Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., January 04, 2007 Tevet 14, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Tax Authority Director Jackie Matza at the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court on Wednesday. (Motti Kimche)
Last update - 17:57 04/01/2007
Police: Tax bribery probe deals only with Matza's term as chief
By Jonathan Lis, Yuval Yoaz and Moti Bassok, Haaretz Correspondents

Police sources told Haaretz on Thursday that the current investigation of the Tax Authority corruption scandal that broke this week does not deal with former Tax Authority director Eitan Rub's term, and is focusing solely on the period of his successor, current Tax Authority Director Jackie Matza.

Police have decided to release Rub and a businessman suspected in the affair, Simo Tobol, with the expiration of both suspects' remand Thursday. They will, however, be placed under house arrest.

Nonetheless, Rub is still suspected of acting as a go-between for bribery. Police suspect that following his resignation from the authority, Rub remained in touch with Matza and other Tax Authority officials who had served under him in the past, in order to advance the requests of businessman Kobi Ben-Bur.

Advertisement

A hearing regarding their final release was to be conducted Thursday evening at the Tel Aviv Magistrate's court in absentia.

The remand of Yossi Steinmetz, who heads the personal imports department at the Tax Authority, was to expire Friday. However, it has not yet been decided whether his remand would be extended or he whether he would be released under restrictions.

At this juncture, police are not investigating sensitive agreements reached during Rub's tenure between the Tax Authority and businessmen and companies that received considerable tax breaks.

The investigation into Matza and Tobol, as well as other suspects, will continue until their release in the National Fraud Investigation Unit in Bat Yam.

Police sources said Wednesday that the police fraud squad is expected to carry out more arrests in the affair.

The sources predicted that businesspeople who obtained tax breaks through the power and influence of prime suspects Ben-Gur and Yoram Karashi will be interrogated, and that additional Tax Authority staffers will be interrogated for suspected involvement in the system that facilitated granting such tax breaks. But the police have not yet decided when to conduct the next round of arrests, as this will depend on developments in the investigation over the next few days.

Attorney General Menachem Mazuz and Civil Service Commissioner Shmuel Hollander will consider suspending the prime minister's bureau chief, Shula Zaken, and Matza, as well as several other tax officials. A decision will be made after the suspects are released from detention or other restrictions imposed by the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court.

Police sources claim that Matza lied in his interrogation regarding two affairs that he was asked to explain. At a bail hearing on Tuesday, the police presented two examples of contradictions between Matza's testimony and the findings uncovered in the prior undercover investigation. Altogether, they said, Matza's 33-page testimony is fraught with inaccuracies or claims that contradict evidence collected.

At that hearing, the judge ruled that Zaken would remain under complete house arrest for 10 days, after which she would be prohibited from going o her office or contacting Prime Minister Ehud Olmert for another 14 days. Matza and other senior tax officials were remanded for a few
days each, but even after they are released, they will presumably not be allowed to return to their jobs before the investigation ends.

The Justice Ministry and the Civil Service Commission released a joint statement Wednesday saying that "at this point, in keeping with the needs of the investigation, the suspects have been distanced from their places of work by the penal code and the detention proceedings. At a later stage, further administrative measures will be considered, including suspension under the civil service code."

The Tax Authority functioned Wednesday without three senior officials  the director general and two deputies, Shmuel Bobarov and Gidi Ben Zakai. Flouting the advice of senior treasury officials, Finance Minister Abraham Hirchson failed to appoint a temporary replacement for Matza yesterday. Hirchson will meet with Tax Authority staffers on Thursday at the authority's Jerusalem offices.

The preferred candidate to replace Matza is apparently Finance Ministry director general Joseph Bachar, an accountant by trade who will be completing his term on Sunday and has the complete confidence of the finance minister, senior treasury officials and Tax Authority staffers. Bachar was pressured to accept the position temporarily, but apparently rejected the request for personal reasons.

On Wednesday morning, Hirchson met with Prime Minister Ehud Olmert for a private discussion of the crisis at the Tax Authority. Both sides declined to reveal the content of their meeting.

Hirchson also convened his staff to discuss the crisis. At a tense meeting, senior treasury officials said that if even only some of the allegations are proven, the affair is earthshaking.

More than 100 police officers took part in Tuesday's arrests and searches of the suspects' homes.

All the suspects were isolated in separate interrogation rooms, where they were shown the evidence against them for the first time and asked to respond. It consisted mainly of thousands of hours of taped phone conversations among the main suspects. The police say that these conversations are incriminating and prove that many Tax Authority staffers helped in doing the bidding of Ben-Gur, Karashi, Zaken and their associates.

In several instances, the suspects were asked to explain substantial discrepancies between the stories they told on Tuesday and the concealed evidence collected over the past 10 months.

"For us, the fact that several suspects gave false testimony immediately upon their arrest is good," one police source said. "They allegedly cooperated and denied the allegations, essentially hog-tying themselves. Today, they had to face the facts we have collected. Cracks were certainly created in some of their stories."

Detectives will try in the coming days to resolve one of the main puzzles in the investigation: The extent of the financial payoffs that Karashi, Ben-Gur and maybe tax officials received from the businesspeople who approached them is still unclear. Detectives are also trying to determine exactly who exploited the allegedly criminal mechanism at the
authority in order to receive tax breaks on their business dealings.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Expecting the best
There is an abundance of maternity fashions to choose from in Israel.
Expensive but worth it
Here is a scorecard of some of the offerings of Israel's finest vineyards.
  1.   Tax affair arrests 07:55  |  Esther 04/01/07
  2.   Arresting Suspects 10:10  |  janice 04/01/07
  3.   When are we going to see 12:25  |  sh 04/01/07
  4.   Wasn`t this investgation leaked prematurely ? 15:57  |  dg 04/01/07
  5.   CORRUPTION 17:18  |  Polna 04/01/07
  6.   Banna Republic 18:20  |  Greg 04/01/07
  7.   house arrest for criminals ans prison for children 20:37  |  Y. Huisman 04/01/07
 Today Online
Haniyeh enters strict security check prior to reentering Gaza
Responses: 99
Israel receptive to Egyptian proposal for four-way summit
Responses: 94
Yair Hirschfeld: Bush policies strengthening radical Iranian regime
Responses: 50
Aluf Benn: Qassams, Katyushas dictating Israel's policies
Responses: 49
Rosner's Domain
* Choosing chaos over Al-Qaida or chaos over stability?
* Rosner's Guest: Evangelicals support left and right
* Poll: What can the U.S. do in 2007?
* 2007 first notes: THAAD, Carter, Boxer


More Headlines
20:38 Mubarak: Israel must avoid steps that impede peace
20:39 3 killed in clashes with IDF troops in Ramallah
20:03 Three people killed in Gaza clashes; Haniyeh urges calm
18:53 Official: Iran amassing raw material for uranium enrichment
20:41 Judge: Reasonable suspicion that Zadorov killed Katzrin teen
13:10 Dignitaries, diplomats turn out for Teddy Kollek's funeral
17:57 Police: Tax bribery probe deals only with Matza's term as chief
13:59 Poll places Livni as clear leader in run-up to Kadima primary
14:06 Haniyeh enters Gaza Strip following stringent security check
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved