Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., January 05, 2007 Tevet 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:42 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 08:38 03/01/2007
6 Hezbollah militants detained during war seek POW status
By Yossi Melman , Haaretz Correspondent

Six Hezbollah detainees being held by Israel since the second Lebanon war will petition the High Court of Justice on Wednesday, asking that they be recognized as prisoners of war.

Attorneys for the six, Semadar Ben-Nati and Itai Hermalin, who were appointed by the Public Defender's Office, are also to ask the court to allow their clients to be visited by the International Red Cross.

Israel has blocked such visits after Red Cross representatives saw the men only twice.

Advertisement

Israel's attitude in this case contradicts its policy, which allows the Red Cross to visit foreign nationals imprisoned in Israel, including terrorists, whom Israel does not recognize as prisoners of war. The stance in this case is a response to Hezbollah's refusal to allow Red Cross representatives to meet with the two Israel Defense Forces soldiers kidnapped by Hezbollah, Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser.

Meanwhile, various official bodies are placing responsibility for the issue of the Hezbollah prisoners at each other's doors. Ten days ago the IDF set up an interview for the Al Arabiya news network and Maariv journalist Chen Kotes-Bar to talk to two of the six detainees captured in Lebanon and who are being held at two prisons.

A Prisons Service spokeswoman asked about this report said she was unable to respond, but added that the Red Cross could visit the detainees in the future, without specifying a date.

An IDF spokesman said the matter is not under its jurisdiction, and the interview was not coordinated with it. The spokesman for the Prime Minister's Office said he was unaware of the matter. The Shin Bet security service also said the Hezbollah prisoners were not its responsibility.

Among the six detainees is Hussein Sleiman, who was not allowed to participate in the interview. He took part indirectly in the kidnapping of Goldwasser and Regev. According to Sleiman's version of events, he was in the group waiting in ambush for Israeli vehicles, but he says he was waiting in case additional Israeli vehicles came to the area to try to free the abducted soldiers. He did not fire his weapon nor take part in the battle, he claims.

All six have been indicted in the Nazareth District Court on charges of membership in a terror organization, prohibited underground military training and the attempted murder of IDF soldiers. The six allegedly were trained in Iran by the Revolutionary Guards.

Meanwhile, Physicians for Human Rights has written to Public Security Minister Avi Dichter that it has information that jail conditions for Hezbollah detainees are harsh, and they have not been issued proper winter clothing. The Prisons Service spokeswoman denied the claim, saying they are being held under the same conditions as all other prisoners.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Disappointing tapas
The quality of the food at Paco tapas bar isn't good enough to compel a second taste.
MySpace wants you
Most Israeli entrepreneurs secretly wish for generous purchase offers from abroad.
  1.   Demand Reciprocity 03:54  |  J K 03/01/07
  2.   Hang them 04:28  |  Realist 03/01/07
  3.   thats it. they have had enough contact, reciprocity or nothing. 04:43  |  ralph 03/01/07
  4.   awwww the poor terrorirsts 04:47  |  vik 03/01/07
  5.   absolutely no visits except a labotomist 04:53  |  bounce 03/01/07
  6.   hezbollah prisoners 04:56  |  skeptic 03/01/07
  7.   They must be joking 05:13  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 03/01/07
  8.   Hezzbollalalal should rot 05:27  |  Adam 03/01/07
  9.   Gitmo encore , Israel style , deja vu , 05:33  |  Joseph E . 03/01/07
  10.   hezbollah detainees want POW status 05:47  |  robin 03/01/07
  11.   lebanese dont need doctors 05:48  |  liban 03/01/07
  12.   Prisoners Of A Non-Sanctioned War Are Terrorists! 05:54  |  Lavi 03/01/07
  13.   I thought they were so tough! 06:05  |  Sherman 03/01/07
  14.   When the Red Cross is allowed to visit Israeli soldeirs in ...... 06:28  |  Amotz 03/01/07
  15.   A complete turn around 06:44  |  maoriboy 03/01/07
  16.   To Liban #11 06:51  |  Steve 03/01/07
  17.   Just kill them. 07:12  |  peacestone 03/01/07
  18.   Is that all 6 miserable Hezbollah captives 07:49  |  Carlos Murphy 03/01/07
  19.   The Audacity?. 07:52  |  Dan 03/01/07
  20.   They cannot be considered POW since they are not part of army 08:22  |  Marwan مروان خوري 03/01/07
  21.   To: maoriboy, just the other day indeed!! 08:48  |  Raed 03/01/07
  22.   They are not POW, but Israel is not Hizballah 09:05  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 03/01/07
  23.   peacestone in new haven 09:05  |  Raed 03/01/07
  24.   Can`t have it both ways 09:10  |  Guy From NYC 03/01/07
  25.   Being consistant. 09:41  |  Clickfool 03/01/07
  26.   Hizb didn`t declare a war; how can they be POWs? 09:43  |  Colin 03/01/07
  27.   Fiar Trade 09:49  |  The Oracle 03/01/07
  28.   Treat them the way you want your POW treated. 10:02  |  Adel 03/01/07
  29.   Hezbollah prisoners POW or criminals? 10:10  |  Brigitte Meier 03/01/07
  30.   idiot from NYC 10:18  |  Watcher 03/01/07
  31.   #24 wrong country posted NYC TRY USA ! 10:32  |  paul harris 03/01/07
  32.   WHEN ISRAELS TWO RECEIVE POW STATUS 10:33  |  paul harris 03/01/07
  33.   POW status 10:35  |  Ralph 03/01/07
  34.   Beauty and the Beast 10:50  |  Ibraheem 03/01/07
  35.   we know how you treat the palestinians. Hypecrate 10:53  |  gus 03/01/07
  36.   Red Cross do your duty for kidnapped Israelis 10:54  |  stony 03/01/07
  37.   To realist, you are not a realist, you are a dreamer 10:58  |  gus 03/01/07
  38.   POW Status 11:00  |  Alan 03/01/07
  39.   to bounce, Hezbullah did say that they are alive and well. 11:06  |  gus 03/01/07
  40.   BECAUSE THEY ARE POW 11:07  |  indrajaya 03/01/07
  41.   BECAUSE THEY ARE POW 11:07  |  indrajaya 03/01/07
  42.   Clickfool-#25-Being consistent? 11:11  |  Daniel Leopold 03/01/07
  43.   Skeptic, not a good advise, Hezbullah will do the same 11:11  |  gus 03/01/07
  44.   And what about Israeli prisoners? 11:17  |  RA 03/01/07
  45.   to Cipora, according to most Arab, All IDF are terrorist 11:17  |  gus 03/01/07
  46.   What rules does Israel want to play with? 11:19  |  BouSameer 03/01/07
  47.   Briggitte, God bless you, you spoke the truth. 11:24  |  gus the Lebanese 03/01/07
  48.   Brigette #29 Hogwash and onions 11:40  |  FOX 03/01/07
  49.   Six `tasty morsels` 12:03  |  ROSEMARY`S BABY 03/01/07
  50.   Some thoughts at noon 12:11  |  FOX 03/01/07
  51.   Brigitte&Gus So Lebanese Army did cross border raid into Israel? 12:15  |  Logician 03/01/07
  52.   Expel them from our Holy Land! 12:16  |  David 03/01/07
  53.   To No. 40 12:16  |  Neil 03/01/07
  54.   Lebanese Gov`t Must Demand POW Status 12:17  |  Terry 03/01/07
  55.   Brigitte Meier 12:22  |  Sarah 03/01/07
  56.   # 45 Gus- Most Arabs hate ALL Westerners 12:26  |  Paul Henzen 03/01/07
  57.   # 50, FOX 12:30  |  indrajaya 03/01/07
  58.   ask the US 12:58  |  jon purizhansky 03/01/07
  59.   Clickfool`s maelstrom #25 13:09  |  Hubal 03/01/07
  60.   # 53, NEIL 13:13  |  indrajaya 03/01/07
  61.   They are not POWs 13:24  |  Rachel Wando 03/01/07
  62.   Saw Red Cross only twice 13:28  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 03/01/07
  63.   Were they wearing the uniforms of Lebanon when they invaded? 13:32  |  PETERSM 03/01/07
  64.   #20 Marvin: illegal militia what about the illegal settelments 13:32  |  Tupac 03/01/07
  65.   They`ll get it though they aren`t 13:37  |  David Teich 03/01/07
  66.   #56: Paul Henzen You Sound Like a Mad Setteler 13:45  |  Tupac 03/01/07
  67.   #59 - well said Hubal! 13:51  |  B.Clarke 03/01/07
  68.   #63: GREAT POINT... then why were you attacking Lebanese infrastr 14:01  |  Tupac 03/01/07
  69.   #40 INDRAJAYA LOOK UP THE GENEVA CONVENTION 14:07  |  paul harris 03/01/07
  70.   Indrajaya projecting again 14:13  |  FOX 03/01/07
  71.   Two-pack #66 14:15  |  FOX 03/01/07
  72.   Excercising BLACKMAIL 14:19  |  Alicia 03/01/07
  73.   detained 14:24  |  reality 03/01/07
  74.   To indrajaya No. 60 14:30  |  Neil 03/01/07
  75.   # 70, FOX 14:33  |  indrajaya 03/01/07
  76.   # 56 Tupac - You mean the Arab settlers in Europe? 14:39  |  Paul Henzen 03/01/07
  77.   Ha,ha,ha! 14:40  |  Nechama 03/01/07
  78.   Hizbollah attacked us. 14:42  |  Yacov 03/01/07
  79.   indrajaya 14:44  |  Rupal T-P 03/01/07
  80.   If they kick Israeli prisoners, you should kick theirs? 14:46  |  Toronto`s Finest 03/01/07
  81.   # 79, RUPAL T-P 15:01  |  indrajaya 03/01/07
  82.   #29 15:07  |  Rod 03/01/07
  83.   WHAT A SCANDAL!! RED CROSS "ONLY" 15:12  |  Robert 03/01/07
  84.   TO #45 GUS 15:26  |  Alicia 03/01/07
  85.   Fox & Paul: 141 Pal Children Were Murdered By IDF 15:37  |  Tupac 03/01/07
  86.   Brigette # 29 - youy are right but who will listen 15:37  |  mollio uk 03/01/07
  87.   One-way Tolerance 15:38  |  Alicia 03/01/07
  88.