Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., January 11, 2007 Tevet 21, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:00 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dreams of a wannabe grandma
By Neri Livneh

Against my will I found myself reading the book "Huledet savta" ("Birth of a Grandmother") by Anat Harari. Against my will, because the title alone was enough to stir up a certain sadness that's stirred up a little too often anyway. Ever since my children's shoe sizes exceeded 40, 10 years ago at least, they've been claiming that I always bug them, that it's getting harder and harder to walk down the street with me or to sit with me in a cafe - if there's a baby anywhere nearby.

"Don't even look," my son David has been saying to me in such situations he since was about 12.

"We're in for it now - in a second she's going to start talking about grandkids," Amitai murmurs in quiet desperation, either to his brother or just to himself.

Advertisement

Only their assertive elder brother, as usual, is quick to clarify the message with utter directness: "Cut out your nonsense, Mom. We'll never marry, we'll never give you grandchildren. Don't you get that we're too young?"

I vividly remember the first time it happened. "What do you mean 'too young?'" I said to Na'aman. "You're 13 and a half already. According to Judaism, you're totally mature now. When I was your age ..."

"Yes, Mom?"

"Well, I'm not saying that now's the time, but in a few more years, let's say."

More than a few years have passed since then - and still nothing. And rightly so from their standpoint. I have to admit that I didn't start thinking about motherhood until I was some years older than my eldest son is now. But the grandmotherly instinct in me is gaining urgency and clouding my judgment. The truth is that ever since I became a mother, I've dreamed of becoming a grandmother. Grandmothers have it made. They get to cuddle and play with these adorable babies and then hand them back to their parents when it's time for a diaper change or a nap. Grandmothers are fun to have around. They're like mothers but lack the oppressive need to educate the children properly, to set boundaries, to see to the constant upkeep. I look at my friends who are grandmothers and am filled with envy.

It wasn't the same when I was growing up. Many of my girlfriends didn't even have a grandmother around (my own paternal grandmother died years before I was born), and most of the grandmothers we knew spoke with a funny accent and really looked like grandmothers, with print dresses and orthopedic shoes, white hair and lots of wrinkles. All of them also knew how to make a cake from one egg, how to produce "meatballs" from bread and, of course, how to sew and knit.

Granted, my grandmother was different: She spoke an eloquent Hebrew with a teacher's clear diction, on Shabbat she would go to hear lectures, she had memories from the era of the Turks and the British Mandate, and she preferred Tchernikovsky's poetry to that of Bialik. Nevertheless, she was still very grandmother-ish, and looked that way despite her dyed hair. She forced awful folk remedies on us, like carob syrup and baking soda; she taught me how to iron her giant pink brassieres (I would have preferred to burn them), to peel tomatoes for a salad and to rinse around my eyes with disinfectant soap.

That's not the kind of grandmother I wish to be. I want to be a grandmother like my friend Yael, who plays soccer with her grandson (and is quite good at it, so it seems); or like my friend Rachel, who lets her granddaughter play with toys that aren't made of wood and also sneaks her bread made from white flour. Or like Judy, who's introducing her granddaughter to all the best coffee shops in town. A subversive and bohemian grandmother like Nurit, or a grandmother like Manuela, who has deep conversations with her granddaughter about boys and the meaning of life.

No knitting!

To be a grandmother, I'm even willing to develop some hobbies, to learn how to put together a puzzle that has more than six pieces, or to stand over and over again in a defensive position so that the grandkids can practice their judo moves on me. I would even seriously consider wearing a bathing suit and going to the beach. There's just one thing that's out of the question for me: I could never truly become a knitting grandmother.

If I were a man, at my age or even 10-20 years older, I'd have more options. I could have another child instead of waiting for a grandchild. I have several lucky male friends who are currently producing grandchild substitutes. If I'd given birth to girls, I might have been able to dream about being a grandmother when I still had enough strength to move around without any technical assistance.

Perhaps, like the new mothers and grandmothers in the group taught by author Harari, my daughters would have also discovered, through their new motherhood, my greatness as their mother. "Every time a child is born, a mother and grandmother is born, too," says Harari, adding: "The moment you become a mother you learn to appreciate anew the motherhood of your mother before you."

She's right. I remember the awe I felt when it dawned on me one day that my mother, too, the same woman with whom I had so many bones to pick, used to get up in the middle of the night to feed and change my siblings and me, and get us back to sleep. That for about five years she, too, must have asked herself just when she would ever sleep eight hours straight, or take a nice long bath instead of a quick shower. The feeling of admiration that came with this epiphany lasted a good few hours.

As a single, grandchild-less wannabe grandma, I've tried everything. I tried to be a step-grandmother, but I couldn't find the right grandfather. I tried to offer my services as a substitute grandmother to several young couples, but they all replied that they already had more than enough grandmothers in the family (two, three and even four - which is what happens when both Grandma and Grandpa divorce and then remarry). "Yes, I see," I told them, "but still, you don't have a grandmother like me. With grandmothers, it's quality that counts."

Unfortunately, I'm left with no choice but to pounce on orphans and establish the Foundation for a Different Grandmother-hood. To offer my services as an adoptive grandmother for grandmother-less grandchildren. And I won't mind sharing the grandchildren days equally with an adoptive grandfather provided by the foundation - as long as one thing is clear: On holidays, the grandchildren are with me.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Luring in the flock
Daniel Ayalon: It is realistic to think of a million Jews immigrating to Israel by 2020.
Humans in lizard turf
For millennia the Egyptian mastigure has lived here in peace. Then we showed up.
  1.   A delightful article 02:47  |  Motic 07/01/07
  2.   grandmother 13:10  |  c.b. 07/01/07
  3.   dreading it! 15:58  |  molly 07/01/07
  4.   Wannabe Grandma 16:54  |  Allan 07/01/07
  5.   Being a grandmother.... 19:46  |  Patricia 07/01/07
  6.   have another child yourself... 20:08  |  smartalec 07/01/07
  7.   You WILL be a grandmother 17:07  |  Jessica 10/01/07
 Today Online
PM dismisses Meshal comments that Israel is a reality
Responses: 139
Police summon settler filmed harassing Palestinians
Responses: 125
Haaretz finds few changes at West Bank roadblocks
Responses: 50
Israel Harel: Gaza pullout, Lebanon war were strategic failures
Responses: 53
Aide: PM asks China to put pressure on Iran
Responses: 45
Israel Factor: Who is better for Israel, Clinton or McCain?
Responses: 55


More Headlines
20:00 Lieberman calls on Peretz to quit over appointment of first Arab minister
21:22 Haaretz poll: Olmert's Kadima sinks to 12 seats, Likud up to 29
18:48 Syrian official in Madrid calls for fresh negotiations with Israel
21:07 IAF drone crashes near Beit Hanun due to malfunction
20:35 IDF officer jailed for 3 years for raping woman soldier in his unit
22:00 Police investigate Hebron settler filmed attacking Arabs
21:30 Senior Iranian official suspected of spying on Iran's nuclear program
19:55 Health Ministry issues warning against drinking tap water
16:37 Rice offers to meet Iranian ladership if it suspends uranium enrichment
17:43 Abbas says he won't tolerate internal Palestinian fighting
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved