Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., January 19, 2007 Tevet 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Retired diplomat Alon Liel speaking about talks he held with a Syrian representative, at the Netanya Academic College on Thursday. (Nitzan Shorer)
Last update - 21:57 18/01/2007
Alon Liel: Israel rejected Syrian bid for wartime talks
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent and The Associated Press

Syria is serious about resuming peace talks with Israel and even proposed holding secret high-level talks during the war in Lebanon last summer, which Israel rejected, retired diplomat Alon Liel said Thursday.

Israel's leaders quickly distanced themselves from reports leaked by Haaretz earlier this week that former Foreign Ministry director general Liel held unofficial talks with a Syrian.

Liel, going public for the first time Thursday, said he briefed government officials every step of the way. He said he believed his counterpart, Syrian-American businessman Ibrahim Suleiman, also had channels to the Syrian government.

Advertisement

"Our testimony is that it is very clear to us that Assad wants to talk," said Liel, referring to Syrian President Bashar Assad.

Liel and Suleiman were brought together by Geoffrey Aronson, head of the Foundation for Middle East Peace in Washington. Eight meetings were held, Liel said, including several reportedly under the auspices of the Swiss.

Liel would not say who his hosts were, but said he believed they used their own diplomatic contacts to check whether the messages coming out of the talks were reaching the Syrian government.

The last meeting took place in late July, during the Israel-Lebanon war, Liel said. On that day, several Israelis were killed by rockets fired by the Lebanese Hezbollah militia, which Israel says is backed and funded by Syria and Iran.

"It was a very difficult day, and the Syrian party suggested that since it's a war and an emergency situation, let's have a very quick track one meeting, high-level meeting, on the level of deputy ministers ... with an American in the room," Liel told a conference at the Netanya Academic College.

Liel said he told government officials of the offer, and pleaded with them to accept.

"And the answer was 'no, no we don't want to meet them'," he said.

He said he believes Israel is reluctant to resume peace talks with Syria because the idea of giving up the Golan is unpopular and because it would counter Washington's policy of trying to isolate Syria.

Liel said he made it very clear at the beginning of each meeting that he did not represent the government, but that he routinely updated Israeli officials, as well as the Turkish government, after each round. The Turkish government had initially been approached by the participants as a possible sponsor, but turned them down.

Aronson said the time is ripe for a resumption of peace talks, though he acknowledged that Syria could just be feigning interest in resuming talks to get into Washington's good graces.

"There is a reasonable basis to assume that well-intentioned official representatives have something to talk about when they sit down," he said.

On Tuesday when the meetings between Liel and Suleiman were first leaked, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert dismissed the talks. "I knew of nothing. No one in the government was involved in this matter. It was a private initiative on the part of an individual who spoke with himself," Olmert told reporters. "From what I read, his interlocutor was an eccentric from the United States, someone not serious or dignified."

Syrian officials said Tuesday that reports of an agreement were "baseless."

In June, the participants wrote a two-page "non-paper" to sum up their talks, Liel said. The centerpiece was a proposal to turn part of the Golan Heights, captured by Israel in the 1967 Six Day War and annexed in 1981, into a "peace park." Syria would be the sovereign in all of the Golan, but Israelis could visit the park freely, without visas.


Related articles:

  • Israeli, Syrian representatives reach secret understandings
  • Both sides deny Haaretz report of back-channel talks with Syria
  • The full text of the draft document

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Four-decade career
    The British Film Festival's brief tribute to director Nicholas Roeg is partial at best.
    A visitor in disguise
    Singer Will Oldham, who performs only under pseudonyms, is now in Israel.
      1.   "Peace" talks with Syrians during war = official surrender 19:52  |  SLAVO 18/01/07
      2.   Israels self delusion... 19:56  |  MIKE KATZ 18/01/07
      3.   War of choice after all 19:57  |  Ronen 18/01/07
      4.   Leil - you are retired!! be quiet 20:10  |  who elected him?? 18/01/07
      5.   No Mention of Explosive Thrown at Jews near Hevron ? 20:20  |  Mike 18/01/07
      6.   talks not automatically-bad but there may only be smoke here 20:30  |  Paul Freedman 18/01/07
      7.   A reject after a reject. 20:37  |  MS 18/01/07
      8.   Look he`s been at the helm of the Israeli FO,no wonder 20:47  |  Absolute Sweden 18/01/07
      9.   They better have a good explanation 20:57  |  Yonatan 18/01/07
      10.   Israel cannot give the Golan Heights back and 21:08  |  Kipperraes 18/01/07
      11.   Is someone telling lies, half truths or truths? 21:21  |  common sense 18/01/07
      12.   NO KISS 21:26  |  Bill 18/01/07
      13.   Talks 21:31  |  DAVID KAPLAN 18/01/07
      14.   peace with Syria 21:39  |  yuval 18/01/07
      15.   Talks with Syria 21:48  |  Lou 18/01/07
      16.   More Haaretz BS 22:27  |  Tod Zuckerman 18/01/07
      17.   The Way To True Enduring Peace 22:38  |  Bader Abu-Ghosh 18/01/07
      18.   there should be a public inquiry 22:44  |  reuben jacobs 18/01/07
      19.   Syria 23:08  |  Jerusalem Shmuel 18/01/07
      20.   Kiss or no kiss, Bill... 23:30  |  christoph 18/01/07
      21.   Wow! Syria Offered to Enter into "Surrender" Talks with Israel! 23:31  |  Albert 18/01/07
      22.   New breed of Zionist 23:37  |  Nathaniel 18/01/07
      23.   The Syrians 00:00  |  Inyaki 19/01/07
      24.   Bullshit 00:22  |  Gili 19/01/07
      25.   Prove it! 00:23  |  Gili 19/01/07
      26.   Syria knows it was lucky and won`t be again 00:25  |  Bimmer 19/01/07
      27.   US delinquint 00:28  |  W 19/01/07
      28.   You think Israel will keep the Golan? 00:47  |  Bill 19/01/07
      29.   the good guys Syria 01:18  |  Larzbeach 19/01/07
      30.   An interesting point made in another article 02:26  |  Johnboy 19/01/07
      31.   AGREEMENT BASED ON BLOOD AND COWARDNESS 03:39  |  MUNIR AZAR 19/01/07
      32.   W? US pressure Israel? Why? 04:38  |  Jerusalem Shmuel 19/01/07
     Today Online
    Olmert, Peretz said likely to clash over Halutz heir
    Responses: 79
    Aluf Benn: It's all over for Prime Minister Ehud Olmert
    Responses: 92
    Sneh: Peace with Palestinians possible within 2 years
    Responses: 192
    Army of Islam: IDF soldier Shalit held exclusively by Hamas
    Responses: 159
    Palestinian convert to Judaism charged with aiding Islamic Jihad
    Responses: 62
    Rosner's Domain
    * Conservative schools and Jewish fathers
    * Has the war with Iran already started?
    * Michael Oren: America's most fateful decision in the Middle East
    * The Carter trap


    More Headlines
    03:12 Abdullah: Jordan will develop nuclear power
    03:06 Alon Liel: Prime Minister's Office was updated about Syria talks
    02:01 UN head says will work toward captive IDF soldiers' release
    22:50 In talks with officials, PM names Gantz, Ashkenazi and Kaplinsky as candidates for IDF chief
    04:27 Mazuz expected to announce decision on Katsav indictment
    22:58 GDP per capita in Jewish sector 3 times more than among Israeli Arabs
    22:12 Unknown assailants set fire to W. Bank settlement synagogue
    04:37 Hamas-led gov't drafts highest annual budget despite aid boycott
    01:25 U.S. Undersecretary of State to visit Middle East this week
    01:43 Iran set to begin installing 3,000 uranium enrichment centrifuges
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Skin Care Products
    Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
    JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
    The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
    ZAKA
    Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
    CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
    Israel's international summer camps!
    Learn Hebrew Online
    Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
    Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved