Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., January 09, 2007 Tevet 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The year of the rocket
By Aluf Benn

The year 2006 deserves to be called "the year of the rocket." It was a year in which the firing of rockets into Israeli territory, from the Gaza Strip and Lebanon, dictated Israeli foreign and security policy more than any other factor. The Katyushas fired by Hezbollah and the Qassams fired by the Palestinians had a greater influence than the change of leadership in Jerusalem and the strengthening of Iran.

Sderot and its environs absorbed about 1,000 Qassam rockets from Gaza over the past year, and during the Lebanon war, about 4,000 rockets were fired at northern Israel. The losses, the injuries and the damage were smaller than those caused in previous wars or by suicide attacks. But the rockets dragged Israel into prolonging fighting in Lebanon and convinced Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and most of the public that it is dangerous to withdraw from additional territory in the West Bank or the Golan Heights.

Olmert buried the convergence plan for a clear reason: Israel can live with rockets on Sderot, and for a limited period even with rockets on the north, but it will have difficulty tolerating Qassams on Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. The Haifa port and oil refinery could be closed for a month, because there are alternative facilities in Ashdod. But there is no substitute for Ben-Gurion International Airport. Nor for the centers of government, commerce and culture in the Tel Aviv metropolitan area and Jerusalem. Therefore, it is difficult to speak about a significant withdrawal in the West Bank, which would include evacuating the Israel Defense Forces from dominant locations, before a solution is found to the Qassam.

Advertisement

Israel's political and security establishments were slow to understand the strategic significance of the rockets. They mocked them as "flying objects," as junky weapons used by armed gangs. With the sophisticated weapons in Israel's arsenal, it is hard to get excited about a steel pipe filled with a mixture of sugar and fertilizer as a propellant, and a few kilograms of explosives in the warhead. What is all that compared to an F-16 fighter plane, an Apache helicopter or the IDF's smart bombs? But the power of the Qassam does not lie in its technology, but in the combination of massive firing and a lack of effective countermeasures. The shelling and assassinations in the Gaza Strip did not stop the firing, nor did the cease-fire.

The first Qassam hit Israel on February 22, 2002. Five years have passed since then, during which time it would have been possible to improve the defenses of the Jewish communities near Gaza and to develop a system for intercepting rockets. According to experts, within about two years, it would be possible to develop an initial defense system of anti-Qassam rockets or lasers. The system would not provide Israel with hermetic protection, but it would reduce the strikes. But senior army officers and the Defense Ministry considered that a waste.

The army's insensitivity seems strange in hindsight. First, the threat was familiar: Israel had been attacked in the past with Katyushas in the Galilee and the Beit She'an Valley. Second, the IDF warned of the thousands of Hezbollah rockets, but developed a response only to long-range rockets and neglected the smaller Katyushas. Third, the army understood that "searing the enemy's consciousness" is what wins wars, rather than the number of dead or the number of shells fired. These insights were not translated into a search for a response to the Qassam.

In the last discussion led by former prime minister Ariel Sharon, a few hours before he collapsed, he banged on the table and demanded that the defense establishment present new ideas to combat the Qassams. "This cannot continue," he shouted. Defense Minister Amir Peretz warned, rightly, that the primitive missile would turn into a strategic threat, and that he was waiting for recommendations for a defensive system. Olmert held a discussion as well.

Olmert and Peretz must assign high priority to the rocket threat and seek a combined military and diplomatic response to it - both in order to save Sderot and Ashkelon, and in order to restore the government's diplomatic freedom of action. Without such a response, the prime minister will find it difficult to keep his promise to create a new "demographic border" for Israel and to bring the settlers down from the hills.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Conservation nation
The building conservation trend is reaching its potential in the older sections of various cities.
The newest patron
Screenwriter Yossi Madmony comdemns the legalization of subliminal TV advertising.
  1.   Maybe the IDF was appeased 10:13  |  Hastaroth 04/01/07
  2.   Never mind the Rocket. What`s next? 10:17  |  Natallie Durson 04/01/07
  3.   Depopulation is the only way 10:19  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 04/01/07
  4.   Rockets, schmokets 10:56  |  Hannah 04/01/07
  5.   It`s was Lefties like Aluf calling Qassams "flying objects" 11:04  |  Ansolute Sweden 04/01/07
  6.   #3 Depopulate my foot 11:04  |  S 04/01/07
  7.   durson "never mind the rockets" 11:13  |  izzy 04/01/07
  8.   durson fears weapons of mass destruction 11:15  |  izzy 04/01/07
  9.   durson "gaza held captive" 11:17  |  izzy 04/01/07
  10.   # 4 Hannah , Enjoy arabs repeated history , 11:37  |  Joseph E . 04/01/07
  11.   Qassams are not just rockets 11:44  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/01/07
  12.   #4, Hannah, dreaming of utopia 11:52  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 04/01/07
  13.   Why should we live with rockets? 12:05  |  Tzfonit 04/01/07
  14.   It is the policy, stupid 12:16  |  Mafalda 04/01/07
  15.   Ms Kohn 12:36  |  Hannah 04/01/07
  16.   Build a Prison for Palestinians in Sderot 12:36  |  Ezequiel 04/01/07
  17.   Will ants, rats, rabbits dig holes and make tunnels collapse? 12:38  |  Ezequiel 04/01/07
  18.   Tell Egypt to build a water channel-in Egypt`s side of the border 12:58  |  Ezequiel 04/01/07
  19.   #3 Shlomo from Tel Aviv 13:22  |  Chris Linthwaite 04/01/07
  20.   #3: Its not called depoppulate its called ethenic clensing 13:36  |  Tupac 04/01/07
  21.   BRACHA/TSFONIT of BEN-AMI OR NAHARIYA 14:15  |  gABE1 04/01/07
  22.   Ronnie Wolman 14:29  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  23.   Take lesson from Somalia 14:36  |  Ian 04/01/07
  24.   #20 Why is it funny for jew to talk about that? 14:39  |  Jens 04/01/07
  25.   Kassams sponsored by Iran-Regime change in Iran will stop kassams 15:25  |  Ezequiel 04/01/07
  26.   Gabe: Clan Cultures,Forests and Trees 15:38  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/01/07
  27.   BRACHA/Tzfonit-Ben Ami Or Nahariya 15:43  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  28.   Ronnie Wolman 16:10  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  29.   Natalie from LaLaLand #2 16:15  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  30.   2. Natallie Durson: What`s next? 16:17  |  KUTW 04/01/07
  31.   16. Ezequiel 16:22  |  KUTW 04/01/07
  32.   HANNAH AND ZIONISM 16:27  |  VENTURECAP 04/01/07
  33.   Natallie Durson, THIS TIME YOU ARE RIGHT!!! 16:56  |  Lasting peace 04/01/07
  34.   Hannah #15 17:01  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  35.   HANNAH.downward spiral.Educated Pals are leaving by the thousands 17:32  |  PETERSM 04/01/07
  36.   Tzfonit # 13 17:44  |  Avrum 04/01/07
  37.   Live with rockets on Sderot 18:00  |  Don Saliman 04/01/07
  38.   Have you read Shakespeare`s 18:08  |  BP SHA 04/01/07
  39.   #2 Natallie`s "FACTS" are scrambled 18:24  |  * BEN JABO 04/01/07
  40.   Avrum #36 18:25  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  41.   Counter-measures are good, peace is better 18:34  |  Tosefta 04/01/07
  42.   Qassams not taken seriously because... 19:20  |  Walter 04/01/07
  43.   Qassams not taken seriously because... 19:20  |  Walter 04/01/07
  44.   Hanna 19:23  |  Eli 04/01/07
  45.   #13 Tzfonit 19:27  |  Ursula 04/01/07
  46.   So stop selling Gaza sugar and fertilizer! Problem solved! 19:28  |  Dr. L. Brnd 04/01/07
  47.   Gabe: Allies and Antagonists 19:36  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/01/07
  48.   Chris Linthwaite 20:29  |  Allon 04/01/07
  49.   Tosefta: Are you not forgetting one thing? 20:39  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/01/07
  50.   TOSEFTA IS DENSE 20:50  |  REUBEN REUBEN 04/01/07
  51.   Ronnie Wolman 20:52  |  Gabe 1 04/01/07
  52.   TOSEFTA UNDERSTANDS NOTHING 20:53  |  REUBEN REUBEN 04/01/07
  53.   TOSEFTA GO BACK TO ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 20:55  |  REUBEN REUBEN 04/01/07
  54.   TOSEFTA AND LEBANON 20:58  |  REUBEN AND REUBEN 04/01/07
  55.   TOSEFTA LEBANON IS DOLLARS 20:59  |  REUBEN REUBEN 04/01/07
  56.   Ursula 21:00  |  Know It All 04/01/07
  57.   Hannahs rockets, schmokets 21:00  |  TOMY 04/01/07
  58.   Durson wants Israel play dead 21:02  |  TOMY 04/01/07
  59.   Can`t repeat myself endlessly (Ronnie #49) 21:05  |  Tosefta 04/01/07
  60.   THE IRANIAN RELATIONSHIP WITH 21:05  |  REUBEN REUBEN 04/01/07
  61.   Gabe Alliances with the Saudis 21:13  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/01/07
  62.   Reuben, don`t be an EYESORE ##50-4 21:14  |  Tosefta 04/01/07
  63.   Please,anybody tell me 21:19  |  TOMY 04/01/07
  64.   Year of the Rocket 21:19  |  P. J. Casey 04/01/07
  65.   Ronnie Wolman #47 21:21  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  66.   #15, Hannah "a grudging...iota of affection" 21:23  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 04/01/07
  67.   Lasting peace, HOW RIGHT YOU ARE !!!!! 21:27  |  TOMY 04/01/07
  68.   7 Izzy 21:31  |  Jose Marcio 04/01/07
  69.   Hannahs predictions 21:37  |  TOMY 04/01/07
  70.   Alliances 101 for Gabe 21:58  |  Jacob Blues 04/01/07
  71.   Roniie Wolman 22:01  |  Gabe1 04/01/07
  72.   Yes Gabe, HAMAS has Israel surrounded in Gaza 22:02  |  Jacob Blues 04/01/07
  73.   #41, "no need for countermeasures in the north" 22:07  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 04/01/07
  74.   Tosefta: Why,Oh Why... 22:56  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/01/07
  75.   re Tzfonit # 13 - Seems I stand corrected 23:10  |  Avrum 04/01/07
  76.   Her`e`s a what if Ben Gurion 23:30  |  Jacob Blues 04/01/07
  77.   Now is the time 23:43  |  Tosefta 04/01/07
  78.   Gabe: Obsessions 00:54  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/01/07
  79.   #30 respect the neighbors 00:57  |  ballistic 05/01/07
  80.   The TERRORISTS will delight in this pathetic article statement: 00:57  |  BMT 05/01/07
  81.   #2 NAZI, Natallie Durson on ARAB PROPAGANDA PAROLE ! 01:03  |  BMT 05/01/07
  82.   Greetings Ursula 01:04  |  Tzfonit 05/01/07
  83.   JACOB BLUES 01:07  |  GABE1 05/01/07
  84.   Tosefta #41 01:11  |  Gabe1 05/01/07
  85.   to Aluf Benn 02:13  |  zeev 05/01/07
  86.   Now is the time (Ronnie #74) 02:30  |  Tosefta 05/01/07
  87.   killing the enemy wins wars 02:36  |  Daweedh ibn Daweedh 05/01/07
  88.   Ronnie Wolman #77 PART THREE of 3<