responses: 80
Peretz: Settler's abuse dwarfs gestures to Palestinians
Responses: 107
EU's Solana shocked at growth of West Bank settlements
Responses: 176
Rock may have killed W. Bank girl said shot by Border Police
Responses: 113
IDF: 44 West Bank barriers allegedly removed did not exist
Responses: 107
Rosner's Domain
* Rosner's Guest: Ira Sheskin on Jewish demography in America
* America and the Mideast: Evangelism old and new
* Why did The Israel Factor panelists downgrade Rice?
* Poll: Transferring money to Abbas - the right move?


More Headlines
00:07 Olmert, Peretz agree on choice of Ashkenazi as IDF chief
22:32 Switzerland says it mediated in informal Israel-Syria peace talks
23:55 Blast rocks Al Arabiya television office in Gaza City; no injuries
22:33 IAEA confirms Iran barred entry of 38 nuclear inspectors
21:50 Government to invest NIS 200 million to assist at-risk youth
21:25 Peretz: Abusive settler renders gestures to PA meaningless
20:20 Negev farmer who killed burglar will not be tried for murder
20:46 Palestinian militants in Gaza fire three Qassam rockets at Israel
20:39 EU leaders meet to seek ways to bolster Mideast negotiations
23:08 Bodies of 2 men found in Rehovot apt.; 1 of men's wife also found dead
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved