Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., January 17, 2007 Tevet 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Deputy Knesset Speaker Ahmed Tibi. (Archives)
Last update - 15:38 13/01/2007
Leftist MK slams Tibi for urging Fatah to 'continue the struggle'
By Avi Issacharoff, Haaretz Correspondent, and Haaretz Service

A left-wing Knesset member slammed outspoken Arab MK Ahmed Tibi (United Arab List-Ta'al) Friday for calling on Fatah supporters to "continue the struggle" until a Palestinian state is established.

MK Avshalom Vilan (Meretz-Yachad) said Tibi - who is deputy speaker of the Knesset - went too far when he advocated a "struggle," a word often used to signify terrorism, at a rally in Ramallah on Thursday marking the 42nd anniversary of the Fatah movement.

"As soon as there are political calls there for a struggle, [Tibi] is essentially crossing the line and creating an impossible situation," Vilan told Israel Radio on Friday.

Advertisement

Vilan noted that Tibi expressed "total identification" with Fatah - referring to himself and his audience as "we" and to Israelis as "they" - even though, said Vilan, Tibi represents all Knesset members and the entire Israeli population.

Vilan also said he continues to believe that Israeli Arabs can potentially serve as a bridge between Israeli Jews and Palestinians, but that Tibi's remarks damage the ability of Jewish and Arab Israelis to work together to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

In his impassioned speech Thursday, Tibi evoked the presence of the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, saying to cheers and gunfire that he "is still with us," and called on the Palestinians to unite.

"My greetings to the Fatah members from whose midst the first martyrs fell and the first prisoners were arrested," he said. "They want to destroy Palestine, but we will continue the struggle until the establishment of a state with Jerusalem as its capital."

Tibi told Israel Radio on Friday that the entity he was calling on Palestinians to struggle against was the Israeli occupation.

The crowd responded: "Millions of martyrs are marching to Jerusalem."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Israeli export
A new book focuses on the role Zim played in the history of shipping and architecture.
Nature online
New online guides to Israel's plants and animals have been launched in the last year.
  1.   Tibi 11:01  |  Avraham 12/01/07
  2.   PUT HIS ASS IN JAIL AND NOT IN THE KENESET 11:02  |  ANGRY REUVEN 12/01/07
  3.   The Meretz MK is 100 % correct 11:10  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/01/07
  4.   Hey we will send weapons just don`t say the word "struggle" 11:14  |  Guy From NYC 12/01/07
  5.   How can left be angry: this is the type Israel they foster!!!!!!! 11:15  |  Ben Uziel 12/01/07
  6.   INQUISITION 11:27  |  stevo 12/01/07
  7.   Note, all those who accuse Israel of being undemocratic and ..... 11:43  |  Nadav 12/01/07
  8.   what does tibi really want? 11:50  |  woken up to reality 12/01/07
  9.   The fifth column 11:53  |  Nora 12/01/07
  10.   Tibi 12:03  |  Frank 12/01/07
  11.   Leftist MK slams Tibi for urging Fatah to `continue the struggle` 12:05  |  paul 12/01/07
  12.   This is exactly what I`m talking about 12:09  |  Avi 12/01/07
  13.   he is representative of the palestinians 12:20  |  flashman 12/01/07
  14.   Bizarre 12:22  |  James McNamara 12/01/07
  15.   tibi is a sleazy little man 12:26  |  israeljury 12/01/07
  16.   stop with the lies 12:45  |  benito 12/01/07
  17.   Tibi: "Kill Jews"...Next day, "How dare you call me racist?!" 12:54  |  RA 12/01/07
  18.   tibi urging fatah to continue 12:55  |  Shmuelshachor 12/01/07
  19.   Suicidal democracy of Israel. 12:59  |  VLAD 12/01/07
  20.   ...to Tibi...be happy ...Defense Minister love you... 13:06  |  UGY the she camel 12/01/07
  21.   Another one who forgot whom he is supposed to represent 13:16  |  krystal 12/01/07
  22.   Paul You are right 13:26  |  krystal 12/01/07
  23.   # 7 "New" Left 13:38  |  Lynn 12/01/07
  24.   INQUISITION 13:41  |  Lynn 12/01/07
  25.   In the same even in which Tibi spoke, the "president" of the .... 13:45  |  Nadav 12/01/07
  26.   Why is Tibi allowed in Knesset and Kahane party not 14:29  |  Joel Kelso 12/01/07
  27.   Krystal and Paul, please consider this an invitation to ascend 14:32  |  Nadav 12/01/07
  28.   No self respect 14:37  |  IW 12/01/07
  29.   Tibi is right! 14:42  |  ariel 12/01/07
  30.   and they just appointed another arab MK yesterday 15:05  |  terrornator 12/01/07
  31.   astonishing. then again in israel nothis is. 15:08  |  uzi silber 12/01/07
  32.   Calling for "struggle" which is not like Jihad or fight 15:21  |  Tamir Gaza 12/01/07
  33.   the pals are not going to be happy,no matter what.why dont you 15:56  |  terrornator 12/01/07
  34.   Integration vs accusation 16:14  |  Ibn Filastin 12/01/07
  35.   tibi 16:34  |  yuval 12/01/07
  36.   Arafat Will Always Be With You 16:50  |  Tex 12/01/07
  37.   LEFT AND ZIONISM ARE TWO OPPOSITE IDEOLOGIES, SO ... 16:51  |  THE JACKAL 12/01/07
  38.   Arab MK. 17:06  |  Vital 12/01/07
  39.   traitor Knesset membes 17:07  |  Hilda 12/01/07
  40.   Send Tibi to Ramallah where he belongs 17:22  |  Bimmer 12/01/07
  41.   Tibi definitly crossed the line here 17:49  |  Lubnani Yehudi 12/01/07
  42.   Poor Leadership From Both Peoples 17:54  |  Brian Freund 12/01/07
  43.   tibi and fatah 18:11  |  racheli 12/01/07
  44.   The longer the Occupation lasts, the worse it will get 18:23  |  Tosefta 12/01/07
  45.   As an Israeli-Arab..... 18:25  |  Rami 12/01/07
  46.   Nadav 18:31  |  krystal 12/01/07
  47.   Nadav cont`d 18:35  |  krystal 12/01/07
  48.   ila ibn filastin, #34 18:38  |  lisa 12/01/07
  49.   Tibi the traitor 18:40  |  noel 12/01/07
  50.   to Tamir Gaza, #32 18:42  |  lisa 12/01/07
  51.   throw him out the knesset he is a threat to secirity 18:49  |  zionist forever 12/01/07
  52.   to Paul of Toronto 19:08  |  Bernard 12/01/07
  53.   #1 avraham 19:21  |  david 12/01/07
  54.   dont lynch the guy just dissmiss him as MK 19:33  |  David G 12/01/07
  55.   To Lisa 20:03  |  Tamir Gaza 12/01/07
  56.   Vilan Suprised? 20:05  |  Barry 12/01/07
  57.   Tibi`s membership in Knesset should be revoked. 20:16  |  Vittorio 12/01/07
  58.   border adjustments 20:20  |  natan 12/01/07
  59.   Mk Tibi`s willed destruction of Israel 20:21  |  Arthur 12/01/07
  60.   The Message to Arabs 20:52  |  Bimmer 12/01/07
  61.   traitor and throw him out is nonsense 20:52  |  flashman 12/01/07
  62.   traitor and throw him out is nonsense 20:52  |  flashman 12/01/07
  63.   REMOVE HIM FROM ISRAEL NOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!! 21:02  |  amir 12/01/07
  64.   Ridiculous 21:08  |  Nemesis 12/01/07
  65.   Traitors deserve to be in jail not the Knesset 21:31  |  K 12/01/07
  66.   Struggle defined// 21:40  |  Joe 12/01/07
  67.   Rami take a look at that... 22:05  |  krystal 12/01/07
  68.   Tibi - Pines-Paz`s buddy 22:13  |  Tod Zuckerman 12/01/07
  69.   HOW GRISLY THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAELI ARABS 23:16  |  paul harris 12/01/07
  70.   Clickfool, where are you today? 23:17  |  Yonatan 12/01/07
  71.   Guy from NYC 23:47  |  rich 12/01/07
  72.   Vilnan wakes up to find Peter 23:49  |  rich 12/01/07
  73.   Question 23:53  |  Jeff Northridge 12/01/07
  74.   He will die very soon 00:14  |  xx 13/01/07
  75.   ISRAEL ARAB TERRORISTS IN KNESSET; 00:26  |  BMT 13/01/07
  76.   Joe # 66 Struggle 00:27  |  Jeff Northridge 13/01/07
  77.   EVERYONE KNOW "STRUGGLE" IS THE CODE WORD FOR "TERRORISM"! 00:39  |  BMT 13/01/07
  78.   Abbas recently said the same thing too! 00:52  |  Avi 13/01/07
  79.   ISRAEL INSANITY 01:04  |  BMT 13/01/07
  80.   A `FIFTH` COLUMN IN THE KNESSET 01:12  |  BMT 13/01/07
  81.   HELLO GLICKFOOL, HANNAH, Khalid 01:28  |  TOBIA 13/01/07
  82.   XX: care to elaborate on that please? 02:29  |  Guy From NYC 13/01/07
  83.   #76..Jeff Northridge..Penn Valley 02:32  |  Barry 13/01/07
  84.   The left just won some points in my book 02:41  |  Gili 13/01/07
  85.   #34 05:07  |  jon feigenbaum 13/01/07
  86.   Incompatible Values lead to Sedition 06:03  |  Eli 13/01/07
  87.   Reply to # 34 06:22  |  Eli 13/01/07
  88.   In post no. 7 and 25 I invited Arabs, Palestinian Arabs, citizens 07:07  |  Nadav 13/01/07
  89.   tibi 07:54  |  eliezer 13/01/07
  90.   millions of martyrs.ï 08:16  |  sandra chitayat 13/01/07
  91.   Tibi 08:40  |  Otto Rand 13/01/07
  92.   #90, Otto Rand 11:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/01/07
  93.   Sandra Chitayat 11:34  |  Guy From NYC 13/01/07
  94.   #78 Avi, Abbas recently said the right thing too! 11:46  |  fatah supporter 13/01/07
  95.   Many ways to "struggle" 14:58  |  David James Vickery 13/01/07
  96.   fatah supporter # 94 Abbas Can Say What He Wants To 15:54  |  Jeff Northridge 13/01/07
  97.   ...to Tosefta #44...Tveria...Israel...are you israeli? 16:33  |  abraham...mico 13/01/07
  98.   Easy on Tibi.... 16:54  |  Fulan 13/01/07
  99.   To fatah (jihad) supporter 17:44  |  Avi 13/01/07
  100.   Tosefta the innocent 17:55  |  FOX 13/01/07
  101.   Jeff..You are really smart..so please answer this 17:57  |  Avi 13/01/07
  102.   Israelis are Suicidal 18:17  |  Peter 13/01/07
  103.   My dear Cipora, 18:22  |  Otto Rand 13/01/07
  104.   Tibi and the Law (Otto Rand #91) 18:52  |  Tosefta 13/01/07
  105.   tibi 18:54  |  charles 13/01/07
  106.   guy from new york,what,you not playing the racism card today? 19:01  |  terrornator 13/01/07
  107.   I remember how Arab Israelis rallied 19:34  |  Mark Lincoln 13/01/07
  108.   Avi # 99 That`s a Difficult Question 19:40  |  Jeff Northridge 13/01/07
  109.   #95,Jeff Northridge 19:49  |  fatah supporter 13/01/07
  110.   #98, Avi the extremist 19:53  |  fatah supporter 13/01/07
  111.   51 zionist forever 19:55  |  Kannah 13/01/07
  112.   #100 avi re jeff, dont asked jeff..ask yr neighbour 20:03  |  fatah supporter 13/01/07
  113.   tibi 20:08  |  michel 13/01/07
  114.   #107,Jeff.. 20:25  |  fatah supporter 13/01/07
  115.   What left? 20:25  |  Avi also 13/01/07
  116.   A total disgrace that this man is not in jail 21:25  |  Shalom Freedman 13/01/07
  117.   he crossed the loine now must be dealth as enemy of state, 21:57  |  ralph 13/01/07
  118.   #97 Abraham Mico and UGY from Afula 22:19  |  Tosefta 13/01/07
  119.   Tibi 23:00  |  jacob Gang 13/01/07
  120.   ...to Tosefta...from Tveria...Israel 00:33  |  abraham...mico 14/01/07
  121.   fatah supporter # 114 In That Case,... 01:08  |  Jeff Northridge 14/01/07
  122.   Double standard 03:01  |  Dr David I. Gross 14/01/07
  123.   Poor Israel 04:01  |  Nad 14/01/07
  124.   CAN YOU TEACH DAVID JAMES VICKERY 05:47  |  TOBIA 14/01/07
  125.   Ben Uziel - what common culture are you refering to? 07:20  |  dana 14/01/07
  126.   To Tosefta #104 07:54  |  Otto Rand 14/01/07
  127.   the 5th column 09:08  |  Rachel 14/01/07
  128.   dana: 4000 yr common history 09:19  |  Ben Uziel 14/01/07
  129.   Ben Uziel on a tangent. What`s al jazeera to do with it? 09:45  |  dana 14/01/07
  130.   Tibi advocating overthrow of state of Israel 10:19  |  Reuven 14/01/07
  131.   Is Tibi also on the defence committee? 12:37  |  Geoff 14/01/07
  132.   Lisa, Integration and Introspection 13:08  |  Ibn Filastin 17/01/07
 Today Online
IDF chief Dan Halutz announces his resignation
Responses: 117
Uzi Benziman: Israel's refusal to give up the Golan will lead to war
Responses: 33
Amira Hass: The founders of apartheid would be proud
Responses: 23
U.S. officials: Cheney updated on secret Israel-Syria talks
Responses: 27
AG Mazuz may decide to probe Olmert over two more affairs
Responses: 5
Rosner's Domain
* Has the war with Iran already started?
* Michael Oren: America's most fateful decision in the Middle East
* The Carter trap
* Poll: Does Barak deserve a second chance?


More Headlines
11:06 IDF Chief of Staff Dan Halutz announces his resignation
12:19 Halutz resignation spurs calls for Olmert, Peretz to quit too
12:23 U.S. officials: Cheney was kept in the loop on Israel-Syria talks
12:08 IDF freezes ban on Israelis driving W. Bank Palestinians
13:15 Ahmadinejad: Israel and the U.S. would not dare attack Iran
11:41 Katsav accuser says fears for life after new evidence released
13:10 AG to consider opening probe against PM in two more affairs
08:39 Israel grants W. Bank access to foreign citizens of Palestinian origin
13:03 Rice: Setting Palestinian borders may be easier than provisional state
06:06 Comptroller considers suspending special advisor for corruption
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Shop high-class skin care cosmetics with Dead Sea minerals. Coupon code "haaretz" for 10% off.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved