Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., January 17, 2007 Tevet 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:25 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Moscow's Mideast myopia
By Yuliya Tymoshenko

Iran's influence in the Middle East is being strengthened not only because of the opportunities created by the frustration of U.S. power in Iraq, but also because of the diplomatic protection it has been receiving from China and, most importantly, from Russia.

Russia, by wielding the threat of its UN Security Council veto, spent much of the past two years whittling away at the proposed list of sanctions that might be slapped on Iran for its refusal to honor its commitments to the International Atomic Energy Agency over its nuclear program. As a result, the sanctions now imposed by the Security Council are so tepid that they are unlikely to be effective.

Russia sees its relations with Iran as leverage to influence diplomacy in the wider Middle East, where the U.S. has successfully sought to exclude the Kremlin since the end of the Cold War. Russia's other self-interest has been to exempt from sanctions the Bushehr nuclear reactor that it is building for Iran (to be in operation later this year), and to ward off a UN-sponsored financial squeeze on Iran that might put at risk the profits Russia hopes to earn from providing nuclear fuel for the reactor.

Advertisement

Russian President Vladimir Putin argues that Iran, unlike North Korea, has not expelled IAEA nuclear inspectors, quit the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) or conducted a weapons test so it should be dealt with gently. But without making Iran weigh real costs against its nuclear plans, it will have little reason to consider the suspension of uranium enrichment and plutonium dabbling (both are usable for nuclear fuel-making but abominable for bomb-making), which the Europeans and the United States have made a condition for serious negotiations to take place.

Russia trades heavily with Iran, which is another reason it is wary of sanctions against it. But the U.S. has been leaning on foreign banks to curb their dealings with Iran. Last month, it added five companies (four in China, and another in the U.S. but representing a Chinese outfit) to its list of those fingered for assisting Iran's weapons program and thus banned from doing business with American companies. There is a growing fear in Moscow that the U.S. administration is now looking at Russian companies with similar ties to Iran and its nuclear ambitions.

Russian policy, based on immediate monetary gain and a hope of diplomatic influence, is dangerously short-sighted. (Ukraine, for its part, opted not to participate in building the Bushehr reactor.) If suspicions are correct that Iran has been secretly learning how to build and trigger a nuclear device, and also to shape a missile cone to carry such a warhead (as well as publicly developing nuclear-capable, far-flying missiles), then once it has fully mastered uranium enrichment, it will soon be poised to break out - at short notice, at a moment of its choosing - from the NPT's limits. By enfeebling diplomacy, Russia is taking the world into more dangerous territory.

This is doubly short-sighted as a nuclear-armed Iran on Russia's border is not in the latter's national interest, particularly with Russia's own 20 million Muslim citizens becoming increasingly radicalized. Indeed, Russia's Muslim population is the only sector of the Russian population that is growing, which means Muslims will become a bigger and bigger factor in Russian domestic politics in the decades ahead. That Iran is often seen as a principal backer of the Chechen separatists is also evidence of the truly short-sighted nature of Russian policy.

But in its quest to enhance its great power prestige today, Russia seems willing to sacrifice its long-term security interests in the region for immediate diplomatic gratification. And it is doing so not only in respect to Iran. The big question about Turkmenistan today is whether the vacuum left by the death of Saparmurat Niyazov (Turkmanbashi) will allow Islamic extremism to spill over from neighboring Iran and Afghanistan. Russia is doing its best to see to it that whatever successor regime comes along, it is willing to do the Kremlin's bidding.

Russia has long had the upper hand in Turkmenistan. Most of Turkmenistan's gas is exported through the Russian pipeline system. Gazprom, the Russian state giant, buys gas at relatively low prices, and then distributes it in Russia or sells it at a profit in Europe.

Israel, like Turkey and the U.S., must be hoping that Turkmenistan's new rulers will seek to diversify gas distribution by adopting a project to build a pipeline beneath the Caspian Sea. But diversification is also needed in that country's politics, because the only opposition with any strength in the country is Islamic fundamentalists.

Russia has had centuries of influence in the Middle East and Central Asia in the Russian and Soviet empires. It could serve as a powerful force for good in the region if it stops seeking short-term advantage and begins to act in its own long-term interests, which will best be served by a prosperous, non-nuclear armed Iran, and a far more open Turkmenistan.

The writer is the former prime minister of Ukraine and is currently leader of the opposition there.

Copyright: Project Syndicate

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Israeli export
A new book focuses on the role Zim played in the history of shipping and architecture.
Nature online
New online guides to Israel's plants and animals have been launched in the last year.
  1.   well, Russia and Iran are effectively allies...just as 10:22  |  American living here 16/01/07
  2.   #1, American livin here 10:55  |  S 16/01/07
  3.   Peculiar article written with surprisingly little knowledge 11:00  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  4.   In final day Iranian rulers will destroys Iran for their stupidly 11:00  |  e.m 16/01/07
  5.   CHINA IS THE KEY 11:13  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  6.   O.K. Israel, when will the IAEA ... 11:22  |  Maureen Ann 16/01/07
  7.   BETWEEN THE PAST GLORY AND THE PROMISE OF TOMORROW 11:42  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  8.   "myopia" ? 12:36  |  andyoufreak 16/01/07
  9.   The Ruskies and the Ayatollahs of Doom 12:43  |  Klaudia 16/01/07
  10.   #1 13:17  |  EE 16/01/07
  11.   # 1 American 13:24  |  Lynn 16/01/07
  12.   #7-hates Jews!Americans too 13:25  |  Adama 16/01/07
  13.   #2 S 13:26  |  Archangel 16/01/07
  14.   # 6 13:29  |  Lynn 16/01/07
  15.   The role of Europe 13:33  |  Jonathan S 16/01/07
  16.   To Hannah #3 13:38  |  S 16/01/07
  17.   # 9, KLAUDIA 13:41  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  18.   to Klaudia on corrupt evil regimes 13:52  |  Anubhav 16/01/07
  19.   to Jonathan S on role of Europe 13:56  |  Anubhav 16/01/07
  20.   # 17, A LITTLE CORRECTION FROM ME 13:56  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  21.   #15, Jonathan 13:59  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  22.   # 17, A CORRECTION (2nd ATTEMPT) 14:11  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  23.   #5 indrajaya: China`s oncoming problems with the radical Islam 14:14  |  Scientist 16/01/07
  24.   Archangel # 13 14:14  |  S 16/01/07
  25.   Israel must realise 14:15  |  Chris Linthwaite 16/01/07
  26.   33 THE RUDITE HANNAH READS RUSSIAN AND CHINESE IM JEALOUS 14:20  |  paul harris 16/01/07
  27.   #8 ANDY PREDICTS DOOM AND GLOOM 14:28  |  paul harris 16/01/07
  28.   To Indrajaya 14:30  |  Klaudia 16/01/07
  29.   To Anuhbav about Europe 14:32  |  Jonathan S 16/01/07
  30.   Response to no.8 14:40  |  Samson 16/01/07
  31.   # 12, ADAMA 14:44  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  32.   To Hannah about Europe 15:05  |  Jonathan S 16/01/07
  33.   comparison 15:08  |  jameel 16/01/07
  34.   #5 Indrajaya 15:12  |  jameel 16/01/07
  35.   # 28, KLAUDIA 15:16  |  indrajaya 16/01/07
  36.   Iran And Russia Longer Have A Common Border 15:42  |  Victor Smolinsky 16/01/07
  37.   #32, Jonathan 15:53  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  38.   The Honeymoon Will Someday End 15:58  |  Tony Anthony 16/01/07
  39.   jameel #33 16:14  |  Gee 16/01/07
  40.   To Hannah about North Sea oil 16:19  |  Jonathan S 16/01/07
  41.   It`s The Global Free Market, Stupid! 16:25  |  Peter 16/01/07
  42.   to Klaudia 16:27  |  Anubhav 16/01/07
  43.   #10, #11 - - - Just listen to yourselves 16:36  |  Roshan 16/01/07
  44.   So In Other Words 16:40  |  Yosemite 16/01/07
  45.   to Jonathan S on EU licking for oil 16:43  |  Anubhav 16/01/07
  46.   #12 Adama--I do believe the issue is 16:47  |  ballistic 16/01/07
  47.   #40, Jonathan 16:53  |  Hannah 16/01/07
  48.   Yes, Russia`s policy is short sighted 16:57  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 16/01/07
  49.   #6 Maureen Ann 17:00  |  Itsik 16/01/07
  50.   #40 Jonathan S I agree about the decline in North Sea Oil 17:08  |  Chris Linthwaite 16/01/07
  51.   #39 gee, #33 jameel 17:18  |  jameel 16/01/07
  52.   Did the US win the Cold War? 17:26  |  Bimmer 16/01/07
  53.   jameel #51 18:23  |  Gee 16/01/07
  54.   #52 Bimmer 18:49  |  Chris Linthwaite 16/01/07
  55.   Indrajaha #7 China is powerful but needs US 19:02  |  albert amato 16/01/07
  56.   New Russian arms deal 19:03  |  Jonathan S 16/01/07
  57.   Not for cash, Jonatan 19:50  |  Uri 16/01/07
  58.   Not just cash 19:58  |  Uri 16/01/07
  59.   to Linthewaite #54 A question for you 20:18  |  Bimmer 16/01/07
  60.   American Jews must be in a panic 20:55  |  Viv 16/01/07
  61.   When Irans Nuke facilities Are Destroyed 20:55  |  Kipperraes 16/01/07
  62.   55# alberto amato 21:10  |  Arik 16/01/07
  63.   #14 Lynn (also #6) 21:15  |  tadchase 16/01/07
  64.   Kipperaes - a warning 21:17  |  anangryjew 16/01/07
  65.   56# Jonathan S 21:27  |  Arik 16/01/07
  66.   I`d Love To See Israel Wiped Off The Map 21:31  |  Jim Miller 16/01/07
  67.   Viv #60 American Jews are more worried about terrorism in the US 21:35  |  albert amato 16/01/07
  68.   #61 Kipperraes; er, I wouldn`t count on that rosy 21:40  |  ballistic 16/01/07
  69.   Viv, apology not accepted 21:59  |  American Jew 16/01/07
  70.   #45 Anubhav 22:23  |  Lynn 16/01/07
  71.   Tor-M1 air defense missile systems 22:27  |  Kenneth Brown 16/01/07
  72.   Klaudia #9 22:29  |  TonyL 16/01/07
  73.   To Uri from Estonia 22:32  |  Klaudia 16/01/07
  74.   Uri #57 22:56  |  TonyL 16/01/07
  75.   @69 American Jew and Viv 23:14  |  Mark B. 16/01/07
  76.   Jim Miller #66 23:16  |  Gee 16/01/07
  77.   Moscow 23:30  |  P. J. Casey 16/01/07
  78.   To Clickfool and Jonathan S. 23:32  |  Mark B. 16/01/07
  79.   Something to ponder vs Moscow 23:36  |  TonyL 16/01/07
  80.   Timoshenko on Iran 23:40  |  Robert 16/01/07
  81.   A reply to Arik in Germany 23:47  |  Jonathan S 16/01/07
  82.   Mark B #75...it is anti-semetism IF 00:03  |  albert amato 17/01/07
  83.   366 AND CONMSIDERING HOW THE WHITES USA STOLE THE LAND JIM 00:08  |  paul harris 17/01/07
  84.   Mark B, you have no credibility 00:09  |  Aaron 17/01/07
  85.   to Jim Miller and ...................Gee 00:10  |  Bimmer 17/01/07
  86.   An answer to Mark B. 00:21  |  Jonathan S 17/01/07
  87.   # 70 - Lynn ... About Canadian Oil Production 00:21  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  88.   # 70 - Lynn ...About the Tar Sands 00:33  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  89.   Russia and China taking advantage 00:49  |  Mark Lincoln 17/01/07
  90.   # 72- Tony L 00:50  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  91.   russia not shortsighted 00:56  |  paulo2005 17/01/07
  92.   #49 Itsik, it has everything to do with Israel. 01:26  |  Maureen Ann 17/01/07
  93.   # 78- Mark B. In the Interests of Knowledge.... 01:27  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  94.   Love For Sale 01:34  |  Tony Anthony 17/01/07
  95.   #14 Lynn, Perhaps Israel is happy not to have a seat. 02:15  |  Maureen Ann 17/01/07
  96.   INDRARAJAYA 02:29  |  TOBIA 17/01/07
  97.   # 83 Klaudia 02:32  |  Lynn 17/01/07
  98.   All you West haters... 02:34  |  Avrum 17/01/07
  99.   VIV WHEN DID ISRAEL ASK FOR OUR BLOOD 02:42  |  TOBIA 17/01/07
  100.   Klaudia #85 02:52  |  TonyL 17/01/07
  101.   Aaron 02:56  |  TOBIa 17/01/07
  102.   #13 Archangel, #24 S 03:01  |  KT 17/01/07
  103.   Maureen IF YOU HATE SO MUCH 03:04  |  TOBIA 17/01/07
  104.   #7 Indrajaya 03:08  |  KT 17/01/07
  105.   Chris Linthwaite on China 03:13  |  Reid 17/01/07
  106.   #43 Roshan 03:16  |  KT 17/01/07
  107.   #60 Viv and #66 Jim MIller 03:24  |  KT 17/01/07
  108.   #66 - Jim Miller 03:25  |  Bonnie 17/01/07
  109.   AMERICAN JEW 03:27  |  TOBIA 17/01/07
  110.   # 100- Tony L 03:40  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  111.   Lynn 03:45  |  Reid 17/01/07
  112.   To #1 03:48  |  GUY 17/01/07
  113.   Mark Lincoln #89 03:59  |  TonyL 17/01/07
  114.   #87 Klaudia, Lynn 04:39  |  tadchase 17/01/07
  115.   #78 Mark B. 04:43  |  tadchase 17/01/07
  116.   Klaudia #104 05:22  |  TonyL 17/01/07
  117.   Chechnya, chechya, chechnya 05:36  |  Voice of Reason 17/01/07
  118.   # 34, JAMEEL 05:38  |  indrajaya 17/01/07
  119.   Gosh! A perm. UN SC member threatens a veto! 05:44  |  Johnboy 17/01/07
  120.   tadchase responding to Kaludia on oil 05:49  |  dana 17/01/07
  121.   # 108- tadchase 05:52  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  122.   TOBIA 06:13  |  Aaron/American Jew 17/01/07
  123.   # 116- Tony L ... I `m With You, Tony ! 06:32  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  124.   HATERS WILL ALWAYS BE HERE 06:32  |  TOBIA 17/01/07
  125.   Tony L .... PS 06:45  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  126.   ARIK 07:11  |  TOBIA 17/01/07
  127.   Read An Islamic Rag Today (Newspaper) 07:13  |  Yosemite 17/01/07
  128.   On Russian Interests - from the other board 07:44  |  dana 17/01/07
  129.   Communism may rise from grave in Iran 07:45  |  Alex 17/01/07
  130.   #96 Tobia to Indra 07:58  |  Poor Indonesian 17/01/07
  131.   # 129- Alex Communism Would be A STEP UP ... 08:09  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  132.   to TonyL on Russia 08:13  |  Anubhav 17/01/07
  133.   # 149- Danite... Double, double toil and trouble... 08:19  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  134.   Michael Savage - Klaudia 08:55  |  Aramis 17/01/07
  135.   #120 dana 08:58  |  tadchase 17/01/07
  136.   Poor Indonesian 09:24  |  Yosemite 17/01/07
  137.   #103 TOBIA, stop playing the persecuted martyr! 09:27  |  Maureen Ann 17/01/07
  138.   # 134 - Aramis ... No, Michael Savage is ONE Source of truth... 09:49  |  Klaudia 17/01/07
  139.   tadchase # 135 remembering chalabi all too well 11:23  |  dana 17/01/07
 Today Online
IDF chief Dan Halutz announces his resignation
Responses: 104
Uzi Benziman: Israel's refusal to give up the Golan will lead to war
Responses: 16
Amira Hass: The founders of apartheid would be proud
Responses: 8
U.S. officials: Cheney updated on secret Israel-Syria talks
Responses: 22
AG Mazuz may decide to probe Olmert over two more affairs
Responses: 5


More Headlines
11:06 IDF Chief of Staff Dan Halutz announces his resignation
11:08 Halutz resignation spurs calls for Olmert, Peretz to quit too
11:15 Katsav accuser says fears for life after new evidence released
10:40 U.S. officials: Cheney was kept in the loop on Israel-Syria talks
11:25 IDF freezes order banning Israelis from giving rides to W. Bank residents
07:57 AG to consider opening probe against PM in two more affairs
08:39 Israel grants W. Bank access to foreign citizens of Palestinian origin
04:21 MKs call on Olmert to resign in wake of Bank Leumi probe
06:06 Comptroller considers suspending special advisor for corruption
06:10 IDF removes 44 dirt barriers from West Bank villages
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved