Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., January 09, 2007 Tevet 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:00 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 22:16 07/01/2007
Gov't to support bill on revoking citizenship for disloyalty to state
By Yuval Yoaz, Haaretz Correspondent

The government intends to support a bill that would allow courts to strip Israelis of their citizenship for committing "an act that constitutes a breach of loyalty to the State of Israel."

The ministerial committee on legislation approved the bill Sunday, which was proposed by Likud MK Gilad Erdan.

The committee also decided that, once Erdan's bill is passed in by the Knesset plenum in a preliminary reading, the bill will be frozen until the Justice Ministry formulates a comprehensive government bill that will be attached to the private bill.

Advertisement

The bill does not provide a clear definition of what constitutes a breach of loyalty, but determines that visiting an enemy country or acquiring citizenship of an enemy country would be considered a breach of loyalty that would serve as a basis for revoking Israeli citizenship.

The bill "will allow the rational revoking of citizenship in order to protect the state from those who wish it harm," said Erdan.

The bill transfers the authority to revoke citizenship from the interior minister to district court panels that deal with administrative issues. Requests to revoke an individual's citizenship will be filed by the attorney general.

While the interior minister currently has the authority to revoke citizenship, this is a step that is rarely taken. Attorney General Menachem Mazuz himself ruled 12 years ago that: "As a rule the revoking of citizenship on the basis of breach of loyalty should be avoided, and the authority to revoke citizenship from an Israeli citizen should not be used, unless he possesses another citizenship."

Israeli citizenship has only been revoked for breach of loyalty in two cases. In September 2002, the citizenship of Kais Obeid was revoked due to the fact that Obeid was a senior Hezbollah militant in Lebanon and involved in the abduction of Israeli businessman Elhanan Tennenbaum. In November 2002, the Tul Karm resident Nihad Abu-Kishak was stripped of his citizenship for being a senior member of Hamas' military wing.

The ministerial committee decided, on the basis of the professional opinion of the Justice Ministry, that the bill should include a solution for situations in which the revoking of an individual's citizenship would leave the individual without citizenship from of country. International law prohibits countries from revoking citizenship from those who as a result would be left without any citizenship.

According to Erdan, "Terrorists and their supporters use all the rights and freedoms provided by a democratic state in order to harm that state and its citizens."

"Israel is faced with such terror from the dawn of its existence and if it is interested in survival, it must act on the basis of the idea of a democracy that is defending itself," continued Erdan. "It must defend itself against those that seek to destroy it, [some of] whom are unfortunately also its residents. One cannot be the citizen of a country he seeks to destroy."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Conservation nation
The building conservation trend is reaching its potential in the older sections of various cities.
The newest patron
Screenwriter Yossi Madmony comdemns the legalization of subliminal TV advertising.
  1.   Too bad we cant apply this to the traitor of the century Fahima 17:49  |  SLAVO 07/01/07
  2.   THIS IS A PROUD DAY FOR ISRAEL 17:50  |  MEIR WEINSTEIN 07/01/07
  3.   good bill being proposed for a change 17:54  |  zionist forever 07/01/07
  4.   This is the best news, so long arab "MK`S" 18:04  |  Like it is 07/01/07
  5.   State of Israel was created to curtail / and Diaspora 18:31  |  H.H.M 07/01/07
  6.   That is an Excellent idea! 18:43  |  Mark 07/01/07
  7.   It is high time, very high time to pass such a bill !!!!! 19:08  |  Nadav 07/01/07
  8.   bill on revoking citizenship 19:33  |  Shmuelshachor 07/01/07
  9.   If Bahrain can do it so can we 19:35  |  Minnie M 07/01/07
  10.   revoking citizenship 19:37  |  vendelah 07/01/07
  11.   What about levy/hEss/fahimi 19:42  |  Ari ben Yisrael 07/01/07
  12.   FINALLY SOME SANITY FROM THE KENESSET! 19:47  |  Ben Avraham 07/01/07
  13.   Revoking 19:48  |  Frank 07/01/07
  14.   The US should do this! Any American Jew (AIPAC) 19:50  |  Patriot 07/01/07
  15.   See South Africa: "Black Homeland Citizenship Act (1970)" 20:25  |  HonestIsraeli 07/01/07
  16.   ARABS NOT CITIZENS 20:38  |  ISHMAEL ISHMAEL 07/01/07
  17.   Where does it end? 21:02  |  Athena 07/01/07
  18.   So if I visit Yemen for work... 21:03  |  Phil 07/01/07
  19.   Revoking Citizenship 21:05  |  David 07/01/07
  20.   Theory good, practice probably bad 21:09  |  Gordon 07/01/07
  21.   Apartheid Legislation in Israel...shame..shame 21:09  |  Johan 07/01/07
  22.   To Minnie #9 21:11  |  Gordon 07/01/07
  23.   My heart is full! 21:22  |  Alicia 07/01/07
  24.   with some careful reservations. i totally support this.big differ 21:31  |  ralph 07/01/07
  25.   First they came for the communists... 21:42  |  Noura 07/01/07
  26.   Another confirmation of Jimmy Carter`s book 21:59  |  Mandela 07/01/07
  27.   The Next Steps 22:00  |  By John Kaminski 07/01/07
  28.   Who has 22:00  |  Citizen 07/01/07
  29.   RE#11 ARI BEN ISRAEL 22:18  |  MEIR WEINSTEIN 07/01/07
  30.   A Democracy Without A Constitution 22:20  |  chet 07/01/07
  31.   Fifth Columnist Beware! 22:21  |  J of Hollywood 07/01/07
  32.   Israeli interpretation of democracy 22:36  |  Kai 07/01/07
  33.   #19, David is one step ahead 23:05  |  Yuval 07/01/07
  34.   Posts # 1 to 12 23:18  |  dana 07/01/07
  35.   J of Hollywood loves this law 23:33  |  dana 07/01/07
  36.   Patriot 23:38  |  Lynn 07/01/07
  37.   Lets suppose... 23:52  |  jerrym 07/01/07
  38.   In good company 00:13  |  Axel 08/01/07
  39.   # 9 "If Bahrain can do it so can we" 00:23  |  Axel 08/01/07
  40.   # 32 Kai 00:27  |  Axel 08/01/07
  41.   # 34 dana 00:34  |  Axel 08/01/07
  42.   eghrrr 02:12  |  moral 08/01/07
  43.   AXEL AXEL???? 03:40  |  Jfrom C 08/01/07
  44.   Disloyalty SHOULD BE Measured By REAL/ACTUAL HARM! 03:54  |  Proud Pal Defender 08/01/07
  45.   PATRIOT GO TELL TO 04:30  |  TOBIA 08/01/07
  46.   #26 04:38  |  TOBIA 08/01/07
  47.   Axel #41 and #43 response 05:15  |  dana 08/01/07
  48.   chet, stay in Canada, we want a Jewish state with ch 05:34  |  PPM 08/01/07
  49.   dana #34, look who is talking about circling of wagons! 05:39  |  PPM 08/01/07
  50.   re # 43 JfromC 10:57  |  Axel 08/01/07
  51.   #49 - bringing up the Indians again? 14:01  |  dana 08/01/07
  52.   U S A Legislation 23:15  |  Joe 08/01/07
  53.   Joe - regarding US citizenship 01:25  |  dana 09/01/07
 Today Online
IDF: Israeli casualties down despite rise in terror activity
Responses: 160
Time to admit failure of peace process in its present format
Responses: 177
Peretz calls for final status talks within six months
Responses: 74
Ehud Barak couldn't rein in the IDF any better than Peretz
Responses: 46
The Arrow can't stop Hezbollah, Syrian or Iranian missiles
Responses: 101
Evangelical Christians and Israel: readers' reactions
Responses: 98
Rosner's Domain
* Evangelical Christians and Israel: readers' reactions
* In Iraq, counting on the stubborn and dealing with the tired
* First thought: Wow. Second thought: Oy
* Poll: More U.S. money to the Palestinians?


More Headlines
22:37 Peretz calls for final status talks within six months
19:27 Shin Bet: 14 percent of suicide bombers had Israeli citizenship
01:18 PA Chairman demands Hamas Executive Force be disbanded
23:58 IAF soldier arrested for allegedly trying to sabotage F-16 plane
21:18 Tax Authority representative in U.S. arrested at airport
23:29 Former education ministers to Tamir: Don't cut teachers' colleges funds
22:05 Knesset okays bill to give some seniors direct nursing benefits
23:43 Israel arrests U.S. deportee over alleged Jihad ties, says brother
01:26 Only 12 MKs donate for Magen David Adom Knesset blood drive
22:39 Israeli professor charged with beating wife to death in U.S.
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved