Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., January 12, 2007 Tevet 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:38 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 22:10 10/01/2007
German Jewish leader sharply critical of new comedy about Hitler
By The Associated Press

A new German comedy film about Adolf Hitler treads on dangerous ground and could inadvertently lead to increased anti-Semitism, a top Jewish leader said Wednesday.

Stephan Kramer, general secretary of Germany's Central Council of Jews, said "Mein Fuehrer," which opens on 250 screens Thursday, could generate empathy for the former Nazi dictator by its portrayal of him as a comic figure who had a bad childhood.

"It gets people to suffer with him, to say 'this poor guy," said Kramer, who said he has seen large parts of the film already.

Advertisement

In the film, director Dani Levy, a Swiss-born Jew who lives in Berlin,
portrays Hitler as a drug addict who plays with a toy battleship in the
bathtub, dresses his dog in Nazi uniform and takes acting tips from a Jewish concentration camp inmate.

Levy has said that the movie, whose full title is "Mein Fuehrer: die wirklich wahrste Wahrheit ueber Adolf Hitler" ("Mein Fuehrer: The Truly Truest Truth about Adolf Hitler"), is meant to explain for himself how it was possible for Germans to follow Hitler, ultimately dragging the nation into war and the Holocaust.

"I had the feeling that I must do it with another genre, do it by being able to exaggerate through comedy," Levy told The AP.

But Kramer said because of the way Hitler is depicted, there is too much room for impressionable people, particularly Germany's younger generation, to be influenced - especially at a time where far-right parties have made inroads in some eastern German states.

"People on the street may take it in the wrong way, that Hitler was just a person to laugh about," Kramer said in a telephone interview. "I heard a statement that it is better to laugh about him than not know about him, but I don't know."

He said treating Hitler in a comic way is not a taboo subject, citing Charlie Chaplin's classic "The Great Dictator" as what he considers a good example of how it can be done. He added that Levy's being Jewish did not necessarily give him any special insight.

"Being Jewish does not give any guarantee that the filmmaker will succeed with his task, and I think he failed," Kramer said. "Chaplin wasn't Jewish and he succeeded; he did a great job with the Great Dictator; he did it in a cynical way."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Deaf ears
The deaf community is suing the News Company for failing to provide closed captions.
Worth the trip
The Terrine restaurant in Yavne is not at all pretentious, rather it is temptingly casual.
  1.   Lighten Up! 23:46  |  Jeez! 10/01/07
  2.   Germany 23:50  |  Bimmer 10/01/07
  3.   much ado about nothing 00:02  |  Andreas 11/01/07
  4.   The man commited the most... 12:59  |  Edith 11/01/07
  5.   A real question about a mediocre film 14:03  |  Jonathan S 11/01/07
  6.   To Bimmer about Germany 14:27  |  Jonathan S 11/01/07
  7.   He is correct that this film may promote anti-Semitism 16:24  |  Stephen Murray 11/01/07
  8.   Get A Life 16:48  |  Rowan Berkeley 11/01/07
  9.   HTILER 17:29  |  JAMES BOND 11/01/07
  10.   hitler shmitler....the piece of garbage deseres nothing BUT 17:31  |  taz 11/01/07
  11.   to John S - thanks 17:34  |  TAZ 11/01/07
  12.   to number 1 19:11  |  sue 11/01/07
  13.   Answering TAZ about Germany 19:20  |  Jonathan S 11/01/07
  14.   JOHN 19:25  |  TAZ 11/01/07
  15.   To Bimmer 20:53  |  Yosi 11/01/07
  16.   stop projecting the past into the present, Jonathan 21:27  |  Andreas 11/01/07
  17.   Oh God, Stephan Kramer again 23:09  |  Axel 11/01/07
  18.   Johantan S 23:21  |  Axel 11/01/07
  19.   Not a "German Jewish Leader" 23:30  |  Axel 11/01/07
  20.   The past that will not pass #16 00:24  |  Jonathan S 12/01/07
  21.   About Stephan Kramer 00:37  |  Jonathan S 12/01/07
  22.   # 20 jonathan s - lies, lies, lies 00:54  |  Axel 12/01/07
  23.   #20 Please enlighten me 01:30  |  Andreas 12/01/07
  24.   Stephan Kramer is general secretary, Jonathan is right. 02:11  |  Andreas 12/01/07
  25.   To #7, a ridiculous post by S. Murray 03:52  |  Tom 12/01/07
  26.   Stop being so sensitive! 09:55  |  Gerry 12/01/07
  27.   # 24 Andreas 11:32  |  Axel 12/01/07
  28.   An answer to Andreas 12:05  |  Jonathan S 12/01/07
 Today Online
Poll: Support for Kadima plummets under Olmert
Responses: 32
Yoel Marcus: We must not let scandals paralyze leadership
Responses: 3
Ze'ev Schiff: Israel is acting like a novice at military operations
Responses: 4
Elie Podeh: Prospects of success in talks with Syria exceed risks
Responses: 1
Wanted: A leader of vision
Send response
Rosner's Domain
* Bush and Iraq: the optimist's way
* Washington notes: Clark, Iraq, Iran, Clinton
* Poll: Wesley Clark, right, wrong or anti-Semitic?
* Evangelical Christians and Israel: readers' reactions


More Headlines
10:15 Reservists mark 6 months since soldiers' abduction
11:11 Leftist MK slams Tibi for urging Fatah to 'continue the struggle'
12:23 Rosenstein, U.S. authorities set to announce plea bargain
11:51 Haaretz poll: Support for Kadima plummets under PM's leadership
11:58 Greece: Domestic terrorists to blame for attack on U.S. Embassy
10:22 Dershowitz seeks to grill ex-president Carter on Israel book
09:19 Number of anti-Semitic incidents in Germany hits 5-year high
06:32 New bill would give discounted electricity to poor families
06:33 Proposed law would prevent Israelis from claiming Nazi-looted art
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved