Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., February 02, 2007 Shvat 14, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:53 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Being ashamed is not enough
By Haaretz Editorial

When the prime minister says he was "ashamed," referring to the behavior of Hebron settler Yifat Alkobi, whose profanity unleashed at the Abu Ayshe family sent them reeling into their home over the Hebron market, we should tell him that a prime minister was not elected to be ashamed, but to take action. When the government under his leadership decides to set up a ministerial committee to deliberate the issue of enforcing the law against Hebron settlers because "it is impossible to accept such brutal behavior," the shame belongs to all of us.

After all, there is no need for a committee to learn the facts and take action. To date no prime minister has proved brave enough to accept the challenge and remove this festering wound of settlement activity, this outcast Jewish settlement, which has managed to drive 30,000 Palestinians from their homes and their shops, and transform the Palestinian center of Hebron into a ghost town. The profanities of Alkobi are peripheral to this entanglement.

The Jewish settlement in Hebron was the first organized illegal outpost, which was set up following the Six-Day War by Rabbi Moshe Levinger on seder eve, 1968 at the city's Park Hotel. Several dozen guests who had come to celebrate the seder in the city refused to return to their homes. They included the historic founders of the settlement movement, who identified this means of illegal activity under cover of the law: takeover by devious methods, lobbying and force, exploiting Israel Defense Forces soldiers and politicians to gain protection, while rolling their eyes, as if all this constituted moral Zionism, to which any opposition implied treason to one's people and motherland. Alkobi is only a natural outgrowth of the Levinger family.

Advertisement

If a peace agreement is ever signed with the Palestinians, the Hebron settlers will have to end their illegal holiday at the Park Hotel, which has been going on 38 years too long, because no border will be able to include this outrageous enclave inside a large Arab city. Following the 1994 massacre by Baruch Goldstein of Muslims praying in the Tomb of the Patriarchs, Yitzhak Rabin should have seized the opportunity to remove the Jewish settlement, but he was deterred. And since then, no leader has even dared think about doing so.

The IDF has law enforcement authority over the Hebron residents, Jewish and Arab alike, and so does the Israel Police, but no one is willing to confront them, knowing the government is not really interested in such enforcement. The soldiers lack the backing and the incentive to enforce the law in a place that has been lawless for years. There is no point in again going over the matter of law enforcement when the presence of the Jewish settlement in Hebron, in a time of conflict - as opposed to the conditions of peace - is blatantly illogical.

The bully settlement in Hebron is an example of the national stupidity that overtook Israel when it decided to settle forcefully in every place of religious significance, regardless of political realities. This is another obstacle that must be removed, and if Ehud Olmert would succeed in carrying out only this one essential deed, it would be possible to describe his tenure in office as having had positive results.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Buying Dead Sea love
The cosmetic company Ahava Dead Sea is considering issuing its shares abroad.
Fruit skewers
Grilling fresh pineapples and strawberries can turn them into a tasty and elegant dessert.
  1.   ASHAMED OF WHAT ? RETURNING BACK TO ATOWN 10:11  |  paul harris 16/01/07
  2.   Jews Lived In Hebron For THOUSANDS Of Years 10:13  |  Yishai Kohen 16/01/07
  3.   the jewish nationalists do themselves no favours 10:14  |  flashman 16/01/07
  4.   No, the IDF has no authority over settlers 10:18  |  Hebronite 16/01/07
  5.   No one in Israel has the guts to take 10:21  |  spyguy 16/01/07
  6.   question: Will the Arabs ever be ashamed of 1929? 10:43  |  American Jew 16/01/07
  7.   Remebering the masacre of the jews of Hebron 1929? 10:45  |  Settler of the line 16/01/07
  8.   If the Arabs wouldn`t murder Jews in Hebron... 10:48  |  Dani 16/01/07
  9.   #5 SPYGUY THEY SAID THE SAME IN 1917 1922 1948 1967 10:48  |  paul harris 16/01/07
  10.   yishai kohen hebron is jewish 10:54  |  flashman 16/01/07
  11.   jews in Hebron 10:57  |  grazia 16/01/07
  12.   Yishai Kohen 10:57  |  sh 16/01/07
  13.   yeshai kohen showy words like 10:58  |  flashman 16/01/07
  14.   spyguy you are delusional 11:00  |  flashman 16/01/07
  15.   grazia: See What Happened In 1929 11:12  |  Yishai Kohen 16/01/07
  16.   Zionist witches are not departed or gone 11:12  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  17.   Ashamed of what? 11:12  |  Giles Martin 16/01/07
  18.   # 1Harris...and #2..#3...ashamed... 11:16  |  ali 16/01/07
  19.   Paul 11:25  |  Cord Kaldrack 16/01/07
  20.   Jews Lived In Hebron For THOUSANDS Of Years 11:43  |  Andreas 16/01/07
  21.   Leftwing ignorance and hatred! 11:53  |  Matthias Roth 16/01/07
  22.   kick `em out and make `em pay the damages 12:04  |  Ralph is back 16/01/07
  23.   Thank you Haaretz 12:14  |  Patricia 16/01/07
  24.   settlers are and represent israeli politics 12:15  |  cristina 16/01/07
  25.   Being Ashamed 12:15  |  Miriam 16/01/07
  26.   Surrounded by Arabs 12:19  |  Shmuel 16/01/07
  27.   hebronites...jewish facists.... 12:27  |  pelsar 16/01/07
  28.   #21, Mathias, living all comfy and cosy in Switzerland 12:39  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  29.   Matthias Roth-excuses excuses 12:40  |  pelsar 16/01/07
  30.   America jew, you are ignorant 12:51  |  Meir 16/01/07
  31.   To the number one...? (# 1 for you, paul;-),.... 12:54  |  eric 16/01/07
  32.   to all the bigots and zealots ... 12:55  |  cristina 16/01/07
  33.   DREADFUL OLD HARPY 13:45  |  Nandi 16/01/07
  34.   electronic intifada:pure propaganda 13:46  |  pelsar 16/01/07
  35.   Why the settler problem hurts me 14:03  |  Tulip 16/01/07
  36.   #24 CRISTINA THE DOOMSTER OF LONDON 14:05  |  paul harris 16/01/07
  37.   Just change the guards in Hebron... 14:06  |  Jack 16/01/07
  38.   2,9 an the other nazional socialists 14:16  |  john and the truth 16/01/07
  39.   The shame is that Arabs are in Hebron 14:19  |  Steven 16/01/07
  40.   #36, Tulip: Why zionism hurts me 14:30  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  41.   Miriam 25 don`t you know? 14:31  |  Steven 16/01/07
  42.   Are We To Believe That Israel Was Unaware of Political Realities? 14:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/01/07
  43.   Interestingly enough traitors from "Haaretz" name Park Hotel in 14:37  |  Absolute Sweden 16/01/07
  44.   Was Israel Unaware of the Political Realities? 14:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/01/07
  45.   Hebron settlers 14:38  |  D Karasick 16/01/07
  46.   why haaretz is not ashamed of itself? 14:40  |  Gene 16/01/07
  47.   #37, Jack 14:45  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  48.   Alkobi is an agent provocateur 14:48  |  Herbert Kaine 16/01/07
  49.   Goldstein massacre and Yaakov Sullivan 14:51  |  Steven 16/01/07
  50.   Yes, being ashamed of editorial boards is more important 14:55  |  David Teich 16/01/07
  51.   Meir #31 15:22  |  Gee 16/01/07
  52.   Hannah..... 15:22  |  Jack 16/01/07
  53.   Mr. Kaine, quite honestely...#49 15:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/01/07
  54.   #52, Jack 15:49  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  55.   Hannah the Rabbi ha ha tell me how: 16:02  |  Steven 16/01/07
  56.   #56, Steven 16:23  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  57.   Herbert Kaine 16:26  |  krystal 16/01/07
  58.   it`s time to be proud of brave Hebron settlers 16:32  |  Margarita 16/01/07
  59.   Hannah vs. Jack 16:40  |  Anita 16/01/07
  60.   Hebron Settlers have hate not courage 16:54  |  Stephen Connor 16/01/07
  61.   apologies stephen connor but 17:07  |  flashman 16/01/07
  62.   Stephen Connor #61 17:10  |  Gee 16/01/07
  63.   Promote a Just Peace. Bring the unsettlers home. 17:10  |  Timothy 16/01/07
  64.   Stephen Connor you have hate and a big mouth 17:11  |  Steven 16/01/07
  65.   #60, Anita 17:12  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  66.   Both of this talkback 17:18  |  S 16/01/07
  67.   Sounds like all the hate is coming from Yaakov 17:18  |  Herbert Kaine 16/01/07
  68.   So, Hannah, you agree that Israel within the 17:27  |  Anita 16/01/07
  69.   #68, S 17:32  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  70.   No, Hannah, zionism is in the Torah 17:38  |  Tulip 16/01/07
  71.   What I understand mr. Kaine is...#69 17:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/01/07
  72.   And where do you squat, Steven?? #66 17:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/01/07
  73.   THE ONE STATE SOLUTION 17:46  |  Stephen Connor 16/01/07
  74.   THE ONE STATE SOLUTION 17:55  |  Stephen Connor 16/01/07
  75.   #68, Anita 18:34  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  76.   Talkback madness 18:35  |  Tom Spender 16/01/07
  77.   stephen connor take your wares elsewhere 18:38  |  flashman 16/01/07
  78.   Settlements are Legal 18:46  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/01/07
  79.   Hebron in the Bible 18:47  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/01/07
  80.   Wish 18:49  |  Choni Davidowitz 16/01/07
  81.   60 - Where is your evidence? 18:51  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/01/07
  82.   Hannah 18:52  |  Anita 16/01/07
  83.   73 - West Bank Arabs are PA citizens 18:54  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/01/07
  84.   56 -What is Zionism? 19:00  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/01/07
  85.   56 - What is Torah? 19:01  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/01/07
  86.   #82, Anita 19:03  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  87.   Choni Davidowitz # 80 19:03  |  Nahum 16/01/07
  88.   bedouins also shafted 19:05  |  Pssd Off American 16/01/07
  89.